Two-Way SBE-RCUK/ESRC Lead Agency Agreement: Relationship Strategies to Bolster Interpersonal Security Over Time

Lead Research Organisation: Goldsmiths University of London
Department Name: Psychology

Abstract

People differ in how willing and able they are to forge bonds in which they feel secure with others. People who achieve greater attachment security have better relationship outcomes, are more confident in pursuing personal goals and better able to handle challenges, and exhibit greater well-being in general. Although attachment insecurity is often a chronic condition, it can and does change with new experiences. This project capitalises on interactions in romantic relationships, which evoke experiences that have powerful effects in regulating a sense of security. This research introduces relationship strategies that couples can adopt, including communication strategies that strengthen trust or confidence and perception exercises that aid in positive reinterpretations of interactions. Many couples desire to improve their relationship and acknowledge that, ideally, they would like to help each other thrive. However, they struggle to modify established interpersonal dynamics that may keep them stuck in a state of interpersonal anxiety (fear of losing a partner's acceptance and support) and/or interpersonal avoidance (discomfort with relying on others or intimacy). The relationship strategies examined in this research target each type of insecurity and are designed to be incorporated in typical couple interactions and daily events. These strategies may also be adopted in non-romantic settings by individuals who have endured negative interpersonal experiences.

The primary goal of this project is to identify strategies that affect couple communication and perceptions to achieve two aims: reduce insecure relational dynamics and enhance attachment security over time. In a series of randomized experiments, couples are assigned to strategies to target anxious tendencies or avoidant tendencies. The first aim is to examine communication strategies aimed at mitigating anxiety versus avoidance, each tested against a control condition. Such communication may reduce immediate relational tension but may not be sufficient to cause enduring changes in attachment security. The second aim, therefore, involves examining interactions and perceptions that can increase confidence among anxious individuals and increase trust among avoidant individuals. The effect of these security-enhancing strategies, combined with communication that mitigates insecurity, will be examined over an extended time. These relatively minor adjustments in couple interactions are expected to ripple into more profound changes in general attachment security, which benefits relationships and promotes meaningful activities that are fundamental to societal well-being.

Planned Impact

This project is expected to have both academic and societal impact, as it introduces new evidence based methods for bolstering attachment security and contributes to ESRC's aim of "enhancing quality of life, health and creative output." Worldwide, psychological well-being matters to people as much as their economic well-being[6]. The outcomes of the project have broad implications for societal improvement, in both the UK and the USA, as attachment security lies at the heart of successful relationships and personal thriving. Although attachment security is typically regarded as unchangeable in adulthood, directing relationships to flourish or flounder, we argue that intimate relationships can be tapped as a crucial resource for bolstering attachment security. Many couples desire to improve their relationships and help each other flourish but do not know how to change the established interpersonal dynamics.

We offer evidence-based intervention exercises that are designed to be easily accessed and adopted by the general public. General interest in improving relationships and feeling better about themselves is evident by the sheer volume of popular publications and websites offering advice on this topic, although the majority are not grounded in scientific theory. We aim to educate the broader public about the science behind the proposed interventions. Individuals who are not in romantic relationships will also be able to use the intervention exercises in the context of other close or interdependent relationships (e.g., family, friend, mentor, co-worker). They may be able to adopt some of the exercises alone as well, such as by using the written exercises to help them learn to trust others or using the communication strategies to quell a friend's anxious or avoidant tendencies. The mini-intervention strategies that will be established in our research are intended for a non-clinical population; we will ensure in our dissemination and educational activities that people are aware of this and that our exercises should not be regarded as therapy. People suffering from severe relationship issues (e.g., abuse), or those with mental health issues will be advised to seek counselling.

Moreover, we expect our strategies to be used by academics, practitioners, and public sector organisations in a wide variety of fields (see statement on Academic Beneficiaries). Our low-cost mini-intervention strategies will be of particular interest to policy makers and others in the public sector who are seeking to improve well-being of the general population, who would not otherwise be in need of extensive therapy or larger interventions. Based on findings of this project, practitioners may be able to offer advice and guidance to such non-clinical sample of couples and individuals, who are primarily seeking to improve the quality of their relationships.

We plan to disseminate the findings of this study widely, to the academic community, private/public/third sector, and the general public. We will actively seek to disseminate our findings through publication of journal articles in a variety of fields and through presentations at conferences, universities, and other academic themed events. We also plan to disseminate our findings to students and the general public, with special attention given to sharing our findings with members of underrepresented groups who may be reluctant to seek out help. To do this, we will seek to have an online presence and will seek to pitch our findings through presentation at general public events. The UK PI will capitalize on being based in London to publicize findings through local and national media and at events aimed for general public. Finally, we will mentor and train future researchers (see Academic Beneficiary section), and we will teach students about the topic in our courses on close relationships and social psychology and during seminars for students of MSc in Psychology of Social Relations at Goldsmiths.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Arriaga X (2020) Self-Efficacy and Declines Over Time in Attachment Anxiety During the Transition to Parenthood in Social Psychological and Personality Science

publication icon
Arriaga XB (2018) Revising Working Models Across Time: Relationship Situations That Enhance Attachment Security. in Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc

publication icon
Arriaga, X. B (2021) Attachment: Fundamental Questions

publication icon
Rice TM (2020) Mind the Gap: Perceived Partner Responsiveness as a Bridge between General and Partner-Specific Attachment Security. in International journal of environmental research and public health

 
Description This project sought to test in non-clinical samples if romantic partners can help insecurely attached individuals become more interpersonally secure through using new theoretically based relationship strategies, without the aid of a counsellor. Given that people develop chronic orientations toward interpersonal insecurities based on their social experiences, it was theorized that close relationship partners can provide repeated situations that may help revise entrenched working models of self and others. For example, anxiously attached tendencies originate from feeling anxious about whether they are valued by others, whereas avoidantly attached tendencies originate from lack of trust that others will be there for them. This project combined experimental and longitudinal methods to test relationship-based experiences that were theorized to increase attachment security among couples. Key findings are summarized below.

The first aim of this project was to test specific communication strategies to reduce momentary insecurities that often occur when a person confronts a personal or relational problem. "Safe strategies" to reduce momentary anxiety (e.g., providing reassurance, deescalating negative emotions) and "soft strategies" to reduce momentary avoidance (e.g., making moments less emotionally intense, accepting a person's independent ways, masking support that a person might resist) were provided to a relatively secure partner, and that person watched videos and worked through writing exercises to learn how to use these strategies with their partner. The effects were not immediate, but individuals reported feeling less insecure one month later; however, the strategies did not target specific insecurities (anxiety versus avoidance).

The second aim was to assign new experiences to experimental couples. Specific experimental conditions were designed to improve the way people perceive, either their own self-worth (e.g., their self-confidence and sense of personal efficacy), versus the value they place on romantic relationships (e.g., benefits of trusting others, relying on others, helping others); these conditions were compared against a control condition without assigned experiences. Although analyses are still ongoing, the intervention to invoke these new experiences did not have the intended effect one month later. Several results point to the difficulty of doing intervention research with couples. However, measures that assessed what couples naturally do on their own regardless of their experimental condition did suggest that individuals became less anxious over time when they felt good about personal goals (confident, supported by their partner).

Moreover, this project also has generated rich resources that could be useful to different groups. A project website includes strategies and other information that people can adapt to their own relationships. The project also has resulted in a series of valuable datasets with a wealth of information concerning not just attachment security but also other topics, such as conditions that affect the feasibility of intervention research.

Finally, the project resulted, in collaboration with other researchers, to offer a more comprehensive model (Attachment Security Enhancement Model) of how close partners can help individuals become more secure over time. Since its publication in 2018, it has been widely cited and has contributed to the wide debate on how people can become more secure.
Exploitation Route The findings of this project will be of interest to academics and practitioners (e.g., marriage counsellors) as well as to the general public. Although attachment security has been robustly associated with beneficial outcomes and that attachment orientations can change, little is still known on how and when attachment patterns change in adults. Our comprehensive model of Attachment Security Enhancement Model offers a clearer roadmap for becoming more interpersonally secure. It suggests that people need to differentiate between stressful situations that may trigger attachment insecurity and peaceful moments when people may be more open to new rewarding experiences that help revise deeply entrenched beliefs (working models) about the self and others. This requires time and repeated exposures to reassuring responses in stressful times and to new, rewarding experiences in peaceful times. Our findings also suggest that partners recognize and apply different strategies when individuals display more anxious or avoidant behaviours. Finally, it is important that couples recognize what works in their relationship, but that it is also important that people step out of their comfort zones and keep trying to find out which strategies offer rewarding experiences that will eventually help revise deeply entrenched working models to become more secure.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy

 
Description The research was covered in popular magazines such as the Atlantic (860K subscribers) and Psychology Today (readership approximately 250K) to describe how attachment styles can change as a consequence of being in romantic relationships. This is important as one aim of the project was to introduce to the general public the idea that attachment security, which has significant implications for personal and relational outcomes, can be bolstered by behaviours of romantic partners, without necessarily requiring extensive therapy. Wide coverage in popular magazines is likely to result in getting people interested in how they can improve their relationships, which can also contribute to the well-being of individuals and society as a whole.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Creation of RelWisdom website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact A website on 'relationships wisdom' was created to: (1) educate study participants and the general public about attachment styles, (2) share tips and advice on improving romantic relationships from other people, and (3) get people to share their own stories on how to improve relationships with us to use for research purposes. The website was mainly shared with potential participants for studies being conducted as part of this award, but was also advertised on websites such as on the International Association for Relationships Research site, an inter-disciplinary organization of relationship researchers designed to promote relationships science.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019,2020
URL https://www.relwisdom.com/