Covid-19 deaths among migrant health care workers: risks and responses
Lead Research Organisation:
The Open University
Department Name: Faculty of Arts and Social Sci (FASS)
Abstract
There is a paucity of robust empirical evidence about whether migrant health care workers have the same level of exposure to Covid-19 infection and deaths as non-migrant health care workers, and whether variations exist between sectors (as between the health and social care sectors) and countries (as between higher income and lower income countries). Such empirical evidence on what responses have emerged in the face of threats to the resilience of health and care workforces and to realising the global goal of universal health coverage worldwide is also weak. Weak surveillance systems and fragmented reporting systems mean that special investigations to properly monitor Covid-19 impacts on health care workers and workforces are required by national and international decision-makers.
This project aims to give proper attention to the place of migrants in health care systems during the Covid-19 pandemic. Migrant workers are of substantial and growing significance in many countries' health and care systems and are key to realising the global goal of universal health care so it is vital that we understand much better how Covid-19 is impacting on them. The project's overarching research question is, in the relation to Covid-19, what risks do migrant health care workers experience, what are the pressures on resilient and sustainable health care workforces, and how are stakeholders responding to these risks and pressures? In addition to strengthening the empirical evidence base on the risks of Covid-19 infection and death among migrant health care workers our project also tracks collective responses to such risks and challenges to sustainable health workforces for universal health coverage.
We collect qualitative and quantitative data on Covid-19 risks, pressures and responses using different methods and techniques. We undertake a systematic literature review (SLR) of academic and non-academic publications using hybrid review methodologies to search for data and content analysis methodology to extract data of interest and evaluate the methods and findings of studies and publications. Coverage of three global languages - English, Spanish and Arabic - ensures greater ethnolinguistic reach and inclusivity of the SLR. We also develop a research method to estimate Covid-19 migrant health care worker mortality rates and trial the method, undertaking statistical analysis and modelling using quantitative data drawn from WHO and OECD data and other demographic and bio-statistical data as available. In addition, we collect data through interviews and documentary analysis on the responses of stakeholders (employers, trade unions, NGOs) to chart emerging patterns of response relating to health care worker training, recruitment, retention, deployment, international migration, and challenges for migrant health care worker protection at work consistent with international recruitment and employment norms.
We involve key stakeholders from diverse communities of policy and practice during the research process, designed to have demonstrable potential for impact by meeting their time-critical requirements for robust empirical and analytical evidence about the multidimensional impacts of Covid-19 on health care workforces. This project is attuned to the urgent need for high quality data and for 'real world' solutions-focused Covid-19 research forged from collaboration. We are focused on the immediate application of proof-of concept findings to a rapidly-evolving global health crisis.
This project aims to give proper attention to the place of migrants in health care systems during the Covid-19 pandemic. Migrant workers are of substantial and growing significance in many countries' health and care systems and are key to realising the global goal of universal health care so it is vital that we understand much better how Covid-19 is impacting on them. The project's overarching research question is, in the relation to Covid-19, what risks do migrant health care workers experience, what are the pressures on resilient and sustainable health care workforces, and how are stakeholders responding to these risks and pressures? In addition to strengthening the empirical evidence base on the risks of Covid-19 infection and death among migrant health care workers our project also tracks collective responses to such risks and challenges to sustainable health workforces for universal health coverage.
We collect qualitative and quantitative data on Covid-19 risks, pressures and responses using different methods and techniques. We undertake a systematic literature review (SLR) of academic and non-academic publications using hybrid review methodologies to search for data and content analysis methodology to extract data of interest and evaluate the methods and findings of studies and publications. Coverage of three global languages - English, Spanish and Arabic - ensures greater ethnolinguistic reach and inclusivity of the SLR. We also develop a research method to estimate Covid-19 migrant health care worker mortality rates and trial the method, undertaking statistical analysis and modelling using quantitative data drawn from WHO and OECD data and other demographic and bio-statistical data as available. In addition, we collect data through interviews and documentary analysis on the responses of stakeholders (employers, trade unions, NGOs) to chart emerging patterns of response relating to health care worker training, recruitment, retention, deployment, international migration, and challenges for migrant health care worker protection at work consistent with international recruitment and employment norms.
We involve key stakeholders from diverse communities of policy and practice during the research process, designed to have demonstrable potential for impact by meeting their time-critical requirements for robust empirical and analytical evidence about the multidimensional impacts of Covid-19 on health care workforces. This project is attuned to the urgent need for high quality data and for 'real world' solutions-focused Covid-19 research forged from collaboration. We are focused on the immediate application of proof-of concept findings to a rapidly-evolving global health crisis.
Organisations
People |
ORCID iD |
| Nicola Yeates (Principal Investigator) |
Publications
Vaillancourt-LaFlamme, C
(2022)
Impacts of Covid-19 on migrant health workers: a review of evidence and implications for health care provision
| Title | Strengthening the rights of migrant health workers: lessons from the pandemic |
| Description | Co-produced between the Open University and Public Services International, this short animation (~ 1 min 45 seconds) succinctly conveys key findings from the research project and the implications of these for pandemic preparedness. |
| Type Of Art | Film/Video/Animation |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Impact | The animation is also available on PSI's website. |
| URL | https://fass.open.ac.uk/research/projects/CRaR |
| Description | Achievements: The study set out to address and redress the near-invisibility of migrant health workers (and migrants more generally) in Covid-19 impact studies. Our research findings achieve these aims. In particular, they show that: (a) there is a lack of robust data infrastructures needed to *confidently* quantify the relative differences in risk of death faced by migrant health workers compared with their non-migrant colleagues especially on a cross-country basis; (b) nevertheless, migrant health workers have been disproportionately adversely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic and responses to it by employers and governments. In particular: - We identify 5 principal factors exacerbating the risks to such workers: health workforce shortages; decent work deficits, including lack of social protection; discrimination, violence and harassment; absence of social dialogue, and changing patterns of international recruitment. These factors are interlocking and have highly consequential implications not only for the rights and welfare of those workers but also for the provision of universal health care and realising rights-based, people-centered sustainable development for all countries. - Few of the policy responses directed at the health workforce have addressed the specific circumstances, risks and needs of migrant members of this workforce, and not all such workers benefited from the measures. Long-term policy responses in relation to rights-based approaches to health worker migration and building sustainable health care systems have been extremely limited. |
| Exploitation Route | The outcomes of this funding can inform evaluations of the impacts of government and other stakeholders responses to the Covid-19 pandemic (2020-2022). They can inform on-going discussions about strengthening data infrastructures, and for data systems with greater capacity for collecting and analysing disaggregated data. In particular, our research reaffirms the World Health Organization's advocacy of standardised measurement and reporting of Covid-19 impacts, and extends WHO's recommendations to improve data on the health workforce in ways that enable disaggregation by sex, age, ethnicity, occupation, health status, migration status, country of origin and whether employed in public or private health care delivery. The outcomes of the funding can also inform pandemic preparedness planning among governments, employers, trade unions and other stakeholders, including international organisations such as the World Bank, ILO, WHO, EU and other world-regional associations. |
| Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy Healthcare |
| URL | https://fass.open.ac.uk/research/projects/CRaR |
| Description | The findings have been used by the project partner, PSI, as part of the development of its strategy document for the forthcoming 4 years. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
| Sector | Healthcare |
| Impact Types | Policy & public services |
| Description | Take up of the project research findings |
| Geographic Reach | Multiple continents/international |
| Policy Influence Type | Contribution to a national consultation/review |
| URL | https://publicservices.international/resources/news/psi-key-policy-brdocuments-2023?lang=en&id=14330 |
| Title | COVID-19 Mortality among Migrant Health Care Workers, 2021 |
| Description | The dataset consists of quantitative data derived mainly from international datasets (ILO, WHO), supplemented by data from national datasets and modelled data to complete missing values. It shows the statistical data we collated and used to calculate estimates of Covid-19 deaths among migrant health care workers and includes details on how missing information was imputed. It includes spreadsheet estimates for India, Nigeria, Mexico, and the UK for excess and reported Covid-19 deaths amongst foreign-born workers and for all workers in the human health and social work sector and in three specific health occupations: doctors, nurses, and midwives. For each group the spreadsheets provide a basic estimate and an age-sex standardised estimate. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| Impact | none as yet |
| URL | https://reshare.ukdataservice.ac.uk/856071/ |
| Description | research presentation |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | Counting Covid-19 migrant health workers' deaths, with Sarah Tipping, presentation to Open University/WELS Thanatology Research Group, 23 March |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| Description | research presentation |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | The presentation was part of an Open University event to celebrate International Women's Day (8th March) - "Health and care at the crossroads: evidencing gender impacts, campaigning for equality". It presented key findings from the funded research study with regard to impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic on migrant health workers and collective responses to the pandemic. It was part of a wider discussion of the devalorisation of care and of strategies and policies to value it and thereby improve health and social equality. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.open.ac.uk/ikd/ |