INTERACT (Investigating New Types of Engagement, Response And Contact Technologies in Policing)

Lead Research Organisation: Edinburgh Napier University
Department Name: School of Applied Science

Abstract

Over recent years, the ways in which members of the public can contact the police have undergone significant change. Whilst much contact is still face-to-face, many police organisations have introduced different types of communication technology, such as online reporting of crimes and answering of queries, body worn video cameras, mobile data terminals, and the use of social media accounts. As a result, the public is increasingly likely to encounter policing in ways that are 'technologically-mediated'.

In the UK, the National Police Chiefs' Council supports this shift, and has a portfolio of work focused on developing technologies for use by the public to contact the police because, they believe, the public now expects that policing will be 'online' just as other services are. However, while attention is being paid to what technology can do, and particularly what it can do for the police, the public side of this encounter has barely been considered. Online reporting (for example) may appeal to some people, or be particularly useful for some crime types, but we do not know enough about how people experience these types of interactions to be confident that they will benefit everyone, in all circumstances. Nor do we know if and how these developments might affect the way people feel about, and act in relation to, the police.

This project therefore focuses on understanding the implications of introducing technologies into conversations between the police and the public. Two main objectives are to explore how members of the public feel about these new developments, and to consider the ways in which the police can and should design their systems to better reflect people's needs and expectations. PoLITiC is designed to include a range of different groups and individuals, for example those who are more and less confident using digital technologies, and those with particular access needs (for example the deaf community). We aim to shape policy and practice, with a view to improving service provision. We will work closely with three police forces, with various communities, and with national policing organisations, so that our findings can directly and positively influence what the police do, and therefore what the public are able to do to access police services.

We know that when people interact with the police they come to conclusions about how much they support the police, how good the police are at their jobs, and how much they trust what the police do. But this knowledge is based on research which assumes that most or all police and public contact happens face-to-face, person-to-person, as it has done for decades. At most a telephone may be involved. Given that this situation is changing, it is important that we reconsider our theories of public trust and police legitimacy, and explore if they are fit for purpose in the current environment and future-proof against new developments.

PoLITiC therefore aims to explore police and public experiences and understandings of technologically-mediated contact by using methods such as interviews, focus groups, and extended observations to gain a deeper understanding of these new forms of contact in action. To help us understand how experiences may differ, we will carry out our research in a variety of different locations (for example urban and rural) and will work with various communities. We will also consider what it means for the police to be 'visible' and 'accessible' in a digital age and assess how the public feel about the different ways the police can be seen and contacted. A series of on-line experimental studies will complement the qualitative methods, and allow us to estimate the causal effects of, for example, different forms of mediation on trust. Using a variety of methods our research will develop understandings of police legitimacy in changing times, and allow us to recommend ways for the police to stay legitimate in the eyes of the public in the 21st century.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Ongoing relationship building with National Police Service regarding target operating model for use of new technologies within the service
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or improved professional practice
 
Description Conference Presentation. 'You've Been Framed' Professor Liz Aston. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Prof Aston and the INTERACT team were invited by Prof Marleen Easton to join a panel on 'Policing in a digitalised world' at the European Society of Criminology Conference, 23rd September 2022, Malaga. The paper was entitled ''You've been framed': Interactional Frames and Technologically-Mediated contact in Policing'. Prof Aston presented alongside colleagues from Belgium and the Netherlands. https://www.eurocrim2022.com/.
Following ESC presentation Prof Aston was approached by Kris Henning at Portland State University and the INTERACT team invited him and his colleagues to present to the INTERACT team on their US based research on online reporting
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Conference Presentation. Drones in Society Conference. Sheffield University. Dr Will Andrews 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Exploration of the use of Drones in UK police forces and their potential impact on matters of procedural justice, considering future implications of drone use in UK policing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Conference Presentation. SIPR Postgraduate Conference Dr Will Andrews 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact 'Drones in UK Policing' presentation delivered by Dr Will Andrews to Scottish Institute for Policing Research Postgraduate Conference. Linking UK police force drone use to matters of procedural justice and setting out research objectives for exploration of this within the INTERACT project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Contribution to Police Foundation event on Contact and Confidence: Improving police-public interactions with technology. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Attendance at and contribution to Police Foundation roundtable on Contact and Confidence: Improving police-public interactions with technology, 15th November 2022, 15:00-17:00. Members of the team shared details of our approach to researching technologically-mediate contact between police and public and provided comment on the Police Foundation's approach and scope. We have since held a meeting between ourselves and the Police Foundation team to follow-up on this event. More details of the Police Foundation report are here: https://www.police-foundation.org.uk/project/contact-and-confidence-improving-police-public-interactions-with-technology/
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.police-foundation.org.uk/project/contact-and-confidence-improving-police-public-interact...
 
Description Invited presentation at Emerging Technologies event ran by the JREF [Joint (Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland) Research and Evidence Forum] 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited presentation by Aston at Emerging Technologies RoundTable event in February 2022, ran by the JREF [Joint (Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland) Research
and Evidence Forum]

'Policing is growing more complex as it seeks to respond to an increasingly diverse set of challenges, some of which are directly attributable to technological advances. Policing does not operate in a vacuum from the rest of society; as new and emerging technologies continue to change the way we live our lives, they are also changing how we access and receive critical public services such as policing. Additionally, as these new technologies develop at pace, public awareness and concern is growing regarding costs and benefits, ethical considerations and privacy concerns.
This RoundTable event will explore some of the many considerations that will inform the adoption of new and emerging technologies across policing in Scotland in the years to
come. It will draw on past experiences and lessons learned, seek to understand experiences from outside of Scotland and from other sectors, and consider key public
interest areas and recent public opinion data at the Scotland wide level.
This event is sponsored by the SPA and Police Scotland Joint Research and Evidence
Forum, which was established in 2019. These knowledge exchange events are used to:
? Bring together expertise of police officers, academics, third sector and
government;
? Explore innovation in use of both statistics and data in modern policing from a
public benefit perspective; and
? Explore areas of future research and evidence-based public debate.
You can watch the event live via our LiveStream and also submit questions and comments in the chat function - our
panels will consider questions and comments arising in the chat. In the event that you are not able to attend, we will be recording the session and will make this available for viewing on the SPA website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.spa.police.uk/strategy-performance/joint-evidence-and-research-roundtables/new-and-emerg...
 
Description Plenary Presentation. Overview of INTERACT project. Professor Liz Aston 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Aston, L. (2022) 'A Just Future for Digital Policing' Invited plenary presentation at Future Scot's 'Digital Justice & Policing' Conference, 13th October 2022, Glasgow. In this invited presentation which was part of the closing plenary session 'The Future of justice Technology' Prof Aston took the opportunity to talk about the INTERACT project and its significance to a large audience comprising technology, policing, regulatory and academic partners. She was on the panel alongside speakers including Diego Quiroz and Dr Brian Plastow (Scottish Biometrics Commisssioner) and Prof Fraser Sampson of the Home Office https://futurescot.com/futurescot-events/digital-justice-policing-2022/
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022