Charging ahead with Multi-layer Ceramic Capacitor materials

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Materials Science and Engineering

Abstract

Multi-layered ceramic capacitors (MLCCs) are the foundation of the electronics (passive components) industry. Each layer within a MLCC is made by sintering a powdered, typically a chemically-doped, functional oxide such as Barium Titanate. This processing route generates a complex microstructure that can include grains, grain-boundaries, pores, interface roughness and graded material properties. Many of these microstructural effects are known to influence device performance but the knowledge of their exact mechanism and strength of their effect is limited. At present the favoured approach towards optimising these effects is based on trial and error experimentation; however, this is challenging and time and resource consuming. It would benefit both academics and industry working on MLCC systems to be able to analyse such microstructural phenomena in a resource efficient, controlled and systematic way. This would not only allow a faster route towards optimisation of current materials and devices, but also allow quickly the analysis of rare earth-free sustainable alternatives.
To achieve this, the project will develop new capabilities in modelling functional materials. We shall develop an advanced microstructural package to create realistic three-dimensional microstructures representing the main microstructural features listed above. By combining this with a state-of-the-art finite element modelling package, we shall be able to test what effects these have on device performance and allow us to guide the processing of the underlaying materials. While this proposal will be targeted towards challenges in functional oxide materials for MLCCs, due to the flexibility of the methodologies used, the codes will also be applicable to a much wider range of functional materials and devices. This includes but is not limited to solid oxide fuel cells, thermoelectric generators, piezo-electric sensors & actuators and beyond into magnetic and radiation damaged materials.
The microstructural generation package will be based on two sources. Firstly, systems will be created from the analysis of experimental microstructures supplied by experimental groups and our industrial partner (AvX Ltd). Secondly, artificial systems will be generated using an array of mathematical algorithms, allowing controllable characteristics and a systematic approach in analysis. The first study using this new package will be to better understand how the doping of the ceramic material, that forms the physical 'core-shell' microstructure, can influence the current flow through the microstructure. This will be extended to how inadequate mixing of the dopants into the base material can manifest itself in a poor electrical response and performance of the device. Further analysis will be conducted on the effects of porosity and interfacial ceramic/metal electrode roughness that contribute to advancing degradation in in MLCCs and are ultimately considered to be the limiting factors in device lifetime.

Planned Impact

Economy & Society:
Demand for multi-layered ceramic capacitors (MLCCs) from computing, automotive, aerospace and telecommunication industries is for smaller components with stable operation at higher temperatures. This is central to a $10 billion global market with an estimated 2 trillion units sold in 2015, predicted to increase to over 3 trillion by 2020.
It is commonly known that changes in microstructure of functional oxide materials can dramatically affect performance. It is unclear however what microstructural features would be required to increase performance, for example to achieve a suitable temperature stable-high permittivity profile (an important figure of merit known as the Temperature Coefficient of Capacitance, TCC).
While leading companies such as Murata, Kyocera and AVX Ltd possess extensive knowledge in materials development, TCC optimisation is achieved by incremental iterative changes to the processing conditions. This is an experimentally based process and generates a prohibitively high cost in time, resource and money in the R&D requirement, acting as a barrier for commercialising new materials. For the UK to remain competitive with overseas companies, it is essential that necessary fundamental research is made towards enhancing MLCC materials for higher performance applications using a faster, cheaper more robust method.
This proposal addresses this by creating a modelling framework that designs complex polycrystalline microstructures for use in multi-layered systems and solves for their electrical response. This will allow us to identify the desired microstructural features quickly providing, guiding the processing to address key industrial issues. This will save significant time and cost in optimisation but also provide advise on materials where optimisation would be ineffective.
After validating this methodology, we will begin to design materials with improved performance assisted by the experimental groups and our industrial partner AvX Ltd (based in Coleraine, Northern Ireland). Furthermore we will also explore new device concepts for MLCCs allowing the UK to maintain competitiveness in the global market.
People:
A PDRA employed on the project will be trained in generating realistic microstructures and solving for their electrical response. This will provide a valuable extension to their skills. In addition, the individual will have the opportunity to improve their transferable skills (writing, presenting) that will be invaluable in a career inside or outside of academia. The PhD students interacting with the packages will benefit from additional skills in programming, using a high performance cluster but also benefit their work directly. Taught masters and undergraduates within the Materials Science and Engineering department will have the opportunity to work on small research projects associated with this work which will provide useful training for their future careers. Finally this funding will also allow my group to grown and gain new capabilities of our in house finite element modelling package, allowing me to become world leading simulating functional materials and strengthen modelling as a whole in the UK.
Knowledge:
Bringing new modelling methods to experimental research teams in functional materials will be a major impact. The new tools will enable novel approaches in understand how the electrical microstructure and ultimately the response of a given physical microstructure can be controlled. This project will provide a platform to engage the public with more fundamental scientific issues, by using the performance and sustainability of MLCCs as a starting point in developing materials for the future. Therefore, science education of the general public will be a key impact from this project. As the project progresses contact will be made with groups outside academic research and there will be dissemination of the knowledge of these modelling methods into industrial R&D group.
 
Title The Electric Field (part of the festival of the mind) 
Description A virtual tour (interactive 3D virtual reality) of a mobile phone to show off the significance of the next generation multi-layered ceramic capacitors. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact A really great teaching tool, this has been used to start discussion in a number of outreach events and lectures i have given. 
URL https://vimeo.com/291514108
 
Description We have successfully developed an advanced micro-strutural design package allowing us to describe functional oxide ceramic materials to a greater degree of accuracy and realism. This has allowed us to study the influence of key micro-strutural features and its effect on impedance spectacular, a key experimental characterisation tool. Using our finite element approach, we have studied how using certain processing routes can lead to porosity within a material and ultimately reduce the lifetime of the multi-layer ceramic capacitor that is made from it. The work has been published and disseminated to industry. Furthermore we have developed novel strategies, based on simulations, to help guide the processing of functional oxide materials for improved device performance. Using this new approach, we have been successful in an InnovateUK application, via a knowledge transfer partnership (KTP), to work with industry to put these ideas into practice. We have also looked at the effect of the size and shape of the pores which have been published and have begun to use this work here, to inform other areas of research in porous materials such as metallic foams and resins.
Exploitation Route The findings have been significant to both academic and industrial. Academically the development of our new software allows to not only to simulate functional oxides, but look at other granular / particulate systems such as metals, composites, resins. Our simulation have also benefited industry by guiding them on key design parameters to improve both performance and lifetime of their components.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Electronics,Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description One of the key findings was using the code generated to simulate the effect of porous ceramic materials in partnership with AvX (Finite element modeling on the effect of intra-granular porosity on the dielectric properties of BaTiO3 MLCCs, 2017, J. Am. Cerm. Soc. 101, 1211-1220). This work provided a greater theory than was presently available in understanding how pores reduce lifetime of manufactured components . As such, the company have now put measures into place within their production to avoid such issues, improving their lifetime as well as making them more competitive with overseas competition, key in the automotive aspects of their work. The study has impacted, in a positive way, the way companies look at using FEM for assessing changes in functional oxide materials for MLCCs and also help highlight the significance to the research community as a whole. The FEM methods developed through this grant are now not only being used in additional functional materials research from microwave dielectrics to battery materials but to further diverse areas such as materials for structural applications, include polymer and resins, cementitious materials and even fusion technologies, where impedance analysis is starting to be used to determine how materials microstructure effects radiation damage and recovery. These findings have also been used to inform and shape content for undergraduate level teaching and inspired a number of outreach events and activities. Finally there is now a wider impact in the education in and around the area on the importance and limitations of electronic devices (specifically multilayered ceramic capacitors) through the outreach talks and "electric field' virtual experience which use much of the research here. (see engagement details for more information)
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Electronics,Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Knowledge Transfer Partnership
Amount £244,701 (GBP)
Funding ID KTP011028 
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start  
 
Description Festival of the mind 2018 (interactive event and talk) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Festival of the Mind is a unique collaboration between our academic colleagues and experts from Sheffield's cultural and creative industries. It is about welcoming the public and our students from all over the world - as we celebrate our University and our city, with themes that are both local and global. it attracted over 50,000 visitors to its performances, talks, exhibitions, virtual reality experiences and interactive events.
As part of this, I design, and managed creating a virtual tour of the key aspects of this research (the microstructure of a multi-layered ceramic capacitor). This combined with a talk to the general public meant I reached a large number of local colleges, schools and general public in understanding eh scientific challenges in this area and what I was doing to try and address them.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://festivalofthemind.group.shef.ac.uk/material-space-electric-field-talk/