Parental time investments in children across countries and over time: What are the implications for inequality?

Lead Research Organisation: Queen Mary University of London
Department Name: School of Business and Management

Abstract

This project will use high quality diary data on individual's activities matched to country-level institutional data for several industrialized countries to explore the relationship between parental education and parental time investments in children, how this relationship has changed over the last five decades, and the factors underlying these trends. Recent evidence shows that parental time investments in children have increased in all developed countries, especially for highly educated parents (Aguiar and Hurst 2007; Jimenez-Nadal and Sevilla-Sanz 2011). The increase in parental time is surprising, given the declines in fertility, the increase in female labour force participation, and declines in home production activities in most developed countries, particularly for highly educated mothers (Bianchi, Robinson, and Milkie 2006; Sevilla-Sanz, 2010). This project will contribute to the socio-economic literature by exploring the causes behind trends in parental time investments.

The policy relevance of this research is clear. Given the Government's interest in reducing inequality, this study will add to the body of work on the transmission of opportunities from parents to children by being the first study to assess the impact of the different institutional variables on the time parents with different educational attainment spend with their children. To the extent that less educated parents spend less time with their children than higher educated parents, and that less educated parents engage in child care activities that are less likely to contribute to the human capital of their children, there is scope for early interventions to equalize time with children across families from different social class backgrounds.
The project will be dividing in two major parts. The first part will document changes in parental time investment for parents with different educational background, what has been called in the literature the "education gradient" of parental time. The second part of the project will aim to explain trends in child care by parents of different educational background across countries. First this study will look at whether the type of economy (according to the level of social equity, welfare provision and gender ideologies) has any relationship with the education gradient in parental time. Second, the study will investigate whether decreases in fertility may have had a differential impact on the time parents spend with children, as educated parents tend to have fewer children and thus may have more time to spend time with them. The third explanation will look at the role of income, as (wage) income has increased more for better educated parents over the last few decades. The fourth explanation has to do with safety concerns, and the fact that heightened concerns about safety may induce parents (especially highly educated parents) to accompany their children in their activities. The fifth explanation will look at the differing parenting practices that have been documented for parents with different educational backgrounds and the impact on the time spent with children by parents from diverging social class. College aspirations will constitute the sixth explanation. The rationale behind it is that college-educated parents will be drawn into the competition for college admissions more so than less educated parents. The seventh explanation will look at flexible working practices, which will be important in understanding the trends in the education gradient in parental time as long as the ability to reconcile work and family is greater for parents with a higher socio-economic status. The last explanation that the project will study is family composition. Large numbers of children in the UK live in lone parent families at some point in their lives and may suffer some disadvantages from doing so. Given the focus on children's welfare, there is a special need to include them in the analysis.

Planned Impact

- Who will benefit from it?
This work is intended to benefit a range of academic and non-academic users. Because this will be the first project of its kind in the UK and, to the principal investigator's knowledge, elsewhere, and because the project will include cross-national comparisons, users include not only those from the UK, but also from Europe, North America, and other developed countries. Nonacademic users include civil servants and policy advisor bodies. The principal investigator will exploit her close contacts with Government departments such as the partnerships team in the Cabinet Office, which coordinate a range of policies across government. The Treasury will also be contacted because of its interest in well-being and supporting communities. The principal investigator will also maintain close links to the Department of Communities and Local Government and the Department of Education, which are the two Departments with prime responsibility for children's well-being. The principal investigator will also develop a list of key potential contacts in other Government departments, and MPs with an interest in this field. In addition to the All Party Parliamentary Groups in Parliament on the Economics of Wellbeing, there are other cross party groups on education, equalities and children, which constitute audiences the principal investigator will want to inform about the results of the project.

Other interest groups include Child Poverty Action Group, 4 Children, Day care trust, Gingerbread, Working Families, the Women's Budget Group (where the principal investigator is a member), and the Family and Parenting Institute; health professionals interested in the effect of parental time with children and child development, and parent's interest groups interested in how to make it possible for families to work and care for their children. Unions and workers representatives will also benefit from the findings in this research, to the extent that the type of job and the amount of work hours matter for reconciling family and work responsibilities, including childcare.

- How will they benefit from the work?
Policy makers will benefit from this work because the findings will improve our understanding of whether and why children born to parents with different educational attainments receive different parental time investments, which will have implications for policies designed to increase equality of opportunities early in life and to reduce inequality later in life. Employees and families, and organisations that represent them, will benefit from the research by learning new information about how parental time with children differs by parental educational background. This information should allow them to make informed parenting choices.

- What will be done to ensure that they have the opportunity to benefit from this research?
The findings of the project will be publicised to the general public and other interest groups through a dedicated section of the School of Business and Management website, which will be updated as the project develops. Key findings will be communicated in press releases to QM well-established network of media contacts, and non-technical summaries will be published in the School's Newsletter. The principal investigator will seek opportunities to offer briefings and to present our findings in a policy context and to demonstrate their policy relevance to Government Departments, MPs with an interest in this field, and other interest groups. The principal investigator will be holding a 1-day workshop at the end of the project where the main results of the project will be presented to policy makers and interest groups alike. The principal investigator will set up an advisory group This group will meet twice during the life of the project, once at the beginning where the project design will be discussed and the project impact plan put in place, and one at the end to discuss findings and write a report.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We firstly document trends in parental time investments for college and non-college educated parents over the last five decades in the UK and compare those to those of other countries in the industrialised world, => Trends in the Education Gradient:



- We document increases in parental time investments in most countries. Parental time investments increased 30 min./day for mothers and 20 min./day for fathers.





- We document a positive education gradient: With respect to non-college educated parents, college-educated mothers devote between 5 more minutes per day (Canada and France), and 20-25 more minutes per day (Sweden, US)

College-educated fathers devote about 10 more minutes in most countries (US 18, UK -3).





- Unlike in the US, trends in the education gradient vary across countries, and for fathers and mothers within a given country. We find that in contrast to previous findings for the United States, the difference between college-educated parents and lower educated parents with respect to time investments has not increased in all countries over this period.



Mothers:

Increases: Netherlands and the US

Decreases: Australia, France, Norway

Constant: Canada, Finland, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden, the UK.

Range: -17 min in France, +15 min in the US



Fathers:

Increases: Australia, Canada, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, the US

Decreases: Finland, France, Spain, the UK.

Constant: Italy, Norway

Range: -11 min in Finland, + 16 min in Canada and the US.





We secondly examine the main explanations offered by the literature for the sources of these differences in parental time investments. Using auxiliary micro-level data on safety concerns and parenting values, we rule out preference-based explanations as a possible mechanism explaining the differences in the trends in parental time with children for college and non-college educated parents. With the exception of the US, trends in children's homework-related activities are not consistent with the evolution of the education gradient in most countries, which suggests that differential trends in the returns to parental time investments for college-educated parents and non-college educated parents cannot explain changes in the education gradient.



In the UK, o single hypothesis seems to adequately explain parental trends in education gradients (much easier to explain positive education gradients or general increases in childcare time)
Sectors Other

 
Description The findings of the project are of benefit to those wishing to understand the trends in parental time and the effect of university competition on how much parents spend with their children. Crucially differences in parental time across parents with different educational backgrounds may have direct implications on inequality. Policy makers have benefited from this work because the findings improved our understanding of how access to university affects parental time for parents with different socio-economic status. This can have implications for policies designed to increase access to less well-off children. Possible measures include placing greater emphasis on admission criteria that parents cannot directly influence and providing less-educated parents with the right information and tools about the admission process during their child's secondary school years. The UK admissions system places weight on examination results and prior academic performance. Targeted measures designed to boost school performance for children from less-advantaged families, such as providing after-school homework clubs, could help. Our study shows that parents with college degrees spent more time on educational activities with their children during a period when competition for university places was increasing," says Professor Sevilla. "This has important implications for policies aimed at reducing inequality and ensuring that children from less-educated parents are able to successfully compete in the university admission process. As planned in our original proposal, we engaged with audiences who might be interested in or benefit from our work and stablished strong links and networks at regional, national, and international level. We also developed a communication strategy to undertake impact in a co-ordinated and professional manner, identifying target audiences and outlining the channels and activities that helped us to engage effectively with stake holders. These activities are described within the "Engagement Activities" in Researchfish. As a result of the interest generated by this project, there was an article on ESRC magazine "Britain Now" about our research (as described under "Outputs" in Researchfish, which brings the findings to the attention of a wider public.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Government, Democracy and Justice,Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description 6th ESRC Research Methods Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Dr Almudena Sevilla convened the session Using Secondary Analysis to Research Social Diversity and Population Dynamics.
This session introduced some of the issues to be confronted when studying social diversity and population dynamics using large and complex survey data sets. Quantitative methods were discussed. Methods span from regression analysis across countries and over time (which are used to identify changes in family life in the UK and elsewhere) to quasi-experimental estimation techniques (which are used to evaluate causal effects from social policies). The session also discussed opportunities, challenges and practicalities of existing data sources to suit research questions on family dynamics in the UK.

to complete
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.ncrm.ac.uk/RMF2014/programme/session.php?id=A3
 
Description Academic Advisory Board Meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Presentation and discussion of research preliminary outcomes. The aim of this event is to bring together researchers with an interest in cross-national research on parental time investments and inequality.

feedback of experts
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.busman.qmul.ac.uk/research/parentaltimeinvestmentsinchildrenproject/documents/101631.pdf
 
Description ESRC Secondary Data Analysis Initiative (SDAI) Networking Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Presentation of research outcomes at ESRC Secondary Data Analysis Initiative Networking Event - British Library, St Pancras, London.
Social Diversity and Population Dynamics Cluster, which sparked questions and discussion about future avenues for research for cluster members.

Presentation of research outcomes at ESRC Secondary Data Analysis Initiative Networking Event - British Library, St Pancras, London. Social Diversity and Population Dynamics Cluster.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.esrc.ac.uk/my-esrc/grants/ES.K003127.1/outputs/read/e3bd3832-640a-42db-8f3d-8617fcaf9114