Optimal geometric structures for hyperbolic groups

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Mathematics

Abstract

This project studies what are known as Gromov hyperbolic groups. A 'group' is a collection of symmetries of some geometric object, and properties of this geometric object correspond to algebraic properties of the group. One of the most important properties of a geometric object is its curvature: is it flat like a plane, positively curved like a sphere, or negatively curved. This last case, called hyperbolic geometry, is less familiar, but is very important as it is the one which arises most often. In the 1980s, Mikhail Gromov introduced what are now known as Gromov hyperbolic groups as a very large and flexible class of negatively curved groups; in some sense almost every group is Gromov hyperbolic.

Rigidity phenomena are of interest throughout mathematics, where some weak resemblance can be upgraded to a strong similarity. A deeply influential example of this is Mostow's Rigidity Theorem, which says that hyperbolic geometry in dimensions three and higher is rigid: if one finite volume hyperbolic object can be deformed into another such object, then they must have had the exact same shape to begin with. The aim of this project is to understand the geometric structure of Gromov hyperbolic groups and explore surprising rigidity properties which they have.

One goal concerns Gromov hyperbolic groups which are close to being one-dimensional, that is, they are groups of symmetries of spaces which grow at rates arbitrarily close to that of a hyperbolic plane. Sometimes these actually are groups of symmetries of the hyperbolic plane: they have an optimal geometric structure as follows from a deep theorem of Casson-Jungreis and Gabai. This part of the project is concerned with the near-misses which do not have the optimal structure: it aims to show that such groups must be of a very specific algebraic form.

The project will also study how hyperbolic groups can act in a volume-respecting way as is of fundamental importance in ergodic theory and dynamical systems. In this context, I will look at hyperbolic groups which have Kazhdan's property (T). This property, introduced by Kazhdan in the 1960s, is a rigidity property in dynamics which is extremely useful in algebra and geometry, and has applications in computer science through the construction of expander graphs. Hyperbolic groups with property (T) are interesting for their connections with probability: Zuk showed in 2003 that certain random groups almost surely have these properties, and recently such groups have arisen as fundamental groups of random topological objects. The project aims to show that hyperbolic groups with property (T) are particularly well-behaved and have an optimal geometric structure.

Approaching these goals will require the use of a mix of ideas and expertise from algebra, analysis and the geometry of group actions.

Planned Impact

This work will benefit researchers in the areas of geometric group theory, analysis on metric spaces and dynamics of group actions. It will do so by bringing together ideas from these different areas in order to open up new connections and provide new tools for future research.

The groups studied in this project are of interest both inside and outside mathematics. One of the earliest applications of Kazhdan's property (T) was Margulis' construction of explicit families of expander graphs. These are graphs which are very highly connected, and so serve as good models for a robust computer network, for example. Hyperbolic groups with property (T) arise in probability as generic groups, and also as fundamental groups of random simplicial complexes. Such random geometric objects are of interest in topological data science and statistics. In this area, one looks for topological features of large data sets which persist under varying forms of measurement; to help quantify which features are relevant it is potentially useful to better understand generic features of random objects. This project will show that such fundamental groups admit an optimal geometric structure, and contact will be made with experts in this field to explore potential applications of this phenomenon.

Beyond pure mathematics, the economic contributions of mathematical science research to the UK are enormous. The 2012 Deloitte report for EPSRC indicated that around 16% of UK Gross Value Added, and over 2.8 million jobs are in this area. As this same report acknowledges, in pure mathematics often the economic benefits are seen further down the road, and in unexpected ways, so strengthening the UK's research base in this area is a wise long-term investment. For example, coarse geometric methods have recently been used in topological data analysis. The proposed research will further strengthen the UK's position as a world leader in geometric group theory. Moreover, it will reinforce academic links between the University of Bristol and Universite Paris-Sud, as well as forge new connections with the fast-developing mathematical community in Uruguay.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Cashen C (2019) A metrizable topology on the contracting boundary of a group in Transactions of the American Mathematical Society

publication icon
Gruber D (2021) Random triangular Burnside groups in Israel Journal of Mathematics

publication icon
Hume D (2020) Poorly connected groups in Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society

publication icon
Hume D (2022) Poincaré profiles of Lie groups and a coarse geometric dichotomy in Geometric and Functional Analysis

publication icon
Hume D (2020) Poincaré profiles of groups and spaces in Revista Matemática Iberoamericana

publication icon
Mackay J (2020) Quasi-hyperbolic planes in relatively hyperbolic groups in Annales Academiae Scientiarum Fennicae Mathematica

 
Description The research funded by this grant has had a major impact on our understanding of groups with negative curvature characteristics.

In joint work with Hume and Tessera, we have shown that for hyperbolic groups whose boundaries achieve their conformal dimension, then this dimension is monotonic under coarse embeddings and so provides a new obstruction to such embeddings existing. This phenomenon was found as just one part of an extensive investigation into the "Poincaré Profile" of a group or graph, which we introduced as a generalisation of the "separation profile" of Benjamini, Schramm and Timar.

Major progress has been made in the study of Gromov hyperbolic groups whose boundaries are close to one-dimensional in joint work with Carrasco Piaggio, fully realising the objectives of this part of the proposal. This work took extended time due to the exciting extension of the methods developed to a more general combination theorem for computing analytic properties in terms of the group's algebraic structure; this paper is now submitted.

One major source of hyperbolic groups with Kazhdan's property (T) are random groups in the triangular model above density one-third. In an unexpected direction, with Gruber we have shown that in a range of densities these groups asymptotically almost surely are acylindrically hyperbolic with uniform constants. Using machinery of Coulon this means we can find a new random model of some of the most mysterious objects in group theory, studied for over one hundred years: Burnside groups.

Finally, many groups are not hyperbolic, but may have some "hyperbolic-like" directions. One way to study these directions is with the contracting boundary of Charney and Sultan and Cordes. This boundary has many useful properties, but its topology is typically not metrisable: with Cashen we found a new, coarser, topology on the contracting boundary which is metrisable, and also retains good properties such as quasi-isometric invariance. This opens up the prospect of using metric, and hence analytic, techniques to study new families of groups.
Exploitation Route Our work on Poincaré profiles has opened up an array of questions of interest and techniques to apply to geometric group theory problems, particularly embedding problems. We expect that these profiles will also be of interest to graph theorists, and indeed our methods have strong links to the rich literature in this area. In another direction, the metrisable topology on the contracting boundary gives a new invariant which is of particular interest to researchers working on CAT(0) groups such as those which can be cubulated; such groups are central to current advances in geometric group theory.
Sectors Education

 
Description Minicourse on Conformal Dimension at Ventotene International Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This prestigious international conference series brings together leading researchers and postgraduate students from around the world, with the focus of the 2019 conference being "Quasi-isometries and groups: rigidity and classification". In addition to research talks there are three minicourses given by experts intended to engage postgraduate students in the area. Mackay gave a three hour minicourse on conformal dimension, building up to and including results arising from this grant.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.ventoteneinternationalworkshops.net/ventotene-2019/
 
Description Minicourse on Conformal Dimension at the Technion 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The PI was invited to give an introductory minicourse on Conformal Dimension to an audience of postgraduates and academics at the Technion in Haifa, Israel, in July 2017. This audience (of around a dozen mainly postgraduate students) was from diverse mathematical areas, and further discussions followed indicating that several participants were interested in learning the PI's methods to use in their own work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Young Geometric Group Theory, Oxford March 2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The PI co-organised, along with Dr Aditi Kar, and Dr Anne Thomas, the Young Geometric Group Theory conference in Oxford. This brought together around 150 doctoral students and young researchers, to allow them to learn from one another, and from international senior mathematicians who gave mini-courses (G. Arzhantseva, E. Breuillard, M. Burger, A. Reid). The aim was to introduce and train postgraduate students in this area of research, and to provide manifold opportunities for collaborations and discussions. The conference was supported by grants won from the Clay Mathematics Institute (approx. £8k), Heilbronn Institute for Mathematical Research (£4k), London Mathematical Society (£5k), (USA) National Science Foundation (approx. £15k), and by the Universities of Oxford and Southampton.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.personal.rhul.ac.uk/udah/001/YGGTVI.htm