The relational body: sharing body representations with significant others

Lead Research Organisation: Royal Holloway University of London
Department Name: Psychology

Abstract

Humans are fundamentally social animals. We form close relationships with others and characteristically live in small, close social groups of siblings, romantic partners, and our infants. Social psychologists have shown that the way in which we process social information from our family members and intimate partners is very different to that from strangers and acquaintances. For example, we show increased empathy when our intimate partners are in pain, mothers have enhanced detection of their own infant's cries, and we show enhanced altruism and trust for our siblings. Evolutionary psychologists argue that these distinct social behaviors serve important biological functions, such as long-term pair-bonding, child-rearing, and maintenance of kin-relationships. In evolutionary history, these processes were central to survival and reproduction. They argue that much of our social behavior in the present day still serves these functional relationships, often on an implicit level. Therefore, evolutionary psychology has provided an explanation of why these special social processes exist, appealing to their specific biological functions.
However, no-one has yet provided an explanation of how we are able to process social signals from our close family and partners in this special way. We suggest that a focus on the role of the body in social cognition may enable us to understand the neurocognitive basis of these evolutionarily important social processes. The way we represent our bodies and the bodies of others plays a central role in our understanding of social signals. Evidence suggests that when we observe the bodily experiences of others, such as touch, pain, emotion and movement, we 'share' these experiences. For example, when we see someone being touched, specific areas of our brains are activated in the same way as if we were touched ourselves. This sharing of others' bodily states, also known as 'bodily overlap', might underlie a number of important social processes, such as empathy, emotion recognition, and understanding others' intentions.
So far, experiments investigating this bodily overlap have only used unfamiliar others as social stimuli, and so our understanding of the role of the body in social processing is restricted to how we interact with strangers. This neglects significant others, such as family and partners. Can differences in the way we represent their bodies in relation to our own explain the enhanced empathy we have for a partner, the increased trustworthiness we see in a sibling's face, or the special ability of a mother to read her infant's emotions and needs? And if we change bodily overlap, can this affect the quality of our relationships with close others? This project will investigate the role of bodily overlap for social cognition in biologically important social relationships, focusing on relationships between siblings, mothers and infants, and partners. For each relationship, we will use a variety of experimental methods to assess bodily overlap and social processing. We will also experimentally increase bodily overlap between individuals, and see how it changes perceived relationship quality.
The results of our research may have a number of diverse applications. One area which our research might impact upon is that of health and well-being. The physical and mental health benefits of close relationships and the adverse effects of family breakdown are well documented. Our research will investigate the effects of increasing bodily overlap within these relationships to improve relationship quality, and this makes our research very relevant to relationship therapies and other family interventions. We also foresee a number of applications in other areas, including the work-place, whereby our research into close adult relationships could be extended to increase our understanding of the role of the body in creating and maintaining functional and productive relationships between work colleagues.

Planned Impact

The key focus of our project is on close social relationships. The health benefits of these relationships and the adverse effects of family breakdown, both for individuals and society at large, are well documented in the medical literature. Breakdown of social relationships are a significant causal factor in the development of both mental and physical illness. By investigating the effects of experimentally increased interpersonal synchrony, our research has the potential to develop simple behavioral interventions to increase self-other bodily overlap. Results from our project will enable us to assess the ability of such interventions to enhance perceived relationship quality, as well as improve the way social signals from significant others are perceived, understood and responded to, potentially enhancing quality of life, health and well-being.
More specifically, our project may inform a number of user groups involved in relationship therapy and therapeutic interventions as well as Third Sector users, such as the Charity "Relate" whose mission is to develop and support healthy relationships. For example, marital counselling is a burgeoning area of the therapy sector, whose growth is in response to rapidly increasing divorce rates in the UK. Our research with long-term romantic partners will inform therapists of the effects of increasing interpersonal bodily overlap on social understanding and perceived relationship quality.
The mother-infant relationship is another potential area of impact, being highly relevant for family therapists and developmental clinicians. Early mother-infant interactions have important consequences for subsequent child development. Intervention therapies are particularly important for mothers with depression, and mothers of premature infants, both of which have reduced synchrony in face-to-face interactions with their infants, poorer interpretation of the infant's needs, and ultimately poorer developmental outcomes. Our research into the role of the body in these important face-to-face interactions will provide data which can inform therapists on the effectiveness of simple behavioral procedures to increase synchrony and responsiveness between a mother and her infant.
The focus on the mother-infant relationship could extend to impact the toy industry. Age appropriate toys for young infants may be designed to induce mother-infant synchrony, perhaps eliciting synchronous touch or action, for example. This may provide strong cues for the infant's developing intersubjectivity, but may also improve the way in which mothers synchronize with their infants during face-to-face interactions. Our research could provide new data emphasizing the importance of toys that support mutually-beneficial bodily interaction between mothers and infants.
Our focus on the mother-infant relationship may also inform the development of new assessments of infant attachment. Existing diagnostic measures of attachment take considerable time to administer and code, are expensive, and not suitable for infants below 12 months of age. Our research has the potential to identify simple, quick and cheap measures of bodily overlap between mother and infant which may reliably predict later attachment security.
Finally, the overall focus of the proposed project on family and close relationships may also be applicable to the workplace. Adults in full-time employment currently spend on average 40hr/week at work with colleagues. The importance of team cohesion, affiliation, and social interaction with colleagues is reflected in the growing number of companies and organisations investing in 'team-building' days as a means to improve productivity and employee well-being. Our research on the role of shared body representations in the development and maintenance of important social relationships may be extended to increase our understanding of how cooperation, interaction and affiliation in the work-place are influenced by embodied processes.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our investigation of shared body representations within romantic partnerships has revealed some fascinating insights regarding the extent to which embodied experiences of self and partner 'overlap', and the role of this overlap in adult romantic attachment (see Maister & Tsakiris, 2016, Cognition, 152, pg. 108-113). We found increased self-other overlap in embodied motor representations between romantic partners as compared to close, platonic friends. A widely-used measure of attachment anxiety was related to this automatic motor resonance, in a positive direction for romantic partners and a negative direction for friends. Existing research into romantic relationships has highlighted a link between attachment style and self-other overlap at a conceptual level. However, ours is the first to identify a similar link with self-other overlap of embodied representations.

Our project further revealed the importance of embodied processing to romantic relationships, by extending our investigation to the interoceptive domain (see Maister, Hodossy & Tsakiris, in press, Psychology of Consciousness). We revealed that observing one's partner's face enhances interoceptive awareness, in a similar way to observing one's own face in other contexts. Taken together, our project has highlighted a novel, embodied aspect of romantic relationships that will open up new avenues of future research.

Our investigations into embodiment in the mother-infant relationship have also been successful. We developed a novel task, the Mother-Infant Bodily Overlap (MIBO) task, designed to measure infants' preferences for shared sensory experiences with their mother or another individual. Infants demonstrated a marked preference towards sharing synchronous tactile experience with their mother, as compared to experiencing asynchronous tactile stimulation, and furthermore, this preference was absent when viewing a stranger. These results suggest that infants mapped their mother's embodied experiences on to their own bodies. Fascinatingly, the extent to which infants 'shared' body representations with their mother was reliably correlated with naturalistic, face-to-face emotional coordination between mother and infant, suggesting that shared body representations play a key developmental role in early social cognition (Maister, Hodossy & Tsakiris, in preparation).

We also investigated mother-infant bodily overlap from the perspective of the mother. We measured mothers' automatic facial mimicry of their own vs. a stranger's infant's emotional expressions. Surprisingly, there was no enhancement of mimicry of their own infant, but there were striking differences in their subjective experience of the babies' emotions. Furthermore, the extent to which mothers mimicked their infants was correlated with their maternal attachment feelings towards them. This suggests that the extent to which mothers' embody their infants' emotions plays an important role in fundamental attachment mechanisms (Maister, Hodossy & Tsakiris, in preparation).

Overall, our project has revealed the importance of shared body representations in two evolutionarily important social relationships; between romantic partners, and between a mother and her infant. We have used a combination of existing, well-validated techniques and novel methods to demonstrate increased bodily overlap in these relationships, as well as links with fundamental aspects of social cognition. This will stimulate new areas of research, to test the role of overlap in different sensory-motor domains and in other important social relationships.
Exploitation Route Scientific Impact: The novelty of this project lay in its ability to link two previously isolated scientific disciplines; the social psychologists' study of close human relationships, and the cognitive neuroscientists' investigation of embodiment in impersonal social situations. By disseminating our research as broadly as possible to other academics, we hope that future work will take into consideration these important links. We have currently disseminated our research in two international journal publications, with at least 3 more in preparation intended for interdisciplinary journals. We have presented our research to other scientists at an international conference ('European Society for Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Conference, Porto, Portugal), and presented our developmental data at two academic meetings (School of Advanced Study, UK; Central European University, Hungary). We also organised an international symposium, bringing together five diverse scientists from all over the world to speak on different aspects of close social relationships (symposium 'Close Human Relationships: From Infancy to Adulthood' organized by L. Maister, ESCAN, Porto).

Economic and Societal Impact: A significant socio-economic impact will probably come from our work on the mother-infant relationship, but since this was the last work package to be developed we expect that the wider impact would take much longer to materialize. The link we have discovered between shared mother-infant touch and coordination during naturalistic interactions has important implications for the development of toys and activities for mothers and infants which could involve shared touch or affect as a primary feature. Furthermore, our data linking automatic mimicry, adult attachment and synchronous movements in romantic partnerships, from which the results are being finalised, have the potential to inform simple behavioural interventions to improve relationship quality. Our findings on partners have attracted the interest of non-academic users who work with couples and relationships and in early 2017 we have been invited to present our results in a conference tailored for mental health practitioners (Regents College, UK). We will continue to seize opportunities to present our research in non-academic audiences and will accompany the publication of our scientific papers with press releases and media outreach activities.
Sectors Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism

 
Description The non-academic impact of our research has slowly started to materialize through engagement with health practitioners, in particular psychotherapists. In June 2017, we were invited to present our work at the Psychotherapy and Counselling Psychology Reflections Research Centre , 4th Annual One-Day Conference, Psychosomatic Clinical Presentations and Implications for Embodied, Relational Psychological Therapy Approaches, that took place at Regent's College London. At the conference we had the opportunity to present the key findings of our research funded by ESRC. For example we presented work highlighting the mechanisms that underlie bodily overlap in romantic partners, and highlighted both the quantitative but also the qualitative differences observed relating to attachment style, a key concept on several psychotherapeutic approaches. We also had the opportunity to present our work on interoception and interoceptive awareness in romantic partners. Following the keynote presentation at that practice-oriented conference, we were invited to submit a paper to the THE JOURNAL OF PSYCHOTHERAPY AND COUNSELLING PSYCHOLOGY REFLECTIONS (JPCPR) which is read by psychotherapists and other mental health practitioners. Similar presentation of our work was given at an international conference that was addressed to both academic and practitioners, namely the 18th Annual Congress of the International Neuropsychoanalysis Society. London, England. Following our presentation there, we were approached by several psychotherapists working in UK and USA who are interested in using some of our measures in the assessment of their clients. We are currently discussing with them how we can take this work forward in a more practice -oriented and client-centred way. In relation to our second line of research, namely the mother-infants interactions and bodily overlap, impact activities have not started as the research is currently under review and therefore unpublished. But we do hope that once it is published and disseminated in academic outlets and the general media, we will be in a strong position to attract the expected interest from potential non-academic beneficiaries.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Description The intersubjective map of erogenous zones 
Organisation Bangor University
Department School of Psychology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Together with researchers at Bangor and UCL, we developed a large scale questionnaire-based study investigating the multisensory nature of erogenous zones. This is an important aspect of embodied close relationships, particularly relevant to the Romantic Partners workstream of the grant. We developed the questionnaire, recruited participants, analysed the resulting responses and are now preparing the findings for dissemination.
Collaborator Contribution Oliver Turnbull at Bangor and Katerina Fotopolou at UCL provided essential input in the development of the study concept, specific support in creating the questionnaire and are providing ongoing input in the interpretation of the results.
Impact The large dataset resulting from this collaboration are still being analysed and the results interpreted. We invisage at least two high-quality publications to arise from this project. The expected impact from this work is in part academic, as it will reveal the interactions between visual and tactile modalities in the experience of erogenous pleasure. It is also in part societal, as it will give new insights into the effects of demographic variables, such as age, gender, and sexuality, as well as the effects of hormonal contraceptives, on subjective experiences of erogenous pleasure. Therefore we expect this study to generate interest in the wider society.
Start Year 2013
 
Description The intersubjective map of erogenous zones 
Organisation University College London
Department Division of Psychology & Language Sciences
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Together with researchers at Bangor and UCL, we developed a large scale questionnaire-based study investigating the multisensory nature of erogenous zones. This is an important aspect of embodied close relationships, particularly relevant to the Romantic Partners workstream of the grant. We developed the questionnaire, recruited participants, analysed the resulting responses and are now preparing the findings for dissemination.
Collaborator Contribution Oliver Turnbull at Bangor and Katerina Fotopolou at UCL provided essential input in the development of the study concept, specific support in creating the questionnaire and are providing ongoing input in the interpretation of the results.
Impact The large dataset resulting from this collaboration are still being analysed and the results interpreted. We invisage at least two high-quality publications to arise from this project. The expected impact from this work is in part academic, as it will reveal the interactions between visual and tactile modalities in the experience of erogenous pleasure. It is also in part societal, as it will give new insights into the effects of demographic variables, such as age, gender, and sexuality, as well as the effects of hormonal contraceptives, on subjective experiences of erogenous pleasure. Therefore we expect this study to generate interest in the wider society.
Start Year 2013