Reconstituting Irish Families Network: RIFNET

Lead Research Organisation: University of Hertfordshire
Department Name: School of Humanities

Abstract

RIFNET will alter the conversation around the Irish family. For too long, understandings of the family have been constrained by an over-emphasis on the 'traditional' unit. Comprised of a heterosexual married couple and their offspring within one household, this understanding is, and has always been, but one expression of the family. In the Republic of Ireland, the family is defined by the constitution in Article 41. This article has been a 'contentious' issue in the Irish State (Visser, 2018), and one which is to be subject to a nationwide conversation in the form of a citizen's assembly, and ultimately a referendum. As senior parliamentary researcher Anna Visser noted in 2018, 'there is a dominant view amongst policy-makers and commentators that it is desirable to amend or repeal Article 41.2.' On both sides of the border, important legal changes have been made in recent years in regards to family and reproductive law (Marriage Equality, ROI 2015, NI 2019), while other changes are still being worked through or demanded (for example, the recent extension to the Commission on Mother and Baby Homes (2019), and renewed attention on the 27th constitutional amendment (2004) which denied citizenship rights to children born in Ireland to non-Irish or British parents).

Working in different fields, scholars of the Irish family have long pointed out the conceptual problems of the 'traditional' Irish family. Nuclear, white, Catholic, settled, and heterosexual, this idea of the 'traditional' Irish family does not, and has never, matched the messy reality. Indeed, the problem is not just conceptual. This view of the family has long been used as the basis of family regulation in Ireland for centuries to the detriment of women, men and children. Generations of Irish families have deviated from the traditional model. Yet, their stories have been overlooked, overshadowed and omitted from the narrative. Historians, sociologists and legal scholars have all captured the lives of historical and contemporary communities of Irish women and men whose family experiences sit outside the assumed norm. While each of these fields have developed a rich disciplinary body of literature, these perspectives have not yet been considered together. RIFNET sits at this nexus and makes an important intervention in scholarship and society to provide academic scholarship and resources. In bringing to the fore marginalised stories and side-lined experiences, this research network provides a powerful challenge to dominant narratives of the family. RIFNET will engage with the latest international research on the concept of family (Finch, 2007;Morgan, 2020), and in turn, will provide a model for analysing the family within a supposed homogeneous society which will be internationally significant. We aim to push the boundaries of existing knowledge to create a new model that captures the broad diversity and messy realities of Irish family life.

Through a series of workshops and impact activities, RIFNET brings together scholars, policy-makers and the general public to engage in critical discussions about the Irish family, both past and present. The work is divided across five work packages, from which the following outputs will flow:
* An embedded research network.
* 2xECR Research seminar presentations.
* Archival research on the family.
* A primary source collection of oral histories and images for future analysis and research.
* A methodological model for accessing, preserving and disseminating diverse family experiences in Ireland. RIFNET members may present findings on The Conversation or Radio Teilifis Éireann (RTÉ)'s 'Brainstorm' or through partner networks.
* Academic workshop facilitating wider networking.
* Special issue of high-impact journal.
* Online exhibition of audio-visual sources on the Irish family.
* A searchable and interdisciplinary academic database of researchers and research on the Irish family.
*Biographies of RIFNET members.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our main achievement has been the curation and creation of objects and oral histories that tell stories about LGBTQ+ family life.

*RIFNET was established with the view to bring to the centre marginalised stories and side-lined experiences of family life in Ireland. We wanted to champion stories of 'family' that sit outside of the perceived view of the Irish family as heterosexual, married, white, rural, and settled. In April 2022, we hosted an object storytelling event at the National Museum of Ireland, Dublin. The purpose of the event was to capture stories of Irish families that are not represented in our national institutions. We invited members of the LGBTQ+ community to share objects that told their story of what 'family' means to them. These objects and their stories are currently being transferred to an online exhibition, which will be hosted by our specially curated project website. RIFNET aims to make a long-term change to contemporary ideas about what constitutes Irish family life, and as part of that commitment we have worked closely with the Digital Repository of Ireland who have agreed to ensure the long-term preservation of these stories and objects.
Exploitation Route Once our project website is live, with its exhibition of objects and oral histories, these outcomes may be used by others interested in learning about the diversity of family life in Ireland. The outputs may also inform research of others working across the social sciences.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.ucc.ie/en/iss21/researchprojects/researchprojects/earlieriss21projects/rifnetreconstitutingtheirishfamilyresearchnetwork/#meet-the-network
 
Description The project has resulted in a number of non-academic and academic outcomes that promise to have an impact on society and culture. 1. Online exhibition of objects and oral histories -The project has resulted in the creation and curation of an online exhibition that showcases objects and oral histories that tell stories of LGBTQ+ family life in Ireland. These will be made 'live' this Spring. These outputs constitute a significant contribution to understandings of family life in Ireland by championing marginalised narratives of what it means (and always meant) to be 'family' in an Irish context. -These outputs will be of interest to the general public, as well as researchers on the family in Ireland. -The pilot event that was behind the collection may also be used as a model to follow for other researchers. 2. Special Issue. A New Agenda for the Irish Family, ed. L. Calvert and M. O'Riordan, History of the Family. -We have agreed to publish a special issue of a journal, based on the work conducted by RIFNET members. -The draft articles are due in April 2023, at which point they will be sent for blind review. We hope to publish in 2024. -The journal will make an important academic contribution to understandings of the family in Ireland and set a new agenda for future research. The papers showcase new, cutting edge methods and research areas in the study of the family from the eighteenth- century to the present day. The papers include: LGBTQ+ family histories; transgender lives and queer approaches to the family; widows and widowed families; single mothers and family; non-human families.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description A New Agenda for the Irish Family: An Interdisciplinary Symposium 
Organisation University College Cork
Country Ireland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution On 15 June 2022, RIFNET held an online symposium managed through the zoom account of the University of Hertfordshire. The symposium was initially planned to take place in person, with a special keynote from Professor Katie Barclay (University of Adelaide). Owing to continuing unease with travel, the symposium was moved online. A call for papers was issued in February 2022 that outlined our mission to bring together scholars to reconceptualise and revitalise understandings of family in an Irish context. We invited short c. 15 minutes research papers, think pieces, calls for action, and agendas for future research from scholars working on Irish families, past and present. The online event was organised by the two project PIs and papers were delivered by the two PIs, 5 members of the network, and 3 external members. The papers were as follows: Panel 1: Performing the Family Liz Kiely (University College Cork): 'We're an outdoorsy family': family display as a conceptual model to understand family. Leanne Calvert (University of Hertfordshire):'Queering the Presbyterian family, c. 1700-1830'. Panel 2: Ideas and Perceptions of Family Janice Holmes (Dalarna University, Sweden): 'Manse life: literary and historical interpretations of Presbyterian clerical family life in the north of Ireland, 1880s-1920s' Ruth Coon (Queen's University, Belfast): 'Mixed marriage in Ireland: Perception and reality' Maeve O'Riordan (University College Cork): 'Negotiating the Irish gentry family through singleness'. Panel 3: Looking Outside the Nuclear Clodagh Tait (Mary Immaculate College, Limerick): 'His son is his son til he have a wife': thinking about parenting, 'other-parenting', kinship and young men in 17th-century Ireland. Ciara Meehan (University of Hertfordshire): 'We will be [happy] when we're a real family again': Widows and the meaning of family in independent Ireland. Panel 4: Horizontal Family Relationships Shannon Devlin (Queen's University, Belfast): 'My brother ... wept in Cookstown street': exploring nineteenth-century Irish family life through sibling relationships. Sarah O'Brien (Mary Immaculate College, Limerick): 'Critiquing the family dynamics of post-Famine Irish emigration to America'. 4-5pm Keynote Katie Barclay (University of Adelaide): 'Emotion and the making of the Irish family'.
Collaborator Contribution The online symposium provided an opportunity to connect RIFNET with others working on the family. The event was open to, and attended by, researchers across the globe. Individuals joined from Australia, England, Ireland, Scotland, and Sweden. There was a good mix of career stages, from postgraduate research students, early-career and mid-career researchers, to established faculty.
Impact Contributors were offered the opportunity to submit their working papers to a special issue of History of the Family, which will be co-edited by the two project PIs. These submissions are now in draft form.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Deirdre Foley Research Seminar 
Organisation University of Hertfordshire
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In our bid for the money, RIFNET outlined its commitment to support the research of our ECR members. This was to be facilitated through two ECR exchanges and seminar presentations. Dr Deirdre Foley, one of our ECR members, subsequently delivered a paper to the University of Hertfordshire research seminar in April 2022. Her paper was entitled " 'Their family responsibilities': Women's work, maternity leave and childcare in the Republic of Ireland, c. 1969-1981". The presentation drew on her forthcoming monograph project into women's work in twentieth-century Ireland.
Collaborator Contribution The host institution (University of Hertfordshire) extended an invitation to Dr Foley to present. Due to ongoing covid concerns, the seminar series is taking place online, and so Dr Foley was not present, in person, in Hertfordshire.
Impact A research seminar presentation.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Roundtable on researching the family hosted by UCC Women's Studies featuring Dr Shannon Devlin, Dr Deidre Foley, and Prof. Lindsey Earner-Byrne chaired by Dr Chiara Bonfiglioli 
Organisation University College Cork
Country Ireland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution An online event that brought together RIFNET members and external partners to discuss the challenges of researching the family in an Irish context. The event was organised by the Irish PI, Dr Maeve O'Riordan, and featured contributions from our two ECR members, Dr Shannon Devlin and Dr Deirdre Foley.
Collaborator Contribution University College, Cork, promoted the event through the Institute of Social Sciences, and the event was chaired by Dr Chiara Bonfiglioli, the coordinator of the interdisciplinary Women's Studies programme at UCC. We are also delighted to have the support and participation of Professor Lindsey Earner-Byre, who has held the Senior Academic Leadership Initiative Chair in Irish Gender History since January 2021.
Impact One day event.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Researching the Irish Family Project: Object Story-Telling & LGBTQ+ Families 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In June 2022, RIFNET hosted a public engagement event at the National Museum of Ireland, Dublin. The event was coordinated with the NMI, who are one of our project partners. The event was in two parts: a digital storytelling event and an academic roundtable.

The first part of the day was the digital storytelling event. This event was intended to serve as a pilot activity, that could be scaled up in the future with further funding. We invited members of the public who identified as belonging to the LGBTQ+ community to bring objects to the NMI that told their stories of family and family life. These objects were then professionally photographed in-house by the NMI, and members of the public participated in oral history interviews about their objects. The objects and their stories will be transferred to an online exhibition, that will be hosted on our research website. Through our partnership with the Digital Repository of Ireland, we have arranged for these objects and interviews to be made permanently available online. The outputs of the event have produced an important data set of sources for understanding LGBTQ+ family life in Ireland.

Six members of the public participated in the interviews. Their objects included family photographs, wedding photographs, zines, and a sash. Through our partnership with the NMI, we also arranged for participants to receive a 'behind-the-scenes' tour of the collections held in the NMI and to discuss the preservation of their object with an archivist.

The second part of the day was an academic roundtable. This event was attended by our public members, RIFNET members, and external panel members. Participants were drawn from higher education institutions, public institutions, activists, and museum professionals. The panel consisted of: Dr Aoife Bhreatnach, Oein DeBhairduin, Edmund Lynch, Dr Tom Hulme, Dr Lorraine Grimes, Dr Mo Moulton, and Orla Egan. The session was chaired by Professor Anne Byrne (NUIG).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/recollecting-the-irish-family-new-directions-and-perspectives-registr...