Shape memory bone and soft tissue fixations

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bradford
Department Name: Faculty of Engineering and Informatics

Abstract

Building on our current research, we will explore enhanced bone to bone and soft tissue to bone fixation devices made from bionert and bioresorbable shape memory polymers (SMP). These recover or partially recover an initial shape when subject to an appropriate stimulus (usually heating) above their glass transition temperature. SMPs will be structured by processing operations, to obtain controlled molecular orientation, whose recovery drives shape reversion. The research will be undertaken in close collaboration with Innovate Orthopaedics, a medical device company and Clinicians from the Fortius Clinic.
The proposed research will address: (i) specific unmet clinical needs in major market segments, (including shoulder and knee ligament injuries, meniscal tears and scaphoid fractures); (ii) treatment of specific patient subgroups to achieve a reduced overall recovery time, including a faster 'return to function' time, e.g. older people - over 50's are more susceptible to traumatic and degenerative injuries; rising levels of obesity are a risk factor in arthritis and meniscal injury; high performance athletes, or military personnel/ manual workers suffer sports or job-related trauma; for most cases, such injuries bring a significant socio-economic cost; (iii) overcoming known deficiencies in existing products (e.g. loosening metal compression screws); (iv) enhanced functionality for surgeons, with the potential for shorter theatre times and simplified procedures, and significantly reduced inventories.
In our research:
(i) SMPs will be formulated for specific applications, by including plasticisers to control reversion onset temperature, and other additives;
(ii) SMPs will be structured by (a) solid phase processing, to obtain controlled molecular orientation, whose recovery drives shape reversion, (b) by precision injection moulding, and (c) by hybrid processing using a range of techniques including: overmoulding of SMP cores; reversion moulding; reverting SMPs into moulded end features; developing novel geometries to reduce heat transfer to tissue; 3-d printing of two materials for solid phase processing.;
(ii) Triggering of shape recovery by body T fluid (saline 37C); micro resistance heating probe; a hybrid
route - trigger start of recovery by heating probe, with prolonged body T reversion by plasticisers; local ultrasound heating
(iii) controlled reversion in clinically relevant timescales - fast or slow according to application, using controlled reversion triggering temperature, including body temperature - and degree of reversion;
(iv) the balance between bioresorption rate and interference force and pull out force from bone (Leeds University facilities);
(iii) the value of shape memory behaviour in accommodating variations in bone and fixing hole quality;
(v) match of bone properties/ osteogenesis including incorporation of nano hydroxyapatite and antiinflammatories being developed in our labs;
(v) modelling (finite element analysis) of stresses in SMP fixations to inform optimal design.
Partner Roles:
Clinicians - a) define Clinical challenges/ requirements for specific indications, especially scaphoid
compression screws and soft tissue fixations, including ACL and rotator cuff repair; b) input to design
of fixation devices and c) help remove barriers to clinical adoption;
Industry - evaluate a) market size, b) process economics, c) routes to market, d) device designs
Regulatory - we will engage with MHRA and BSI via our MeDe Innovation Centre.

Planned Impact

We aim for significant healthcare impact from our research, with commercially significant outcomes, with a defined route to regulatory certification and a clear patent pathway, particularly in bone to bone and tissue to bone fixation devices for a range of orthopaedic repairs.
Healthcare impacts will be in (i) meeting specific unmet clinical needs in major market segments, (including shoulder and knee ligament injuries, meniscal tears and scaphoid fractures); (ii) treatment of specific patient subgroups to achieve a reduced overall recovery time, including a faster 'return to function' time, e.g. older people - over 50's are more susceptible to traumatic and degenerative injuries; rising levels of obesity are a risk factor in arthritis and meniscal injury; high performance athletes, or military personnel/ manual workers suffer sports or job-related trauma; for most cases, such injuries bring a significant socio-economic cost, therefore treatments will not only benefit patients but also their carers, and also the NHS by reducing pressure through shorter hospital stays and faster rehabilitation; (iii) overcoming of known deficiencies with existing products (e.g. the loosening of metal compression screws); (iv) enhanced functionality for surgeons, with the potential for shorter theatre times and simplified procedures. Our clinicians are leaders in sports injuries (but also with for example, active service medical expertise and general trauma expertise) but we see the sports applications, with its extremes, as a potentially valuable 'accelerated' model of fixations for broader cases. In addition, there will be additional economic impact in reduced inventories and in emerging business through these new technologies.
The total annual estimated global healthcare market (2015) that could potentially be addressed using shape memory polymeric for orthopaedic soft tissue lesion repair is estimated to be around $1.2bn p.a., and small bone fracture fixation implants is around $2bn p.a. This market is expected to grow, driven by increased sports participation, and an aging demographic. Our programme will contribute to the UK position of strength in medical device technology and manufacturing, including a strong SME base - including our partners. We will engage with Regulatory bodies, including MHRA and BSI via our MeDe Innovation Centre, to help promote routes to assessing these new technologies. We will also achieve further academic impact, to help maintain a world-leading position for the UK in solid phase orientation processing of polymers research and precision micromoulding research in the Polymer IRC laboratories at Bradford, and continuing international visibility by the outputs from this research and the proposed Early Career Researcher exchanges with China, based on the UK-China advanced materials for healthcare community which we lead.

Publications

10 25 50

 
Description building on previous EPSRC awards for shape memory polymers (SMP), we have developed novel bioresorbable and bioinert shape memory fixations (e.g. plugs for ACL repair, bone screws for bone to bone repair and sutures). We have incorporated active ingredients (drugs) into some of these fixations. An excellent collaboration with Innovate Orthopaedics and the Fortius Clinic; and also with Leeds University (Dr A Herbert) on fixations in joints. We also have a new contact with more local clinicians (Leeds) - unfortunately because the PI badly dislocated his right shoulder in 2020, leading to a very successful keyhole surgery operation in July 2020 using Arthrex bioresorbable fixations. A recent success is a bio-inert shape memory bone fixation which reverts its shape (to pull together bone sections) at body temperature, so needing no further triggering. We have further developed hybrid fixations using a stainless steel screw element with a shape memory polymer fitting - this would allow surgeons a rapid 'first fix' using the screw, with a shape memory fixation occurring over a tailored timescale. This device could use body temperature triggered SMPs which are bioinert or ones which we seek to develop which are bioresorbable.
Exploitation Route clear potential for commercial/ clinically acceptable shape memory fixations. Clinician links, including new ones in Leeds, offer a route to development; the collaborating (SME) company has had to spend a lot of time on regulatory issues (courtesy of Brexit) which has unhelpfully limited their involvement. Even so they are active in advising on new designs we have made, such as hybrid shape memory polymer-metal fixations. We are actively exploring how to develop the prototype products, in discussion with industry and clinicians.
Sectors Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description consideration of a hybrid shape memory polymer-metal fixation device by collaborating company. A bio-inert shape memory fixation which reverts at body temperature (so not needing any external thermal triggering) has been developed. A recent success is a bio-inert shape memory bone fixation which reverts its shape (to pull together bone sections) at body temperature, so needing no further triggering. We have further developed hybrid fixations using a stainless steel screw element with a shape memory polymer fitting - this would allow surgeons a rapid 'first fix' using the screw, with a shape memory fixation occurring over a tailored timescale. This device could use body temperature triggered SMPs which are bioinert or ones which we seek to develop which are bioresorbable.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Royal Society Newton Advanced Fellowship
Amount £111,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NA150222 
Organisation The Royal Society 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2015 
End 08/2018
 
Description Clinical and Med Tech market collaborations 
Organisation Fortius Group Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution underpinning research into bone and soft tissue fixations of value to leading knee and ankle surgeons
Collaborator Contribution Leading knee and ankle surgeons at the Fortius Clinic provide insights and advice to the research team for design, function and operation of soft tissue and bone fixation devices made using shape memory polymers - a vital input to our team. Innovate Orthopaedics help us with market opportunity and other medical technology product development advice and guidance. An excellent and lively combination.
Impact Clear guidance given to the research team (materials engineers, biomaterials specialis,t and processing physics/engineering members) for potential exploitation of bioinert and bioresorbable shape memory polymers for fixations of soft tissue and/or bone.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Clinical and Med Tech market collaborations 
Organisation Innovate Orthopaedics Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution underpinning research into bone and soft tissue fixations of value to leading knee and ankle surgeons
Collaborator Contribution Leading knee and ankle surgeons at the Fortius Clinic provide insights and advice to the research team for design, function and operation of soft tissue and bone fixation devices made using shape memory polymers - a vital input to our team. Innovate Orthopaedics help us with market opportunity and other medical technology product development advice and guidance. An excellent and lively combination.
Impact Clear guidance given to the research team (materials engineers, biomaterials specialis,t and processing physics/engineering members) for potential exploitation of bioinert and bioresorbable shape memory polymers for fixations of soft tissue and/or bone.
Start Year 2018