Behaviour and design of stainless steel structures in fire

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: Sch of Engineering

Abstract

Owing to its unique combination of excellent corrosion resistance, low maintenance requirements and high performance in fire and under impact loading, stainless steel manifests itself an appropriate and advantageous construction material for projects where corrosion resistance, durability, maintenance costs or resistance to fire or extreme loading are of importance. Stainless steel is also highly recyclable and reusable, making it a sustainable construction material. Traditionally, due to its initial high material cost, stainless steel has been regarded as an option limited to specialist and prestige applications. However, with increased awareness on whole life-cycle costing and sustainability, rather than simply initial expenditure, the use of stainless steel in the construction and offshore industries has been increasing.

At elevated temperatures, stainless steel displays higher strength and stiffness retention relative to carbon steel with different material stress-strain response, leading to considerably enhanced structural performance for stainless steel structural elements relative to those made of carbon steel in fire. However, thus far, this high performance of stainless steel structural elements in fire has been neither scientifically well explored, nor has a design guidance leading to its efficient exploitation been developed. In fact, the current British and European structural steel fire design standard Eurocode 3 Part 1.2 recommends the design methods originally developed for carbon steel members for the fire design of stainless steel structural members. This unsurprisingly leads to very inaccurate estimations of the response of stainless steel structures in fire, precluding the efficient use of their high performance at elevated temperatures by structural engineers in practice. For projects where thermal protection is not used to showcase the attractive appearance of stainless steel, inefficient fire design rules, which may govern cross-section sizes, lead to excessive material use and thus very uneconomic solutions.

With the aim of achieving a step-change in understanding the response of stainless steel structural elements at elevated temperatures and in their fire design, the proposed research will involve comprehensive numerical studies on the behaviour of stainless steel structural elements in fire and lead to the development of statistically validated design guidance able to exploit the high performance of stainless steel structures at elevated temperatures. The proposed research will not only consider structural elements made of traditional stainless steel grades but also those made of a number of novel, cost-effective and high performance stainless steel grades recently introduced into the market for structural engineering applications; for the first time, elevated temperature material tests will be carried out on these stainless steel grades in this project. Possessing a number of novel aspects such as involving the first comprehensive investigations on the response of stainless steel plates, sections, columns and beams in fire and the elevated temperature material tests on new stainless steel grades whose elevated temperature material properties are unknown, it is envisaged that the proposed project will fill an important gap of knowledge with respect to the behaviour and design of stainless steel structures in fire. In this project, all the design guidance will be prepared adopting the Eurocode 3 Part 1.2 philosophy; it is anticipated that the project will generate design methods suitable for incorporation into the future versions of Eurocode 3 Part 1.2.
 
Description Capital Investment Fund for Elevated Temperature Material Testing System, School of Engineering, University of Warwick
Amount £35,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Warwick 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2020 
End 12/2021
 
Title Advanced nonlinear finite element modelling of the behaviour of stainless steel structural elements in fire 
Description Advanced nonlinear shell finite element models of stainless steel structural members capable of replicating their structural response in fire have been developed by means of the finite element analysis software Abaqus. The structural response obtained by means of the created finite element models has been compared against that observed for stainless steel structural members in fire experiments; very good agreement has been observed. Python and Matlab scripts were created to perform a high number of numerical parametric studies very effectively and automatically, whereby a very high number of data from the numerical parametric studies were generated, processed and assessed. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The development and validation of the advanced nonlinear finite element models are extensively discussed in our published and submitted papers below. This will provide very important guidance to the researchers in the field in the development of their own numerical models. It is expected that other researchers in the field will refer to our papers from our project in the description of the development of their numerical models. 1. Kucukler, M., 2023. Shear resistance and design of stainless steel plate girders in fire. Engineering Structures, 276, p.115331. 2. Quan, C., Kucukler M., 2023, Cross-section resistance and design of stainless steel CHS and EHS at elevated temperatures. Engineering Structures, Accepted for publication & In press. 3. Quan, C., Kucukler M., 2023, Design of stainless steel SHS and RHS at elevated temperatures. Thin-Walled Structures, Under Review. 
 
Title Research database on the cross-section response of stainless steel structural members in fire 
Description A very large number of dataset have been created on the cross-section response of stainless steel structural members in fire, considering the behaviour of about 39000 stainless steel structural members at elevated temperatures. The dataset have been obtained by carrying out the advanced finite element simulations of the structural response of stainless steel members in fire. Various cross-section geometries, cross-section slendernesses, member slendernesses, loading conditions and elevated temperature levels have been taken into consideration. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Such a large database had not existed in the literature before. The research database provides a significantly improved understanding of the cross-section response of stainless steel structural members in fire and has been used and reported in the following submitted publications: 1. Quan, C., Kucukler, M. 2023. Cross-section resistance and design of stainless steel CHS and EHS at elevated temperatures. Engineering Structures, Accepted for publication & In press. 2. Quan, C., Kucukler, M. 2023. Design of stainless steel SHS and RHS at elevated temperatures. Thin-Walled Structures, Under Review. 
 
Title Research dataset on the elevated temperature material properties of novel, high performance grade 1.4420, 1.4527, 1.4410, 1.4622 stainless steels used in the construction and offshore industries 
Description Elevated temperature material tests have been carried out on novel, high performance grade 1.4420, 1.4527, 1.4410, 1.4622 stainless steels used in the construction and offshore industries. Their material response and material properties at different elevated temperature levels have been obtained. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Currently, the elevated temperature material response and properties of novel, high performance grade 1.4420, 1.4527, 1.4410, 1.4622 stainless steels used in the construction and offshore industries are largely unknown. This dataset provides a very important understanding of the material behaviour and properties of these considered novel, high performance stainelss steel grades available to the construction and offshore industries. Using this understanding, the fire design of stainless steel structures made of the novel, high performance grade 1.4420, 1.4527, 1.4410, 1.4622 stainless steels can be effectively carried out. The dataset will be included in a journal publication which will be submitted to one of the top journals in the field. 
 
Description Collaboration with Outokumpu 
Organisation Outokumpu Stainless Ltd
Country Finland 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Myself and my Postdoctoral Research Associate have been performing elevated temperature material tests on novel, high performance stainless steel grades (grade 1.4420, 1.4577, 1.4410 and 1.4622) which have been developed by our project partner Outokumpu for use in the construction and offshore industries. Our project partner Outokumpu has provided all the material to us for the considered novel, high performance stainless steel grades (grade 1.4420, 1.4577, 1.4410 and 1.4622). The elevated temperature testing campaign includes 336 elevated temperature material tests, whereby the material response and properties of the considered novel stainless steel grades are obtained. Currently, the elevated temperature material response and properties of grade 1.4420, 1.4577, 1.4410 and 1.4622 stainless steels are largely unknown. Therefore, this research will provide extremely valuable information for the fire design of stainless steel structures made up of grade 1.4420, 1.4577, 1.4410 and 1.4622 stainless steels.
Collaborator Contribution Our project partner Outokumpu has provided all the material to us for the considered novel, high performance stainless steel grades (grade 1.4420, 1.4577, 1.4410 and 1.4622). Outokumpu has also provided their valuable opinions regarding our experimental set-up, the instruments we utilise and the parameters we consider in our elevated temperature material testing campaign.
Impact The collaboration will lead to a journal publication in one of the top journals in the research area.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Collaboration with the Steel Construction Institute 
Organisation Steel Construction Institute (SCI)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Myself and my Postdoctoral Research Associate have generated a very high number of data obtained from advanced numerical simulations on the structural response of stainless steel cross-sections, columns and plate girders in fire. In total, about 40000 stainless steel structural members in fire were taken into consideration to generate this data. Previously, such a comprehensive dataset had not existed in the literature on the structural response of stainless steel members at elevated temperatures. Various cross-section types and shapes, cross-section slendernesses, member slendernesses, elevated temperature values and loading conditions have been considered. Bespoke fire design methods have been devised for stainless steel cross-sections, columns and plate girders which had not existed in the literature before. One of the research papers reporting the research has been published in Engineering Structures. Two additional research papers reporting this research have been submitted to Engineering Structures and Thin-Walled Structures (top journals in the field). The second research paper submitted to Engineering Structures has been accepted and is currently in press. The third research paper submitted to Thin-Walled Structures is currently under review.
Collaborator Contribution Using their expertise, our project partner the Steel Construction Institute (SCI) has provided their opinions with regard to the obtained results on the behaviour of stainless steel structural members in fire. The SCI has also assessed the developed fire design methods and provided their valuable opinions regarding their appropriate use in practice. Their opinions have been very valuable particularly in the development of the fire design methods for stainless steel structures. With the SCI, we plan to present the research and the developed fire design methods to the CEN/TC250 Subcommittee 3.2 responsible for drafting the British and European structural steel fire design standard BS EN 1993-1-2. The objective will be the incorporation of the fire design methods developed in our project to the next version of BS EN 1993-1-2. This will enable practicing structural engineers to use our methods in the fire design of stainless steel structures in the UK, Europe and other countries that adopt EN 1993-1-2 as their structural steel fire design standard. This will ensure a very high impact of our research and collaboration with the SCI in our research project.
Impact 1. Kucukler, M., 2023. Shear resistance and design of stainless steel plate girders in fire. Engineering Structures, 276, p.115331. 2. Quan, C., Kucukler M., 2023, Cross-section resistance and design of stainless steel CHS and EHS at elevated temperatures. Engineering Structures, Accepted for publication & In press. 3. Quan, C., Kucukler M., 2023, Design of stainless steel SHS and RHS at elevated temperatures. Thin-Walled Structures, Under Review.
Start Year 2021
 
Description 6th International Stainless Steel Experts Seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A presentation has been delivered by myself regarding a part of the research carried out in our project in the 6th International Stainless Steel Experts seminar, highlighting our project and the support of the EPSRC. Both myself and my Postdoctoral Research Associate attended the seminar. The audience involved industry participants, professional practitioners, academics and postgraduate students specialised on stainless steel structures; the audience was international. The intended purposes were to (i) inform this very specific audience specialised on stainless steel structures regarding the activities of our research project, (ii) hear their opinions regarding our research and the fire design methods we are developing for stainless steel structures and (iii) discuss potential collaboration opportunities for further impact. The presentation and our research have received a very good feedback from the audience and there were very valuable recommendations. Future collaboration plans were made regarding research on stainless steel structures.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://steel-sci.com/stainlessexperts2022/