Failure process and optimal design of hybrid adhesive joints - a microscale experimental and numerical approach

Lead Research Organisation: Lancaster University
Department Name: Engineering

Abstract

With development of new engineering materials, hybrid structures are now widely used to achieve desired performances by applying new materials instead of conventional ones. This is especially so in the automotive, aerospace and defence industries, since it is a major method to achieve enhanced performance, better fuel efficiency and to minimise greenhouse gas emissions. This technique is being rapidly exploited in other high-value manufacturing-based economies such as Germany and the US. To fabricate hybrid structures, adhesive joining technique attracts more attentions due to their advantage of enabling cost-effective, highly integrated structures with a uniform load distribution and improved damage tolerance. However, there are still some limitations to the use of adhesive joining in hybrid structures. The concept of "hybrid joint" involves a combination of two or more different constituents, with different material properties. To date, there is no well-established theory, which can describe the relationships among the combination of constituents, geometric configuration (microstructures of interfaces and adhesive layer, thickness and overlap of adhesives, etc.) and the overall performance of a hybrid joint. Furthermore, optimization of hybrid adhesive joints is another challenge, since the number of possible effective factors for hybrid adhesive joints is significantly higher than conventional joints and the factors are interactional. In practice, there is no effective optimization method for hybrid joints. Those limitations have resulted in the tendency to "overdesign" hybrid-joining structures. Therefore, the project will focus on a fundamental study of failure mechanisms of a hybrid adhesive joint, and the development of an optimization strategy, which aligns with perspectives from both academia and industry.

To achieve the objectives, the project has four main work packages (WPs). In WP1, the failure mechanism of the joint will be analysed using advanced testing facilities, with consideration of the effects of microstructure. Then, in WP2, a DEM model will be developed to describe the mechanical properties of the joint and generate essential date points for optimization. Based on the results of WPs 1 and 2, an optimization algorithm will be developed in WP3 using DoE and Genetic Programming techniques for generating optimal design for hybrid adhesive joints according to design requirements. Finally, case studies will be carried out based on real-world applications for validation. It is intended that the outcomes of the project will substantially overcome the current limitations of the researches in this field and allow a step change in development of high-performance hybrid structures in high value manufacturing.

Planned Impact

The immediate impact of the project will be on the academic community as described in the section "Academic Beneficiaries". However, further impacts will also be on the economy, society and environment.

The UK is one of the largest industrial nations in the world. As one of the most important parts of its economy, manufacturing industry contributes significantly in GVA and employment. To maintain the UK's position as a leader in high-value manufacturing, more fundamental studies and innovation researches are requested. The outcomes of this project will enable the development of both new hybrid structures with desired performances and a "smart" manufacturing process for such structures. Because of multiple applications of the hybrid structures, it is foreseeable that the impact will be applicable in a range of industrial sectors, such as automotive, shipping and aerospace industries, within the context of Industry 4.0. Hence, the productivity, efficiency and creativity of related industries will be upgraded. So far, the proposal has been discussed with several UK based industrial companies, such as Henkel, members of Northern Automotive Alliance and WMG High Value Manufacturing Catapult Center to ensure that the outcomes are exploitable in real world manufacturing. As a result of these discussions, the developed testing methods in this project will be used by Henkel to develop new testing standards for hybrid adhesive joints, which are currently not available in any ISO standard. Moreover, the WMG Catapult Center will adopt the proposed numerical model and optimization algorithm in their real-world project, such as light rail project "LightJoin" (Innovate UK) in WMG.

Besides the impact on economy, the society and environment will also be benefited by the outcomes of the project. For instance, the knowledge and methodology developed in the project could enable recently developed lightweight and eco-friendly engineering materials to be used in hybrid structures delivering a step change in the mass of vehicles, aircrafts and ships. Moreover, optimal designs of the structures will be determined autonomously based on the proposed optimization algorithm to reduce the material and energy costs in R&D phase. Hence, better energy efficiency and less greenhouse gas emissions will be achieved through the design, manufacturing and usage phases. This is in alignment with the government's environment policy and the global strategies, such as Paris Treaty. Therefore, the social benefits will be in a sustainable environment and a higher quality of life.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The outcomes are summarized as following:

1. A new research method, which combines discrete element method (DEM) and a machine learning technique genetic programming(GP), was developed successfully for the first time, for the research into complicated micro-mechanical behaviors of hybrid adhesive joints. According to the current research outcomes, it is approved that the developed method could overcome the limitations of conventional numerical method (FEM). And, the developed numerical models could be used as a reliable tool for analyzing and predicting the deformation and failure mechanisms of, not only hybrid adhesive joints but also other engineering structures with interfaces between dissimilar materials. For instance, the developed algorithm could suggest optimal combinations of adherends and suggest most suitable adhesive and configurations for lightweighting structures to avoid overdesign and time consuming lab tests in automotive, aerospace, civil engineering, and electronic packaging industries. Therefore, it could improve the productivity and efficiency of the industry sectors significantly.

2. By using the developed hybrid methodology (combining DEM and GP), some micro-mechanical behaviors (different deformation and failure modes) along the interface between dissimilar materials have been discovered and summarized, which can cover a wide range of adherends (metals, polymers and composites) and adhesives (rigid/brittle structural adhesives and rubber-like flexible sealants/adhesives). Especially, the effects of the adhesive thickness on the failure of a joint have been explored, which explains an unclear phenomenon in practice, the strength of a joint starts decrease, when the thickness of the adhesive increases to a certain magnitude according to different combinations of joint components and configurations. The new obtained knowledge is a important contribution to the development of adhesion theory.
Exploitation Route The proposed work focuses on a fundamental understanding of micromechanical deformation and failure mechanisms of hybrid adhesive joints, which are currently missing in the research of this field. The knowledge acquired in this project could contribute the existing adhesion theory and the developed methodology could help the researchers and engineers to overcome the current obstacles in practice, not only in joining technology but also in the researches of new mechanical meta-materials, composites and coatings.

Beside the academic impact, the use of DoE and GP techniques will help to generalize the knowledge obtained with DEM simulations to real industry applications. The overall solution will be applicable to an expandable database of adherends and adhesives, and subsequently to develop a new smart "expert system" for joining process in automotive, aerospace and civil engineering industries aligning the development of the 4th industrial revolution. In the future, the developed strategy could also be extended to the optimization of other manufacturing processes.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description At present, one of the hottest research topics in manufacturing sectors is light-weight hybrid materials/structures. This is especially so in the automotive, aerospace and civil engineering industries, since it is a major method to achieve enhanced performance, better fuel efficiency and to minimize greenhouse gas emissions. So far, the knowledge and technology developed in this project have already attracted attentions of our industry partners, and be involved in their industrial projects in practice. For instance, the concept and methodologies developed in this project have been considered in a light-rail project "LightJoin" in WMG High Value Manufacturing Catapult to optimize braided composite beams and adhesive joints for lightweight rail structures. So far, 3 joint academic papers have been published in prestige international journals. It is expected the outcomes of the project will be introduced to wider industrial sectors through our project partners, such as Henkel, WMG and Northern Automotive Alliance (NAA).
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Lightweight Joint collaboration with Henkel 
Organisation Henkel Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The project uses two kinds of engineering adhesives from Henkel Limited in case studies of the developed numerical models. The experimental and numerical results of the project are to reported to Henkel for a deeper understanding of the products and offer potentials to improve the specific adhesives. Especially, the final analysis methodologies developed in this project will be introduced to the research and development department in Henkel and their potential customers.
Collaborator Contribution Henkel Limited contributes their professional knowledge of adhesives in this project. In addition, Henkel also provides adhesive samples and access to their testing facilities in Hemel Hempstead site including technical supports from their senior technicians. At the end of the project, it is expected Henkel will offer their contributions on the dissemination of the outcomes of the project by promoting the analysis methodologies and knowledge of hybrid adhesive joints among their customers.
Impact None for far.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Lightweight Joint collaboration with WMG 
Organisation University of Warwick
Department Warwick Manufacturing Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The research team of this project has established a closed collaboration with the research team of Dr Darren J Hughes in WMG. The concept and methodologies developed in this project have been considered in a light-rail project "LightJoin" in WMG High Value Manufacturing Catapult to optimize braided composite beams and adhesive joints for lightweight rail structures. So far, three joint academic papers have been published in prestige international journals. In addition, two joint applications are in preparation for the beam time in Diamond Light Source and a further EPSRC grant respectively based on the current project.
Collaborator Contribution The research team from WMG offers collaborative access to general facilities in manufacturing and material group at WMG. In addition, expert support are offered to prepare the further grant applications. And the current outcomes of the project has been introduced in the research group in WMG and their current industry focused project.
Impact Joint Publications so far: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2021.115107 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2020.113389 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2021.108894
Start Year 2021
 
Description 1st International Conference on Mechanics of Solid 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 1st International Conference on Mechanics of Solid is an international conference attract more than 70 academic participants (2022).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://web.fe.up.pt/~ms2022/
 
Description 25th International Conference on Composite of Structures 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 25th International Conference on Composite of Structures is one of the biggest international academic conferences in composite materials, more than 300 participants are from both academy and industry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.iccs25online.com/