Chemistry of open-shell correlated materials based on unsaturated hydrocarbons

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

This is a long-range basic research project that targets the synthesis of a new crystalline materials family whose chemical, electronic and magnetic properties will create opportunities in fundamental science. To date, such advances have mainly been made in inorganic materials. This project will extend that opportunity to materials where the electronically active component is an organic anion.

Our understanding of materials such as silicon and copper relies on a description of the electrons in which they do not interact strongly with each other. The electronic behaviour of materials in which the electrons do interact strongly, known as correlated materials, differs from such classical free electron materials. Correlated materials have been a fruitful source of new electronic and magnetic ground states and properties. This behaviour has overwhelmingly been observed in inorganic systems, because of the capability offered by inorganic solid state materials chemistry to position multiple distinct metal cations and thus predictably arrange spins, orbitals and charges. We have no such synthetic capability or crystal chemical understanding for organic correlated electron materials. The one example of success is the fulleride superconductors such as K3C60, where the underlying crystal chemistry is based on sphere packing that is directly analogous to well-studied inorganic systems, enabling extensive synthetic control and property design.

While currently offering an outstanding range of properties, all-inorganic systems are restricted to the atoms provided by the periodic table, whose crystal and electronic structures are controlled by the ionic size and orbital characteristics of those elements. If we could achieve similar general control of structures based on electronically active organic species, such as anions derived by reduction of unsaturated molecules studied here, the resulting structural and electronic properties would be determined by the molecular size, shape and electronic structure. In contrast to the inorganic ionic systems, these steric and electronic structures of the organic molecules that would be the building blocks of such materials are controllable by synthetic chemistry.

In two recent papers in Nature Chemistry, we have reported chemical synthesis approaches that produce crystalline salts of reduced unsaturated aromatic molecules and access new electronic states, including a candidate for the quantum spin liquid ground state in a three-dimensional pi-electron based material. This advance demonstrates the potential to create a family of tuneable crystalline organic electronic materials beyond the fullerides. The project will establish this family, allowing the positioning of electronically and sterically tuneable building blocks to control electronic, magnetic, optical and charge storage properties.

This will be achieved by developing the synthetic chemistry capability to produce crystalline materials from a broad range of unsaturated organic molecules. To generate materials of comparable compositional and structural complexity to the inorganic systems, we will apply and expand this chemistry to materials with multiple metal sites and with more than one molecular component. This will allow us to control extended electronic structure by positioning of and charge transfer between the molecular units to target geometrically frustrated magnetic lattices and mobile charges in quantum spin liquids as examples of the new electronic ground states this chemistry will enable. The compositions, charge states and structures of the resulting hydrocarbon salts will reveal the charge storage potential of this family of materials.

We will use informatics techniques to guide efficient exploration of the chemical space, and apply a range of structural, thermodynamic, spectroscopic, electronic and magnetic measurement techniques with our international collaborators to identify the new electronic states that arise.

Planned Impact

The project will deliver understanding and capability in the synthesis and design of new crystalline organic materials based on reduced unsaturated hydrocarbons with currently unpredictable electronic, magnetic, optical and redox properties. The short-term impact will be on academic and industrial basic research.

Understanding of the design of advanced materials contributes broadly in the long-term to innovation across multiple high value industry sectors where our ability to control material structure and properties at the atomic and molecular level is essential to deliver advances in materials and resultant product functionality. It is also possible to identify potential long-term ramifications for specific technologies.New electronic ground states produce opportunities for information storage or processing technologies. For example, the new materials families are candidate quantum materials for ground states such as the quantum spin liquid (QSL). The excitations of exotic magnetic states such as fractional spinons in the QSL have been proposed as components of low-energy computation because they can be manipulated without charging. The entanglement of states in the QSL enables certain quantum computing architectures.The specific understanding and materials arising from insertion of electropositive metals into redox-active unsaturated organic molecules is relevant to the development of lightweight, recyclable high charge storage capacity battery cathodes.

The basic understanding emerging from the project could enable reduced energy use in computation and diversification towards organic materials, with associated environmental benefits. Society will benefit from two postdoctoral researchers trained in the synthesis, characterisation and design of a new generation of advanced materials, and equipped with an understanding of informatics methods.

Advances relevant to energy storage will be evaluated with battery materials developer PV3 and the Faraday Institution, for low-energy computing with the Energy Efficient ICT theme of the Royce Institute(where Liverpool are partners) and Colour Synthesis Solutions (also display technologies), and for quantum technology via the Innovate UK (iUK) KTN Special Interest Group. We will engage with UK industry through the Knowledge Centre for Materials Chemistry (KCMC) to realise the broader long-term impacts. KCMC fosters collaboration with chemistry-using industries and delivered £200M GVA to the UK economy in its first 5 years. The PI is a founding member of the KCMC Management Group. Relevant advances identified at monthly formal project meetings will be communicated to KCMC knowledge transfer staff, who will disseminate the information via their extensive network to the most appropriate industrial beneficiaries. This will raise industry awareness of the opportunities this new class of materials and the advances in capability required to access them present, and identify challenges unmet by current materials classes. KCMC will work with iUK, KTN and High Value Manufacturing Catapult staff to maximise exploitation of project advances.

Intellectual property will be protected by University of Liverpool Business Gateway. The project team have licensed two patents arising from basic research to UK industry.

Project advances will be disseminated by high profile publications including journals such as Nature and Science, where the team have a strong track record. We will engage with the Directed Assembly and Dial-a-Molecule EPSRC Grand Challenge networks to highlight project advances, as well as presenting at IOP, RSC and international meetings.

Project advances will be highlighted to policymakers and stakeholders beyond academia via KCMC events such as the 2016 "Materials for the Future" attended by over 80 senior industrialists and the CEO of iUK. We will engage the public through press releases and web-based dissemination such as the 2018 Science webinar at Curious 2018.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description A machine learning model to predict co-crystal formation has been developed, and is now being implemented with commercial partners and as live web apps. This model was demonstrated in a published study on experimental unsaturated hydrocarbon discovery. The synthesis and evaluation of new reduced aromatic hydrocarbon materials has led to detailed understanding of their reactivity, in turn opening new pathways for the synthesis of this family of materials, which until this time have been lacking robust synthetic protocols. This has now enabled work on the physical properties and crystal structures of these materials, which is ongoing. By controlling this synthetic chemistry for the first time, we have accessed open-shell systems and are now connecting their properties to their structures. It has become clear that the changes in molecular packing required to allow metal insertion are more dramatic in this family of materials than in other, much better-studied classes of carbon intercalation host, which is at the root of the challenge in identifying appropriate synthetic conditions.
Exploitation Route Through application of the software and materials in other related areas, as exemplified by the machine learning model.
Sectors Chemicals,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Collaboration with Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre on the application of one-class classification to the prediction of co-formers which will form co-crystals began 22/01/2021. From UoL this involves A Vriza, M S Dyer and V Kurlin. From CCDC this involves Ioana Sovago, Pete Wood and Susan Reutzel-Edens. This has resulted in a paper in advanced draft form, soon to be submitted to the Journal of Chemical Information and Modelling. It also led to two live web apps for predicting co-formers likely to form co-crystals.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Chemicals,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Economic

 
Title CCDC Co-crystal mapping 
Description Web app mapping all the co-crystals in CCDC and providing direct link to web-CSD after clinking to each point on the map. Includes all the existing co-crystals in the CSD and was created using a new crystal invariant, namely Pointwise Distance Distribution (PDD). PDD was used to represent the co-crystal structure derived from the Crystallographic Information File (CIF). The distance between all the existing co-crystals was measured using the Earth Mover's Distance (EMD) between the PDD invariants and the TMAP algorithm was used to draw the co-crystals tree map. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact allows public access to all known co-crystals available in the CCDC database 
URL https://csd-cocrystals.herokuapp.com/
 
Title High-throughput discovery of a rhombohedral twelve-connected zirconium-based metal-organic framework with ordered terephthalate and fumarate linkers 
Description Multiple folders containing powder x-ray diffraction data, thermogravimetric analysis and N2 adsorption isotherm data for mixed linker Zr based MOFs with terephthalate and fuamrate linkers reported in 'High-throughput discovery of a rhombohedral twelve-connected zirconium-based metal-organic framework with ordered terephthalate and fumarate linkers' 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact No known impacts 
 
Title Molecular Set Transformer for co-crystal screening 
Description Web app providing two models for rapid in-silico co-crystal screening reporting the scores and uncertainty of any user given molecular pair. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Allows public access to a model for co-crystal formation using CCDC datasets 
URL https://share.streamlit.io/katerinavr/streamlit/app.py
 
Description Collaboration with Denis Arcon, Jožef Stefan Institute, Slovenia 
Organisation Institute Josef Stefan
Country Slovenia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have prepared new alkali metal intercalated polyaromatic hydrocarbon compounds which show interesting magnetic properties. We have solved the crystal structure of these materials by powder X-ray diffraction and performed some initial magnetic property measurements.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners at Jožef Stefan Institute, Slovenia have measured the Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) properties of the compounds to give further insight into the magnetic and electronic properties of the materials
Impact Measurements are still on-going and manuscripts are being planned. This is a multi-disciplinary collaboration, the challenging chemical synthesis and crystal structure determination have been performed at Liverpool while physical property measurements relating to magnetic properties are being performed at Jožef Stefan Institute.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Collaboration with Stockholm University 
Organisation Stockholm University
Country Sweden 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Our team contribute samples of new intercalated poly-aromatic hydrocarbon materials being tested as correlated materials for structural analysis.
Collaborator Contribution Stockholm University are experts in structural characterisation using electron diffraction methods. They provide structural analysis of these materials.
Impact None yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description K Vriza gave a talk at 4th RSC-BMCS / RSC-CICAG Artificial Intelligence in Chemistry 28/09/2021 "Attending to co-crystals in the Cambridge Structural Database" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact K Vriza gave a talk at 4th RSC-BMCS / RSC-CICAG Artificial Intelligence in Chemistry 28/09/2021 "Attending to co-crystals in the Cambridge Structural Database"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description K Vriza gave a talk at CCDC Science Day 26/05/2021 "Attending to co-crystals in the Cambridge Structural Database: How co-crystal discovery can be accelerated through Machine Learning" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact K Vriza gave a talk at CCDC Science Day 26.05.2021 "Attending to co-crystals in the Cambridge Structural Database: How co-crystal discovery can be accelerated through Machine Learning"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description K Vriza gave a talk at University of Liverpool PGR chemistry symposium 26/03/2021 "Machine learning identification of co-crystal formation: How Machine Learning and CSD database analysis can accelerate co-crystal discovery" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact K Vriza gave a talk at University of Liverpool PGR chemistry symposium 26/03/2021 "Machine learning identification of co-crystal formation: How Machine Learning and CSD database analysis can accelerate co-crystal discovery"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Materials Conference 15 (MC15) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Poster presentation at MC15. Title "Functional co-crystals prediction following data-driven approaches".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021