Examining health system performance for indigenous people in the Peruvian Amazon through the lens of tuberculosis control.

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Infectious and Tropical Diseases

Abstract

This project will investigate and identify the key features required by the Peruvian health system to provide high-quality health services to vulnerable populations. In order to do this, we will focus on one particularly vulnerable group: Indigenous People from the Amazon who suffer disproportionately from several health problems including tuberculosis (TB). The Project will focus on the barriers, enablers and facilitators of deliverying context appropriate, feasible and culturally respectful services to detect, diagnose and treat TB among one particular indigenous group: the Ashaninkas from the Central Amazon of Peru, located in the región of Junin.

Ashaninkas are the largest Peruvian Amazonian IP group, and have a higher prevalence of TB compared with other urban areas in Peru. Most health care policies in Peru, including TB policies have been designed with an urban approach making such policies inappropriate and ineffective in rural areas such as the Amazon.

This Project aims to address the limitations of current health system delivery strategies in rural areas through the study of TB health policies and implementation practices in the Peruvian Amazon. Through interviews with different stakeholders such as indigenous TB patients, community leaders, representatives of indigenous organizations, regional and national health care officials we aim to identify the constraints in service delivery for vulnerable groups and the opportunity to make feasible changes. We will focus on cross-cutting systemic issues to provide high quality health care. Through a systematic analysis of the data collected and one workshop with each type of stakehodler we aim to develop using a participatory approach, a comprehensive package of scalable interventions in order to improve the quality of care delivered by the NTP to Peruvian Amazonian communities and other vulnerable groups.

Technical Summary

This study has one primary research question fed by three secondary questions focused on indigenous groups
The primary question is: What are the key features that are required to strengthen the health system to improve the the detection, diagnosis, and treatment of tuberculosis for Peruvian Amazonian indigenous peoples (IP) and guarantee the provision of high-quality health services?
The secondary questions are:
(a) What are the barriers, enablers and/or facilitators for appropriate TB detection?;
(b) What are the barriers, enablers and/or facilitators for appropriate TB diagnosis? and
(c) What are the barriers, enablers and/or facilitators for appropriate TB treatment?

In each of these questions we will use the World Health Organization's building blocks approach to health systems (14) that looks into six major dimensions: leadership and governance, financing, health work force, information system, service delivery and medical products and technology.
We will capture views and information from three key scenarios:
i) community organizations, including indigenous federations;
ii) health facilities, including users and providers; and,
iii) health managers, and decision makers.

We will have three phases:
Phase 1 will address all three secondary questions;
Phase 2, will assemble all information gathered and, design/prepare a proposal of TB health system's strengthening; and,
Phase 3, will address a wider consultation with key stakeholders to validate the proposal.

Planned Impact

The final product of this development grant will be a set of interventions to improve detection, diagnosis and treatment (DDT) of TB. These interventions are expected to be tested as part of the Research Grant stage in three health networks: Satipo (Junin), Maynas (Loreto) and Condorcanqui (Amazonas), all of them serving IP. The testing phase will entail implementation and evaluation of scalability, acceptability and economic feasibility. The evidence generated by this project will shape the development of a comprehensive package of scalable interventions aimed to improve the quality of care delivered by the NTP to Peruvian Amazonian communities.
The participatory design will develop research capacity and seed local involvement in decision making about healthcare priorities delivery.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description TB control activity is standardised across the whole of a country.
We used an assessment of the way in which the National TB Control Programme Peru operates and delivers care in indigenous populations living in the Peruvian Amazon as a window on how healthcare for these people differs from that for people living in less remote parts of Peru. We found that the metrics by which performance of diagnostic and treatment services are evaluated were significantly lower than for the country as a whole, highlighting the shortcomings in healthcare delivery to these populations. This was not a surprising finding, confirming our hypothesis, but it did provide tangible hard evidence which can be used for influencing policy and practice.
Exploitation Route Those working in other healthcare fields - management of chronic non-communicable diseases such as diabetes and epilepsy and mental health problems - can carry out health needs assessments in these populations to expand the knowledge base about where innovative healthcare delivery models need to be implemented and tested
Sectors Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x1z6PozZLY&list=UUrp849Dd-CWQ6CmLQjwwPHA&index=10&t=0s
 
Description Multiple educational videos which can be used for advocacy and lobbying eg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x1z6PozZLY&list=UUrp849Dd-CWQ6CmLQjwwPHA?dex=10&t=0s
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Grant to develop 3 videos
Amount $3,000 (USD)
Organisation Center for Law and Social Transformation 
Sector Academic/University
Country Norway
Start 01/2017 
End 05/2017
 
Description Videos developed and posted online for healthcare personnel highlighting the challenges in delivering TB care to indigenous populations 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Extensive on-site filming in the Peruvian Amazon captured the challenges in delivering TB care to indigenous populations through the eyes of the user and the patient-facing healthcare personnel.
Editing to create succinct 5 minute video clips - purpose is really to highlight to healthcare workers the challenges faced by their fellow healthcare workers in these settings and the populations trying to access healthcare
URL for first is inserted below and two others can be found at :
https://youtu.be/2q21PJ9czyY
and
https://youtu.be/biHN7GtQQQ8
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016,2017
URL https://youtu.be/ya2JlgK2TYs