Novel Tow Termination Technology for High-Quality AFP Production of Composite Structures with Blended Ply Drop-offs

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Aerospace Engineering

Abstract

The automated fibre placement (AFP) process is a cutting-edge technology to manufacture complex composite aerospace structures, which was first developed in the early 1980s. This process lays down a set of pre-impregnated carbon fibre tapes called 'slit tape' or 'tow' following designed paths on a 3D surface. Despite increasing demands for the fibre placement technologies, the process-induced defects in fibre placement process are critical problems that need to be solved so as to guarantee the quality and structural reliability of composite aircraft components. Those defects mainly result from the limitations of the modern AFP machines.
One of the major limitations is that they always generate resin pocket defects when producing composite components with thickness variation by terminating the tows inside the laminates. The conventional guillotine tow cutting mechanism, which almost all modern AFP machines are adopting, creates stepped tow ends when cutting the tows. Although the tow thickness is quite small (~0.12 mm), empty gaps are produced when the next ply covers the ends due to the high bending stiffness of the carbon fibres. The gaps are filled with resin matrix after a curing process, and act as crack initiation points under loading. This is an example how a manufacturing limitation can increase the design complexity and manufacturing cost. This provokes complex design problems to optimise the tow termination locations considering their detrimental effects on the structural performance, which significantly delays the design process and increases the design cost.
The conventional approaches dealing with these defects have been mainly about how to quickly and accurately predict their detrimental effects on the structural performance and take them into account in the design stage. However, this project aims to provide an inventive solution to eliminate those defects by tackling the fundamental weaknesses of the concept of modern AFP machines, which is a tow scarfing mechanism that can taper the tow ends when the machine terminates the tows during the automated lay-up process. This novel mechanism, which has never existed before, will allow for eliminating the resin pocket defects in automated manufacturing of composite aircraft components, ensuring high quality and reliability of the end products. At the same time, the design process as well as the post-performance evaluation process can be shortened and simplified by removing the effort to take into account the process-induced defects. The objectives of this project are not only for developing a new mechanism but also for providing fundamental understanding of the mechanics in tow cutting process and how the geometry of the terminated tow end affects the internal load transfer and failure mechanism. This project is ultimately for establishing a design guideline supported by experimentally validated data to effectively use the advantages of the new tow termination method.

Planned Impact

The novel tow termination technology to be developed in this research will be an innovative and disruptive technology in automated composites manufacturing, allowing for minimisation of the resin pocket defects, which is the most common and critical in modern automated fibre placement processes. This new technology will benefit the following groups in different aspects.
1) Aerospace industry
The aerospace industry will be able to remarkably improve the quality of composite components such as wings, spars, fuselages, aero-engine fan cases and blades, leading to enhancing the structural efficiency and reliability of the composite aircraft structures, saving the maintenance and repair costs, reducing the time and cost for quality inspection process and consequently increasing the overall production speed. Furthermore, this unique capability will help the UK aerospace industry to be clearly distinguished from other countries' in terms of the advance in automated fibre placement technology, which can lead the major aircraft and aerospace component manufacturers to invest in the UK aerospace sector in order to develop their high-quality future composite products. This will also strengthen the UK composites supply chain and industrial collaborations.
2) Automated Fibre Placement (AFP) machine manufacturers
The mechanism to be developed in this project can be applied to various types of modern AFP machines to improve the production quality. The UK aerospace companies such as Rolls-Royce, BAE Systems, Airbus, and GKN who are currently producing major structural components for aircraft (e.g. fan blades, wing skins, spars, and fuselage) could significantly reduce the manufacturing defects and save the inspection cost. In addition, the fundamental understanding of the structural improvement through the defect elimination, which is supported by theoretical and experimental results, will create additional momentum for innovation towards next-generation AFP technologies. A spin-off or start-up engineering company supplying customised modular devices for different types of AFP machines could benefit the UK economy and composite industry.
3) Composite designers and manufacturing engineers and researchers
The AFP process-induced defects have been the major huddle preventing the composite designers from quickly and accurately evaluating the structural performance of the designed composite components. The improved AFP process without generating the resin pocket defects will significantly shorten and simply the design and analysis process, which will help them to achieve more performance-driven designs. The new mechanism will help composite manufacturing engineers to question the conventional paradigm and come up with more challenging and innovative AFP technologies.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Most of the aerospace composite structures have thickness variations, which allows for optimally distribute the material to achieve high structural efficiency. They are laminated structures comprising laminas (so called plies) with a constant thickness. In order to varying the thickness of a composite laminate, some of the plies need to be cut (or dropped) within the laminate, which forms defects at the dropped ply end (e.g. fibre discontinuity and resin pockets). When the laminate is loaded, a delimitation damage is always initiated from those defects. This is a major complication in designing and manufacturing a lightweight composite aerospace structure.
The novel solution proposed in this research was to change the cutting method. The main reason for the defects described above is that the conventional guillotine cutting method always creates an abrupt thickness change at the ply drop. The novel tow termination mechanism developed in this research can control the taper angle of the dropped ply end. The experimental and numerical analyses in this research showed that by optimally choosing the taper angle, the delamination can be completely supressed and the laminate strength can be improved by 10-15%. More importantly, the elimination of those defects significantly reduce the time and cost for the layup design process, as the designers do not need to pay much attention to ply drop sequences. Furthermore, the drop weight impact test results showed that the tapered ply ends improve impact damage tolerance.
Exploitation Route The new tow termination method could be applied to current automated fibre placement machines, depending on the requirements of the end users. Therefore, it has great potential for industrial application and commercialisation. Another main advantage of this research is that the new mechanism is optimised based on scientific knowledge rather than empirical data; the tow cutting characteristic studied in the initial stage of this research is used to make the mechanism work much more efficiently and accurately and require a compact device that can fit in the current automated fibre placement machine. Furthermore, this research will also provide the potential end-users with the information about how much they could further improve the performance of their composite products by eliminating the resin pocket defects.
The team is closely engaged with the industrial partners (Airbus, BAE, and Rolls-Royce) to discuss the suitable composite products where the new tow termination method could apply. In order to maximise the industrial impact, more end-users will be exploited through the National Composites Centre.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine

 
Description The novel tow termination technology developed in this project will contribute to solving one of the major quality issues in manufacturing composite aerospace components, which is the UK's strength in global economy. Aerospace industry has started realising the limitations of the current automated fibre placement technologies, and one of them is their cutting method that always creates defects, which have been simply accepted as manufacturing features despite of their detrimental effect on the structural performance. In this project, the feasibility of the new cutting method was successfully validated and its impact of eliminating such defects on the improvement of the structural integrity has been demonstrated numerically and experimentally. The industrial partners of this project will get the direct benefits by applying the technology to their current products and improve the production quality. The technology developed through this project is something that has never tried before and has a special capability that any existing machines can achieve, which is innovative and disruptive. Its successful industrial application will result in production of highly reliable composite components, which could be the major strength of the UK's aerospace industry. This will contribute to the EPSRC's vision for Productive Nation. The project team is in a process of developing industrial impacts based on this outcome of this project. Recently, the team was awarded an IAA exploratory award from the university and successfully expanded the application area to a non-aerospace industry, which is wind turbine blades manufacturing. The project proved that the new cutting method is very effective to increase the delamination on-set stress of composites made of thick dry carbon fibre fabrics. The project team is currently exploring project opportunities with wind turbine blade manufacturers to make this process industrially applicable.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Impact Acceleration Award (Exploratory Impact Award)
Amount £69,321 (GBP)
Organisation University of Bristol 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2021 
End 09/2021
 
Description Novel tow termination technology for high-quality AFP production
Amount £40,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 1791408 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2016 
End 09/2020
 
Description Airbus - UoB 
Organisation Airbus Group
Department Airbus Operations
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Technical presentation at the advisory board meeting, enhancing their understanding of the new tow termination technology and its advantage against conventional methods
Collaborator Contribution Attendance of the advisory board meetings, provision of technical information about potential applications
Impact N/A
Start Year 2017
 
Description BAE Systems 
Organisation BAE Systems
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Technical presentations in the advisor board meetings, exploring collaboration opportunities, enhancing their understanding of the new technology and its advantages
Collaborator Contribution Attendance of the advisory board meetings, technical discussions
Impact N/A
Start Year 2017
 
Description National Composites Centre 
Organisation National Composites Centre (NCC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Technical presentations in the advisor board meetings, exploring collaboration opportunities, enhancing their understanding of the new technology and its advantages
Collaborator Contribution Attendance of the advisory board meetings
Impact N/A
Start Year 2017
 
Description Owens Corning (OCV CHAMBERY INTERNATIONAL) 
Organisation Owens Corning
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This collaboration was established after the official project period, through the EPSRC Impact Acceleration Award (described in Further Funding section). This new partner was particularly interested in investigating the applicability of the novel tow cutting method developed in the original project to their composite materials used in wind turbine blade manufacturing. We expect that the novel cutting method we developed would be much more effective than what we observed in prepreg materials used in aerospace industry. Based on our result, the partner could promote their material to help wind turbine industry to improve the production rate and the product reliability.
Collaborator Contribution The partner company provided £10k cash contribution together with in-kind support such as materials and technical information. However, since this contribution was made after finishing the original project, it was included not in this section but in the further funding section.
Impact The project has started from Jan 2021, but the actual start date was postponed to 1st Apr 2021 due to the Covid lockdown. No specific output or outcomes were produced yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Rolls Royce plc 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Technical presentations in the advisor board meetings, exploring collaboration opportunities, enhancing their understanding of the new technology and its advantages
Collaborator Contribution Attendance of the advisory board meetings, technical discussions
Impact N/A
Start Year 2017
 
Description IAA project meetings (kick-off, interim and final reviews) with wind turbine blades experts at Owens Corning in France 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Based on successful demonstration of the novel tape termination technique developed the original award (for prepreg materials used in aerospace industry), an IAA exploratory award project was applied and granted with support of Owens Corning at France to test the technique for thick dry carbon fabric materials used for wind turbine blades. In the IAA project, it was successfully demonstrated that the novel termination technique is applicable to their materials and is very effective to increase the delamination on-set stress in tension and compression loadings. The results were presented to their export group and a follow-up project is currently being discussed to further develop the technology and apply it to their production process.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
 
Description Technical advisory board meetings 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Experts in composites manufacturing from the industrial partners participated in the advisory board meetings organised at the national composites centre. The research team and the experts discussed the potential of the novel tow termination technology, its application areas in industry, potential risks, and how it could fit in their business roadmap to create industrial impact.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018