Holographic beam shaping of high power lasers for additive manufacturing

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Engineering

Abstract

The modern world has an ever increasing demand for consumer products and technology which has a direct impact on the manufacturing industry who are always trying to minimise costs and increase efficiency whilst minimising the impact on this production on both society and the environment. The manufacturing industry has recently seen a massive rise in direct fabrication processes such as 3D printing which require minimal tooling and can produce high quality items at low costs and low environmental impact. Most recently there have been a series of highly adventurous manufacturing techniques developed such as additive manufacture (AM) which has greatly expanded the range of materials that can be processed from plastics to metals to other more exotic materials.

One of the most important AM processes has resulted from the use of high powered lasers to deliver high energy light waves which can be used to melt a metallic powder and gradually add layer up on layer of material to make up a final manufactured part or product. These systems use a scanning mirror to control the positions of a high powered laser spot onto a bed of powder. This process creates a very intense region of heat at the focus of the laser which fuses the powder, however the control of this thermal energy is very difficult due to the highly localised nature of the laser spot in the process. This leads to thermal stresses and distortions in the part being made which are very difficult to predict and even more difficult to control reliably.

Computer generated holograms use optical diffraction as a means of controlling the distribution of energy in three dimensions based on a two dimensional pattern which is displayed on a liquid crystal display. The diffraction process can then be used to control the distribution of the write laser on the powder to give a more controlled area of powder melt, minimising the thermal impact of the writing process. The hologram can also be used to compensate for imperfections in both the laser and the optics, hence it can deliver near diffraction limited performance. More importantly, the melt process and be monitored in real time and the hologram can be recalculated to mitigate these effects as well as control the shape, quality and material of the AM process. One of the biggest limitations tot his holographic control is the amount of optical energy that can be controlled by the liquid crystals display. This limit will be investigated fully and a new generation of displays will be produced as a result of this research which are designed specifically for high power laser illumination in AM processes.

Planned Impact

The true impact of this proposal lies in the delivery of a new Additive Manufacture system based on holographically shaped laser beams. The enhanced control created by the holographic approach will allow the next generation of AM systems to realise their full potential. The impact will not only be on the use of AM in 21st century products, it will also be in the technology that drives the control of the optical energy; spatial light modulation. The results of this project will also help to further expand the potential impact of many other high power laser techniques and applications which use the phase of light rather than amplitude, allowing diffraction and interference to be the means of light manipulation. The true extent of these applications has only just begun, and their likely effect on the Uk and industrial photonics will be substantial.

The proposed project focuses on the testing and development of a new optical technology that could be immediately applied in a research context as well as being developed for commercial exploitation. Therefore, the two major areas of potential impact for holographic AM and high power SLMs are:

a) Implementation into research activities: With the successful development of this new optical technology, it could be immediately integrated into on-going research in the areas of high-speed high power beam manipulation and laser machining. The team has strong collaborative links with biomedical scientists, particularly in the Cambridge Cancer Centre and this new approach to AM could find immediate integration into their systems as well as impacting on more speculative biomedical applications such as robotic and laser based surgery. Furthermore, the PI has strong links with the Centre of Industrial Photonics at the Institute for Manufacturing at Cambridge, who specialise in laser machining, providing further opportunity to open up new collaborations.

b) Commercial exploitation: As with all technology development projects, it is likely that exploitable intellectual property will be generated. This will be actively pursued to maximise the benefits from this research. This will be done in two main parts:

i) The development of new AM techniques through adaptive holographic beam shaping, focussing on the optimisation of the AM process through enhanced control and area writing.
ii) The creation of optimally designed new high power SLMs capable of driving applications including AM.
 
Description Additive Manufacture (AM) is the production of objects by combining material in contrast to subtractive processes. AM in metals is dominated by Laser Powder Based Fusion (L-PBF). Powder is spread in layers 10s of microns thick and selectively melted by scanning a laser or electron beam heat source over the bed. The main aim of this research is to increase the efficiency and versatility of a laser-based AM process by using diffraction based holographic beam shaping to create two dimensional patterned areas of laser energy which can melt the powder in one operation. The holographic approach to beam shaping allows an aberration corrected arbitrary write area to be formed by diffraction of the laser. The desired layer pattern to be written can be calculated in real time and will compensate for potential limitations of the AM process such as thermal effects that can lead to sample distortion, creep, fatigue and residual stresses. To date the work has been mostly theoretical as the access to the high power laser labs has been restricted due to the pandemic. A simple polymer based holographic AM process has been developed and successfully used to demonstrate the principles. A high power SLM is currently being commissioned to initiate the delayed metal powder phase of he project. There have been several issues with securing a postdoctoral researcher which have been the result of the pandemic which have caused further problems in developing a reliable high poer system. It is not clear if the intended AM of mettalic compounds will be feasible in the remaining time of the project.
Exploitation Route It is hoped that the AM techniques developed in this project will become part of commercially produced equipment with little modification required to the overall optical system.
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Agriculture

Food and Drink

Construction

Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

Manufacturing

including Industrial Biotechology

Transport

 
Description There has been some interest in the work from this project despite the negative impact that Covid had on its practical outcomes. Many of the papers generated have been well cited and there has beena follow on grant submitted by the PhD student on the project who is now an assistant professor at Nottingham. There is also a potential collaboration from this work via the postdoctoral researcher on the project who is now at Heriot Watt. The team there is also interested in holographic additive manufacturing in conjunction with the group at Liverpool.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport
Impact Types Societal

 
Title HoloGen: An open-source toolbox for high-speed hologram generation 
Description The rise of virtual and augmented reality systems has prompted an increase in interest in the fields of 2D and 3D computer-generated holography (CGH). The numerical processing required to generate a hologram is high and requires significant domain expertise. This has historically slowed the adoption of CGH in emerging fields. In this paper we introduce HoloGen, an open-source Cuda C and C++ framework for computer-generated holography. HoloGen unites, for the first time, a wide array of existing hologram generation algorithms with state of the art performance while attempting to remain intuitive and easy to use. This is enabled by a IC# and Windows Presentation Framework (WPF) graphical user interface (GUI). A novel reflection based parameter hierarchy is used to ensure ease of modification. Extensive use of C++ templates based on the Standard Template Library (STL), compile time flexibility is preserved while maintaining runtime performance. The current release of HoloGen unites implementations of well known generation algorithms including Gerchberg-Saxton (GS), Liu-Taghizadeh (LT), direct search (DS), simulated annealing (SA) and one-step phase-retrieval (OSPR) with less known specialist variants including weighted GS and Adaptive OSPR. Benchmarking results are presented for several key algorithms. The software is freely available under an MIT license. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/nzk4swwsrg
 
Title HoloGen: An open-source toolbox for high-speed hologram generation 
Description The rise of virtual and augmented reality systems has prompted an increase in interest in the fields of 2D and 3D computer-generated holography (CGH). The numerical processing required to generate a hologram is high and requires significant domain expertise. This has historically slowed the adoption of CGH in emerging fields. In this paper we introduce HoloGen, an open-source Cuda C and C++ framework for computer-generated holography. HoloGen unites, for the first time, a wide array of existing hologram generation algorithms with state of the art performance while attempting to remain intuitive and easy to use. This is enabled by a IC# and Windows Presentation Framework (WPF) graphical user interface (GUI). A novel reflection based parameter hierarchy is used to ensure ease of modification. Extensive use of C++ templates based on the Standard Template Library (STL), compile time flexibility is preserved while maintaining runtime performance. The current release of HoloGen unites implementations of well known generation algorithms including Gerchberg-Saxton (GS), Liu-Taghizadeh (LT), direct search (DS), simulated annealing (SA) and one-step phase-retrieval (OSPR) with less known specialist variants including weighted GS and Adaptive OSPR. Benchmarking results are presented for several key algorithms. The software is freely available under an MIT license. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/nzk4swwsrg/1
 
Title Research data supporting "Automated Computer Vision-Enabled Manufacturing of Nanowire Devices" 
Description Figure2c,e: Detected spatial distribution, length and orientation of isolated InAs nanowires in a 1 × 1 mm^2 region. Figure 4: Transfer characteristics of automatically fabricated nanowire devices with (a) 0.5 µm channel length, (b) 1.0 µm channel length, (c) 2.0 µm channel length, and (d) 2.5 µm channel length at source-drain voltage VDS = 10 mV. (e) Statistical data of nanowire device misalignment measured from the center of the nanowire to the center of the electrode pattern. Statistical data of (f) on/off ratio, (g) peak current, and (h) threshold voltage measured in automatically fabricated nanowire devices. Figure S8: Statistical data of (a) mobility and (b) hysteresis measured in automatically fabricated nanowire devices. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/341921
 
Description Collaboration with Sony on LCOS SLMs 
Organisation SONY
Country Japan 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are investigating the feasibility of using our flexo material mixtures in Sony SLMs, discussions are at an early stage post pandemic.
Collaborator Contribution Current Sony SLM on loan to CMMPE group a Cambridge. we are also investigating the possibility of testing the newly developed Sony SLM at high laser powers as part of the additive manufacturing research.
Impact Nothing as yet, awaiting SLM and MTA
Start Year 2022
 
Description Flexoelectric device fabrication for next generation phase modulators. 
Organisation Huawei Technologies Research and Development UK Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Device fabrication for use in holographic switches in telecommunications networks with Huawei. This includes both ferroelectric and flexoelectric devices .
Collaborator Contribution Huawei have set up a feasibility study on the use of flexoelectric liquid crystals in the next generation of liquid crystal over silicon spatial light modulators for use in telecommunications networks. this includes the design and fabrication of a suitable; backplane for the devices which will be fabricated in Cambridge.
Impact none as yet, all work with Huawei has been suspended due to pandemic and politics with China.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Focal Depth Tracking for Improved Three Dimensional Holographic Displays 
Organisation University of Cambridge
Department Centre for Advanced Photonics and Electronics (CAPE)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Designed and built a custom eye tracking system to improve the d=filed of view of a holographic near to eye display system,
Collaborator Contribution Financial support including access to a state of the art eye tracking system
Impact Publications listed
Start Year 2020
 
Description Low cost SLM interface board for advanced microscopy and holographic display of biological structures 
Organisation OpenPlant Fund
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Novel interface development for the Bluejay liquid crystal spatial light modulator which has allowed the design and development of a novel holographic display system.
Collaborator Contribution Funding support
Impact Custom SLM development board for general usage
Start Year 2020
 
Description Holographic beam shaping to deliver a boost to metallic 3D printing 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Web article on the University web pages, Cambridge engineers have begun a three-year research programme to help speed up the manufacture of metallic 3D printed parts and products, by using computer-generated holography.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://www.eng.cam.ac.uk/news/holographic-beam-shaping-deliver-boost-metallic-3d-printing
 
Description Interviewed by the Naked Scientists 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact CMMPE student Peter Christopher was interviewed today as part of a program by the Naked Scientists. In it, he was asked questions by Nadeem Gabbani about a recent Nature paper on "acoustic trap displays". In it, precise ultrasound manipulation is used to maneuver a small object in 3D space. Changing the colour of the ball allows 3D shapes to be drawn using persistance of vision effects. Researchers from the UK and Japan also used advanced acoustic control to give volumetric sound and haptic feedback.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p07v6q55#t=21m04s