Development of ultra-compact combustors for low-carbon technology using trapped vortex concepts

Lead Research Organisation: Delft University of Technology
Department Name: Aerospace Engineering

Abstract

Energy demand will be up by more than a quarter by 2040 [International Energy Agency data]. Given the dominance of combustion in meeting this demand, it is imperative to develop low-carbon, efficient gas turbine (GT) engines to reduce emissions impact and tackle the global warming as set by the Paris Agreement. In recent years lean premixed technology has attracted interest due to its potential of reduced emissions and high efficiency. However, lean combustion is prone to instabilities that may lead to unwanted oscillations, flame extinctions and flashbacks. Use of low or zero-carbon fuels like hydrogen is also limited because the high speeds needed to prevent flashbacks due the high low-heating values (LHV) can destabilise the vortex dynamics. Further development is thus required to achieve better efficiency and lower emissions, and effective flame holding techniques are crucial for this development. In ultra-compact combustor design, trapped vortex (TV) systems are implemented either in the primary zone or in the inter-turbine region to increase the resident time of combusting gases, resulting in better mixing, thus higher efficiency and lower emissions. Higher resident times also imply a shorter combustor, thus a lighter engine and less fuel consumption, also helping the process of hybridisation in multi-cycle devices. TV are locked stably within a cavity and thus are less sensitive to external disturbances even at high speeds, allowing use of low or zero-carbon fuels with high LHV like hydrogen. However, the process of flame stabilisation is rather complex because of the shear and boundary layer (BL) vortex dynamics, the strong heat transfer to the wall and the simultaneous occurrence of flame propagation and auto-ignition processes. The effective control of the flame dynamics requires a deep understanding of these processes.
This project aims to develop improved understanding of the fundamental processes governing flame stabilisation in TV systems for ultra-compact combustion design, and their potential to deliver improved flame stability and low emissions at high speed (subsonic) conditions in the context of lean premixed technology. In particular, the TV physics will be studied i) in presence of a radially accelerating flow representing the swirled flow dynamics at the entrance of the combustion chamber; and ii) in presence of an axially accelerating flow when the cavity is located within the converging duct near the combustor exit. Both swirled and axial acceleration can destabilise the vortex dynamics, so this dynamics has to be understood before TV systems can be effectively employed. The analyses will be conducted through high-fidelity large eddy simulations (LES), which represents a cost-effective tool as compared to expensive experimental investigations. In this way the effect of turbulence, equivalence ratio and cavity geometry can be explored in details via parametric study. Moreover, the performance of different alternative fuels and their implication in terms of flame holding and model performance can be evaluated for different TV designs. An improved model involving presumed PDF approaches based on mixed flamelets/perfectly stirred reactor will be developed to account for the aforementioned physics. The fundamental understanding for this development will be extracted from unprecedented detailed direct numerical simulation (DNS) and by using validation data from experiments provided by the project partners.
The outcomes of this project will significantly help the development of modern, low-carbon engines, and improve the understanding of the fundamental physics within these devices. Moreover, the project will lead to the development of CFD codes and models that can be used in industrial design cycles. Thus, this project is timely and strongly relevant for leading UK industries such as Rolls-Royce and other emerging industry, and will help them to maintain their leading role in the power-generation sector.

Planned Impact

The development of trapped vortex systems for ultra-compact combustion (UCC) engines in the context of lean premixed technology, and predictive numerical tools to explore and understand the complex physics within these devices both have a strong long-term impact on the UK and the international industry. In particular, the collaboration with Rolls-Royce, which is a project partner, will aid to maintain the technological leadership in the power-generation sector within the UK. In addition to the UK strategic need for environmental impact due to the development of more efficient and low-carbon engine technology, UCC design implies a lighter structure, which implies less fuel consumption and can help the process of hybridization with electric sources and multi-cycles engines for high-speed transport flights and `green' power plants. Moreover, the better flame anchoring achieved through the use of trapped vortex cavities may allow effective use of fuels with high LHV like hydrogen (that produces no carbon) or syngases (i.e. gases with a percentage of hydrogen) to achieve a carbon-neutral strategy, meaning the amount of carbon produced is sustainable because balanceable by current technologies. The long term goal of the present research in understanding how to control the stabilisation process in these devices will thus strongly benefit the environment and consequently the health and quality of life of the society. Only considering that by 2040 the aviation sector will account to about 25% of the CO2 emissions of the entire transportation sector, shows the high impact that this research can have in the middle and long term. The lighter structure (less fuel per kilometre) allowed by ultra-compact devices also lead to decreasing the cost of travelling. The more efficient engine will reduce the cost of on-demand electricity produced in power-plants. This also plays in favour of local societies in developing economies.

This research will complement other EPSRC strategic researches on flame stabilisation based on different concepts such as plasma and electric fields stabilisation, flameless combustion and closed-loop engine generators, and thus add a significant contribution to the achievement of low- or zero-carbon technology. UK-based multinationals such as Siemens and Rolls-Royce (RR) are leading developers of lean premixed technology and thus will directly benefit from this research. Furthermore, the development of optimised, accurate and computationally-effective models for compressible flows, and in particular the statistical approaches explored in the present research, is of paramount importance to these industries as these models can be effectively employed within industrial design cycles of novel engines. This intent was declared at the First Workshop on Compressible Combustion (WCC) held in Aachen, Germany, in May 2019, where leaders of Siemens, Rolls-Royce and international academic groups met to discuss further advances within lean premixed technology and its modelling for relatively high speed (compressible) conditions. Thus, the proposed research is timely and will have a direct long-term impact to the above and other emerging UK industries.

The potential manufacturing of UCC devices and novel design concepts for low-carbon engines in the longer term will have further economical benefits. On the one hand, it will lead to additional researches to address further technological issues, thus creating employment for future academics; on the other hand, novel concepts may lead to creation of opportunities for emerging industries as well as further employment in leading industries in the aeronautical and power generation sectors (e.g. Rolls-Royce and Siemens within the UK, Alstom, GE, etc). The understanding and knowledge achieved within this and future related researches will thus help the formation of skilled people with specific expertise in a key area for the future of low-carbon technology.
 
Title Prometheus hydrogen flame 
Description The "T" in the logo of TU Delft, representing the Torch of Prometheus, was replaced by the RQL combustor geometry used for the simulations in the EPSRC project, and the Prometheus flame on the torch was replaced by the hydrogen flame simulated. With this we reached out to the general public with the message that we are making the Prometheus flame, which represents the gift of knowledge and wisdom given to men, also sustainable, and that sustainability if one of the core values we need as society to pursue. 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact We engaged the general public and collaborated with a professional artist. Our message on the importance of sustainability was well received. 
URL https://youtu.be/C2EUtofEfRA
 
Description In the original planning of the award there is a benchmark of the fidelity of our numerical approach against high-resolution direct numerical simulations from one of the project partners (Sandia National laboratories). The configuration studied is a back-step stabilised reacting flow where the flame is near the wall. The objective is to understand the implication of the wall proximity in terms of the numerical modelling, as this is relevant for the next phases of the project studying trapped vortex cavities. This benchmark was pursued and lead to the following findings:

- The reaction rate is affected by the wall proximity despite the flame being outside the region indicated in literature for which this effect should be relevant. This is due to the presence of the recirculation of burnt gases in the same region, which results in low velocities and consequently makes heat diffusion relevant. The numerical modelling used in the project (large eddy simulation with flamelet and presumed probability density function approach) was modified to include these effects and results after this modification improved significantly.
- The boundary layer in the region of the recirculating flow plays a significant effect in addressing the above effect correctly. Common wall function approaches in the literature used for non-reacting flows are limited even if the mesh size captures the logarithmic region. Our findings from sensitivity analyses indicate that the modelling constants used to address the diffusion effect have to be modified in the boundary layer region. We have also identified alternative models in the literature for these diffusion. These findings are in review in the Physics of Fluids Journal.

The investigation of the trapped vortex cavity was performed via both LES and quasi-DNS. The effect of axial acceleration was first investigated via 2D DNS and 3D Large Eddy Simulations using different geometries with a cavity within a divergent or convergent duct. The analysis resulted however in no tangible advantage for the combustion process. Instead, the key finding was that the trapped vortex cavity concept could become relevant if used within a Rich-Quench-Lean (RQL) combustion system configuration, and hydrogen as fuel. This system was thus tested using hydrogen as fuel, on a simplified geometry. The test led to the finding that the high reactivity of hydrogen is predominant as compared to its also high diffusivity when injected in the cavity, meaning that hydrogen burns immediately after being injected without giving time for mixing with air first. This implies high levels of toxic nitric oxides (NOx). In order to understand how to control this behaviour, a quasi-DNS simulation was performed, whose data will be analysed within the next months. To slow down the chemical time scale of hydrogen as compared to the mixing time scale, in order to achieve premixing and suppress NOx, the hydrogen inlet temperature will be investigated next, within the complementary PhD project (formally associated with the present EPSRC grant) running at Loughborough University. The effect of radial acceleration (swirl) will also be investigated within this PhD project.
Exploitation Route Our outcomes provide modelling indications for treatment of reacting flows when the flame is close to a wall in presence of a recirculation of burnt gases. As recirculation of burnt gases is one of the most common stabilisation mechanisms in combustion devices, our finding can help other researchers in the modelling choices to make to simulate such flows. The further findings on trapped vortex cavity within a RQL-type system give critical insights on the behaviour of hydrogen within these system (in particular about how to inject the fuel in the cavity), as such a detailed simulation of this type is yet not present in the literature.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy

 
Description Part of the data produced within this project was used by professional artist Jeroen van der Most for his presentation during the Delft Blue Grand Opening in Delft, September 30 2022. The data was used to make a visual story of a future world and leveraged to open discussion on sustainability during the event.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Environment
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Internal funding provided by the Aeronautical and Automotive Engineering Department
Amount £60,000 (GBP)
Organisation Loughborough University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2022 
End 08/2025
 
Description Detection of flashback in hydrogen combustion towards decarbonization 
Organisation Indian Institute of Science Bangalore
Country India 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We simulated with large eddy simulations a reheat geometry where hydrogen is used as fuel, and tested different techniques for the stabilization of the hydrogen flame. This collaboration led to further fundings (5000 eur via joint TU Delft & IISc/IIT seed fund scheme) for travel exchange to the IIS Bangalore.
Collaborator Contribution The partners provided a DNS database to validate the results
Impact - Award of joint TU Delft & IISc/IIT seed fund scheme (5000 eur). The new project is titled "Detection of flashback in hydrogen combustion towards decarbonization" - Research findings expected end of 2023
Start Year 2021
 
Description Project's partnership 
Organisation Loughborough University
Department Department of Engineering
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I and my team contributed to the collaboration by the training of the staff working on the project (postdoc), and the creation of a shared account for data storage on SurfSara, so to allow access to partners for data exchange.
Collaborator Contribution Sandia National Laboratories: Intellectual input and the provision of two highly-valuable direct numerical simulation (DNS) datasets of two conditions relevant for the project. These DNS have been used to benchmark the numerical methodology used in our work. Rolls-Royce has contributed to the partnership via intellectual inputs at the project's meeting. Loughborough University (LU) has also participated to the project's meetings and provided intellectual input. In addition, a PhD studentship has been allocated by LU (estimated to start April 2022) and tied with the present project, under a formal agreement established between LU and TU Delft.
Impact This collaboration has not yet lead to any output. However, a paper has been recently submitted to the International Combustion Symposium.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Project's partnership 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution I and my team contributed to the collaboration by the training of the staff working on the project (postdoc), and the creation of a shared account for data storage on SurfSara, so to allow access to partners for data exchange.
Collaborator Contribution Sandia National Laboratories: Intellectual input and the provision of two highly-valuable direct numerical simulation (DNS) datasets of two conditions relevant for the project. These DNS have been used to benchmark the numerical methodology used in our work. Rolls-Royce has contributed to the partnership via intellectual inputs at the project's meeting. Loughborough University (LU) has also participated to the project's meetings and provided intellectual input. In addition, a PhD studentship has been allocated by LU (estimated to start April 2022) and tied with the present project, under a formal agreement established between LU and TU Delft.
Impact This collaboration has not yet lead to any output. However, a paper has been recently submitted to the International Combustion Symposium.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Project's partnership 
Organisation Sandia National Laboratories California
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution I and my team contributed to the collaboration by the training of the staff working on the project (postdoc), and the creation of a shared account for data storage on SurfSara, so to allow access to partners for data exchange.
Collaborator Contribution Sandia National Laboratories: Intellectual input and the provision of two highly-valuable direct numerical simulation (DNS) datasets of two conditions relevant for the project. These DNS have been used to benchmark the numerical methodology used in our work. Rolls-Royce has contributed to the partnership via intellectual inputs at the project's meeting. Loughborough University (LU) has also participated to the project's meetings and provided intellectual input. In addition, a PhD studentship has been allocated by LU (estimated to start April 2022) and tied with the present project, under a formal agreement established between LU and TU Delft.
Impact This collaboration has not yet lead to any output. However, a paper has been recently submitted to the International Combustion Symposium.
Start Year 2021
 
Description COMBURA symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The event, organised by this PI for years 2021 and 2022, is the national conference on Combustion (COMBURA Symposium). The research findings of the present EPSRC research were disseminated both via poster and presentation. The audience was composed mainly by PhD and postdoctoral researchers working on combustion-related topics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
URL https://www.combura.nl/
 
Description Delft Blue Grand Opening 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This event was co-organised by the PI as part of the celebration for the opening of the new HPC server in Delft. We participated with a poster and a presentation for the general audience. A video was created out of the EPSRC research outcomes and used to replace the "T" of TU Delft with an RQL combustor fuelled by hydrogen, as a symbol for sustainability. This served to promote greatly the research on trapped vortex and reaching out potential wannabe researchers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.tudelft.nl/evenementen/2022/dcse/the-art-of-scientific-computing