Closed Loop Digitalised Data Analytics and Analysis Platform (DAAP) for Intelligent Design and Manufacturing of Power Electronic Modules
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Greenwich
Department Name: Mathematical Sciences, FACH
Abstract
Power electronic modules (PEMs) and higher-level systems play an increasingly important role in adjustable-speed drives, unified power quality correction, utility interfaces with renewable energy resources, energy storage systems, electric or hybrid electric vehicles and more electric ship/aircraft. The power electronic technologies provide compact and high-efficient solutions to power conversion but deployment of power electronic modules in such applications comes with challenges for their reliable and safe operation.
This project aims to address four key challenges which the power electronics manufactures, and PEM end-users continue to face:
Challenge 1: No in-line and non-destructive inspection methods for PEM package quality and internal integrity assessment (wire bonds, die attachment and encapsulant) embedded within the production line.
Challenge 2: No comprehensive PEM data on design-quality-reliability characteristics, no processes for chartreisation and test data integration and management, and for data modelling and analysis.
Challenge 3: No advanced capabilities for accurate assessment of PEM deployment risks and for lifetime management.
Challenge 4: No or limited data is fed back from end-users to PEM designers/manufacturers, no application-informed design and manufacturing quality.
The project seeks to develop a digitalised Data Analytics and Analysis Platform (DAAP) for PEMs. The following novel and beyond current state-of-art developments in the project address the above stated challenges:
1) Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) with real-time data acquisition capability. A novel technique for NDT using LF-OCT imaging will be enhanced and optimised to provide quality data for individual PEMs. The proposed NDT method can quantitatively measure the mechanical deformation of gel-encapsulated bonding wires down to nanometer level. It can capture an entire cross-sectional image without any mechanical scanning, providing novel capability of running in-line with the packaging process.
2) Quality Predictions using AI and Machine Learning (ML): Research on integration and use of multiple data formats and sources, including standard datasets of electrical parameter test measurements, image data from in-line LF-OCT, and off-line X-ray and other imaging techniques, will be undertaken. The integrated data will underpin the accurate and automated quality evaluation of each individual PEM by enabling the development of ML and Deep Learning models. The modelling capability will enable packaging quality evaluations based on comprehensive sets of design and packaging process attributes.
3) Reliability Predictions. Current state-of-art in design-reliability and in-service degradation modelling for PEMs will be advanced through the proposed inclusion of manufacturing quality characteristics and design attributes in the reliability predictions. This will result in enhanced knowledge and more accurate, quality-informed reliability modelling and insights into the relations between design, quality and reliability by analytics of manufacturing and end-user data.
4) Data-Modelling-Optimisation Capabilities' Integration. The proposed integration (DAAP) of data, information exchange, and different modelling capabilities with multi-objective optimisation methods will be a novel development. The proposed optimisation routines will provide new capabilities for power semiconductor packaging design (e.g. module architecture, materials, interconnect solutions, application-specific reliability performance, etc.) and optimal process control on the manufacturing line.
This project aims to address four key challenges which the power electronics manufactures, and PEM end-users continue to face:
Challenge 1: No in-line and non-destructive inspection methods for PEM package quality and internal integrity assessment (wire bonds, die attachment and encapsulant) embedded within the production line.
Challenge 2: No comprehensive PEM data on design-quality-reliability characteristics, no processes for chartreisation and test data integration and management, and for data modelling and analysis.
Challenge 3: No advanced capabilities for accurate assessment of PEM deployment risks and for lifetime management.
Challenge 4: No or limited data is fed back from end-users to PEM designers/manufacturers, no application-informed design and manufacturing quality.
The project seeks to develop a digitalised Data Analytics and Analysis Platform (DAAP) for PEMs. The following novel and beyond current state-of-art developments in the project address the above stated challenges:
1) Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) with real-time data acquisition capability. A novel technique for NDT using LF-OCT imaging will be enhanced and optimised to provide quality data for individual PEMs. The proposed NDT method can quantitatively measure the mechanical deformation of gel-encapsulated bonding wires down to nanometer level. It can capture an entire cross-sectional image without any mechanical scanning, providing novel capability of running in-line with the packaging process.
2) Quality Predictions using AI and Machine Learning (ML): Research on integration and use of multiple data formats and sources, including standard datasets of electrical parameter test measurements, image data from in-line LF-OCT, and off-line X-ray and other imaging techniques, will be undertaken. The integrated data will underpin the accurate and automated quality evaluation of each individual PEM by enabling the development of ML and Deep Learning models. The modelling capability will enable packaging quality evaluations based on comprehensive sets of design and packaging process attributes.
3) Reliability Predictions. Current state-of-art in design-reliability and in-service degradation modelling for PEMs will be advanced through the proposed inclusion of manufacturing quality characteristics and design attributes in the reliability predictions. This will result in enhanced knowledge and more accurate, quality-informed reliability modelling and insights into the relations between design, quality and reliability by analytics of manufacturing and end-user data.
4) Data-Modelling-Optimisation Capabilities' Integration. The proposed integration (DAAP) of data, information exchange, and different modelling capabilities with multi-objective optimisation methods will be a novel development. The proposed optimisation routines will provide new capabilities for power semiconductor packaging design (e.g. module architecture, materials, interconnect solutions, application-specific reliability performance, etc.) and optimal process control on the manufacturing line.
Publications
Hassan S
(2024)
Coupled thermal-mechanical analysis of power electronic modules with finite element method and parametric model order reduction
in Power Electronic Devices and Components
Rajaguru P
(2024)
Damage Mechanics-Based Failure Prediction of Wirebond in Power Electronic Module
in IEEE Access
Stoyanov S
(2025)
Modelling the fatigue damage in power components using machine learning technology
in Power Electronic Devices and Components
Stoyanov S
(2024)
Reliability Meta-modelling of Power Components
Yang X
(2025)
High-speed low-cost line-field spectral-domain optical coherence tomography for industrial applications
in Optics and Lasers in Engineering
Zhang X
(2024)
IGBT Module DPT Efficiency Enhancement via Multimodal Fusion Networks and Graph Convolution Networks
in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics
Zhang X.
(2024)
IGBT Module DPT Efficiency Enhancement Via Multimodal Fusion Networks and Graph Convolution Networks
in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics
| Description | A novel LF-OCT method has been optimised and tailored towards industrial applications. The method has been successfully demonstrated and presents an opportunity to be deployed by manufacturers of power electronics components and modules as an imaging inspection technique that can monitor the quality on the manufacturing line by detecting unacceptable manufacturing deviations and defects in the assembled materials. Dynamic responses of the assembled product can also be characterised with great accuracy. A qualification test procedure for assessing the functional performance and characteristics of power devices is developed and demonstrated. A complex AI-enabled model of the test is developed and validated. This is a notable contribution as the machine learning model is capable of providing accurate performance characterisations and thus it can substitute the time-consuming physical testing. This development can benefit both manufacturers and end-users by equipping them with a powerful toolset for a cost- and time-efficient characterisation of power devices. High-fidelity physics-based models with non-linear material behaviour were developed and deployed to investigate and assess the sensitivity of the power component reliability performance to quality-related variations and uncertainties in product characteristics and parameters. These models can support power electronic components and modules manufacturers such as the project partner Dynex Semiconductor Ltd to improve their quality control procedures through insights and better understanding of fabrication and assembly process parameter effects on key quality-reliability relationships. New material damage prediction models for the most common failure modes in power components were developed using machine learning technology and physics-informed datasets. The outputs from this element of the research project enabled a practical solution for bridging the gap between manufacturers and end-users in terms of effective data sharing. The proposed model format is easy to deploy and use. It enables the end-users to evaluate the power device for the specific loads of their application without any need to access and know the manufacturer's intellectual property behind the product. The potential impact is that the qualification test and reliability models can be delivered as part of the technical datasheet of the component to the end-users, allowing for a much-informed component deployment approach that is not possible at present. |
| Exploitation Route | This project has developed and successfully demonstrated a number of new technologies, both equipment-based (LF-OCT for industrial applications) and model-based (multi-modal fusing networks of dual pulse tests, metamodels for fatigue damage prediction, and model order reduction technique for fast mechanical analysis), that deliver enhanced capabilities for characterization of power devices and their performance optimisation. These are designed to support both the manufacturers and the end-users of power components, fundamentally allowing the bridge the current information and data gap between them. When deployed, the technologies enable to have greater insights into the quality and reliability performance and characteristics of the product. The impact on manufactures is the ability to improve designs and execute better quality control through characterisation of important quality-reliability relationships. The impact on end-users is the complete removal of efforts on product characterisation, as part of current practices, that is needed to carry out a model-driven verification of the reliability performance under their application conditions. The models developed under the project deliver that same capability without need for product chatresiation and without the need to use advanced simulation tools and expert skill sets. |
| Sectors | Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software) Electronics Energy Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology |
| Description | A new-model based capability that enables the manufactures of power electronics components and modules to deliver an enhanced set of product information (technical datasheet) to the end-user, allowing the end-user to carry out a virtual model-based chataresiation of the product for their application deployment but without the requirement to access any intellectual property-sensitive product information. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2025 |
| Sector | Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Electronics,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology |
| Impact Types | Economic |
| Description | Real-time Virtual Prototypes for the Power Electronics Supply Chain |
| Amount | £1,036,589 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | EP/X024377/1 |
| Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 06/2023 |
| End | 03/2026 |
| Title | High fidelity model of power electronic module to analyse impact of manufacturing uncertainties |
| Description | This is a stage alpha finite element model developed in the project to investigate effects of manufacturing tolerances that influence the quality of wire bonded power electronic module and how these may propagate into subsequent reliability performance of the electronic device. Continuing model development in progress. Will be made available at a later stage of the project. |
| Type Of Material | Computer model/algorithm |
| Year Produced | 2023 |
| Provided To Others? | No |
| Impact | The model is developed to generate results within an approach that will also enable the creation of a metamodel. The metamodel will be computationally efficient and will be capable to perform sensitivity analysis on key manufacturing and product parameters, and will be part of the device datasheet. This will help manufactures of power electronic modules to gain understating of process parameters that need to be controlled, and also end users to deploy with confidence these devices in different applications that have different requirements. The full impacts will be achieved at the end of the project when all related developments within the project are completed. |
| Description | DAAP module characterisation |
| Organisation | University of Nottingham |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Under this project, we engaged with these universities to access particular expertise and advanced metrology equipment. We have prepared and provided the specification requirements in relation to a power module characterisations which can provide datasets for the modelling methodologies researched in the project. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Chatressiation datasets of devoices underpinning the modelling-related research in the project. |
| Impact | Output creation is currently in progress. |
| Start Year | 2023 |
| Description | DAAP module characterisation |
| Organisation | University of Sheffield |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Under this project, we engaged with these universities to access particular expertise and advanced metrology equipment. We have prepared and provided the specification requirements in relation to a power module characterisations which can provide datasets for the modelling methodologies researched in the project. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Chatressiation datasets of devoices underpinning the modelling-related research in the project. |
| Impact | Output creation is currently in progress. |
| Start Year | 2023 |
| Description | Real time prototypes for PEM |
| Organisation | University of Nottingham |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | This collaboration has shaped in the form of preparing joint project proposal between the University of Greenwich and the University of Nottingham. The project has been successful. My contribution is as project Co-I where the main input is in developing new modelling technologies for prediction thermo-mechanical reliability (lifetime modelling) of power electronic modules. This has been substantially informed by this EPSRC project and the early research that has been taken place on related modelling capability development. |
| Collaborator Contribution | University of Nottingham contributed with research proposal related top the electro-thermal modelling of PEM virtual prototypes, semiconductor modelling, and experimental testing and validation |
| Impact | No outputs yet, partnership as a project to start in June 2023. The only outcome at present is the grant award for the proposed project. |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Title | Finite Element based Model Order Reduction Technique for Thermo-mechanical Analysis with Non-linearities in material behaviour |
| Description | Finite Element based Model Order Reduction Technique for Thermo-mechanical Analysis with Non-linearities in material behaviour. Programming code calculation procedure implemented and methods successfully tested and validate. Programming code available as in-house tool and under development towards a open source version. Developments partly supported by the project grant. |
| Type Of Technology | New/Improved Technique/Technology |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Impact | New modelling capability to undertake fast mechanical simulations with linear material behaviour in applications such as power electronics and microelectronics component and assembly charatresiation. |
| URL | https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2772370424000087 |
| Description | Keynote talk at IEEE EuroSimE-2024 conference |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | Keynote talk at IEEE EuroSimE-2024 conference covering research undertaken under this EPSRC project |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| Description | Project referenced along with an outline to a research audience abroad, through an invited talk at Technical University of Sofia, Bulgaria, March 2023 |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | As part of an invited talk, outline of the project, its aims and objectives, and key technologies researched. Emphasis was on opportunities for collaborative Research in the stated areas. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
