Communication and Non-Speaking Children with Physical Disabilities: Opportunities and Reflections from Design-Oriented Research

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Culture, Communication and Media

Abstract

Non speaking children with severe physical disabilities experience the world differently compared with children who use natural verbal speech. Connected to their bodily impairments, these children have limited opportunities for social interaction, play and learning, posing significant social risk factors for later life. Responding to how technologies might reduce social risk factors, assistive technologies for communication have largely focused on designing technologies that enable electronic speech generation or supporting children to meet typical developmental milestones. However, the abandonment rate for these technologies continues to be high, which suggests a need for rethinking how assistive technologies might reflect the contemporary concerns of non-speaking children with severe physical disabilities and their social groups.

To respond to these challenges, my doctoral thesis sought to inform new ways of designing for communication involving non-speaking children with severe physical disabilities. The overarching goal was to disrupt the widely cited view that communication centres around speech and happens at the level of the individual through the transmission of information. Through a series of empirical studies, my PhD research demonstrated that it is possible to design for digitally mediated communication in new ways by applying multiple, alternative frames that acknowledged children's values, multimodal and co-constructed communication. My research contributed new insights for research and practice in three distinct ways. First, it offered a new perspective for studying communication in the fields of AAC and HCI where existing work has largely been dominated by linguistically-driven and deficit-orientated perspectives. Second, the findings made a methodological contribution for involving 'hard to reach' children in research and design work. Finally, third, the empirical findings contributed to design by identifying new opportunities as well as new ways of using design documentaries as a tool for inspiring design in this context.

Building on these findings, this fellowship will disseminate the findings of my PhD research and begin to generate new discussions by focusing on ways of representing and designing for children's communication experiences. I intend to build stronger links with a growing network of professionals from both academic and nonacademic settings who can inform and be informed by these insights.

To achieve this goal, within academia, I will share the findings of my PhD research through written publications in peer-reviewed journals and relevant conference proceedings within the fields of human computer interaction, augmentative and alternative communication and multimodal communication. Outside of academia, I will connect with practitioners from special education and mainstream schools, assistive technology and healthcare settings. Through a contained, small project that produces 'bite-sized' video documentaries about the findings, I intend to generate new discussions and connections for future design work. In doing so, the fellowship will offer exciting opportunities for me to develop my skills as an early career researcher and plan for further research that builds on and extends my specific research interests in disability, design and communication.
 
Description The objectives of this fellowship were to communicate the findings of my doctoral research, to mobilize stakeholders around my research and to advance my early career researcher skills and planning of next steps. Over 12 months, I developed my skills in media communication through accessing training and development in film editing which resulted in the creation of two practitioner videos intended for teachers, therapists and assistive technologies, translating the research findings into practice.

The fellowship also enabled me to publish two peer reviewed academic articles from my PhD research, and present these findings at the Communication Matters Conference; the UK's national conference for practitioners, researchers and people who use augmentative and alternative communication (AAC). This introduces new considerations for the design and use of AAC technologies in conversations.

I also have another paper that has been accepted for presentation at the International Society of AAC's flagship conference, ISAAC, to be held in Mexico/remotely in July 2023. This paper introduces a new application of social semiotic multimodality into the domain of AAC, rethinking the idea of conversational asymmetry and how participants who use AAC are able to 'hold the floor' in conversation.

Lastly, the fellowship has enabled me to develop my early career researcher skills, particularly in the area of grant writing. I planned and submitted two follow up fellowship applications and am currently working as a postdoctoral research associate on a UKRI funded Future Leaders Fellowship that is investigating child mental health and technology enabled interventions.
Exploitation Route The findings of the published research articles are likely to be useful for researchers from the fields of AAC, Human Computer Interaction (HCI) and disability studies, who are interested on building on the empirical, methodological and theoretical insights.

The practitioner videos may be helpful for teachers, therapists and assistive technologists who are interested in improving teaching and therapy involving people who use AAC technologies, as well as designers of technology.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Healthcare

URL http://www.smallspeaks.com/2021/11/02/project-update-autumn-fall-2021/
 
Description The findings of this fellowship have informed discussions with NHS assisitve technology practitioners, which lead to the preparation and submission of follow up funding for an NIHR Advanced Fellowship, intended to directly impact on children's health services. Whilst the fellowship application itself was not awarded, in preparing the application, I closely collaborated with NHS clinicians a specialist assistive technology service, that has since lead to the development of an assistive technology network involving NHS clinicians and academics, who meet quarterly to explore future research collaborations amd support.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Education,Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Title Investigating children's voice in qualitative research involving children with severe speech and physical impairments 
Description This work describes methodological reflections for investigating children's voice in participatory research with children who have severe speech and physical impairments. Drawing on my doctoral research findings, I discuss considerations that can be useful for researchers and practitioners when undertaking participatory work involving children with disabilities. These are: 1.Theoretical lenses guiding data collection, analysis and interpretation; 2. Developing credible accounts through strong and prominent ideas; 3. Children's ways of participating evidencing their voices, and; 4. Methods hindering the promotion of child centred accounts. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact To date (Feb 2023), this work has been downloaded 2213 times, with 11 citation since publication in June 2021. 
URL https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09687599.2021.1933389
 
Description Network for clinicans and academics in assistive technology 
Organisation National Health Service
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution Since developing links with the Barnsley Assistive technology NHS team using my ESRC postdoc fellowship, I have been part of a new clinical network on Assistive technology since it's inception. The group is formed of NHS clinicians and academics who work in the area of assistive technology and my role has been to provide and mentorship for clinicians who are engaging in assistive technology research, as well as exploring new research directions within the group.
Collaborator Contribution The network was formed May 2022 and meets on a monthly basis to share knowledge about current clinical and research activities. Through the Future NHS forum, the group have engaged in supporting collaboration and peer support for those who are working as clinical academics, on a clinical academic pathway, or researching within AAC and EC assistive technology services.
Impact - Worked with Barnsley Assistive technology multidisciplinary team to create a proposal for an NIHR fellowship application.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Creating and sharing two publicly available practitioner videos on designing and using assistive communication technologies with children 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Two practitioner videos that translate research into practice were created for speech and language therapists, teachers and assistive technologists. The videos were shared on the project's research blog, youtube and social media accounts, as well as sign posted to at a UK national conference for Augmentative and Alternative Communication. The videos are estimated to have has approximately 4000 impressions on social media, and have sparked follow up discussions with colleagues who work in the NHS in the area of assistive technology.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inYQQkq5v_I
 
Description Interview for UCL Collaborative Social Sciences Domain podcast series 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The collaborative social sciences domain (CSSD) podcast series showcases interdisciplinary research happening across UCL. The interview was published on the UCL CSSD website and soundcloud channel and has been listened to 450 times in the first month of air.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.ucl.ac.uk/research/domains/collaborative-social-science/podcasts/collaborative-social-sc...