The Ends of Modernism: Understanding the Political Uses of Modernist Art among Muslim Intellectuals in Bangladesh since 1952.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Social and Political Science

Abstract

Political movements in the postcolonial world often bring artist out into the streets along with intellectuals, students and workers. The death of Egyptian artist Ahmed Basiony at the hands of security forces in Tahrir Square is a poignant case in point. Basiony's death added great urgency to his posthumous Egyptian Pavilion at the 2011 Venice Biennale in which the work of art measured the costs of action. But how can we understand the role of the fine arts in political movements and political action? How can we understand the roles artists and objects of arts may play in creating political awareness or spurring social movements? How do objects of art or aesthetic environments make political hope or aspiration tangible and produce affective responses in viewers? And in what ways do artists in postcolonial societies turn to the visual and plastic arts to pursue concrete political goals, often in contexts of political repression?

This research project investigates the uses of modernist art in political movements from a social science perspective. Modernist art is often considered to be autonomous and free from social constraint. Its practitioners and critics believe it encourages new ways of seeing the world, presenting viewers with revolutionary new sensations and visions. The radical break with the past that avant-garde modernist artists imagine makes for politically subversive works of art. As a global art form, modernist art has been controversial and groundbreaking in many parts of the world.

In Bangladesh, the modernist dream of creating something radically new has been a leitmotif in the various attempts to liberate, develop and transform this part of Bengal. The modernist dream of progress and universal principles is at the heart of contemporary Bangladeshi society and politics. It can be discerned as easily in the politics of donors as in that of its artists . This project focuses specifically on the role of artists and modernist art practices within the politics of remaking East Pakistan/Bangladesh. Since independence from Britain in 1947, artists from this part of the world have been at the forefront of important and radical political movements and contests in the new state of East Pakistan that in 1971 became Bangladesh. Modernist works of art and artists have been at the receiving end of significant state repression in various forms of censorship in East Pakistan/Bangladesh. At the same time, politicians have embraced public works of modern art as a means to increase their own legitimacy. International organizations in Bangladesh have similarly linked the arts to political goals, such as the engagement with local artists by the Goethe Institute or British Council. Modern art has consistently been sought out for political ends in this part of the world.

To understand the ways in which the arts are used as tools for political contestation in Bangladesh, I will interview artists, art students and policy makers in Dhaka's galleries, arts organisations, universities and NGOs. Archival work in significant Bangladeshi archives will explore the original writings of key East Bengali intellectuals and artists. I will also observe arts classes at important universities and arts institutes and explore with students how they learn to appreciate, understand and make art. I will observe the uses of public space around important modernist buildings and structures. Combined, these methods will illuminate the ways in which modernist art and artists have been part of the political contests of post-colonial East Pakistan/Bangladesh. This research project will contribute to our understanding of the links between culture and politics in the world today.

Planned Impact

Besides the academic beneficiaries outlined above, a number of non-academic users and beneficiaries of this project can be identified:
- National public stakeholders in arts policy at the Bangladesh Ministry of Information and the Ministry of Cultural Affairs, including the Bangladesh Shilpakala Academy.
- International stakeholders in foreign arts policy related to Bangladesh such as the directors of the foreign cultural institutions such as the British Council and Alliance Française and the cultural attachés of diplomatic missions in Dhaka.
- National and International NGOs and development organisations with an explicit arts and culture agenda, such as Probhortona and UNESCO.
- Arts practitioners such as artists, curators, gallery owners, arts collectors, arts magazine editors and art students within Bangladesh and abroad with an interest in contemporary South Asian arts.
- The general public in the UK and Bangladesh with an interest in the arts, particularly in postcolonial and Muslim-majority societies.

The relevance of the research for these different users and beneficiaries consists of:
- New research data about the links between fine arts and politics that can inform policy in the UK, Bangladesh and abroad and inform the general public.
- New insight into the functioning of cultural politics in a postcolonial and Muslim-majority society that can inform policy and the general public.
- Formal analyses and narrative accounts of objects of art and artistic practice in East Pakistan/Bangladesh that will provide new perspective on contemporary and historical modernist practices that can inform arts practitioners, critics and the general public.

To ensure that these beneficiaries have the opportunity to engage with and be informed about this research project, the following impact strategies will be developed:

- Focus groups
During of the field research I will hold three focus groups at the Film Development Corporation, Goethe Institute and British Council and invite national and international stakeholders and local arts practitioners to discuss initial research findings around the relation between politics and fine arts in Bangladesh.

- Policy report
The results of the focus groups will be a policy report to be shared with the three institutions, the cultural attachés of diplomatic missions in Dhaka, and the relevant NGOs, INGOs and development organisations in Bangladesh.

- Advanced training course
I will develop and co-teach a masterclass on art and politics for the new Summer School of the Scottish Graduate School of Social Science, which will be open to students as well as those working in policy-oriented research environments such as the third sector and local government in Scotland.

- Media features
I will collaborate with media contacts to produce media features for newspapers, radio and television about my research. I will contribute articles to the well-read open source journal Himal Southasian, the popular Bangladeshi arts magazines Jamini and Depart, and the popular social scientific magazine Economic and Political Weekly.

- Public lectures
I will give two public lectures in Dhaka for local audiences.

- Blog
Throughout the project I will maintain a research blog where I will post research vignettes, analysis, imagery and accounts of arts exhibitions and events. A dedicated YouTube channel will be linked to the blog, on which selected video-clips from the research will be uploaded.

- Exhibition
I will collaborate with Bangladeshi photographer and filmmaker Paul James Gomes to produce an exhibition and catalogue about the research project to be shown in Dhaka and Edinburgh.

- Documentary
I will develop a short documentary film based on this research which will be submitted to international documentary and ethnographic film festivals.
 
Title Video 'Dhaka's Digital Effects' 
Description This video presents the recent changes in filmmaking in Bangladesh due to the arrival of new digital technologies. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact This video was viewed by the general public through my Vimeo account and my blog 'De Media Automatic' and I received responses to it. 
URL https://vimeo.com/91727147
 
Title Video 'Eid at Champakoli' 
Description This is a brief video documenting the celebration of Eid at a popular cinema hall on the outskirts of Dhaka in 2013. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2013 
Impact Viewership through Vimeo and my blog 'De Media Automatiek' was realised and I received response to it. 
URL https://vimeo.com/74181974
 
Description ESRC grant objectives

In the research project 'The Ends of Modernism: Understanding the Political Uses of Modernist Art among Muslim Intellectuals in Bangladesh since 1952', I set out to understand how modern art has been used politically by artists and institutions. The aim was to understand the place of modernist art and artists in the processes of political contestation that have marked Bangladesh (and East Pakistan, as it was until 1971), and from this understand more generally how art may be used politically. Due to the changing nature of the political situation in Bangladesh during my fieldwork period, and staffing changes over the course of the grant, I came to focus on filmmakers and cinema as field of artistic production. In particular, I focused on the Film Society Movement in East Pakistan/Bangladesh, a broad coalition of independent filmmakers and film connoisseurs who have understood film art as socially relevant and politically efficacious. A study of this movement, the members of which have in many ways been linked to other areas of the visual arts, has allowed me to discover how they perceive cinema to train the senses to be more critical in understanding the world around them, how politically repressed ideas and truths may surface in film and how (public, open-air) film-screening can help galvanize political commitments and movements for large audiences. This is how cinema is perceived by my interlocutors to be politically efficacious.

I have created a body of original data by interviewing many of the Film Society Movement's protagonists, collecting their writings, doing archival research in newspapers from the 1950s onwards, by analyzing their films and by watching and participating in their training events. I have also undertaken archival research at the Bangladesh Censor Board, where I investigated the files related to the so-called 'Black Law' by which film societies have been controlled by the Bangladeshi state since the 1980s. This has generated new empirical research data.

In the course of this project, I have established new and consolidated existing research networks and collaborations. Within Bangladesh, I have expanded my connections to the Ministry of Information (including the Censor Board, the Film Archive and the Bangladesh Film and Television Institute), made connections with private galleries and arts organizations, and spoken at arts festivals and events. I have started an ongoing collaboration with Dr. Sanjukta Sunderason at Leiden University and have co-organised an international conference and co-written a journal article with her. I have been invited to speak at a range of academic events about my new work. I continue to maintain a blog about my ongoing research work.

The research project has increased my research capability. I acquired new skills through courses at the Institute of Academic Development in Edinburgh. A fellowship at the Department of History of Art with Professor Iftikhar Dadi has provided me with the opportunity to familiarize myself with the discipline of art history. A recent invitation to speak at a significant gathering of art historians of South Asia bespeaks these new skills.
Exploitation Route During the course of the project I ran a learning event for one of the film societies in Bangladesh and I was consulted about the curriculum of the newly established Bangladesh Film and Television Institute at the Ministry of Information. I believe that the outcomes of my research, as they develop, will continue to provide tools to those who are working within the field of film in Bangladesh, especially as regards socially conscious cinema.

The data I have collected can be significant in sensitizing artists and connoisseurs about the ways in which cinema can be politically efficacious. Arts practitioners in Bangladesh and elsewhere may find the ways in which the Film Society Movement there has created socially conscious cinema and uses film to educate and mobilize people a useful model for thinking about their own ways of using cinema in activism and for political change.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://mediaautomatiek.wordpress.com
 
Description As detailed in portfolio, I have used my findings in consultancy with national and international organisations, government institutions, through media interview and through artistic production and my blog.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description BFTI consultancy
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Forms of the Left 
Organisation Leiden University
Country Netherlands 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This is an ongoing collaboration with Dr. Sanjukta Sunderason of the Institute for Area Studies at Leiden University across our shared theme of the the aesthetic forms of the leftwing artistic production in postcolonial South Asia. Across a series of workshops, panels and symposia that we have co-organised, I have contributed my expertise and intellectual input as well as resources to the ongoing exchange of research outcomes and the production of a forthcoming edited volume.
Collaborator Contribution Dr. Sanjukta Sunderason of Leiden University has contributed her expertise and intellectual input as well as resources to the series of workshops, panels and symposia that we have co-organised as well as to the ongoing exchange of research outcomes and the production of a forthcoming edited volume.
Impact Lotte Hoek, Sanjukta Sunderason, "Journeying through Modernism: Travels and Transits of East Pakistani Artists in Post-Imperial London", British Art Studies, Issue 13, https://doi.org/10.17658/issn.2058-5462/issue-13/hoek-sunderason Hoek, Lotte and Sanjukta Sunderason (eds). Forthcoming Oct 2021. Forms of the Left in Postcolonial South Asia: Aesthetics, Networks and Connected Histories. London: Bloomsbury. [in production] This is a mutli-disciplinary collaboration. Dr. Sunderason is a historian of art and works in an Area Studies department.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Asia Art Archive consultancy 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was consulted on the extension of the Asian Art Archive's bibliography project to Bangladesh and helped design the inaugural events for the project. It included a workshop which involved student training on building bibliographies in South Asian languages with regard to modern and contemporary art as well as a panel discussion involving key professional practitioners in the field of the fine arts and art writing in Bangladesh.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.aaa.org.hk/Programme/Details/762
 
Description Bangladesh Independence Day Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact During this event, I collaborated withMizan Rahman of the Edinburgh and Lothians Regional Equality Council and the BanglaScot community organisation for those of Bangladeshi descent and heritage to stage a Bagladesh Independence Day event at the University of Edinburgh. I shared elements of my research findings with community participants and discussed matters of concern within the local area. Through this, colleagues and I invited the community into university space and shared insights around the place of art, culture and heritage to the political struggle that led to Bangladeshi indepedence in 1971.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Daily Star feature 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact I was featured in the weekly supplement of the largest English language newspaper of Bangladesh, the Daily Star. This occurred in response to my participation at the 2013 Hay Festival (Dhaka).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://archive.thedailystar.net/beta2/news/lotte-hoek/
 
Description Hay Festival lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I gave a public lecture at the Hay Festival (Dhaka) as part of the "On the Move" panel on16 November 2013. It reached a body of general audience members as well as international and national authors of fiction and non-fiction. The talk was extensively reported in the national print media and my research and I were profiled in a number of high circulation national daily newspapers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.hayfestival.com/p-7522-on-the-move.aspx?skinid=16
 
Description Podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I participated in the podcast series accompanying the high profile biannual Chobi Mela - International Festival of Photography (https://chobimela.org/). The podcast series was curated by artists and curator Munem Wasif. The 1 hour long episode "Contemporary Dissent - Echoes of the '80s - Lotte Hoek and Catherine Masud in conversation" featured a dialogue about our respective work around cinema and dissent in Bangladesh, as well as a broader conversation around visual culture and the short film movement. The international reach of the festival is signifcant, aided this year due to a partial online aspect, which facilitated my participation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://chobimela.org/podcasts/free-jazz-and-the-weight-of-the-camera-4/
 
Description RAI International Festival of Ethnographic Film 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was lead co-organiser of the the 2013 RAI International Festival of Ethnographic Film which was held jointly at the University of Edinburgh and the National Museum of Scotland. This 4 day festival gathered international anthropologists and filmmakers in Edinburgh and was open to the general public. It was a highly successful festival with many members of the general public and professional practitioners participating. As part of the stream 'New Observations' I screened the film by prominent Bangladesh filmmaker and artist Naeem Mohaimen and hosted a discussion with the filmmaker and the audience about cinema, Bangladesh and its contested histories of the left.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://raifilmfest.org.uk/film/festival/2013/conference/187-naeem-mohaiemen-united-red-army-the-youn...
 
Description Shilpakala Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I ran a workshop at Shilpakala, National Academy of Fine and Performing Arts, Bangladesh. This is the foremost government organisation in the field of the performing and fine arts in Bangladesh. In collaboration with the film society Moviyana, I ran an all day workshop with students of the 'Digital Filmmaking Workshop' on 9 March 2014, regarding popular cinema in the context of Bangladesh. As part of the formal training of the new generation of Bangladeshi filmmakers, I believe this workshop would have had impact on their development of cinematic awareness.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Video Workshop "Telling Our Own Stories" 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact I collaborated with Dr. Kazuyo Minamide (Kobe College, Japan; filmmaker and anthropologist), Dr. Mujibul Anam (Jahangirnagar University, Bangladesh; anthropologist) and Paul James Gomes (filmmaker) to run a two week workshop for undergraduate students to think about vide as a means to narrate stories important to their everyday life. This was not an academic workshop but a hands-on filmmaking workshop in which I shared aspects of my research and participated in conversations with students. The final films produced by the students were screened on social media.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019