Understanding the impact of discrimination on health and wellbeing

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Epidemiology and Public Health

Abstract

Growing evidence suggests that people who experience discrimination suffer poorer mental health and may even be at increased risk of physical health conditions, including cardiovascular disease and obesity. Discrimination, as a social stressor, may adversely affect health and wellbeing through biological stress pathways, promotion of unhealthy behaviours as a means to cope with or escape negative affect, and/or restricted access to or uptake of healthcare and disease prevention services. Research in this field has been dominated by studies of racism in the USA, and the current evidence base on the impact of discrimination on health lacks high-quality longitudinal data, and consideration of varied types of discrimination (e.g. discrimination on the basis of age, sex, ethnic group, nationality, religion, language, sexual orientation, health condition, disability and weight). Examining the influence of social factors on mental health is one of the ESRC's core strategic priorities. Discrimination is a topical issue in Europe with the migrant crisis, UK 'Brexit' vote and recent terrorist attacks in England and elsewhere fuelling negative attitudes towards social minority groups. Moreover, addressing health inequalities is a major policy focus, so it is crucial to understand how discrimination affects health and wellbeing in vulnerable groups and to identify the policy levers that can reduce inequalities in health that occur as a direct result of discrimination. This study is a collaboration between an academic group at University College London and several charities working on issues of discrimination and wellbeing (Age UK, Leonard Cheshire Disability and Weight Concern), and will clarify these relationships using data from large cohorts of adults from the UK and across Europe. Our partner charities have a specific focus on discrimination based on age, disability and obesity, but we shall also address issues related to gender, ethnicity/nationality, and religion. Our specific objectives are: 1) To estimate the impact of perceived discrimination on health and wellbeing, including the extent to which effects vary according to the type of discrimination, health outcome, and European country; 2) To examine health impacts in relation to the frequency and pervasiveness of discrimination; 3) To explore mechanisms through which the multi-faceted nature of discrimination affects health and wellbeing. We anticipate that findings from this study will help policy-makers and practitioners develop policies and interventions that can help improve health and wellbeing in the different groups that experience discrimination.

Planned Impact

There are a number of beneficiaries of this research on whom the impact of the proposed work will be apparent. These include:
i) Policy-makers: Addressing health inequalities remains a central concern for governments worldwide, and features of the current social climate in the UK and across Europe such as the migrant crisis, terrorist attacks in Paris, Brussels, Nice and England, and the UK's 'Brexit' vote make discrimination an increasingly critical issue. This research offers great potential to evaluate whether policies designed to address discrimination deal effectively with inequalities in health, and identify policy targets that could reduce the burden of discrimination on health and wellbeing. The research questions addressed in this project have been identified through discussion with Age UK, Leonard Cheshire Disability and Weight Concern; charities concerned with discrimination and health, with the explicit intention to ensure the results are policy-relevant. We intend that our findings will be relevant to policy-makers in national and local government. By identifying specific types and sources of discrimination that are relevant to health and wellbeing in vulnerable groups, our findings will be useful in targeting levers for change, and directing policies and initiatives to reduce health inequalities. Professor Steptoe has regular contact with policy advisors and analysts in the Departments of Health, Work and Pensions, and Transport, and will use these connections to ensure that the research funding will have impact.
ii) Third-sector organisations: A large number of voluntary sector organisations and charities have recognised inequalities in health and wellbeing in minority and vulnerable groups (e.g. the elderly, people with disabilities, ethnic minorities) and the high risk of discrimination in these groups. These include Age UK, Leonard Cheshire Disability, The Monitoring Group, Scope and the LGBT Foundation, which have all highlighted the need for high-quality research to support policy and lobbying activities. We anticipate that our findings will contribute to their work, and plan to work with our collaborators at Age UK, Leonard Cheshire Disability and Weight Concern to produce policy briefing papers targeted at policy-makers as part of our dissemination activities.
iii) Practitioners: Our findings will be valuable to social and health professionals, carers and volunteers who work with groups vulnerable to discrimination, helping them identify individuals at risk and provide them with appropriate support. If certain types of discrimination prove to be particularly harmful for health and wellbeing, it may be possible to target these more precisely and ensure that resources are focused more effectively.
iv) General public: We aim to increase knowledge and awareness of different sources of discrimination and prejudice, and document how these processes may not only be hurtful and distressing, but may also impact on health and wellbeing. These issues are relevant not only to individuals belonging to groups that are vulnerable to discrimination (of whom there are many), but also to the wider public among whom awareness of the consequences of discrimination may encourage greater consideration of their actions and fair and equal treatment of others, irrespective of group membership. This could be achieved by writing articles for broadsheet newspapers, as well as publications targeted at the general public, such as the Economist, Community Care and the Health Service Journal.
We will disseminate our findings at a workshop targeted at stakeholders from each of these groups upon conclusion of the study. Our work with Age UK, Leonard Cheshire Disability and Weight Concern will ensure dissemination of these findings at the highest levels of policy-making in the UK and the EU.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Hackett RA (2019) Sex discrimination and mental health in women: A prospective analysis. in Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association

 
Description This work has broadened our understanding of how discrimination affects health. Previously, the predominance of literature in this area focused on racism and mental health, was conducted in the USA, and used a cross-sectional design that meant it was impossible to disentangle the direction of causation. We have explored associations between different types of discrimination (including those related to age, sex, disability and sexual orientation) and a range of mental and physical health outcomes over time. The results provide consistent evidence that different forms of discrimination, experienced by a broad range of vulnerable groups, are associated with adverse health outcomes, ranging from decline in mental functioning and quality of life to the onset of chronic diseases (such as heart disease, stroke, and depression).

Examples of media coverage:
Until we take sex discrimination seriously, women's mental health will suffer. The Telegraph, 9 September 2019. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/work/take-sex-discrimination-seriously-womens-mental-health-will/
WOMEN WHO EXPERIENCE SEXISM 'THREE TIMES MORE LIKELY TO REPORT DEPRESSION'. The Independent, 9 September 2019. https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women/women-sexism-depression-mental-health-discrimination-ucl-study-a9097116.html
Sex discrimination linked to depression in women. The Times, 9 September 2019. https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/sex-discrimination-street-harassment-linked-to-depression-in-women-t73rrngdn
Age discrimination could have a negative impact on people's physical health. The Independent, 4 April 2019. https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/age-discrimination-poor-healtAgeism may increase people's risk of ill-health, study finds. The Guardian (online), 4 April 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/apr/04/ageism-may-increase-peoples-risk-of-ill-health-study-finds
One in four over-50s say they are victims of ageism in stores, restaurants and hospitals. The Daily Mail, 4 April 2019. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6884311/One-four-50s-say-victims-ageism-stores-restaurants-hospitals.html
Middle-aged treated like 'second class citizens', with 25 per cent of over-50's poorly treated in shops and hospitals. The Telegraph, 4 April 2019. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/04/03/middle-aged-treated-like-second-class-citizens-25-over-50s-poorly/
Age discrimination linked to poorer health in England. ITV News, 4 April 2019.
https://www.itv.com/news/2019-04-03/age-discrimination-linked-to-poorer-health-in-england/
Age discrimination is rife in Britain, UCL study finds, as one in four over 50s report being unfairly treated. The Telegraph, 4 April 2019. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/04/03/age-discrimination-rife-britain-ucl-study-finds-one-four-50s/

Infographic created in collaboration with the Young Women's Trust, summarising results of our work on sexism and mental health:
https://www.youngwomenstrust.org/assets/0001/2669/Impact_of_sexism_on_young_women_s_mental_health.pdf
Exploitation Route These outcomes provide evidence that is important for shaping policy decisions around protected groups. Being able to provide high-quality evidence of adverse impacts of discrimination on health and wellbeing will bolster efforts to lobby for greater protection against discrimination. The results may open health professionals' eyes to an additional risk factor for ill health among already vulnerable groups.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare

URL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30954145
 
Description This work has broadened our understanding of how discrimination affects health. Previously, the predominance of literature in this area focused on racism and mental health, was conducted in the USA, and used a cross-sectional design that meant it was impossible to disentangle the direction of causation. We have explored associations between different types of discrimination (including those related to age, sex, disability and sexual orientation) and a range of mental and physical health outcomes over time. The results provide consistent evidence that different forms of discrimination, experienced by a broad range of vulnerable groups, are associated with adverse health outcomes, ranging from decline in mental functioning and quality of life to the onset of chronic diseases (such as heart disease, stroke, and depression).
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services