Measurement and characterisation of additively manufactured surface texture

Lead Research Organisation: University of Huddersfield
Department Name: Sch of Computing and Engineering

Abstract

Having a number of advantages over conventional (subtractive) manufacturing techniques, AM technologies possess the potential to change the paradigm for manufacturing. To facilitate the successful uptake of AM technologies into a wider range of applications, AM needs metrological methods to measure, evaluate and validate both AM processes and AM parts, in order to improve the accuracy and reliability of AM products.
The compound complexities of surface geometry and surface topography of AM parts have caused many problems for existing surface measurement techniques, including tactile, optical and XCT methods. Furthermore, due to the nature of AM processes, the AM-produced surface topography differs from conventionally machined surfaces. Following conventional surface characterisation methods, without considering the unique characteristics of AM surface topography, cannot lead to reliable and meaningful results. This dilemma is further aggravated by the complex surface geometry of the functional AM components, which result in serious distortions to surface characterisation techniques.
Facing these challenges, this research programme will investigate the applicability of various methods for the measurement of AM surface texture, including tactile, optical and XCT techniques. It will also develop bespoke surface characterisation methods for AM layer surfaces, aiming to reflect the characteristics of AM processes, and advanced surface characterisation methods needed for complex AM surfaces, with the aim of predicting the functionality of AM products.
The project aligns with the EPSRC's 'Manufacturing Technologies' topic within 'Manufacturing the Future' theme, and meets the UK's national strategy on AM technology. The outcome of this project will contribute to the control of AM process, and verification of AM product quality. It has great potential to positively impact on the UK's economy through the exploitation of AM technology in the key sectors concerned with high value manufacturing, including the aerospace, healthcare, high-end automotive and creative industries.

Planned Impact

The proposed research programme, along with its outputs, will produce impacts across a range of groups.
1) Impact on the metrology industry
The metrology industry will be a direct beneficiary of a new generation of surface characterisation methods. It will open the door for XCT to become a valid tool for surface texture measurement, and thereby promote the adoption of XCT into surface metrology. It will also provide the metrology industry with a feasible solution for the inspection of complex AM products, which can be very difficult if using traditional measurement techniques.
2) Impact on AM stakeholders in key industrial sectors
The proposed project will benefit three key industrial sectors that extensively exploit AM technologies, i.e., aerospace, automotive and healthcare. In the aerospace sector, it will provide a metrological solution to verify that the surface quality of complex functional AM components lives up to the necessary stringent requirements; in the automotive industry, it will facilitate the quality control of AM parts, the geometrical non-conformance and manufacturing defects of which are of significant concern; in healthcare, it will help in the investigation of the bio-compatibility of surface texture in medical AM components, in terms of cell attachment and tissue growth.
3) Impact on wider industrial beneficiaries through the project partners
The proposed project, in collaboration with the National Physical Laboratory (NPL), will have an impact on NPL's relevant Good Practice Guides, and thus will inform the wide scope of industrial metrologists on how to effectively measure and characterise AM surface texture. Cooperation with the Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC) will enable broadcasting the research outputs to a wider range of end-users in the high value manufacturing sector, helping them with AM product quality control. The impact on further AM exploiters, which require their AM components to have greater accuracy, surface finish or mechanical performance will, be through the MAPP EPSRC Future Manufacturing Hub of the University of Sheffield (MAPP: Manufacture using Advanced Powder Process).
4) Impact on the host institute
The proposed research programme aligns with the 'Metrology for Additive Manufacturing' platform topic of the recently-launched Future Advanced Metrology Hub (an EPSRC Future Manufacturing Hub), based at the Centre for Precision Technology (CPT) of the University of Huddersfield (UoH). It will strengthen CPT's research capability concerning surface metrology, and promote its participation in the development and enhancement of the relevant metrology standards.
5) Impact on staff development
Two PGR students and a PDRA involved in this project will be trained in a multi-disciplinary skill set, covering precision metrology, AM, applied mathematics and computer programming. Moreover, the research will enhance the learning experience of postgraduate students through the Advanced Metrology MSc course and other training activities delivered by the CPT.
6) Impact on society and economics
The proposed research programme will impact the UK's economy through the exploitation of AM technology in key sectors, concerned with high value manufacturing. It will also contribute to environmental and social sustainability through reducing scrap, saving raw materials, lowering CO2 emissions and being better personalised to suit consumers.

Publications

10 25 50

 
Description (1) A digital virtual reference additive manufacturing (AM) sample has been developed (WP1).
(2) The impact of voxel size of CT has been investigated via simulation using this virtual reference sample (WP1).
(3) A definition of surface topography features of powder bed fusion produced components was developed (WP2).
(4) A protocol that comprises the capable filtration and segmentation techniques have been developed to enable the separation of melt tracks and particle features on the surface (WP2).
(5) An investigation was carried to find how surface topography varies in respect to different inclination angles; qualified areal surface texture parameters are targeted to characterise the staircase effect and the particle features; a height thresholding method was developed to further characterise the particle features (WP3).
(6) A 3D watershed segmentation method has been developed as a part of the advanced surface characterisation tools for AM surface texture (WP3).
(7) A filter technique based the clustering theory has been developed and is used to suppress the noise and outliers for optical measurement of AM surface (WP3).
(8) An approach that harnesses the 3D material ratio curve and the 3D volume parameters were developed to quantity the severity of open surface pores shown up on the high-speed sintering parts.
Exploitation Route (1) The 3D watershed segmentation method is useful for the implantology, which can be used to evaluate the surface peak and pit density closely relating to the cell growth.
(2) The virtual AM reference sample is currently adopted by the National Physical Laboratory to investigate the uncertainties of XCT measurement.
(3) The research outcome of the inclined surfaces provides very useful information to develop a best practice for the industry to target suitable parameters for the surface texture of additive manufacturing components.
(4) The developed 3D material ratio and volume parameters allow the measurement information to be feed back to additive manufacturing process control.
(5) The clustering filter technique will benefit the widespread optical measurement of AM surfaces and laser processed surfaces in which many noises and outliers can appear.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description (1) HiETA Technologies, a technology-intensive company specialising in the use of metal additive manufacturing technology is using our developed surface texture evaluation module. The module is particularly useful for their investigation of the surface quality of the internal channel of heat exchangers. (2) NPL benefits from the development of virtual reference additive manufacturing samples to investigate the influence of focal spot size, voxel size, beam hardening on XCT surface texture measurement. (3) A*Star AMRC used our developed virtual artefact to evaluate the influence of sample orientation on XCT surface texture measurement. (4) The 3D surface characterisation techniques have been transferred to the metrology company Digital Surf and was integrated into their latest software MountainsMap.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Education,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Comments to the draft ISO 52902 (AM-Test Artefacts-Geometric Capability)
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or Improved professional practice
Impact This ISO standard affects the measurement practice for the additive manufacturing industry.
 
Description 3M Buckley Innovation Centre Fellowship - Working towards holistic geometrical verification of additive manufacturing components
Amount £9,000 (GBP)
Organisation 3M Buckley Innovation Centre 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2021 
End 03/2023
 
Description Future Metrology Hub Innovation Project - A toolbox for freeform triangle mesh surface characterisation and its verification method
Amount £80,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Huddersfield 
Department Future Metrology Hub
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2023 
End 04/2024
 
Description Future Metrology Hub Innovation Project - Investigation of Dimensional Accuracy and Surface Roughness of Polymeric Parts Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing
Amount £80,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Huddersfield 
Department Future Metrology Hub
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2023 
End 04/2024
 
Description PhD studentship sponsored by National Physics Laboratory (Miss Xiao Chen, Measurement of 3D additively measured surface texture)
Amount £27,000 (GBP)
Organisation National Physical Laboratory 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2019 
End 04/2023
 
Title Measurement database for selective laser melting artefact with various surface orientation 
Description A bespoke artefact named 'truncheon' was fabricated by selective laser melting. The truncheon has various surface orientation ranging from 0-180 degree with 3 degree increment. Each inclined surface was measured by focus variation microscope in three different locations, leading to the construction of a large database of measurement data. This database facilitated the investigation on how surface topography and associated surface texture parameters vary in respect to surface inclination. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The database led to the publication of the journal paper 'Surface Texture Characterization of Metal Selective Laser Melted Part with Varying Surface Inclinations'. It makes impact on the additive manufacturing community on targeting suitable surface texture parameters to link with process control and functional performance. The database is available per reasonable request. 
 
Description Collaboration of the MTC on investigating the surface topography of selective laser melted part with varying surface inclinations 
Organisation Manufacturing Technology Centre (MTC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Dr Shan Lou provided the initial idea of this research, the expertise of surface characterisation, and supervision of research students. Two research students, Mr Shubhavardhan Narasimharaju and Mr Weidong Liu conducted the measurement and data analysis.
Collaborator Contribution The MTC partner helped fabricate the bespoke artefact and provided the expertise of SLM process.
Impact This collaboration led to the joint publication: S. R. Narasimharaju, W. Liu, W. Zeng, T. L. See, P. J. Scott, X. Jiang, S. Lou 2021 Surface texture characterization of metal selective laser melted part with varying surface inclinations, Journal of Tribology (Accepted)
Start Year 2020
 
Description Collaboration of the NPL on investigating measurement techniques for additively manufactured parts 
Organisation National Physical Laboratory
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Dr Shan Lou provided the initial idea of this research, the expertise of surface texture measurement and simulation, and supervision of research student. The PhD student, Miss Xiao Chen, is working on comparing XCT with tactile and optical techniques for AM surface texture measurement, and improving XCT's capability on this aspect.
Collaborator Contribution The NPL partner provides the expertise of XCT and also financial support to sponsor the research student.
Impact This collaboration led to four joint publications so far now: W. Sun, X. Chen, C. Guisca, S. Lou, C. Jones, H Boulter, S. Brown, Evaluation of X-ray computed tomography for surface texture measurements using a prototype additively manufactured reference standard, 11th Conference on Industrial Computed Tomography, Wels, Austria W. Sun, C. Giusca, S. Lou, X. Yang, X. Chen, A. Wilson, H. Boulter, X. Jiang, S. Brown 2022 Establishment of X-ray computed tomography for surface texture evaluation using an additively manufactured reference standard, Additive Manufacturing 50: 102558 S. Lou, S. Brown, W. Sun, W. Zeng, X. Jiang, P. J. Scott 2019 An investigation of the mechanical filtering effect of tactile CMM in the measurement of additively manufactured parts, Measurement, 144: 173-182. X. Chen, Q. Zhang, W. Sun, W. Zeng, X. Jin, P. J. Scott, X. Jiang, S. Lou 2020 Development of virtual reference samples for XCT measurements of additively manufactured surface texture, 10th Conference on Industrial Computed Tomography, Wels, Austria.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Digital Surf on 3D freeform surface characterisation 
Organisation Digital Surf
Country France 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution (1) Develop a general framework for the triangle mesh-based complex freeform surface characterisation; (2) Develop a robust association method for the separation of nominal form and surface textures of surface with known nominal geometry; (3) Develop a reliable and distortion-free triangle mesh filtration method for the decomposition of different surface components;
Collaborator Contribution Digital Surf provide the industrial guidance and assistant for the development
Impact Future Metrology Hub - Innovation Project: A toolbox for freeform triangle mesh surface characterisation and its verification method
Start Year 2021
 
Description Collaboration with Singapore A*STAR Advanced Remanufacturing and Technology Centre on AM XCT metrology 
Organisation Advanced Remanufacturing Technology Centre
Country Singapore 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution (1) 3D surface texture characterisation techniques based on XCT generated triangular mesh, which is useful for the analysis of additively manufactured lattice structure. (2) Literature review of fabrication and metrology of additively manufactured lattices.
Collaborator Contribution (1) Design and fabrication of metal additively manufactured lattices. X-ray CT scanning of the fabricated AM lattices. (2) Development of algorithms to characterize the dimensions and surface roughness of the fabricated lattices. (3) Functional mechanical testing of the fabricated AM lattices.
Impact (1) 1 joint PhD studentship (Mr Ronnie Ssebaggala); A*Star sponsors the student via its A*Star research attachment programme, including two years bursary, one-time airfare grant, settling-in allowance, housing subsidy, medical insurance and conference & IT allowance; Project: Precision Metrology of Additively Manufactured Lattice Structures Using Industrial X-Ray Computed Tomography (2) 1 MSc by Research part time student (Mr Bisma Mutiargo); A*Star sponsors Mr Mutiargo with the full-time salary while he is visiting in the UK; Project: Fast surface determination method based on XCT simulation and machine learning
Start Year 2021
 
Description Collaborations with Sartorius Stedim Lab Ltd. on Metrology for Polymeric Parts Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing 
Organisation Sartorius
Department Sartorius Stedim UK Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution (1) To target the capable measurement techniques and associated optimum measurement settings for Sartorius AM parts guided by the existing experimental and simulation research outcome; (2) To apply the developed advanced geometry characterisation techniques (fitting, filtration and segmentation) to verify the dimensional accuracy and surface roughness of Sartorius AM parts; (3) To optimise the established AM processes/post-processes at Sartorius and to correlate surface geometry of Sartorius AM parts to their functionality (assembly, sealing and biological properties)
Collaborator Contribution Sartorius will design artefacts with various features, which will be produced by in-house state-of-the-art AM systems including selective laser sintering, vat photopolymerisation, digital light processing and material extrusion. Different printing parameters will also be used to manufacture the artefacts. The selected printed artefacts will be further subject to post-processing by the cutting-edge vapour smoothening machine. Based upon the measurement results obtained from Huddersfield, further testing within Sartorius will be performed, including mechanical properties, biocompatibility, E&L properties.
Impact (1) Colloborative Ventures Funding: Investigation of Surface Roughness and Form Tolerance of Polymeric Parts Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing (2) Future Metrology Hub - Innovation Project: Investigation of Dimensional Accuracy and Surface Roughness of Polymeric Parts Manufactured by Additive Manufacturing
Start Year 2022
 
Title Morphological filter plugin for Digital Surf's surface analysis software MountainMap 
Description A plugin software which provides 3D morphological filters were developed. This plugin was provided to the industrial partner Digital Surf under the license between the University of Huddersfield and the company. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Digital Surf is in the process of commericalising the plugin software and aims to provide its customers with a capability to deal with 3D triangular mesh data, e.g. XCT data. This is a great enhancement to their current product, which can only manager regular sampled lattice data. 
 
Description A technical presentation deliver to A*Star Advanced Remanufacturing and Technology Centre 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact ARTC & the University of Huddersfield (UoH) are seeking to build a relationship in the advanced metrology for additive manufacturing domain. Initial contact was made by a member of ARTC engineering staff who will be undertaking their Master's degree with Dr Lou at UoH in 2022. The proposed ARAP funded PhD project will facilitate staff exchange and knowledge exchange between ARTC and UoH.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Invited talk on a Manufacturers Metrology Network event on Hybrid & Additive Manufacturing (hosted by National Physical Laboratory) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Research outcome exposed to the wide manufacturing industry, and build more connections
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Research presentation to HiETA Technologies 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Dr Shan Lou was invited by Mr Henry Greenhalgh and Mr Cameron Breheny of the HiETA Technologies to introduce the research work in surface metrology for additive manufacturing. This was followed by a discussion on the interest of HiETA on surface texture and future colloboration.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020