Eating Attentively: Episodic Memory & Eating Behaviour

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Institute of Psychology Health & Society

Abstract

Obesity is now a major biosocial issue that affects most of the developed world. Rises in obesity have been caused primarily by increases in the amount of food people have been eating. However, the long-term reductions to food consumption which are required to promote weight loss are difficult to achieve for most people on their own. Recent work has shown that memory for recent eating experiences is an important determinant of eating behaviour; by having an accurate memory representation of what we have been eating throughout the day, we can make better decisions about how much to eat. This raises the possibility of developing intervention tools that target memory for recent eating in order to help people eat more healthily. In line with this, initial results suggest that encouraging individuals to eat in a more 'attentive' manner, by ensuring attention is paid towards meals being eaten, improves memory for recent eating and reduces the amount of food people tend to eat. These finding are promising as even modest reductions to food consumption can promote weight loss and therefore have positive effects on health and well-being.
Although it has been suggested that memory informs food consumption, how this process occurs is unclear. If we are able to understand how 'attentive' eating reduces food consumption, this may have public health benefit. Thus, a thorough investigation of how memory influences eating behaviour is now required. Memory for recent eating consists of multiple episodic 'elements', such as visual memory for meal size and memory for how filling a meal is remembered to have been. Understanding which episodic 'elements' determine how much food we consume and explain why eating attentively reduces food consumption will provide us with novel theoretical information. This in turn will also enable us to design effective intervention tools to target memory for recent eating, so we can help overweight individuals eat less and lose weight, which will be of wider public health benefit.
This research will be the first to develop a theoretical account of how memory for recent eating influences eating behaviour and the process by which an 'attentive' eating style reduces food consumption. This new knowledge will then guide a translational 'real world' intervention study; taking the findings from initial promising laboratory studies and using cross-disciplinary methods to test whether 'attentive eating' principles can be applied in a public health intervention setting to help overweight people eat less and lose weight. Studies 1 and 2 use laboratory feeding methods to manipulate and interfere with memories for recent eating, in order to test and understand the influence that different memory elements have on food consumption. Study 3 tests whether targeting memory for recent eating and promoting a more 'attentive' approach to eating through the use of smartphone technology can help overweight and obese individuals eat less and lose weight.
The present project will address an important biosocial question and benefit from cross-disciplinary research methods. By the end of the research we will have developed a better understanding of how memory for recent eating influences food consumption and examined the applied relevance of this new knowledge. These novel insights will have the potential to help tackle the widespread obesity problem faced by the majority of the developed world.

Planned Impact

As this work will provide a novel theoretical contribution to the area of appetite regulation, it has the potential to impact the work of scientists who study appetite regulation from behavioural, physiological and cognitive backgrounds. Given that we will also be investigating a translational approach to achieving sustained reductions to energy intake and weight loss, the methods used and findings of this grant will also be of use to public health researchers developing behavioural interventions for obesity. To reach these academic beneficiaries we will focus on regular conference presentations, publication in leading journals and develop a dedicated grant website.
The translational nature of this research means that it will have applied relevance and the potential to be far reaching in its impact. Obesity is now a widespread problem in most of the developed world and research clearly shows that even modest reductions in body weight can promote meaningful improvements in quality of life. However, these reductions are difficult to achieve with the current tools to which the general public have access. The development and testing of the 'attentive eating' mobile phone intervention in Study 3 directly addresses this issue. If shown to be effective in this grant, this theory driven intervention will have real potential to benefit public health and it would be suitable for larger scale testing. As we are using a simple and scale-able platform to deliver our intervention (the majority of UK adults now own mobile phones), this work has real potential to benefit a wide spectrum of society. For example, if shown to be effective in the long-term, such a tool could eventually be made available to medical practitioners as a treatment option for weight loss or the general public. Because of this, an important part of this grant is the networking opportunities and links the planned study visits will afford the PI. For example, as well as being linked to key stakeholders by his mentor, the PI will spend time working on dissemination activities with collaborator Aveyard, a science advisor on obesity to the Department of Health and contributor to NICE guidelines for the treatment of obesity. In addition, the PI will maintain regular dialogue with key stakeholders (e.g. Public Health England) and plan a flagship dissemination event to target both local and national public health stakeholders and advisory boards.
We are also aware that the cross-disciplinary approaches used and focus on obesity means that our work will be of interest to the general public. We have a number of planned activities to engage with this audience, including local and national media engagement and attendance at a UK public science dissemination event (British Science Festival). See Pathways to Impact for more information.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Haynes A (2018) A systematic review of the relationship between weight status perceptions and weight loss attempts, strategies, behaviours and outcomes. in Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity

publication icon
Robinson E (2017) Perceived weight discrimination mediates the prospective relation between obesity and depressive symptoms in U.S. and U.K. adults. in Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association

publication icon
Robinson E (2018) Self-perceived overweight, weight loss attempts, and weight gain: Evidence from two large, longitudinal cohorts. in Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association

 
Description Memories for recent eating have been shown to affect how much people eat and prior to this grant there was some initial evidence that eating more attentively (e.g. focusing on food being eaten to improve memory) results in people eating less. The objectives of this grant were to better understand the role that attentive eating has on food intake and to test whether a smartphone-based app that encourages an attentive eating style is an effective approach to help people lose weight. Three main planned studies were conducted as part of the grant: two laboratory studies to achieve the first objective and one weight loss trial to achieve the second objective.

Our laboratory studies did not replicate previous findings showing that eating attentively reduces food intake, instead we found no effect of eating attentively on food intake. We also found no improvement to meal memories when participants ate attentively, even though we used a range of memory measures. Because of these unexpected findings, we conducted additional laboratory studies to attempt to explain the lack of replication and these additional studies also produced negative results. Overall, these results indicate that the effect of eating more attentively does not have a reliable influence on how much people eat and the assumption that eating attentively improves meal memory may be inaccurate. We will publish all of these negative results in academic journals because this information will be important for other researchers interested in cognition, memory and eating. Further theoretical research is now be warranted to better understand whether eating attentively can affect how much people eat, as our results suggest this effect is not as reliable as initially thought.

The results of our weight loss trial indicated that participants using the attentive eating smartphone based app did not lose any more weight than participants in the control condition of the trial. We also conducted a series of analyses to examine whether participants who used the app very regularly lost more weight than the control group and this was not the case. The results of the trial also found no evidence that the app resulted in participants eating more healthily (measured via self-report). Overall, these results suggest that the attentive eating smartphone app developed is not an effective tool to help people lose weight.

The overall discovery from this grant is that encouraging people to eat more attentively may not be an effective approach to reducing food intake and losing weight. We are confident in the individual conclusions from our studies as we used best practice methodology, recruited sufficient sample sizes for our main analyses and pre-registered studies. Yet, across studies we found no evidence of any health benefit to attentive eating. Our findings have relevance to researchers attempting to identify effective healthy eating and weight loss interventions and researchers developing theoretical models of the influence that attention and memory have on eating behaviour.
Exploitation Route The evidence base we have generated indicates that the attentive eating app we developed is unlikely to help people lose weight. It is therefore not appropriate to promote widespread use of the app (e.g. through the NHS) or encourage others to distribute it for the purpose of healthy eating promotion or weight loss. However, now that all studies have been completed we will continue to disseminate these negative results because they suggest that eating attentively alone is unlikely to provide benefit to people trying to lose weight. We will publish all of the grant studies and we imagine that this research will be taken forward. For example, there are relatively few UK-based weight loss trials of smartphone apps. It may also be the case that researchers identify other ways that attentive eating can be trained in order to effectively promote healthier eating and weight loss. Likewise, our negative laboratory results are the first to question the reliability of the effect of attentive eating on food intake. These conflicting findings may now encourage others to study why our studies failed to observe a beneficial effect of attentive eating, but others have produced positive effects.
Sectors Other

 
Description Starter grant
Amount € 1,365,346 (EUR)
Organisation European Research Council (ERC) 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 01/2019 
End 12/2023
 
Description Collaboration on research methods for grant study 
Organisation University of Bristol
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Data collection
Collaborator Contribution Expertise in psychophysical task used for data collection
Impact Work is currently ongoing.
Start Year 2016
 
Title Attentive Eating Intervention for Weight Loss 
Description The mobile phone app we have recently developed is currently being tested in a small proof-of-principle trial to examine it's effect on dietary intake and weight loss (a research objective of our current ESRC grant) 
Type Therapeutic Intervention - Psychological/Behavioural
Current Stage Of Development Early clinical assessment
Year Development Stage Completed 2017
Development Status Under active development/distribution
Impact N/A 
 
Title Attentive Eating for Weight Loss Smartphone Application 
Description For our ESRC funded work we have developed in-full a mobile phone app that is designed to reduce food consumption and promote weight loss. It is compatible with Apple and Android platforms. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact At present we are testing the clinical effectiveness of this app. If it proves to be clinically effective then we will explore the most comprehensive approach to make it widely available and acessible. 
 
Description Conference presentation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact At the British Feeding and Drinking Group, 2017 we present the results of our first grant study. This is a useful dissemination outlet because the audience includes other academics and members of the food industry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Dissemination of on-going weight loss trial at a national obesity forum and a national behavioural medicine conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact We presented our on-going mobile phone app weight loss trial at the UK Association for the Study of Obesity national conference and the UK Society for Behavioural Medicine. This event includes third sector groups working in public health, individuals with link to national policy making (e.g. Public Health England) and patient group members. As a result of interest, we will update interested parties on the results of our trial when it is complete later this year.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description New Scientist Live Talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I presented work from both our recent MRC and ESRC funded research as an invited speaker at New Scientist Live 2018. New Scientist Live is an international science festival for the general public. The work I presented discussed how obesity can be tackled as a public health issue and what role the general public have in this. The talk was well attended, members of the general public expressed interest in the work, that it had changed the way they think about obesity and requested further information.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://live.newscientist.com/speakers/eric-robinson
 
Description Pint of Science - Local community public engagement 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We delivered a talk and presentation as part of a local science public engagement festival on our MRC and ESRC grant funded research which sparked questions and discussion afterwards.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Series of public engagement visits in local community 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Our group hosted a series of interactive events in the local community. These included stalls at a local museum, large local shopping centre and waiting area at a large central train station. Members of the general public took part in interactive displays that taught them about how our on-going research on food, attention and obesity relates to their everyday life (ESRC funded), as well as our research on portion size (MRC funded). A number of attendees reported having learnt new information and this open up an opportunity for dialect and discussion. As a result of the success of these events, our group is now running a workshop for staff members at our University in order to teach others about public dissemination strategies and opportunities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Talk to general public 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Over 100 members of the general public and potential psychology students visited our research institute as part of an open day. I presented our research during a 30 minute talk with a Q+A section. The talk raised awareness in obesity research and was well received.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017