UK-Africa network to improve the nutrition of infants and young children living in poverty (NINO LIP) in urbanising subSaharan African countries

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University

Abstract

Globally, more than a quarter of children under the age of five years are stunted (undernourished). Stunted children experience lifelong problems with their health and are more likely to die early. The time at which an infant transitions from receiving only breastmilk to needing additional foods (complementary feeding) has been shown to be associated with increasing problems with stunting. Currently only 22% of Kenyan and 8% of Malawian children aged 6-23 months receive the minimum acceptable diet, down from 39% (Kenya) and 19% (Malawi) between 2008 and 2014. It is estimated that interventions which promote optimal infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices could prevent 20% of deaths in under-fives in countries with high levels of child deaths. Approximately one-third of urban residents in low and middle income countries live in slums, with an additional 100,000 moving in daily. Children living in slums are more likely to suffer from under-nutrition than other urban children. Nevertheless the literature tells us that there is a lack of evidence regarding nutrition interventions in slum environments, and almost no evidence regarding the potential for 'nutrition-sensitive' interventions that target the drivers of poor nutrition such as poverty, cultural and social practices, and poor physical environments. Successful design of these types of intervention requires a well-integrated interdisciplinary approach. In addition to nutrition expertise, contributions from other disciplines are needed to understand the cultural, social, physical and economic environments that influence IYCF practices.

We therefore propose an interdisciplinary network with the aim to produce evidence to drive future research and inform policies to improve the nutritional status of IYC living in poverty in sub-Saharan African countries (SSA) experiencing rapid urbanisation. The network is led by Loughborough University with Kenyan partners at the African Population and Health Research Centre and Malawian partners at the University of Malawi and The Lilongwe University of Agriculture and Natural Resources as well as UK partners at The Universities of Sheffield and Southampton. The specific network objectives will be to: 1) Prepare a rapid review of evidence documenting interventions for the urban poor to improve the nutrition of IYC in SSA; 2) Convene the first network workshop (to include stakeholders) to firstly guide analysis of existing data sources on this topic, to secondly consider the current evidence base and policies identified in the rapid review and finally to ask key stakeholders to identify highest-ranking evidence/research gaps for improving IYC feeding programmes and policies; 3) Undertake analyses of existing data from demographic and health surveys in sub-Saharan Africa and pre-existing data from slums in Nairobi to explore how the various drivers of IYCF practices are influenced by urbanisation and to consider whether those drivers vary for the urban poor compared to other urban populations; and finally 4) Facilitate end-of-project workshops to develop research proposals informed by evidence from the first three objectives and to present findings of the secondary analysis and discuss these with stakeholders (including Ministries of Health, NGOs, communities) and policy-makers. The network will also foster the development of skills in data analysis and evidence synthesis in early career researchers in the UK, Malawi and Kenya, thus helping to ensure a sustainable group with potential for evolving future leadership. In the longer term we will develop a UK-Africa interdisciplinary network with expertise to support interventions to promote optimal IYCF practices in rapidly urbanising environments. It is envisaged that such interventions will improve the human capital of developing countries by reducing under nutrition, thus promoting optimal cognitive and physical development, and thereby increasing prospects for economic prosperity.

Technical Summary

Globally, >25% of children under the age of five years are stunted. Currently only 22% of Kenyan and 8% of Malawian children aged 6-23 months receive the minimum acceptable diet. Approximately one-third of urban residents in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) live in slums, with an additional 100,000 moving in daily. Slum children are more likely to suffer from under-nutrition than other urban children. Nevertheless evidence-based interventions to improve infant and young child (IYC) health/nutrition in slums are lacking. We will form a Loughborough University-led interdisciplinary network with partners in Malawi, Kenya, Southampton and Sheffield with the aim to produce evidence to drive future research and inform policies to improve the nutritional status of IYC living in poverty in sub-Saharan African countries (SSA) experiencing rapid urbanisation. The network has four main objectives:1) Prepare a rapid review documenting current evidence on nutrition-specific/sensitive interventions for improving the nutrition of IYC who are receiving complementary foods in the context of rapid urbanisation for the urban poor in SSA; 2) Convene the first network workshop (to include stakeholders) to a) Guide secondary data analysis, b) Consider the current evidence base/policies identified in the rapid review, and c) Apply the DELPHI method with stakeholders to identify highest-ranking evidence/research gaps for improving IYC feeding programmes/policies; 3) Undertake secondary data analysis of existing African demographic and health surveys and pre-existing data from slums in Nairobi to explore how various drivers of IYC feeding practices are influenced by urbanisation and to consider whether those drivers vary for the urban poor compared to other urban populations; and 4) Facilitate end-of-project workshops to a) Develop research proposals informed by evidence from the first three objectives and b) Present and discuss findings with local policy-makers and stakeholders.

Planned Impact

The impact of our 12 month global nutrition and health network; "UK-Africa network to improve the nutrition of infants and young children living in poverty (NINO LIP) in urbanising sub-Saharan African countries" will be to mobilise an interdisciplinary research and policy agenda to promote optimal infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices in rapidly urbanising environments in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), with a focus on the urban poor and those living in slums. Our longer term impact goal is to improve nutrition at a critical point in the life-course through the development of nutrition-sensitive interventions and holistic approaches to reduce infant and young child (IYC) stunting in SSA countries; this will be our route to achieving change across the global nutrition/health research landscape.

The benefit of this project to LMICs is that the research need has been identified by researchers and partners in Kenya and Malawi, and that impact activities are an integrated component of the 12 month network. We have already engaged with key stakeholders in preparation of this proposal, and in order to build our global nutrition network. Our early engagement is evidenced through the letters of support already received from UNICEF, Kenya; the Ministries of Health in Kenya and Malawi, and the African Nutrition Society. Further stakeholders will be identified through the extensive links of the UK, Malawian and Kenyan investigators and their respective institutions. By the end of the 12 month network, we will have extended our stakeholder links to other African countries. Starting our global nutrition and health network with two African countries at different stages of economic development will allow a better understanding of the barriers and opportunities for nutrition-sensitive interventions in the different cultural contexts.
Within four months of the network's inception, we will host our first stakeholder meeting in Nairobi, Kenya. The workshop will be used to present findings from the rapid review of interventions to reduce the risk of stunting among the urban poor, and will then use a ranking method to identify the highest rated gaps in evidence and research. We will consult stakeholders in preparation of the workshop and at regular intervals throughout the 12 month project. A second stakeholder engagement workshop will take place in Malawi at the end of the project, with stakeholders from Kenya and Malawi invited. The workshops will help stakeholders to understand the key evidence gaps in the promotion of optimal IYCF practices in rapidly urbanising environments in SSA for the urban poor. Based on the findings of the secondary data analysis, workshops will also identify predictors of stunting in slum communities and whether these are comparable to other African environments . This project will produce two academic publications by the end of 12 months and will lead to the development of a UK-Africa interdisciplinary network with the knowledge, evidence and skills to develop interventions to improve IYCF. The stakeholder workshops, along with the research findings and ideas generation with the investigators in SSA, will stimulate global nutrition research, and form the basis for larger-scale funding applications aimed at improving IYCF and reducing stunting in SSA countries.

People

ORCID iD

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Objective 1. Prepare a rapid review documenting current evidence on nutrition-specific and nutrition-sensitive interventions for improving the nutrition of infants and young children (IYC) who are receiving complementary foods in the context of rapid urbanization in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA);

Key Findings
- There is a need for more evidence regarding complementary feeding, and the factors that drive it, in poor urban areas in LMICs, as well as a need for additional interventions in LMICs to support optimal complementary feeding. The evidence base for sub-Saharan Africa is particularly lacking with the exception of limited evidence from South Africa.
- The rapid review identified six intervention studies published since 2014 and up to 2018. The quality assessment indicated that these were all of medium quality. It is worth noting that reporting of outcome measures and details of controlling for confounds were the areas where studies commonly achieved lower (medium) quality ratings, which reflect the write-up of the study rather than the quality of the research conducted.
- Although intervention adherence was high in most studies and indicators of maternal knowledge and infant and young child (IYC) nutritional intake (e.g., dietary diversity) increased as a result of the interventions, the effects on IYC anthropometric status were small, even when statistically significant.
- No studies were identified that reported interventions to improve the complementary feeding of IYC from low-income urban settings in SSA, other than one of the two studies in South Africa. It is noteworthy that only two studies assessed diet quality.
- Most of the studies focused on anthropometric outcomes rather than the pathways to achieving those outcomes, and no included studies specifically examined complementary feeding.
- The use of health service/community activities and home-based participatory play interventions could also provide an important platform for improving IYC feeding practices.
- Our rapid review shows that the gap in evidence around nutrition-sensitive interventions in urban areas of low-income countries persists, confirming the earlier findings of a Cochrane systematic review. The evidence base in rural areas is stronger.

Objective 2. Convene the first network workshop with academics and stakeholders in Kenya to:
a) Guide the secondary analysis of data
b) Consider the current evidence base and policies identified in the rapid review
c) Apply the DELPHI method with stakeholders to identify the highest ranking evidence/research gaps for improving IYC feeding programmes and policies;

Key Findings:
• Future complementary feeding interventions should include an assessment of diet quality.
• Nutrition-sensitive factors should be considered when developing and evaluating complementary feeding interventions in urban low-income informal settlements or slums; this will help to maximise the potential impact and effectiveness of nutrition-specific interventions.
• Multisectoral approaches are needed to improve the nutritional status of urban poor children of complementary feeding age in sub-Saharan Africa.
- More than 75% of stakeholders across sub-Saharan African countries reported that the recommendations around, and the value of, complementary feeding were not well understood by urban poor caregivers. Moreover, 90% believed that the reasons for poor complementary feeding in urban poor areas need to be better understood, and 100% of participating stakeholders indicated that efforts are needed to better understand current practices around complementary feeding.
- It was generally agreed (91%) that existing IYCF messaging and nutritional counselling interventions are effective at increasing exclusive breastfeeding, indicating that this is less of a priority area for nutrition-related interventions.
- It is noteworthy that other aspects of behaviour change (e.g., the provision of social support or demonstration of a behaviour) have been shown to be effective in bringing about changes and might warrant inclusion alongside education in future intervention development.

Objective 3. Support early career researchers to undertake secondary data analysis of existing SSA demographic and health surveys and pre-existing data from slums in Nairobi to explore research questions 2/3;
Objective 4 - Facilitate end-of-project workshops to
a) Develop research proposals informed by evidence from the first three objectives
b) Present findings of the secondary analysis and discuss these with stakeholders.

Key findings from objectives 3 and 4
- networking and sharing more complex data analysis skills was valuable for the early career researchers in the network. They reported learning new skills in multi-level modelling learned. The network developed between the early career researchers meant that there was a feeling of support between the early career researchers.
- Based on the mentorship given to early career researchers from the network two early career researchers were supported to apply for grants - one successful through the British Academy and a second one to The Wellcome Trust which was not successful but laid the foundations for future applications from this researcher and developed skills in grant writing.
- We learned that there were challenges in identifying the urban poor in DHS data because of the small sample sizes within most countries of the urban poor. Most surveys contained very small numbers of children defined as urban and in the lowest quintile of the wealth index.
- Despite the small numbers in the surveys, the basic descriptive statistics showing that the urban poor had equivalent nutrition risks for poor growth to children living in rural areas was reported to be particularly important in the Malawi setting. The Malawi government reported that it had not previously seen urban nutrition as a priority because rural nutrition was perceived to be worse. The academic literature has also focused on rural nutrition. Using the data to show the vulnerability of the urban poor changed thinking about the need to think about the nutritional needs of urban poor children.
- Forming the network led to a group of experts who have gone on to collaborate together and submit a number of applications on topics related to this award. The successful applications are detailed in the further funding area of this submission.
Exploitation Route Others could note the gaps in evidence in relation to interventions to support complementary feeding in children aged 6-23 months of age for urban poor children in the sub-Saharan context and work to build this evidence base through research and work with national governments in sub-Saharan African countries to help to develop evidence based policies and implementation systems to support complementary feeding in children aged 6-23 months in urban poor areas.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description When we reported the findings of our project to the Kenyan government, they were keen for us to continue forward from the network to undertake further research on this topic among the urban poor. However, they also alerted us to the fact that nomadic pastoralists in Kenya were experiencing the poorest levels of nutritional health in Kenya and encouraged us to also address this problem from our network skills and expertise. We have secured funding related to extending this work with nomadic pastoralists (from the British Academy) but have been unable to achieve further impact with the urban poor because we have not managed to secure funds as a network that facilitate us to realise that impact among the urban poor although we continue to try to do this. We did go onto achieve impact working with the nomadic pastoralists in Kenya in Kajiado County. Supporting an early career researcher at the African Population and Health Research Centre we applied as co-principle applicants to the British Academy for funds to undertake a research project with the nomadic pastoralists in Kajiado County in Kenya. From this project we identified the caring practices in the community and worked with local stakeholders to: 1. Identify priorities for supporting nurturing care including optimal nutrition 2. To understand how local traditional caring practices can be promoted in nurturing care guidelines 3. To identify a way forward to support nurturing care in the county Out of these discussions emerged a priority to understand how to support the development of guidelines for the setting up of daycare centres in Kajiado County. We generated impact by sharing the findings about caring practices in Kajiado community with stakeholders, bringing together stakeholders from Nairobi County (where daycare guidelines already exist), and facilitating stakeholder group discussions to help to draft a childcare bill for the Kajiado County assembly. That bill was led by the nutrition department and includes appropriate support for nutrition as well as all other aspects of the nurturing care framework. Our facilitation of our research evidence into these discussions as well as the facilitation of bringing local experts in policy together has contributed to the bill being adopted and now working through the process of transitioning to an act. The support for the development of the bill was requested by the stakeholders that we have built strong relationships with in Kajiado County. We have just recently completed a stakeholder engagement meeting with county officials as well as those working to support childcare in Kajiado County and caregivers to work out a way forward for future steps for the work. The future plan for generating impact has been agreed to focus on: 1. Supporting the development of regulations to ensure the implementation of the childcare act including developing measures for monitoring and evaluation in Kajiado County. 2. Providing expertise to develop tools to support childcare facilities and caregivers to support active play and physical literacy alongside healthy nutrition across Kenya.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Education,Healthcare,Other
Impact Types Societal

Policy & public services

 
Description CAring Practices And Support for Early Childhood Development and learning among nomadic pastoralists - informing the development of a support system to foster optimal early childhood development in Kenya (CAPS-ECD study)
Amount £299,707 (GBP)
Organisation The British Academy 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2019 
End 11/2021
 
Description Early Child Education Maximising Impact
Amount £50,000 (GBP)
Funding ID MI2\100022 
Organisation The British Academy 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2023 
End 01/2024
 
Description Kenya-UK development award to support the design of a whole system approach to facilitate the functioning of the baby friendly community initiative within the Kenyan health system
Amount £100,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 130285 
Organisation National Institute for Health Research 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2020 
End 12/2020
 
Description New strategies to reduce anaemia and risk of overweight and obesity through complementary feeding of infants and young children in Peru
Amount £582,398 (GBP)
Funding ID MR/S024921/1 
Organisation Medical Research Council (MRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2019 
End 04/2023
 
Description Peru infant feeding collaboration 
Organisation Nutritional Research Institute
Country Peru 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution As a result of our group presenting our preliminary findings of our evidence at a meeting in Peru we were invited to become part of a collaboration with Peruvian partners to apply to the MRC/CONCYTEC Newton call on nutrition in Peru. Emily Rousham from our network led this application and it was succesfully funded. We (Emily Rousham, Paula Griffiths, Michelle Holdsworth, Rebecca Pradeilles and Emma Haycraft from the NINO LIP network) are now working in collaboration with Peruvian partners to support programming for double duty actions targetted at infants aged 6-23 months to reduce anaemia and overweight.
Collaborator Contribution We bring our global knowledge on community based interventions to improve infant nutrition to the collaboration. We also introduced design experts that we have been working with on other projects to the Peruvian team. We have expertise in social sciences which provide expertise in understanding context, psychology which supports understanding of supporting of infant feeding behaviours such as fussy eating as well as responsive feeding, nutrition which supports appropriate advice and intervention for infants of this age as well as assessing diet, nutrition policy which supports understanding of the policy environment which we can leverage and biological anthropology which drives knowledge on appropriate assessment of outcomes.
Impact MRC/CONCYTEC Newton award £1.06million entitled; "New Strategies to reduce anaemia and overweight/ obesity among infants and young children in Peru." Funded April 2019-April 2022. The collaboration is multi-disciplinary including: Social Sciences (Demography), nutrition, anthropology, psychology, biological anthropology and social anthropology.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Lilongwe stakeholder meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This event brought together about 30 stakeholders from Malawian government and NGOs and donors along with a small number of stakeholders from Kenyan government. Paula Griffiths presented the project and its objectives. Jesman Chintsanya presented initial findings we already had gained from engagement with stakeholders in Kenya and across sub-Saharan Africa through our network's DELPHI activities, and Nyovani Madise chaired a session that reported on the findings from stakeholder discussion groups regarding the prioritisation of evidence gaps from what had been learned about key evidence gaps from the DELPHI process from our network's activities.

The stakeholders in Malawi were very clear that the evidence gap for them was not knowing whether the urban poor children are worse off than the rural poor and until such evidence exists they would not want to target this group separately. There was therefore a request for us to fill this evidence gap. The Kenyan stakeholders on the other hand were able to be presented with clear evidence about the urban poor in Kenya and were convinced that this group needs special programming and voiced interest in the need to adapt the Baby Friendly Community Initiative for poor urban contexts.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Stakeholder meeting in Nairobi 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Approximately 40 stakeholders predominantly from Kenyan government departments and NGOs with an interest in child health plus a small number of stakeholders from Malawian government came to Nairobi to engage in discussions about the need for new evidence and how to fill evidence gaps to better understand the nutrition of infants aged 6-23 months in poor urban environments in Nairobi. The event included presentations from Paula Griffiths as study PI and Elizabeth Kimani Murage as the lead local researcher as well as round table discussion of the evidence gaps which were specific to the country of the stakeholder. Stakeholders fed in their ideas of evidence gaps and we worked together to plan the next steps forward to carry out a DELPHI study to engage with a wider group of stakeholders through our research and a subsequent stakeholder meeting in Malawi.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018