New tool - a breakthrough in incremental sheet forming

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

Many high strength and lightweight materials, such as aluminium, magnesium and titanium alloys, have been increasingly used, for example in automotive and aerospace applications, due to their excellent strength-to-weight ratios. Many of these materials have limited ductility at room temperature therefore it is difficult and costly to manufacture these materials into sheet products with complex geometries. Deforming these hard-to-deform materials at elevated temperatures is required. However, traditional sheet forming techniques, such as stamping, may not be cost effective for production of small batch and customised products. This is because these traditional forming techniques involve high costs and long development cycles for manufacturing moulds/dies required for each product.

Incremental sheet forming (ISF) is a flexible, cost effective and energy efficient process, particularly suitable for prototype and customised products with complex geometries. ISF only requires a simple tool with a hemispherical head to deform the sheet material incrementally by moving the tool along predefined tool paths. The tooth paths can be created directly from the product CAD model to perform ISF using a conventional CNC machine. No special moulds/dies or heavy duty forming equipment are required therefore cost effective for small batch manufacturing. However, one of the most crucial limitations of ISF is that it is generally performed at room temperature therefore it cannot manufacture hard-to-deform materials due to their limited ductility at room temperature.

This project aims to develop a new type of ISF tool to facilitate vibration-assisted ISF at elevated temperatures without the need of using any additional device, equipment and extra energy input. The new ISF tool enables high amplitude and low frequency vibration-assisted ISF which creates localised material softening and heating therefore improves the material ductility for manufacturing products with complex geometries. In this project, the proof-of concept experiments will be conducted to assess enhanced capabilities of the new ISF in forming light alloys. Demonstrable products will be identified, developed and manufactured to benchmark the capabilities and limitations of the proposed new tool enabled vibration-assisted ISF.

Planned Impact

Potential impact on knowledge:
The project will develop a new RT-ISF which will potentially benefit researchers and manufacturers in developing novel manufacturing techniques. The discovery of the material softening mechanism under the high amplitude and low frequency vibration will introduce an alternative way for vibration-assisted forming techniques, currently predominantly using the low amplitude and high frequency vibration generated by ultrasonic technique.

Potential impact on the UK manufacturing and economy:
This project will overcome the current limitations of ISF technology therefore expand its manufacturing capabilities. It will benefit end users and manufacturers as well as enhance the UK's overall capabilities in high value manufacturing which will impact on the UK economy.
The new RT-ISF can enhance capabilities in manufacturing high value, small batch and prototype sheet products cheaply, quickly and energy efficiently. It can bring considerable economic impact because of lead time reduction and overall cost savings. The enhanced competitiveness will open future opportunities for UK manufacturing companies.
The developed process optimisation and automation procedures can be transferred to other forming processes to complement current skill-based craftsmanship in process development for new products. It can bring a significant impact on enhancing production efficiency and product quality, contributing to the UK economy.

Potential impact on society and people:
The RT-ISF will enable the manufacture of high performance and new products made of a variety of materials. For example, it can be used to manufacture sheet products made of light alloys quickly and cheaply for automotive and aerospace applications. This will support the lightweight transport strategy for reduced CO2 emissions and improved fuel efficiency. Achieving CO2 emission reduction targets will contribute to environmental protection and future sustainability, benefiting our society and people in the long-term. Industrial applications of the RT-ISF will bring opportunities for people working in sheet forming and tool-making industries to gain new skills which bring positive impacts on the development of people.
 
Description The project has successfully developed novel tools to facilitate rotational vibration assisted incremental sheet forming (RV-ISF) at elevated temperatures. The project proved that the novel concept of the RV-ISF for processing hard-to-form lightweight materials without the need of using additional device and equipment thus overcoming one of the critical limitations of incremental sheet forming (ISF). The materials tested in this project so far has included magnesium alloy (AZ31B), aluminium alloy (AA5251 & AA3003) and grade 1 titanium. A number of demonstrative parts have been designed and manufactured by the developed RV-ISF process, including a cranial implant and a motorcycle headlight fairing.

Due to the delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, lab closure and changes of researchers, the project has been extended by EPSRC for completion on 30th September 2022.
Exploitation Route By applying the developed RV-ISF, other users can explore the capability of this new ISF process for forming other hard-to-form materials, and design and manufacture other demonstrative parts for wider applications and industrial sectors.
Sectors Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description We have developed a new collaboration with Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. This is to explore how the flexible manufacturing technology developed in this project could be applied in a medical context, and is representative of many similar applications categorised by the need for plastic-forming moulds and per-patient customisation. One case study has been developed by designing a bespoke brace for adolescent scoliosis, an abnormal curvature of the spine, affects around 2-3 percent of the population and usually starts in children aged 10 to 15. The case study developed the design and manufacturing process for the bespoke brace, including creating a CAD model of the brace from a 3D scan based on an X-Ray of a patient, adapting the CAD model to a geometry feasible for manufacturing, finally creating a toolpath for CNC production. An example of the manufacturing brace and development details can be seen at this weblink: https://isf.sites.sheffield.ac.uk/showcase/case-studies/scoliosis-braces The collaboration is continuing through a following-on project EP/W010089/1.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Doctoral Training Partnerships - EPSRC UKRI
Amount £75,630 (GBP)
Funding ID X/014315-13 - RTSG 
Organisation University of Sheffield 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2021 
End 09/2025
 
Description Rotational Vibration Assisted Increment Sheet Forming by Novel Tooling (RV-ISF)
Amount £1,016,187 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/W010089/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2022 
End 01/2025
 
Description Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust - to develop case studies for medical applications of the developed manufacturing technology in this project. 
Organisation Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We have developed a collaboration with Kate Chauhan, a Clinical Specialist Orthotist- Paediatrics, to develop case studies for medical applications.
Collaborator Contribution They have provided suggestions and data for potential case studies and these have beed used in the development of the case studies. Please see the details in the Impact Section. Some patients' stories treated by Kate's team can be found here: https://www.steeperclinic.com/about-us/insights-and-case-studies/
Impact The work of this collaboration is continuing. We will report any progress in a follow-on project to this project: EP/W010089/1
Start Year 2022