In-shoe sensory systems to assess and avoid diabetic foot disease

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

This project concerns exploratory research to develop a new type of tactile (touch) sensing technology and investigate its exciting potential to transform treatment of Diabetic Foot Ulcers - a huge clinical challenge worldwide.

Background: The project has been designed to address the UK strategic research ambition to 'Optimise Diagnosis and Treatment' of Diabetic Foot Disease. Diabetes affects over 4.5m of the UK population and the condition acts to affect soft tissues in the body, notably the feet, leading to formation of ulcers. Studies estimate that over 2.5% of those with diabetes will have a diabetic foot ulcer (DFU), a hugely debilitating condition which has a significant impact on personal quality of life and costs the NHS up to 1.13billion each year. For effective diagnosis and treatment of DFU it is important to understand the behaviour of the sole of the patient's foot. This is a challenging task and while modern assessment methods use in-shoe digital measurement systems they are expensive and measure only a small part of the information that would be clinically useful.

The novel idea at the heart of this project is to develop tactile sensing technology based on small electronic coil elements which can be easily printed onto flexible films using mass manufacturing techniques. Sensor films will be composed of a bottom coil layer, a thin middle layer which can be squashed and a top contact layer. Crucially, this concept allows 1) pressures to be measured in different directions (side-to-side, fore-back, up-down) and 2) a grid or 'array' of sensing elements to be placed across a film, so measurements can be obtained at more than one location.
The sensing technology will be applied to develop a prototype 'next-generation' in-shoe assessment system for DFU with the ability to simultaneously measure pressures in different directions. A sensing 'sole' will be developed using a grid of sensing elements placed at key regions of the foot combined with a mobile data logging system. While the idea is ambitious it has the potential to transform assessment and treatment of DFU. It will enable improved measurements to guide diagnosis and treatment at lower cost and with the potential to produce personalised systems for long-term monitoring of 'at-risk' patients.

The project will use of a series of collaborative placements to ensure it is clinically relevant, has a commercial future and to promote the use of engineering science to advance healthcare. We will work with industry partners and manufacturing experts to help develop a future commercial product. We will work closely with clinical partners to understand first-hand DFU treatment and how this technology should be developed accordingly. We will run research internships in which undergraduate students from Leeds and India collaborate on the project, notably exploring how this technology could be adapted to benefit healthcare systems in Low and Middle-Income Countries.

The outcomes from this work will help make a positive impact to society, benefit the research community, and help expand the UK economy. We will work closely to involve the general public with our work to demonstrate how engineering science research is relevant and crucial to society. We will present at public events (e.g. Science Festivals) and produce public demonstration systems to showcase our research.
For society, the in-shoe sensory technology developed by this research will directly help improve diagnosis (through affordable measurement technology) and accelerate treatment (through detailed, personalised assessment).
For the UK, advances in Sensor Technologies are central to UK Government's strategy on Robotics and Autonomous Systems (RAS), defined in the Innovate UK RAS2020 roadmap and linked to needs for international competiveness, productivity and economic growth.

Planned Impact

*KNOWLEDGE
This project will generate advances in knowledge on methods for the design, optimisation and fabrication of flexible tactile sensors. This will span areas including multi-physics modelling of sensor systems, sensor fabrication (using mass-manufacture printing methods) and sensor characterisation.
Clinical application of this research to Diabetic Foot Ulcers (DFUs) will generate improved understanding of the condition, particularly the underlying biomechanics, and thus be of direct benefit to biomedical and clinical researchers investigating means to the prevent, assess and treat DFU.

*ECONOMIC IMPACT
The core sensing technology developed in this research has broad commercial appeal, with a focus here on the healthcare sector through treatment of DFU but also with clear relevance to other sectors, notably the expanding field of robotics. For UK PLC, advances in Sensor Technologies are central to UK Government's strategy on Robotics and Autonomous Systems, defined in the Innovate UK RAS2020 roadmap and linked to needs for international competiveness, productivity and economic growth.

The research will specifically benefit companies working in healthcare technology related to diabetic foot disease. A potential SME partnership has been identified and will developed at project start. This will benefit the SME by enabling them to exploit innovative technology, advance products for DFU and so improve their commercial competitiveness in the UK and worldwide. More broadly, it will drive innovation in the healthcare sector, thereby generate increased industry-linked funding and R&D investment, with consequent returns in the generation and exploitation of new IP.

*SOCIETAL IMPACT
For society, the importance of DFU assessment, treatment and prevention, is critical. The condition is predicted to increase worldwide as a result of increased prevalence of type 2 diabetes, compounded by calls for improved treatment with fewer resources. The in-shoe sensory technology developed by this research will help drive advances in treatment of DFU by packaging research improvements into a clinically useable form. This will directly help improve diagnosis (through improved measurement technology) and accelerate treatment (through detailed, personalised assessment). The National Diabetes Audit showed that cost savings of £650M would result through faster treatment of DFU.
An important aspect of this research is its relevance to Global Health, with DFU a significant problem in Low/Middle Income Countries, often having minimal treatment options. This research has the potential to bring technology to lower the cost of treatment, making it more accessible in these contexts. Ultimately this will contribute toward patient benefit and improved quality of life for people in the UK and worldwide.

*PEOPLE
The most important beneficiaries from this research will be people with diabetes; the application of this research to improve understanding, prevention and treatment of DFU will help mean that this population enjoy improved quality of life without suffering from this debilitating condition.
This research will provide a compelling example of how engineering science can solve societal 'grand challenges' through application to healthcare. Outreach events will show the value of STEM and higher education to those in secondary education while undergraduate internships will promote post-graduate research to attract new researchers and sustain capabilities in an increasingly competitive graduate recruitment market.
The UK has a strong history of fostering innovation outside research institutions to produce economic and societal benefit. Our public events will support this, raising public awareness through public science events. As a result we expect improvements in public knowledge and engagement with STEM, the engineering sciences and research institutions in general.
 
Description This research has made a number of advances of benefit to the research community, medical community and also wider industry.
- thin and compact sensing technology has been developed capable of measuring forces in different axes
- the sensing technology has been applied to produce the 'SLIPS' instrumented shoe sole, capable of measuring shear force on the bottom surface of the foot
- the SLIPS insole represents the first instrumented system capable of measuring shear stresses across the whole foot during gait
- preliminary data of shear loading at the foot surface has been gathered in healthy participants to inform future research
Exploitation Route The outcomes from this research are relevant in the following ways:
- to research/industry wishing to develop similar load sensing capabilities, either for assessment of foot loading, or more broadly across healthcare or robotics
- to medical researchers wishing to understand the complex biomechanics of the foot and the causative effects of foot diseases such as diabetic foot ulceration.
- industry partners and healthcare professionals seeking to develop new preventative interventions or assessments for foot disease
Sectors Electronics,Healthcare

URL https://eps.leeds.ac.uk/mechanical-engineering-research-design-robotics-optimisation/doc/robo-foot
 
Description The findings developed during this research have been translated to support a commercial project with MedTrade Ltd. to optimise their wound-care dressings. This collaborative link was established after MedTrade researchers found our published work and contacted the PI (Dr Culmer) to explore how the SLIPS sensing technology could be used to help measure and characterise the shear loading response of various woundcare dressings made by the company. This work has led firstly to the development of methods to characterise the shear loading response of woundcare dressings (e.g. they aim to minimise transmission of shear load to the surface of the skin) and secondly informed the development of new dressings, optimised to reduce the transmission of shear load. These contributions demonstrate the wider societal impact of this research and its relevance to support advances in healthcare and the medtech industry.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Industry partnership with Steeper PLC 
Organisation Steeper Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution We are investigating the potential to add sensing technology to Steeper orthotic insoles for assessment of diabetic foot disease
Collaborator Contribution Steeper have supported our research through the provision of product samples, technical expertise and clinical links.
Impact Steeper have supported a student project which is being exhibited at the Manchester Robotics and AI industry forum.
Start Year 2018
 
Description College of Podiatry Conference 2018 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact We presented an update of our research at the College of Podiatry conference in 2018 - disseminating to a HCP audience
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://engineering.leeds.ac.uk/news/article/495/university_of_leeds_team_shortlisted_for_national_e...
 
Description Public engagement at the BBC's Operation Ouch Interactive Public Science week - Bradford Science and Media Museum 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact We exhibited our SLIPS sensing technology at this medicine and science event aimed at the general public (and a younger audience in particular).
Estimates were that 3000-4000 people attended the event.

Our exhibition was an interactive demonstration of the sensing technology, discussion of the clinical background and encouragement towards the young audience to engage with STEM activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/about-us/press-office/operation-ouch-half-term-national-sci...
 
Description Robotics and AI Industry Showcase 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact We exhibited our SLIPS project and related undergraduate research at this industry focussed event, providing good exposure to the latest research and industry developments, and to the commercial audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://rai2019.co.uk/
 
Description Shortlisted for The Engineer - "Collaborate to Innovate awards" 2018 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Our research project was shortlisted for the annual 'The Engineer ' Awards, in the healthcare category.
http://awards.theengineer.co.uk/

We attended the prize ceremony and through the media attention and networking at the event have developed good research links for future use.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://engineering.leeds.ac.uk/news/article/495/university_of_leeds_team_shortlisted_for_national_e...