Fast Aircraft Load Calculations

Lead Research Organisation: University of Southampton
Department Name: Faculty of Engineering & the Environment

Abstract

Air transportation is becoming more accessible to a greater number of people who can afford to travel by air. The air transportation sector forecasts that passenger and freight traffic will increase at an average rate of 4-5% per annum over the next two decades, leading to a doubling of the aircraft fleet by 2034 with respect to 2015. Formidable progress has been made since the introduction of jet-propelled aircraft about 65 years ago, but much of this improvement is offset by the huge increase in air traffic today. The Advisory Council for Aviation Research and Innovation in Europe (ACARE) "FlightPath 2050" calls for reductions of 75% in fuel burn, 65% in perceived noise, and 90% in oxides of nitrogen emissions by 2050 compared to the year 2000. NASA has proposed similar goals in the US for the "N+2" (service-entry 2025) and "N+3" (service-entry 2030-2035) generations of aircraft. These environmental constraints have generated a large effort to reduce the aerodynamic drag and to generate more efficient engines. A small reduction in fuel burn multiplied by the total number of transport aircraft leads to a significant reduction of emissions into the atmosphere.

The FALCon project will develop new methods and tools to design a new generation of transport aircraft that take advantage of wing flexibility to improve the global aircraft efficiency. The project is specifically developed around a long-standing industrial challenge: assessing the impact of aerodynamic changes on the structural loads used for structural sizing of aircraft components is an expensive process (from several weeks when low-order methods are employed, to several months when employing higher-fidelity methods). Generally, the computing cost of an aeroelastic analysis is largely dominated by the aerodynamic analysis. The novelty of the FALCon project lies in the development of a computationally-efficient aerodynamic solver that reduces the computational time by, at least, 80% compared to current state-of-the-art methods.

The FALCon project will contribute to:

- Improved realism of predictions earlier in the aircraft design process, reducing the risk of not meeting customers' expectations and shortening the time to bring new aircraft on the market.

- Reduce current conservatism in aircraft design by performing dynamic (time-domain) aeroelastic analysis, which are today neglected because of the computational costs.

- Implement a paradigm change in aircraft design through the development of enhanced design tools for conceptual and preliminary phases, including aero-servo-elastic design constraints from the start of the design process. A new design paradigm is proposed, shifting the structural deformability from a performance limitation to a design opportunity.

- A close collaboration with industry guarantees that the outcomes of the project will feed back to the UK and European aviation sector, strengthening its competitiveness. A seamless integration within the existing industrial design process is expected, adding no complications to current procedures.

Planned Impact

The proposed research programme is expected to enable and facilitate a wide range of new technologies, many of which are likely to have a major future impact in a number of spheres beyond academia.

1) Society. The impact here is through: a) contributing toward environmental sustainability and protection; and b) improving the quality of life, health, and well-being.

Commercial aviation is one of the fastest growing sources of greenhouse gas emissions and yet a critical component of the global economic infrastructure. In addition to current growth of CO2 emissions, that will easily outstrip any gains made by improved technology, more than 30 million people will also be exposed to serious aircraft noise by 2025. The need for next-generation aircraft is readily evident from the cumulative impact of the current global fleet. Building upon the work carried out in the FALCon project, the global aircraft efficiency will be increased through the reduction in drag and in structural weight by means of enhanced design procedures. A further enhancement can be expected by increasing the load control capability using morphing devices, such as those based on a trailing edge adaptive camber mechanism. Although the project is not focused on developing morphing technologies, the aircraft configurations and the adopted tools will be able to include and quantify the gain in load alleviation due to the morphing capabilities. The expected benefits can be quantified as a reduction in aircraft drag greater than 8% together with a reduction of the structural weight greater than 10%. This combination will provide a reduction in fuel burn and pollutant emissions of at least 20% using today's engines.

2) Economy. The impact here is through enhancing the efficiency and performance of businesses, contributing toward wealth creation and economic prosperity.

Innovation in industrial aircraft design is hindered by the lack of adequate methodologies to be employed in the development of new design concepts and technologies. Hence, there is an immense potential for new methodologies, overcoming limitations of current methods and enhancing physical insights, to be integrated within an industrial environment. Any improvements, in particular, in the areas of aeroelastics and loads can lead to: a) reduction in structural weight compared to today's reference aircraft; b) reduction in induced drag, hence a reduction in fuel burn; and c) reduction in flight tests for assessing the flight control laws, hence a reduction in the time to bring new aircraft on the market.

The PI will continue to work closely with the Project Partner (Airbus Operations Ltd) to transfer and implement new methods within an industrial environment. A demonstration on current aircraft configuration will be carried out to highlight expected improvements. These actions will foster global economic performance, in particular, the economic competitiveness of the UK, and increase the effectiveness of the aerospace sector (see Letter of Support from Airbus Operations Ltd).

3) Knowledge. The impact here is through: a) enhancing the research capacity, knowledge and skills of businesses and organisations; and b) training of skilled people for non-academic professions.

Throughout the duration of the FALCon project, the PI will be engaged with the Project Partner to conduct a review of the industrial aircraft design process, as well as to facilitate the transfer of research methods to industry. During this phase, the PI will train a number of qualified engineers to use effectively the new methodologies, and explore potential ways to enhance the current design loop. In addition to this, the wider community of the CEASIOM software will benefit from improved methods (see Letter of Support from CFSE).

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Drofelnik J (2019) Fast identification of transonic buffet envelope using computational fluid dynamics in Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology

publication icon
Franciolini M (2018) Efficient infinite-swept wing solver for steady and unsteady compressible flows in Aerospace Science and Technology

publication icon
Kharlamov D. (2021) AIAA Journal in Fast Load Calculations based on a Generalised Unsteady Coupling Algorithm

publication icon
Li D (2018) A review of modelling and analysis of morphing wings in Progress in Aerospace Sciences

 
Description The most significant achievement from the award is the development of a software tool with an unprecedented level of efficiency (up to 97% compared to state of the art methods) while maintaining the accuracy in calculating aerodynamic loads around an aircraft configuration. This demonstrates that excellent academic research can have a real and tangible impact on improving the pace at which aircraft design proceeds through maturity gates.

All objectives of the FALCon project were met.

Capitalising on the outgrowth of the FALCon project, we have started looking at various research directions: a) investigating the sensitivity of the optimal aerodynamic shape on the modelling (how optimal is the optimal solution?); b) introducing the sizing of the high-lift actuators on the aero-structural optimisation problem; and c) assessing the impact of aerodynamic uncertainties on the aeroelastic response of three-dimensional configurations.
Exploitation Route A collaboration University of Southampton/Airbus/Moog is exploiting the FALCon software tool for sizing the high-lift actuators and use accurate estimates to "enrich" the classic aero-structural optimisation taking it to a further complexity.

It is worth mentioning that FALCon has become an instrumental enabler for a large, Airbus-led project under the Aerospace Technology Institute funding. To date, the project proposal is being submitted. Hence, the outcomes of FALCon attracted significant attention from one of the project stakeholders who is planning to continue developing the tools to support next-gen vehicles. This is an excellent example of how academic research can improve real-world challenges and can produce deep changes to the working methods.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine

 
Description The methods and tools developed within FALCon project were deployed at Airbus Operations Ltd for production. The software finds a good fit within the industrial environment as it provides a unified approach to analyse low-speed and high-speed performances during the conceptual and preliminary design phases of the aircraft design. Before the introduction of the software, different and often incompatible tools were used in the low-speed and high-speed regimes. Benefiting from the developed software, aircraft design is further streamlined because a unified tool is deployed across different disciplines and relevant physical phenomena are captured correctly in the simulations. The implemented methods have been used in the order of 10,000 times by Airbus to support routine calculations and to explore new design concepts. There is a strong interest to bring these methods and tools to a deeper deployment within the industrial environment, and new research streams are being considered to allow further extensions into areas that are becoming more relevant as futuristic concepts are considered.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine
Impact Types Economic

 
Description (IMPACT) - Aircraft advanced rear end and empennage optimisation enhanced by anti-ice coatings and devices
Amount € 1,882,658 (EUR)
Funding ID 885052 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 09/2020 
End 08/2023
 
Description AFOSR
Amount $140,000 (USD)
Funding ID FA9550-17-1-0324 
Organisation Airforce Office of Scientific Research 
Sector Public
Country United States
Start 08/2017 
End 08/2020
 
Description EPSRC Industrial CASE Studentship 2017
Amount £27,800 (GBP)
Funding ID 17100044 
Organisation Airbus Group 
Department Airbus Operations
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 09/2021
 
Description H2020-MG-2016-2017, MG-1.3-2017
Amount £5,000,000 (GBP)
Organisation European Commission H2020 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 06/2018 
End 05/2021
 
Title Fast Aerodynamic Calculations based on a Generalised Unsteady Coupling Algorithm 
Description *** DOI assigned 10.5258/SOTON/D1717*** Database in support of AIAA Journal publication "Fast Aerodynamic Calculations based on a Generalised Unsteady Coupling Algorithm" 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The database is in support of a journal publication to appear in AIAA Journal, 2021. It contains first-time presented results obtained with the methods and tools developed in FALCon. Due to the novelty of the results and the test cases, it is expected the database will attract attention from the community working on fast aerodynamic methods. 
 
Description Noesis Solutions N.V. 
Organisation Noesis Solutions NV
Country Belgium 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution My research group has teamed up with engineers at Noesis Solutions N.V. to work on the process integration software platform Optimus. Optimus is a large software tool, and my team has addressed challenges related to the adaptive design of experiments methodology, which are currently used within an industrial environment for surrogate-based optimisation and uncertainty analysis.
Collaborator Contribution Noesis Solutions N.V. has provided, free of charge, the commercial software Optimus for a long time. They have also provided their experience, and time on a weekly basis, as well as the ability to take quick actions in case of unforeseen problems. Overall, they provided a well-rounded support for our research activities.
Impact Da Ronch A, Panzeri M, Abd Bari MA, d'Ippolito R and Franciolini M, "Adaptive design of experiments for efficient and accurate estimation of aerodynamic loads", Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology, 2017; 89(4): 558-569 doi: 10.1108/AEAT-10-2016-0173 Da Ronch A, Panzeri M, Drofelnik J and Roberto d'Ippolito, "Sensitivity and calibration of turbulence model in presence of epistemic uncertainties", Aeronautical Journal. Submitted 17 Jan 2018
Start Year 2017
 
Title Infinite-swept wing solver in DLR-Tau 
Description Through the EPSRC-funded project FALCon, we have developed, implemented, and validated a now algorithmic solution that was found to reduce the CPU time by 80 - 97% compared to existing state-of-the-art solvers. This solver has been implemented into DLR-Tau flow solver starting from version 2016.1.0 and it is now deployed for production in Airbus Operations Ltd. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact Software tool developed in academia has been integrated into a large software platform, now used by Airbus Operations Ltd for production. 
 
Description Open Days at University of Southampton 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Participation to several Open Days at the University of Southampton. The purpose is to attract high quality students and encourage more women to participate at STEM related activities. Talks about the impact of FALCon project at industrial level attracted attention from visitors, inspired by the outcomes of academic research to address real-world challenges.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018