Compulsive Worlds: Improving Therapeutic Practice for Tourette Syndrome and Working with Care in Dementia
Lead Research Organisation:
Swansea University
Department Name: College of Science
Abstract
Rooted in my doctoral study, this Fellowship aims to develop a better understanding of human behaviours that are perceived as irrational, meaningless, purposeless and are therefore deemed unwanted.
Compulsions associated with the Tourette syndrome diagnosis are ill-understood and unwanted behaviours as they are perceived as irrational, purposeless and meaningless. Whilst previous research has focused on the brain and psyche, my doctoral research demonstrate how these behaviours are actually very much influenced by the bodily surroundings. In fact, the absence of human intentionality in compulsive touching, ordering and aligning interactions expresses the material qualities of objects and spaces for people with Tourette syndrome in completely new ways. Indeed, these compulsions reveal a whole new understanding of the relations between the human body, everyday objects and spaces. My doctoral study of these relations thus raises questions about the fundamental underpinnings of person-place relationships. This Fellowship then allows me to develop this 'compulsive theory' in a monograph to fulfil its full potential.
With this in mind, this Fellowship aims to further work through the effects compulsions have on the wellbeing of an individual, in particular because my work demonstrates that these behaviours have strong effects on the wellbeing of those who perform them, which includes remarkably positive ones. For instance, one participant testified how her partner sculpted a 'thing' she can hold in her hands and which 'triggers' compulsive touching, and which calms her anxieties. This demonstrates that objects can have compulsive capacities, and which can be 'brought out' in their design. Using these new insights in compulsivity, and as part of a small further study, I intend to develop and test 'therapeutic objects' that can both ameliorate bodily tensions and nervousness, and be used to actively incite sensory pleasure. These outcomes could be especially effective for people with dementia or Alzheimer's disease, as their worlds progressily 'contract' to sensory ones rather than also social ones. Therefore, this study attends to the 'compulsive vitality' that interactions of these people with such objects might incite, and explores how this can improve their quality of life; both mentally and physically.
The study contributes in the development of dementia treatment that is based on sensory engagement, such as aromatherapy and bright light therapy (Burns et al. 2002) and recent advancement in the development of 'sensory rooms' (Collier & Jacob 2017), in favour of pharmacological treatment that often has detrimental effects, especially in late-stage dementia (McShane et al. 1997, Ballard et al 2001, Herrmann 2001) to combat agitation, depression, delusions, wandering, sleep disturbance, and hallucinations (Finkel et al. 2000). These insights can, in turn, be used by dementia care homes to better accommodate for the needs of their clients and alleviate pressures on care provision. This is of vital importance as the numbers of people with a dementia or Alzheimer's diagnosis are rapidly increasing in the UK, as outlined in the UK's Industrial Strategies.
Addressing the Industrial Strategy on two points, this Fellowship aims to:
(1) improve care provision in care home facilities for people with dementia or Alzheimer's. I propose to do so by working with the Swansea University Centre for Innovative Aging, Care UK, large and successful care home companies (HC-One and Barchester Healthcare) and a care home charity (MHA) to streamline care provision with these technologies. I will provide both practical implementation guidance and policy recommendations for Care UK.
(2) implement the development of therapeutic object technology in Welsh Further Technical Education. I propose to set up and guide a problem-oriented project for students taking a range of courses at Gower College Swansea to design these objects.
Compulsions associated with the Tourette syndrome diagnosis are ill-understood and unwanted behaviours as they are perceived as irrational, purposeless and meaningless. Whilst previous research has focused on the brain and psyche, my doctoral research demonstrate how these behaviours are actually very much influenced by the bodily surroundings. In fact, the absence of human intentionality in compulsive touching, ordering and aligning interactions expresses the material qualities of objects and spaces for people with Tourette syndrome in completely new ways. Indeed, these compulsions reveal a whole new understanding of the relations between the human body, everyday objects and spaces. My doctoral study of these relations thus raises questions about the fundamental underpinnings of person-place relationships. This Fellowship then allows me to develop this 'compulsive theory' in a monograph to fulfil its full potential.
With this in mind, this Fellowship aims to further work through the effects compulsions have on the wellbeing of an individual, in particular because my work demonstrates that these behaviours have strong effects on the wellbeing of those who perform them, which includes remarkably positive ones. For instance, one participant testified how her partner sculpted a 'thing' she can hold in her hands and which 'triggers' compulsive touching, and which calms her anxieties. This demonstrates that objects can have compulsive capacities, and which can be 'brought out' in their design. Using these new insights in compulsivity, and as part of a small further study, I intend to develop and test 'therapeutic objects' that can both ameliorate bodily tensions and nervousness, and be used to actively incite sensory pleasure. These outcomes could be especially effective for people with dementia or Alzheimer's disease, as their worlds progressily 'contract' to sensory ones rather than also social ones. Therefore, this study attends to the 'compulsive vitality' that interactions of these people with such objects might incite, and explores how this can improve their quality of life; both mentally and physically.
The study contributes in the development of dementia treatment that is based on sensory engagement, such as aromatherapy and bright light therapy (Burns et al. 2002) and recent advancement in the development of 'sensory rooms' (Collier & Jacob 2017), in favour of pharmacological treatment that often has detrimental effects, especially in late-stage dementia (McShane et al. 1997, Ballard et al 2001, Herrmann 2001) to combat agitation, depression, delusions, wandering, sleep disturbance, and hallucinations (Finkel et al. 2000). These insights can, in turn, be used by dementia care homes to better accommodate for the needs of their clients and alleviate pressures on care provision. This is of vital importance as the numbers of people with a dementia or Alzheimer's diagnosis are rapidly increasing in the UK, as outlined in the UK's Industrial Strategies.
Addressing the Industrial Strategy on two points, this Fellowship aims to:
(1) improve care provision in care home facilities for people with dementia or Alzheimer's. I propose to do so by working with the Swansea University Centre for Innovative Aging, Care UK, large and successful care home companies (HC-One and Barchester Healthcare) and a care home charity (MHA) to streamline care provision with these technologies. I will provide both practical implementation guidance and policy recommendations for Care UK.
(2) implement the development of therapeutic object technology in Welsh Further Technical Education. I propose to set up and guide a problem-oriented project for students taking a range of courses at Gower College Swansea to design these objects.
Organisations
- Swansea University (Fellow, Lead Research Organisation)
- University College London (Collaboration)
- DURHAM UNIVERSITY (Collaboration)
- Deakin University (Collaboration)
- University of the Basque Country (Collaboration)
- Newcastle University (Collaboration)
- University of Minnesota (Collaboration)
- University of Antwerp (Collaboration)
Publications
Beljaars D
(2022)
Compulsive Body Spaces
Beljaars Diana
(2022)
Compulsive Body Spaces
Beljaars DNM
(2022)
Compulsive Body Spaces: Confusions and rationalisations
Bervoets J
(2023)
Letting Tourette's be: The importance of understanding lived experience in research and the clinic.
in Developmental medicine and child neurology
Conelea CA
(2022)
A call for caution: 'stop that' sentiments threaten tic research, healthcare and advocacy.
in Brain : a journal of neurology
Description | Monograph and 2 papers: (1) Crucial insights into everyday life of people with Tourette syndrome, (2) the influences of the social and material environment on compulsive behaviours, (3) how the medical and clinical sciences leave a number of question surrounding the context and experience of Tourette's and compulsions unanswered and this can be attended to in multidisciplinary analyses, in particular via surplus models rather than deficiency models, (4) how compulsivity can be used to understand seemingly irrational, meaningless, and purposeless behaviour in general, and (5) how such understanding has political, ethical, and further societal effects Handbook chapter: the reasons for combining quantitative and qualitative methods in disability geography research Research proposal that will be sought futher funding for: the set up of a project that models compulsive interactions to develop a predictive element to them |
Exploitation Route | Academic: - human geographers, other social scientists and medical humanities scholars: using compulsivity in analyses that aim to go beyond interpretation, meaning production, and that do not see people as inherently rational agents. Their work could also be taken forward in the development of a way to more fully engage with the medical and clinical sciences - medical and clinical scientists with an interest in Tourette's, compulsivity, and/or people living with mental health problems and/or neurological disorders could use the outcomes of this study to better attend to socio-material contexts, lived experience, and political implications of their work. - if I can do the secondary analysis of the UCL dementia datasets, human geographers could attend better to the geographies of dementia and medical and clinical sciences can better attend to the socio-material contexts of demented behaviours in their analyses. Non-academic: - people with Tourette's have a better understanding of the influence of their everyday environments and can make adjustments to these spaces - Tourette syndrome patient organisations can offers members better information about the influence of people's homes, school/work, and other public places - various forms of therapies can be supplemented with a more fundamental attendance to patients' homes, school/work, and other public places to improve the efficiency of existing forms of therapy. - if I can do the secondary analysis of the UCL dementia datasets, carehomes could adjust the set up of their public spaces and therapeutic for residents to improve reseidents' wellbeing |
Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare |
Description | My findings have informed a reaction paper in 'Brain' to an academic paper by a group of medical scientists whose argument has problematic consequences for people with Tourette syndrome. The reaction paper I co-wrote urged caution and explained why certain suggestions were problematic. It has been found by people with Tourette's who are vocal about patient emancipation online, and is used to challenge the original paper's points on its implications for the everyday life experiences of Tourette's and the ways it is treated. The author groups includes academics, clinicians, and non-academic people with Tourette's. A large chunk of the paper is underpinned by the narrative and critique I have developed during the Fellowship. The pre-prints and accepted version of the paper has been read by a large audience that includes clinicians and therapists. I have also been asked by an Assembly Member to provide information for a debate about Tourette syndrome services in Wales in the Welsh Sennedd. |
First Year Of Impact | 2021 |
Sector | Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice |
Impact Types | Societal |
Description | Advisory function in Tourette patient network set-up |
Geographic Reach | Multiple continents/international |
Policy Influence Type | Membership of a guideline committee |
Description | Membership of the Welsh Government's ND MAG (policy) |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Participation in a guidance/advisory committee |
URL | https://www.gov.wales/neurodivergence-ministerial-advisory-group |
Description | Work used in Senedd debate for Tourette's care in Wales (policy) |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Contribution to a national consultation/review |
Impact | It contributed to a Welsh Government effort to attribute £12m to better care for neurodivergent people in Wales; Tourette's is one of the 3 major conditions mentioned. |
URL | http://www.senedd.tv/Meeting/Archive/356d1487-cc5b-4e1b-9dc3-66a05de3a40f?autostart=True# |
Description | (COVINFORM) - COronavirus Vulnerabilities and INFOrmation dynamics Research and Modelling |
Amount | € 4,941,656 (EUR) |
Funding ID | 101016247 |
Organisation | European Commission |
Sector | Public |
Country | European Union (EU) |
Start | 11/2020 |
End | 10/2023 |
Description | Hans Eijsackers Award 2020 |
Amount | € 1,800 (EUR) |
Organisation | Gilles de la Tourette Foundation |
Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
Country | Netherlands |
Start | 10/2021 |
Description | Thinking Through Things |
Amount | £105 (GBP) |
Organisation | Wellcome Trust |
Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 02/2020 |
End | 02/2020 |
Description | Compulsivity and Art |
Organisation | Durham University |
Department | Institute for Medical Humanities |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The interpretation of compulsivity in visual art |
Collaborator Contribution | Art historical knowledge applied to compulsivity |
Impact | We will write a paper for a peer-reviewed journal in summer 2021 based on an interview with an artist with compulsive skin-picking disorder |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | Dementia and compulsion in the home |
Organisation | University College London |
Department | Dementia Research Centre (DRC) |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | This collaboration entails the secondary analysis of certain video datasets of the UCL project 'Seeing What They See' (https://www.ucl.ac.uk/drc/research-studies/seeing-what-they-see) by myself. I will share my analysis with them and present my findings to their team. |
Collaborator Contribution | They will provide me with access to their datasets |
Impact | This is a multidiciplinary project that involves neuroscientists, psychologists and me as a social scientist/humanities scholar (human geographer). Outcomes will entail an analysis of compulsive behaviours in people with Alzheimers in their own home and in a laboratory setting. It will allow me to write an academic paper and use the outcomes in the grant application I'm writing for after this Fellowship. Also, ongoing collaborations beyond this particular project cannot be excluded |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | NNMHR 2023 panel collaboration |
Organisation | Deakin University |
Country | Australia |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | I set up a panel with a variety of Tourette's activists and academics for the NNMHR conference 2023 in April 2023. I manage it, organised the proposal, asked everyone, and will lead the discussions beforehand and during the session. |
Collaborator Contribution | They provided their details for the conference organisers, and will provide their perspectives on the panel. |
Impact | not yet |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | NNMHR 2023 panel collaboration |
Organisation | Newcastle University |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | I set up a panel with a variety of Tourette's activists and academics for the NNMHR conference 2023 in April 2023. I manage it, organised the proposal, asked everyone, and will lead the discussions beforehand and during the session. |
Collaborator Contribution | They provided their details for the conference organisers, and will provide their perspectives on the panel. |
Impact | not yet |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | NNMHR 2023 panel collaboration |
Organisation | University of Antwerp |
Country | Belgium |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | I set up a panel with a variety of Tourette's activists and academics for the NNMHR conference 2023 in April 2023. I manage it, organised the proposal, asked everyone, and will lead the discussions beforehand and during the session. |
Collaborator Contribution | They provided their details for the conference organisers, and will provide their perspectives on the panel. |
Impact | not yet |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | NNMHR 2023 panel collaboration |
Organisation | University of Minnesota |
Country | United States |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | I set up a panel with a variety of Tourette's activists and academics for the NNMHR conference 2023 in April 2023. I manage it, organised the proposal, asked everyone, and will lead the discussions beforehand and during the session. |
Collaborator Contribution | They provided their details for the conference organisers, and will provide their perspectives on the panel. |
Impact | not yet |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | Philosophy of Tourette syndrome |
Organisation | Newcastle University |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | This is a group of three philosophers working on questions on sense-making around Tourette syndrome and tics. I bring knowledge about Tourette's and post-phenomenology and posthumanism to the collaboration. We are working on a paper. |
Collaborator Contribution | The collaborator from Antwerp is the lead in the project and is an analytical philosopher with an interest in Tourette's, and the collaborator from the Basque country is an analytical philosopher with an interest in language and interpersonal connections. |
Impact | It is multidisciplinary, and we have been working on a paper that is in review. We've done two conference presentations: 1. 21 April 2021: 4th Congress of the Northern Network for Medical Humanities Research, Durham University: "The Production of Tourette Syndrome: Erasures, Framings, and Silences" 2. 2 October 2021: ESSTS Annual Conference 2021, European Society for the Study of Tourette Syndrome: "An innovative person-centred research approach for Tourette's " We've also done two webinars: 1. 27 April 2021: IAS Research Group, University of Basque Country philosophy department: "Making sense of Tourettic sensibility (the joy of being let be?)" 2. 18 November 2021: NeuroEpigenEthics Research Group, University of Antwerp: "'Letting Tourette's be?', a NeuroEpigenEthics Interdisciplinary lecture" (http://www.neuroepigenethics.com/2021/10/25/letting-tourettes-be-a-neuroepigenethics-interdisciplinary-lecture/) |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | Philosophy of Tourette syndrome |
Organisation | University of Antwerp |
Country | Belgium |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | This is a group of three philosophers working on questions on sense-making around Tourette syndrome and tics. I bring knowledge about Tourette's and post-phenomenology and posthumanism to the collaboration. We are working on a paper. |
Collaborator Contribution | The collaborator from Antwerp is the lead in the project and is an analytical philosopher with an interest in Tourette's, and the collaborator from the Basque country is an analytical philosopher with an interest in language and interpersonal connections. |
Impact | It is multidisciplinary, and we have been working on a paper that is in review. We've done two conference presentations: 1. 21 April 2021: 4th Congress of the Northern Network for Medical Humanities Research, Durham University: "The Production of Tourette Syndrome: Erasures, Framings, and Silences" 2. 2 October 2021: ESSTS Annual Conference 2021, European Society for the Study of Tourette Syndrome: "An innovative person-centred research approach for Tourette's " We've also done two webinars: 1. 27 April 2021: IAS Research Group, University of Basque Country philosophy department: "Making sense of Tourettic sensibility (the joy of being let be?)" 2. 18 November 2021: NeuroEpigenEthics Research Group, University of Antwerp: "'Letting Tourette's be?', a NeuroEpigenEthics Interdisciplinary lecture" (http://www.neuroepigenethics.com/2021/10/25/letting-tourettes-be-a-neuroepigenethics-interdisciplinary-lecture/) |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | Philosophy of Tourette syndrome |
Organisation | University of the Basque Country |
Country | Spain |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | This is a group of three philosophers working on questions on sense-making around Tourette syndrome and tics. I bring knowledge about Tourette's and post-phenomenology and posthumanism to the collaboration. We are working on a paper. |
Collaborator Contribution | The collaborator from Antwerp is the lead in the project and is an analytical philosopher with an interest in Tourette's, and the collaborator from the Basque country is an analytical philosopher with an interest in language and interpersonal connections. |
Impact | It is multidisciplinary, and we have been working on a paper that is in review. We've done two conference presentations: 1. 21 April 2021: 4th Congress of the Northern Network for Medical Humanities Research, Durham University: "The Production of Tourette Syndrome: Erasures, Framings, and Silences" 2. 2 October 2021: ESSTS Annual Conference 2021, European Society for the Study of Tourette Syndrome: "An innovative person-centred research approach for Tourette's " We've also done two webinars: 1. 27 April 2021: IAS Research Group, University of Basque Country philosophy department: "Making sense of Tourettic sensibility (the joy of being let be?)" 2. 18 November 2021: NeuroEpigenEthics Research Group, University of Antwerp: "'Letting Tourette's be?', a NeuroEpigenEthics Interdisciplinary lecture" (http://www.neuroepigenethics.com/2021/10/25/letting-tourettes-be-a-neuroepigenethics-interdisciplinary-lecture/) |
Start Year | 2020 |
Description | Citizen Science at science festival 'Feel the urge' |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | I had a stand at the Swansea Science Festival 2022 (in-person event) in which I did a demonstration and explanation and asked mainly children, parents, and other general public members to do the activity. It consisted of them organising objects and us talking through why that organisation to explain more about compulsion. It served as citizen science project and the pictures I was allowed to take of the object organisations serve as data that I'm analysing for a paper. The project set-up also served as a pilot for a large research grant I'm trying to get funding for. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://www.swansea.ac.uk/swansea-science-festival/museum-zone/ |
Description | Interview for a patient association magazine/periodical |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A magazine, newsletter or online publication |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Patients, carers and/or patient groups |
Results and Impact | I was interviewed (in Dutch) about my research on Tourette syndrome for the magazine of the Dutch Tourette association, because I had won their first Hans Eijsackers Award; "a stimulation prize for researchers in whose research the patient perspective has a meaningful position". The interview is 1500 words long; the questions were posed to me and I wrote the answers and had full editing rights over the final piece. The Interviewer is Marion van Ginneken, and the interview is published in the paper-based September issue 2020. I have not been contacted as a result of the publication, nor do I know of any new outcomes hat have arisen from the publication. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2015,2020 |