Robotic Inspection of Mooring Chains in Air and Water (RIMCAW)

Lead Research Organisation: London South Bank University
Department Name: School of Engineering

Abstract

Failure of mooring chains that secure floating structures in off-shore production of oil and gas results in oil leaks due to the rupture of flexible pipes that bring product to the surface. The clean-up costs of environmental pollution run into hundreds of millions of pounds. It is therefore important to inspect the mooring chain links to assess the extent of corrosion, fatigue cracking and developing weld faults before they result in failure of a chain. It is very expensive to remove a chain weighing many tons and bring it to shore to inspect it. Savings can be made by performing non-destructive testing (NDT) of a chain in-situ while it is in operation. The heavy chains generate large dynamic forces so that inspection using divers is extremely hazardous. The project aims to develop a small, compact mobile robot that can climb on mooring chains both underwater and in air to scan chain links with advanced ultrasound sensors. The robotic NDT system will provide a tool to assess the condition of mooring chains to enable asset managers to make decisions on repair and remaining lifetime of a chain. It will reduce inspection costs by speeding up coverage of a mooring chain and remove the need for diver inspection which costs £40,000 per floating structure and puts their lives at risk.

Planned Impact

PESTLE analysis indicates that oil will remain important for the world economy for the next 20 years with rising demand forecast; increasing offshore oil extraction will promote new oil & gas projects and increase the market size for RIMCAW to meet fast emerging technology requirements for NDT that minimises human intervention; more preventive maintenance and continuous monitoring of moorings will increase the demand for NDT autonomous products; remote automated monitoring will become important making RIMCAW an ideal solution. Wider expected Impacts from a successful uptake of RIMCAW are:
(a) Reduced environmental impact and improved safety of offshore production [5]. Loss of platforms due to chain failure result in rupture of oil risers which is costly (£3M per day from lost production alone). It damages the environment e.g. the Deepwater Horizon incident in 2010 cost BP £90bn, prompted new safety legislation in the US and Europe (2015 US offshore safety drilling rule, 2013 EU Offshore Safety Directive).
(b) Improved profitability of operators: By reducing production losses from mooring failure (estimated £3M in lost production), reducing leaks and downtime, saving the industry £750 million over 4 years [6] and enabling monitoring service providers to deliver new services for more cost-effective asset management saving the industry £270M over 5 years. (c) Generate new business: Target users are asset operators doing own inspections, sub-sea engineering contractors and specialised inspection companies. Targeting UK companies with a global reach will create new jobs in the UK. In-situ NDT on mooring chains is a new market driven by very recent standards and directives. For the service provider, this will repay the investment in RIMCAW equipment within 1 year and generate revenues of £74M, creating 470 new jobs.
(d) Impact on Health and safety: The EU Safety of Offshore Oil and Gas Operations directive requires improvement of safety and reliability of moorings and risers in off-shore installations and makes companies fully liable for environmental damage. Operators are under increasing pressure to use cost-effective automated monitoring of the structural integrity of mooring chains. The EU Major Accident Reporting System database (MARS) records approximately 96 incidents relating to major accident potential and loss of containment 1980-2006, equates to an overall loss of 11 lives, 183 injuries and a loss of over £170Million. The risk of accidental deaths resulting from failure in mooring chains is far too high [7]
Remote automated NDT of mooring chains with RIMCAW will eliminate loss of lives and injuries to divers.
5] http://www.moorinspect.eu/partners.jsp,[6] http://www.innotecuk.com/-Majic,Hunter
[7] http://www.shipsandoil.com/features/ , [8] http://www.bu.edu/sustainability/ deepwater-horizon-oil-spill/ [9] Petroleumstilsynet report - www.ptil.no

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Developed a mooring chain climbing robot, the first of its kind that operates on chain sections that are both underwater and in air.This work was presented to stakeholders at a FPSO network meeting hosted by Oil and Gas UK, and extensively disseminated in trade newsletters and networks and via keynote lectures at international and national conferences.
The work demonstrated the use of phased array ultrasound deployed by a robot arm to inspect critical regions (crown region) of a chain link.
Exploitation Route Progression towards a higher TRL by the industrial companies collaborating in this project can result in a commercial product with large economic benefits.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Environment

URL http://www.lsbu.ac.uk/case-studies/rimcaw-robots-inspect-mooring-chains
 
Description In this 12-month project, London South Bank University's innovation Centre for the automation of NDT (LSBIC), performed the innovative design of a mooring chain climbing robot that enabled SME company InnotecUk to develop the RIMCAW climbing robot. The work was reported at the CLAWAR 2018 international conference held 10-14 Sept 2018, Panama: "Matthew Kimball, Gurvinder Singh Virk and Tariq Sattar, Moor chain climbing robot for NDT inspection applications". Related work led to the award of best paper by the CLAWAR Association to Mahesh Dissanayake, Md Omar Howlader, Tariq P. Sattar, Tat-Hean Gan, Ivan Pinson, "Development Of A Novel Crawler Based Robot For Mooring Chain Climbing". Successful trials of the robot were reported in the following trade journals: (a) Marine Technology - "Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials" (b) Subsea World News - "New Mooring Chain Inspection Robot Passes Field Trials" (c) Cambridge Network- "Climbing Robot With Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials". LSBIC gave invited talks to the PSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen: "Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection" and to the International Congress on Energy Efficiency and Energy Related Materials (ENEFM), 22-28 October 2019, Fethiye, Mugla- Turkey: "Inspecting critical infrastructure in the energy sector using mobile robots to perform non-destructive testing" During the project, LSBIC developed a 5-axis scanning arm equipped with a phased-array ultrasound system to perform automated full matrix capture to assess the structural integrity of mooring chains that has enabled TWI Ltd to develop a resource to research automated NDT on other projects. This work is reported in IEEE Access journal: Mahesh Dissanayake, David Carswell, Michael Corsar, Tariq Sattar, Mark Sutcliffe, Shehan Lowe, Tat-Hean Gan (2018), "Automated Application of Full Matrix Capture to Assess the Structural Integrity of Mooring Chains", IEEE Access, 26 Nov 2018, pages 1-12, Print and on-line ISSN: 2169-3536, DOI, 10.1109/ACCESS.2018.2883378
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Environment
Impact Types Economic

 
Description RIMCAW collaborations 
Organisation CIT-Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Knowledge transfer about the dimensions, types and operating environments for mooring chains, state-of-the-art climbing robots and magnetic adhesion systems. Our team generated designs of chain climbing robots, performed simulation and strength analysis of robot structures, permanent magnet adhesion systems and ultrasound NDT scanning arms. One climbing robot design and ultrasound probe holder was translated into laboratory evaluation prototypes and demonstrated to partners. A five axis scanning arm was modified to build a laboratory scanning arm to test the NDT deployment method and demonstrated to the collaborating partners. These results were shared with TWI, CIT and Innotec Ltd. to inform their development of a chain climbing robot and link scanning ultrasound NDT system.
Collaborator Contribution Our collaborating partners adopted our design of chain climbing robot, ultrasound probe holder for in-air NDT, and GUI. InnoTecUK constructed the fully integrated system for underwater testing in a diving tank. All partners participated in underwater trials ina diving tank owned by TWI in Middlesbrough. TWI and LSBU disseminated the results of this project via technology lectures, conference and journal, trade networks and news letters as follows:: 1. Talk by LSBU presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Keynote talk by LSBU: Inspecting critical infrastructure in the energy sector using mobile robots to perform non-destructive testing, 5th International Congress on Energy Efiiciency and Energy Related Materials (ENEFM), 22-28 October 2019, Fethiye, Mugla- Turkey 7. Keynote Lecture:, by LSBU: NDT robot applications in hazardous environments, at the Robots in Society: Event 2 - Current robotics organized by the Worshipful Company of Information Technologists, the Chartered Institute for IT and the CLAWAR Association, at London South Bank University, 8 Nov 2017 8. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Impact Outputs: 1. Two mooring chain climbing robot prototypes to demonstrate chain climbing capability, one completed by us and the other nearing completion by Innotec. 2. A laboratory five axis robot scanning arm to deploy and test phased array ultrasound probes on a chain link. 3. A special probe holder to present a phased array ultrasound probe with water couplant supply. 4. Experiments to NDT defects in a chain link. The project is multidisciplinary using robotics, the phased array ultrasound NDT technique, software for robot control and NDT data display. 4. Three articles in Conference proceedings and three journal articles. RIMCAW dissemination: 1. Talk presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Start Year 2017
 
Description RIMCAW collaborations 
Organisation Innovative Science and Technology Limited
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Knowledge transfer about the dimensions, types and operating environments for mooring chains, state-of-the-art climbing robots and magnetic adhesion systems. Our team generated designs of chain climbing robots, performed simulation and strength analysis of robot structures, permanent magnet adhesion systems and ultrasound NDT scanning arms. One climbing robot design and ultrasound probe holder was translated into laboratory evaluation prototypes and demonstrated to partners. A five axis scanning arm was modified to build a laboratory scanning arm to test the NDT deployment method and demonstrated to the collaborating partners. These results were shared with TWI, CIT and Innotec Ltd. to inform their development of a chain climbing robot and link scanning ultrasound NDT system.
Collaborator Contribution Our collaborating partners adopted our design of chain climbing robot, ultrasound probe holder for in-air NDT, and GUI. InnoTecUK constructed the fully integrated system for underwater testing in a diving tank. All partners participated in underwater trials ina diving tank owned by TWI in Middlesbrough. TWI and LSBU disseminated the results of this project via technology lectures, conference and journal, trade networks and news letters as follows:: 1. Talk by LSBU presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Keynote talk by LSBU: Inspecting critical infrastructure in the energy sector using mobile robots to perform non-destructive testing, 5th International Congress on Energy Efiiciency and Energy Related Materials (ENEFM), 22-28 October 2019, Fethiye, Mugla- Turkey 7. Keynote Lecture:, by LSBU: NDT robot applications in hazardous environments, at the Robots in Society: Event 2 - Current robotics organized by the Worshipful Company of Information Technologists, the Chartered Institute for IT and the CLAWAR Association, at London South Bank University, 8 Nov 2017 8. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Impact Outputs: 1. Two mooring chain climbing robot prototypes to demonstrate chain climbing capability, one completed by us and the other nearing completion by Innotec. 2. A laboratory five axis robot scanning arm to deploy and test phased array ultrasound probes on a chain link. 3. A special probe holder to present a phased array ultrasound probe with water couplant supply. 4. Experiments to NDT defects in a chain link. The project is multidisciplinary using robotics, the phased array ultrasound NDT technique, software for robot control and NDT data display. 4. Three articles in Conference proceedings and three journal articles. RIMCAW dissemination: 1. Talk presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Start Year 2017
 
Description RIMCAW collaborations 
Organisation TWI The Welding Institue
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Knowledge transfer about the dimensions, types and operating environments for mooring chains, state-of-the-art climbing robots and magnetic adhesion systems. Our team generated designs of chain climbing robots, performed simulation and strength analysis of robot structures, permanent magnet adhesion systems and ultrasound NDT scanning arms. One climbing robot design and ultrasound probe holder was translated into laboratory evaluation prototypes and demonstrated to partners. A five axis scanning arm was modified to build a laboratory scanning arm to test the NDT deployment method and demonstrated to the collaborating partners. These results were shared with TWI, CIT and Innotec Ltd. to inform their development of a chain climbing robot and link scanning ultrasound NDT system.
Collaborator Contribution Our collaborating partners adopted our design of chain climbing robot, ultrasound probe holder for in-air NDT, and GUI. InnoTecUK constructed the fully integrated system for underwater testing in a diving tank. All partners participated in underwater trials ina diving tank owned by TWI in Middlesbrough. TWI and LSBU disseminated the results of this project via technology lectures, conference and journal, trade networks and news letters as follows:: 1. Talk by LSBU presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Keynote talk by LSBU: Inspecting critical infrastructure in the energy sector using mobile robots to perform non-destructive testing, 5th International Congress on Energy Efiiciency and Energy Related Materials (ENEFM), 22-28 October 2019, Fethiye, Mugla- Turkey 7. Keynote Lecture:, by LSBU: NDT robot applications in hazardous environments, at the Robots in Society: Event 2 - Current robotics organized by the Worshipful Company of Information Technologists, the Chartered Institute for IT and the CLAWAR Association, at London South Bank University, 8 Nov 2017 8. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Impact Outputs: 1. Two mooring chain climbing robot prototypes to demonstrate chain climbing capability, one completed by us and the other nearing completion by Innotec. 2. A laboratory five axis robot scanning arm to deploy and test phased array ultrasound probes on a chain link. 3. A special probe holder to present a phased array ultrasound probe with water couplant supply. 4. Experiments to NDT defects in a chain link. The project is multidisciplinary using robotics, the phased array ultrasound NDT technique, software for robot control and NDT data display. 4. Three articles in Conference proceedings and three journal articles. RIMCAW dissemination: 1. Talk presented to the Integrity Management Group, TWI on 1st August 2018, Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains. 2. Article in SUBSEA WORLD NEWS: New mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 3. News article in Cambridge Network: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 4. News article in Marine Technology News, May 3 2018: Chain-climbing Underwater Robot Passes Trials 5. News article in NDT.NET ISSUE - 2018-06-NEWS: Climbing Robot with Ultrasonic Imaging For Mooring Chains Inspection Passes Field Trials 6. Invited talk: Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen
Start Year 2017
 
Title Mooring chain crawler 
Description First of their kind Mooring chain climbing robots. One robot climbs using permanent magnet adhesion to a link and uses tracked wheels for rapid motion. The other robot uses an inchworm motion method to climb on a chain. 
Type Of Technology Physical Model/Kit 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The two mooring chain climbing robots are the first of their type and the wheeled robot has so far been reported via two conference paper s and one accepted journal paper. The inchworm robot is nearing completing and will be tested in a water diving tank in March 2018 before the 12 month project finished on 31st March 2018. 
 
Description Article in Cambridge Network News 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Cambridge Network article " Climbing robot with ultrasonic imaging for mooring chains inspection passes field trials,
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.cambridgenetwork.co.uk/news/climbing-robot-with-ultrasonic-imaging-for-mooring-chains-in...
 
Description FPSO Network meeting, Aberdeen 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact This invited talk described the RIMCAW mooring chain inspection robot : Development of a mooring chain climbing robot for NDT inspection. FPSO network meeting, Oil and Gas UK, 20 June 2018, Aberdeen. The audience attendees were FPSO operators, engineers in the off-shore oil and gas industry. Great deal of interest was generated with follow up enquiries. Also resulted in Chevron discussing another off-shore problem looking for a possible solution.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description International Institute of Marine Surveying 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact International Institute of Marine Surveying published an article reporting results of field trials of the RIMCAW mooring chain inspection robot: "New innovation for inspecting mooring chains above and below water successfully trialled", May 8, 2018 by News Hound
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.iims.org.uk/new-innovation-inspecting-mooring-chains-water-successfully-trialled/
 
Description Keynote at CLAWAR 2017 and Robots in Society, London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Plenary keynote at the CLAWAR 2017 International conference held in Porto, Portugal in September 2017. The keynote made a case for the use of mobile robots in industrial inspection tasks to provide access to large safety critical infrastructure that may be located in hazardous and extreme environments. The AWI and RIMCAW projects served as case studies. A keynote was also presented at the "Robots in Society" event held in London in November 2017 where the use of inspection robots for operation in hazardous environments was presented as an example of the benign use of robots in society.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description NDT.net Journal 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact NDT.Net Journal, issue 2018-06: Climbing robot with ultrasonic imaging for mooring chains inspection passes field trials
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Paper presentations at CLAWAR 2017 International conference Portugal, IEEE ICIIS 2017 conference Sri Lanka, plenary keynote at CLAWAR 2017, keynote at Robots in Society conference, London, Poster presentation and talk to RAI networking event, London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The two conference papers were aimed at the robotics and engineering research community with up to 200 attendees. The Robots in Society event was aimed at a wider audience that included engineers, IT researchers and social scientists.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description RAI networking and Keynotes 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Poster and 3 minute presentation to describe the AWI project at the RAI networking event in London on 30 January 2018.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Seminar Integrity Management Group TWI 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk to the INTEGRITY MANAGEMENT GROUP , TWI. Non-Destructive Testing of Mooring Chains, 2018, 1st August. Described the RIMCAW project and its outcomes
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Subsea World News 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Subsea world news: New Mooring Chains Inspection Robot Passes Field Trials
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description TWI Inspection trials 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact TWI publicised results of the RIMCAW trials in a water tank in Middlesbrough: Article title: Climbing robot with ultrasonic imaging for mooring chains inspection passes field trials
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.twi-global.com/media-and-events/press-releases/2018-05-climbing-robot-with-ultrasonic-im...