The Role of Complement Component C1Q in Tuberculosis and Diabetes Co-morbidity

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Infectious and Tropical Diseases

Abstract

People with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) have a three-fold enhanced risk of developing tuberculosis (TB) following infection than the general population. As the global burden of T2DM is rapidly growing, and increasingly overlapping with the TB epidemic particularly in low and middle income countries, there is an urgent need to develop new intervention strategies. The underlying causal mechanism linking the two diseases is unknown.

The Complement system is part of the immune system which enhances the actions of immune cells and antibodies, enabling better killing and clearance of pathogens. The role of Complement in TB has not been fully investigated. Complement consists of several protein components, which can exert their effect on downstream components in a cascade pathway. The first component which is activated in the classical pathway is C1. Recently, it has been discovered that expression of C1q genes and proteins are upregulated in blood in TB patients, although its exact role is unclear. It may be acting to enhance killing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis bacilli by phagocytes, but it may also be allowing the bacilli to escape killing by down-regulating the killing ability of the phagocytes, as C1q is known to carry out a regulatory role in other diseases. C1q activity has also been implicated in T2DM, in which free circulating concentrations of C1q are elevated.

In this project, we will ask whether C1q acts as a mechanistic link between TB and T2DM, such that elevated free C1q in T2DM patients predisposes them to develop TB disease. Further, we will investigate how C1q might act, by investigating its effects on macrophages, which are the main cell type infected by M. tuberculosis. Together, the studies will reveal whether C1q is an important regulator of TB disease development, as part of a common pathway linking TB disease susceptibility with T2DM pathogenesis.

Additionally, the project will serve as a platform for enhancing scientific links between the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine and Padjadjaran University, and facilitate capacity development particularly in cellular and molecular immunological techniques in the Indonesian laboratory.

Technical Summary

The C1q Complement component has been separately implicated in (TB), where it is upregulated in blood, and in T2DM where the proportion of free C1q is elevated due to a reduction in circulating adiponectin which usually complexes with C1q. This project will investigate C1q as a potential biological mechanism linking TB susceptibility and T2DM.

C1Q gene expression (Cliff et al, JID 2013) and protein expression is elevated in TB patients' blood but its effects on macrophages are unclear. In healthy donors in the UK, we propose to 1) determine the human cellular source of C1q and whether expression is up-regulated by M. tuberculosis, and 2) determine whether C1q regulates macrophage function, including differentiation and polarisation to an alternatively activated M2 phenotype, M. tuberculosis phagocytosis and growth restriction, and cytokine production. We will exploit RNASeq technology to investigate the intracellular impact of exogenous C1q.

T2DM patients reportedly have elevated circulating free C1q, which might interfere with macrophage control of M. tuberculosis. In Bandung we propose to 1) compare C1q, C1q-adiponectin and related factors in plasma from a cohort of TB, T2DM, TB-T2DM patients and HC, to determine whether a synergistic elevation in exists in comorbidity, and 2) investigate C1q involvement in macrophage control of M. tuberculosis in T2DM patients and HC, to determine whether the results obtained in healthy donors are clinically relevant.

There is a strong capacity development component to the project, as a research assistant from Indonesia will spend 6 months receiving training in immunological laboratory skills in London. Assays will be transferred to Universitas Padjadjaran, so that immunology research can be further strengthened there to complement existing strengths in clinical and epidemiological research.

Planned Impact

This research is intended to increase our understanding of why some people are more susceptible to developing active TB disease, whereas most people are able to contain the infection and remain healthy. In particular, people living with type 2 diabetes are three times more likely to develop TB disease once they are infected than the general population. By increasing our understanding of why some people are more likely to develop disease, we are aiming firstly to develop ways to identify those people and intervene by giving them anti-tuberculosis medicines before they become ill, and secondly to develop new host-directed treatments which boost the correct protective immune response, so that those people are able to resist the infection. The research also has far-reaching implications for TB vaccine development, as we do not really understand why the current vaccine, BCG, fails to protect against adult pulmonary TB in most TB-endemic countries, and we may gain insight into the role of a previously under-researched component of the immune system in TB.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Eckold C (2021) Impact of Intermediate Hyperglycemia and Diabetes on Immune Dysfunction in Tuberculosis. in Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America

publication icon
Lachmandas E (2019) Metformin Alters Human Host Responses to Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Healthy Subjects. in The Journal of infectious diseases

 
Description There have been substantial achievements throughout the award, which are explained below, related to the original aims, objectives and deliverables. The work in the UK (London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine) funded by the MRC has largely been successfully completed. Our partners in Indonesia (funded by DIPI) have also achieved a lot, but their work has been seriously affected by Covid-19, so we are working through options to complete the analyses. We are currently preparing a manuscript for publication based on the achievements with healthy donors at LSHTM: figures are available on request.

Aim 1: To determine whether C1q regulates the ability of macrophages to control M. tuberculosis in vitro.
1.1 Characterisation of cells producing and/or upregulating C1q gene and protein expression in response to M. tuberculosis stimulation in healthy donors in UK

We had previously found that mRNAs encoding C1q A, B and C subunits were upregulated in blood in TB patients, but had not known the likely cellular source. Here, we developed flow cytometry methods to detect intracellular C1q expression, and have transferred the assays to our Indonesian colleagues via exchange visits. At LSHTM, using venous blood from healthy donors, we have shown that C1q is primarily expressed in the majority of circulating monocytes in all donors (median 90%, range 70 - 100%), highly variably expressed in neutrophils, (median 49%, range 0-93%) and in myeloid dendritic cells (median 18%, range 3-55%). There was low level expression in plasmacytoid dendritic cells (median 5%, range 0-10%).
Stimulation of monocytes with M. tuberculosis H37Rv in vitro upregulated the amount of C1q expressed, assayed by flow cytometry and quantitative RT-PCR. Monocyte-derived macrophages which had been polarised into M2-macrophages using M-CSF were secreted higher concentrations of C1q than M0 or GM-CSF differentiated M1 macrophages. This could imply that in TB, type-2 polarisation within lung granulomas permissive to M. tuberculosis might be associated with higher C1q concentrations.

1.2 Involvement of C1q in macrophage response to M. tuberculosis: phagocytosis, killing and cytokine production

Exogenous C1q supressed mycobacteria-induced production of IL-6 and IL-10, measured by ELISA and qRT-PCR, implying it down-regulated the M0 to M1 polarisation of macrophages which is usually elicited by mycobacteria. Conversely, inhibition of C1q expression by siRNA greatly increased the expression of TNFa, IL-1b and IL-6, in response to M. tuberculosis. Exogenous C1q and inhibition of C1q via siRNA had no effect on M2 macrophage polarisation. This suppression of M1 macrophage polarisation by C1q might inhibit the macrophage's ability to control M. tuberculosis in vivo, leading to dissemination and worsening of symptoms.
Exogenous C1q also significantly enhanced the survival and growth of M. tuberculosis H37Rv in monocyte-derived macrophages in vitro, whereas C1q siRNA inhibited growth, showing that upregulation of C1q is deleterious not protective in TB.

1.3 Effect of C1q on global transcriptomic response to M. tuberculosis in macrophages

In order to understand how C1q was exerting its deleterious effect on the macrophage's ability to control M. tuberculosis, we performed an unbiased analysis of total gene expression by RNAseq. Monocyte-derived macrophages from 12 healthy donors were incubated +/- C1q and +/- M. tuberculosis. RNA samples were pair-end sequenced using Illumina technology, at a read-depth of >13M / sample. As expected, M. tuberculosis caused large scale differential gene expression, with 4,427 genes significantly up-regulated and 4,786 significantly down-regulated, compared to the growth medium control. The impact of C1q on global gene expression was more moderate, either in the presence or absence of M. tuberculosis, with around 2,000 genes significantly up- or down-regulated in each case. The most striking finding was the down-regulation of genes involved in the macrophage stress response to metal ions and in zinc and copper homeostatis - these included the zinc transporters and various metallothioneins, which were upregulated by M. tuberculosis but repressed by C1q, and still completely repressed by the C1q and M. tuberculosis combination. The inability of macrophages to regulate their zinc control in response to M. tuberculosis infection has drastic effects on their ability to survive and respond, as M. tuberculosis has evolved zinc uptake and efflux systems to modulate the host cell biology.
Moreover, C1q prevented the up-regulation of expression of genes normally induced by M. tuberculosis as part of the protective pathway, including significant inhibition of genes most significantly upregulated by M. tuberculosis: NK-kB, CD44, RNF144B, EHD1 and HS3STB1.
These data have strong implications for the need to control C1q production and control zinc ion metabolism in TB, with indications for the development of host-directed therapies.

Aim 2: to determine whether changes in C1q and C1q-adiponectin are clinically relevant in TB-T2DM.

This work was primarily conducted by our partners at UNPAD university, in Indonesia.

2.1 Plasma concentrations of C1q, adiponectin, C1q-adiponectin complex
2.2 cellular source of C1q in TB and TB-T2DM patients
2.3 Impact of C1q on macrophage control of M. tuberculosis in T2DM and healthy donors

Most of the work involved under this aim was successfully conducted. Patients were recruited and samples, from TB patients +/- diabetes and from healthy controls, were obtained and cryopreserved. All assays were transferred from LSHTM to UNPAD, via exchange visits including Indonesian partners visiting LSHTM, and the LSHTM PI working in UNPAD labs to ensure assays were working optimally. Unfortunately, the Covid-19 epidemic started just as we were about to analyse the clinical samples, and the completion of this Aim is currently still outstanding.
Exploitation Route Manipulation of this host response might be an option for host-directed therapy for TB
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description Blood transcriptomics to develop biomarkers for melioidosis diagnosis and treatment response
Amount £12,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NI170152 
Organisation Newton Fund 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2017 
End 09/2019
 
Description MRC-KHIDI UK-Korea Partnering Awards: Building investigator links for studies on the roles of complement C1q and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress in macrophage polarisation during Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection
Amount £9,931 (GBP)
Organisation Medical Research Council (MRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2019 
End 09/2020
 
Description VALIDATE (VAccine deveLopment for complex INtracellular neglecteD pAThogEs
Amount £39,744 (GBP)
Funding ID #MR/R005850/1 
Organisation Medical Research Council (MRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2018 
End 09/2019
 
Description Indonesian Partners in this Newton Frund Grant 
Organisation Padjadjaran University
Country Indonesia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This project is a collaborative project between ourselves at LSHTM and our partners in Padjadjaran University. At LSHTM, we are conducting intensive investigations into immune responses to Mycobacterium tuberculosis in healthy donors. We have hosted a visitor (research assistant) from Padjadjaran University for 6 months as part of this project. I have visited the labs in Bandung in Autumn 2017 and again for 2 weeks in February 2020. I gave presentations to their Faculty/ Medical School both times. We have regular teleconferences and we communicate regularly by email about techniques and reasearch directions.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners in Padjadjaran University are recruting TB patients with and without diabetes, and are conducting immune response analysis in cells obtained from these patients. A research assistant visited LSHTM for 6 months to learn techniques and to receive training in Biosafety. The Research Assistant, and a previous LSHTM MSc student, have taken the assays which we taught them at LSHTM and set them up very well in their own labs in Bandung.
Impact This project reported here is a new project, with a new PI (Dr Afiat Berbudi) in Padjadjaran University. Previously, I have collaborated with other researchers at Padjadjaran University, as part of the TANDEM consortium (2013 - 2018). Output: doi: 10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70011-7 We are completing our analyses and will report our findings soon.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Prof. Chang-Hwa Song, our partner in the reported MRC-KHIDI-UK-South Korea partnership award 
Organisation Chungnam National University
Country Korea, Republic of 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We are planning to have workshops in Chungname and the UK, to exchange ideas and teach each other lab skills. So far, we have been communicating by teleconference and email. Our planned visit to South Korea has been postponed due to Covid-19.
Collaborator Contribution We have had very fruitful discussions related to our research directions with C1q and tuberculosis, and are building ideas for future larger scale applications.
Impact This collaboration has only just started.
Start Year 2019