Building States, Empowering Citizens: Rethinking intervention as politics of improvement

Lead Research Organisation: Aberystwyth University
Department Name: International Politics

Abstract

Efforts to help, develop, and empower people and places around the globe shape both policies and imaginations. Whether they are Brexit plans for restructuring development and peacekeeping costs, stand-offs around aid shipments in Venezuela, or the EU's changing relationship with its neighbourhood and candidate states-the news of intervention projects that cross borders in order to aid and develop seem ubiquitous. This project starts from the observation that the eye-catching 'intervention events' - donor projects in developing countries or EU negotiations with third countries - are propped up by a myriad of small and large projects that seek to empower individuals, build peace, promote economic progress, and secure democracy in more subtle and widespread ways. These efforts range from technical assistance and financial aid to capacity building and small educational workshops. And while they go through adjustments in response to changing circumstances, they are apparently a permanent fixture of international politics whose continuation, ironically, depends on never achieving their goal.
The project Building States, Empowering Citizens: Rethinking intervention as politics of improvement proposes a major shift in the way practitioners and academics approach interventions like development and statebuilding. It proposes to study these processes as a politics of improvement. By using the concept politics of improvement, I am able to go beyond classical understandings of intervention as found in studies of statebuilding and development. Seeing them as politics of improvement situates these efforts alongside other processes that aim at improvement of diverse people and spaces, and their effects on and perceptions by individuals. Such an interdisciplinary approach uncovers areas of political, economic, and social life that are otherwise left invisible, and allows a fuller understanding of social transformations and their consequences.
Specifically, the concept of politics of improvement goes beyond international intervention in three ways:
1) it is able to engage a wider range of actors by looking past the local/international positions usually found
in the literature;
2) it is attentive to different ways that these subjects are engaged and can thus take into account seemingly
contradictory policies within same projects;
3) it is open to a more nuanced understanding of outcomes than the popular liberal/illiberal diagnoses.
This reorientation to politics of improvement also includes a methodological commitment to using the experiences of the beneficiaries of these projects as the analytical starting point. The project uses two policy areas in Serbia as sites for the study: non-formal youth education in the form of schools of democracy, human rights, and empowerment; and agricultural policy that seeks to modernise Serbian agriculture and bring it closer to EU standards. Within the two sites, the starting points of my analysis were not the international experts who drive the intervention projects, nor their local partners who implement them, but the many people who live with the consequences of these efforts to empower citizens and build states.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description There are two main findings of the award. First, in terms of scholarly framings, the project found that the concept of 'international intervention' used to study projects of building peace, democracy, and development is limiting when it comes to engaging the experiences of people living in areas of intervention. The award found the concept limiting in three ways: conceptualisations of agents, acts, and aims of intervention.

Second, the research discovered a growing significance of agriculture as a site of multiple interventions: Europeanisation of agricultural governance on the one hand, and foreign direct investment from diverse global actors on the other. This contributes to the emerging research agenda on the international politics of agriculture and food systems, and will be developed by Dr Kušic in a further project.
Exploitation Route Research outcomes will be useful for scholars working on international intervention, South East Europe, and fieldwork-based methods.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Government, Democracy and Justice,Security and Diplomacy

 
Description HORIZON-MSCA-2021-PF-01
Amount € 199,440 (EUR)
Funding ID 101060995 
Organisation University of Vienna 
Sector Academic/University
Country Austria
Start 09/2023 
End 08/2025