Enhancing the Methane Generation from Food Waste Anaerobic Digestion Mediated by Fluidic Oscillator Generated Microbubbles

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Chemical & Biological Engineering

Abstract

As a civilisation, we generate an enormous amount of food waste with over 2 billion tonnes produced per year, much of which can be utilised as energy using AD in a sustainable manner if properly processed. The EU, with UK being the leading offender, generates over 89 MT of food waste per year. This waste can be redistributed as food source for animals as a first step, but with that failing, it is better to recover the energy using AD. AD represents nutrient recovery and is a preferred option over all other means of waste management as prescribed by the Waste Food Hierarchy discussed in the 2015 House of Lords report on food waste. AD is a process which converts food waste or biomass or manure in anaerobic (without presence of air) conditions by the breakdown of higher chain compounds into methane and other lower chain compounds. This process conventionally follows the following steps - 1. Placing biomass (wet food waste) into sealed air tight container 2. Digestion of this biomass(wet food waste) using anaerobic microbes present in the system to produce methane rich biogas to be used for energy generation 3. Digestate to be used as manure or compost
The pathway we are proposing is replacing the airtight container with fluidically oscillated CO2 rich microbubbles obtained by sweetening of the flue gas on-site using CaCaCa process[1] and microbubble technology[2-5]. Periodic injection (5 minute) of CO2 rich microbubbles has shown to increase CH4 production by 110% as compared to the conventional process. This is a dual pronged process with removal of metabolites/wastes by microbubble stripping and simultaneous nutrient injection. The CH4 generated can be used for energy generation thereby offsetting fossil fuel use and reduce Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Emissions . We get the CO2 rich microbubbles by sweetening biogas gas using the CaCaCa process in order to capture the CH4 which is then burnt and the flue gas is CO2 rich (potentially with water vapour which can be easily condensed. This is further self sustaining since the burning of the CH4 produced in the first step leads to flue gas generation. The fluidic oscillator for microbubble generation underpins the sweetening and methanogenesis (the process in AD wherein methane is generated). This greatly increases the value of products formed in AD whilst consuming the CO2 generated thereby further offsetting GHG emissions. Recovering the heat from the process add to this energy balance which can be used for on-site heating via Combined Heat and Power (CHP). The project is going to investigate the onsite prototype build of this novel fluidically oscillated CO2 rich microbubble process for AD and simultaneous sweetening of the flue gas generated using the CaCaCa process optimised with Perlemax's fluidic oscillator driven microbubbles. The CHP and CH4 generation can be further increased by optimisation of the process variables as discussed in AppendixB part 2. This would possibly increase CH4 generation over the slated 110%.
This ensures a minimisation of the carbon footprint whilst maximisation of the energy generated for the same. The combination of these potential benefits could be economic without subsidy or tariff skewing the market.

Planned Impact

In summary, this proposal aims to support the circular economy whereby waste materials, specifically food wastes are-purposed, re-used, or become feedstocks for other processes in order to create value from waste. It aims to exploit the new enabling features of microbubble AD to generate 100-110% more methane and then using microbubble mediated mineral carbonation to sweeten the biogas to sequester the CO2 and generate enriched CH4 which can be used for energy generation or stored and sent off to the electricity grid.

The exploitation path, however, for this proposal is tightly aligned to the endusers. The endusers would welcome the increase in the process efficiency and energy generation as well as a process that sequesters the CO2 whilst achieving the primary goals of the plant. The process integration achieves a reduction in OPEX due to the increase in CH4 production and the is only a significant increase in CAPEX. The co-product in this is a high quality manure making this process extremely beneficial and wide reaching in its impact to industry in a variety of sectors.

Perlemax are looking to exploit their IP around their patent portfolio, and catalyse the industrial early adoption of their technology for microbubble AD. This proposal is directed at the perceived barriers to commercialisation -- scale up and demonstration at sufficient scale to warrant industrial scale demonstration. CaCaCa and Perlemax would like to see the mineral carbonation operate onsite in order to establish key performance parameters with which they can be benchmarked with current technology. This technology can be used across a wide set of sectors and therefore wouldn't have many problems for the same.

The short term impact will be made with the commercial partners on the grant, but their commercial plans are to roll out the technology to endusers, but likely to license it to a service company for the waste management sector.
 
Description Prior to starting this proposal, we published a Chemical Engineering Science with proof of concept in the laboratory that dosing with CO2-rich microbubbles for just five minutes a daycould enhance the rate of methane production by *double*, i.e. the typical 20+ day cycle could be halved. Laboratory-based optimisation studies varying the key parameters now suggest that the acceleration is by a factor of 4-6, crucially by using only sub-100 micron diameter bubbles. The pilot plant study with industrial partners on the InnovateUK grant is achieved in the initial instance a doubling of the methane production rate. Getting further tests with commercial partners Viridor at the Parkwood landfill site in Sheffield is delayed while Environment Agency approval is sought, but should occur in 2019.
The first, unoptimised, pilot scale study achieved 100% rate increase over the conventional time scale for anaerobic digestion to produce all the expected biogas yield. The Parkwood site is now operational, and further experimentation with the assembled facility from the grant is underway.
Exploitation Route The InnovateUK award is focussed on commercialisation and development. We are engaging with potential enduser / commercialisation partners, and community facilitiators such as BioVale, and the Catapult, CPI, to arrange further testing. An CalSeed grant, led by Univeristy of California at Riversidewith additional support from the City of Riverside municipal government, was awarded in 2018 and expected to start in summer 2019. (Delayed until at least 2020 due to the decisions by Californian coordinators).
Perlemax, the industrial led partner on the InnovateUK award, is part of a consortium looking to exploit the findings and followup studies (see the URL above about the award by the Anaerobic Digestion and Bioresource Association, international award for Best Industrial R&D Innovation, 2019) for upscaling through a Strength in Places Fund bid with other Yorkshire and Humberside AD R&D and enduser organizations. We believe we have found a fundamental new mechanism by which microbubbles accelerate metabolism of microorganism communities, which will be pursued in EPSRC grant proposal in progress.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Energy,Environment

URL https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/cbe/news/research-project-scoops-top-industry-award
 
Description Spinout company Perlemax and partner Viridor (waste management company serving Sheffield) conducted pilot scale trials at Parkwood (Sheffield city centre waste management facility) on the major advances first studied in this InnovateUK Energy Catalyst programme. A business plan was developed, which unfortunately, due to corporate takeover, Viridor is not participating in. However, the business plan underpins a ~£2m new facility to be built in Malaysia by government contract. The contract was approved in May, 2021, but has been delayed by the pandemic disruption. Still delayed. Another Saudi Arabian government initiative is progressing for full scale testing to the contract stage in Spring 2023. More details will be reported in the next ResearchFish period as the "Waste Factory" project initiates.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Energy
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description c1net Proof of Concept Microbubble enhanced gas exchange in a methanotroph gas fermenter
Amount £50,000 (GBP)
Funding ID POC-19-zimmerman-C1net 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2017 
End 05/2018
 
Description Collaboration with Viridor on Anaerobic Fermentations and Ammonia/Methane Stripping processes mediated by Microbubbles 
Organisation Viridor
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Collaboration with Viridor on Anaerobic Fermentations and Ammonia/Methane Stripping processes mediated by Microbubbles
Collaborator Contribution Collaboration with Viridor on Anaerobic Fermentations and Ammonia/Methane Stripping processes mediated by Microbubbles
Impact Still ongoing
Start Year 2017
 
Title FLUIDIC OSCILATORS 
Description A new fluidic oscillator is described comprising at least one inlet port (57) in communication with at least two outlets (61) via a nozzle region A and two outlet conduits (58, 62), the two outlet conduits being separated from each other by a splitter region and each outlet conduit comprising a resonance chamber (60) in fluid communication with the conduit. The resonance chambers are key in controlling the oscillation of the device and the fluidic oscillator is operated through a new acoustic switching mode. 
IP Reference WO2020208250 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2020
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact This new oscillator has been demonstrated to achieve very rapid removal of ammonia from wastewaters and digester centrates, with tuneable liquid volumes, via microbubble distillation. A waste management company has supported pilot scale trials for landfill leachate remediation with this oscillator making the liquid treatment volumes readily engineered via conventional size plumbing.
 
Company Name REEPEL LTD 
Description Reepel is a vertical farming company that has a unique selling point in how it engages with the circular economy for novel fertilizers that use waste ammonia and carbon capture technology, exploiting fluidic engineering design including microbubbles for microgation and Desai Artificial Lichen (like dispersed small biofilms complexed around microbubbles) with in situ surface cleaning / removal of biofilms due to dispersed microbubbles. 
Year Established 2020 
Impact The company has won, as part of a consortium of partner companies, an InnovateUK and a BEIS grant (confidential at the moment), for UK-based R&D on the technology. It already has a demonstration in Dubai and is short-listed for facilities implementation in some Middle East sustainable cities projects.
Website https://www.reepel.co.uk/
 
Description Contributed as a technical expert to a television episode on mysterious occurrences in seas/ waterways 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I contributed to the technical content and was interviewed on the Discovery Channel series "Mysteries of the Deep" (Season 1) on the topic of bio/chemical methane microbubble releases from the ocean floor in the Bermuda Triangle, and how such localized releases cause "sinkholes" due to density variation on the ocean surface. The stronger the release, the more likely that craft experiencing such a "sinkhole" would crash to the bottom of the ocean, arriving with significant momentum, potentially decimated on impact. Releases are accompanied by electrokinetic effects on the surfaces of any vessel in passed by the plume, which can build up substantial charge/potential, similar to a Vandergraaf device, playing havoc with controls and radio transmissions. The producers had documented significant releases, vented from volcanic activity or from pockets captured from bio/chemical activity, as well as anecdotal encounters of "boiling seas", and were looking for the science underpinning methane microbubble plumes.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/cbe/news/professor-zimmerman-stars-new-show-discovery-channel