Pathogen exchange at the human wildlife interface - a comprehensive molecular study on vector-borne disease in rural Sulawesi.

Lead Research Organisation: University of St Andrews
Department Name: Sch of Medicine

Abstract

The rural poor, the wildlife they encounter and the potential exchange of pathogens between humans and wildlife is not known in much of the world, including Sulawesi, yet emerging infections of zoonotic origin that become epidemic and pandemic are feared. The collaborative molecular study proposed here focuses on emerging mosquito-borne infections with the fundamental goal to discover pathogen exchange where humans and wild Sulawesi macaques share habitat. The UK PI has a strong track record in this field as co-investigator and investigator in ground breaking molecular research that lead to the discovery and characterization of zoonotic malaria in the human population in Malaysian Borneo. Plasmodium knowlesi, a malaria parasite of macaque monkeys, had entered the human population and as a result of that work is now recognised as the 5th type of malaria in humans. The Indonesian PI is a clinically qualified medical entomologist with special interest in mosquito vectors of disease. He has extensive field research experience and is based in Hasanuddin University, Sulawesi. By joining their expertise and that of key co-investigators and collaborators, with particular expertise in patient recruitment in remote rural Borneo (CJD) and wildlife veterinary research (DKS) they plan to investigate, for the first time, pathogen transmission, particularly malaria transmission, within and between the unique Sulawesi macaque species and remote rural populations. Clinical, pathogen, mosquito, and wildlife data will be generated from study sites where rural populations share habitat with the Sulawesi macaques. The expected primary outcomes are: 1) to describe the clinical impact and molecular fingerprint of vector-borne pathogens transmitted within remote rural populations in Sulawesi; 2) to identify mosquito vector species and the pathogen genotypes they transmit between humans at each location; 3) to catalogue mosquito vectors that feed on, and vector-borne pathogens harboured by macaque troops, that overlap with humans at each location; 4)compare pathogen genetic fingerprints generated from mosquito vectors, macaque and human hosts to determine pathogen crossover events between hosts, particularly zoonotic crossover from macaque monkeys to humans and 5) develop location-specific tools and strategies for the Indonesian department of health and local communities to use to pre-empt emerging vector-borne zoonoses.

The information generated by this study will immediately inform measures to reduce vector-borne infections and improve health and wellbeing of the study populations, by definition the remote rural poor. The study protocol could be used as a template for similar study in the region. The approach is internationally competitive molecular research (genetics, genomics and bioinformatics) and the partnership will foster human resource and capacity strengthening in cutting-edge infectious disease research in Indonesia. Our ODA compliant study when viewed through the lens of the sustainable development goals (SDG's) will contribute to Goal 1 - Ending poverty that includes ensuring that the poor and vulnerable have access to basic services - including health. Goal 3 Health - that includes ending neglected tropical diseases and malaria. Goal 8 - decent job creation, in this case through building expertise in the bio-medical research sector in Sulawesi and Goal 17 Partnerships - achieving the SDG's through sustainable equal partnerships.

Technical Summary

Vector-borne pathogen entry into the human population from macaque monkeys is on-going in Southeast Asia, currently the best-known example is zoonotic malaria. The UK PI was co-investigator on ground breaking research in Malaysian Borneo that uncovered the entry of Plasmodium knowlesi, a malaria parasite of Southeast Asian macaques, into the human population. Sulawesi has seven unique macaque species that most probably radiated from Borneo in the middle Pleistocene. The macaques of Borneo have up to five Plasmodium species and it is not known if any of those species traveled with the macaques to Sulawesi. Using field-appropriate sampling, downstream genetics, genomics and bioinformatics the applicants propose to investigate, for the first time, vector-borne pathogen transmission, particularly but not limited to malaria transmission, within and between the unique Sulawesi macaque species and remote rural populations. A comprehensive set of pathogen DNA fingerprints from mosquito vectors, macaque hosts and the human population will be produced to capture vector-borne pathogen transmission at each remote study site in Sulawesi. The expected outcomes are to: 1) describe the clinical impact and molecular fingerprint of vector-borne pathogens transmitted within remote rural populations in Sulawesi; 2) identify mosquito vector species and the pathogen genotypes they transmit between humans at each location; 3) catalogue mosquito vectors that feed on, and vector-borne pathogens harboured by, macaque troops that overlap with humans at each location; 4)compare pathogen genetic fingerprints generated from mosquito vectors, macaque and human hosts to determine pathogen crossover events between hosts, particularly zoonotic crossover from macaque monkeys to humans. The outputs will inform location-specific strategies to pre-empt emerging vector-borne zoonoses.

Planned Impact

The joint research proposed is inspired by UKRI driving innovation and maximizing impact of research investment and also ODA compliance and the Newton fund model.

Fundamentally the genetic sweep approach proposed to determine pathogen exchange at the human wildlife interface includes next generation sequencing platforms, genetics and bioinformatics yet the remote rural poor in Sulawesi will benefit in several ways: The study will draw attention to the needs of remote communities, particularly health needs and also the degree of poverty, through interaction with the study team. More specifically the study will identify vector-borne disease exposure in each community in a way that will identify reservoirs of disease, shared host and mosquito vectors. This information will inform the rational design of strategies to prevent vector borne - disease and immediately offer a means to improve the health and well-being of the rural poor. A general health check will have the potential to identify additional needs and problems that will help local authorities and the communities to begin to develop solutions. At the very least the study will reduce the health impact of vector-borne disease, including malaria, and go some way to improve community empowerment, wellbeing and productivity and in the best possible case to begin to alleviate poverty.

Capacity strengthening and human resource development is an integral part of our research partnership. During a pump-priming exercise in Hasanuddin University the UKPI identified international standard molecular biology as an area in need of strengthening. Through physical space and sustainable human resource development Sulawesi will have the potential to become competitive in international standard bio-medical research collaborations. To this end sustainable training and mentoring in international standard research for early career scientists, from the UK and Indonesia, recruited onto the project will be offered. Particularly developing expertise field studies and molecular biology. With this expertise in place in Sulawesi there is the potential for economic development through increased investment in the bio-medical research sector opening career opportunities for biomedical scientists.

Sulawesi is a megadiverse island of interest to biologists, ecologists, primatologists, entomologists to name but a few. Strong research ties between the UK and Sulawesi will facilitate a wide range of equally partnered research activities with facilities for international standard equally partnered collaborative research. Equally partnered international research should not be underestimated in improving the quality and quantity of outputs. Relevant UK science communities would have opportunities to address research questions with Indonesian partners in uniquely biodiverse setting.

Therefore our proposed study will impact the remote rural poor in Sulawesi, the biomedical research sector in Indonesia, career scientists in Indonesia and the UK and local and international users of our research outputs.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have a data bank for the study population and area.

Preliminary research data show that the macaque monkeys in our study have malaria parasites.

We have developed a method to generate long read genome and RNA sequence data from macaque faecal samples - we are in the process of sequencing samples and the important data sets generated a will be made public when analyses complete
Exploitation Route We plan to take the methodologies forward and package for transfer to local centres for monitoring emerging infections - particularly fevers on unknown origin among the rural poor.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Title Methods to sequence macaque faecal samples 
Description A method was developed sequence complex macaque faecal samples for metagenomics 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The method facilitates RNA (ds cDNA) and DNA sequencing macaque faecal field samples - from sample collection, preservative, nucleic acid extraction and sequencing. A metagenomics pipeline is currently being developed to analyse the data outputs the detect signatures of low copy number pathogen genomes. 
 
Title Third generation sequencing wild Macaque blood sampling 
Description Method to collect Macaque blood samples in remote rural field sites for down stream third generation sequencing. The methods used produced high quality DNA following storage at ambient temperature in the field and transportation to the research laboratory before aliquoting and BioBanking at -20oC and -80oC. These methods will be published with metagenomics outputs - manuscript in preparation. 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact All of the bioinformatics tools, currently underdevelopment, will be published and available on GitHub. 
 
Title Metagenomics analysis for Monkey Blood and Monkey faeces genome sequencing 
Description The link is to the analysis pipeline for third generation sequencing outputs for wild Macaque blood and faecal sample collected during the study - and is ongoing and available 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The sample collection, processing and analysis will be available to other researchers characterising and documenting potential emerging infections in any given environment (healthcare, veterinary, local environment. 
URL https://github.com/peterthorpe5/JCS_metagenomics_blood_and_poo
 
Description Emerging malaria - Hassanuddin University, Macassar, Sulaweisi UNHAS 
Organisation Hasanuddin University
Country Indonesia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Collaborate on studies at the macaque human interface. Develop methodologies - Dr Isra Wahid, UNHAS is the Indonesian Partner PI on the Pathogen exchange study Our partnership began 2016 with funding 2018 and the Pathogen exchange study reported here MRC Newton Partnership grant with Hasanussin University, (Dr Isra Wahid Indonesian PI)
Collaborator Contribution Entomology, veterinary and local knowledge
Impact Hasanuddin University was the Indonesian partner for the pathogen exchange study
Start Year 2019
 
Description Strong, productive working collaboration with Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Sulawesi. 
Organisation Hasanuddin University
Country Indonesia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have prepared draft documents and protocols for the study and co-ordinated collaborative agreement, an MTA, and ethical approvals for animal work and human participation to the study from the University of St Andrews and Hasanuddin University. We have organised two meetings in Makassar (March 2019 and November 2019) to present the study and to formalise the UK-Indonesian investigator and study team. In addition we held meetings with the Indonesian Wildlife Department (BKSDA) representatives in Makassar (March 2019) to form a good working relationship the BKSDA and to obtain advice and support on how apply for the required permit to work with the Sulawesi macaques. In November we held a meeting to select three study communities (remote villagers who live close to and use the forrest habitat of local monkey troops) from several options. Represents from the relevant local wildlife ranger department and healthcare providers were invited to the meeting. They are part of the field teams and will support fieldwork and provide local knowledge to facilitate the study, particularly advising on local perceptions and effective engagement with human participants and to advise on local macaque behaviours to inform selection trapping sites. As part of capacity strengthening we advised on the layout and specifications of the new molecular lab facility for the project in the Medical Entomology Department, School of Medicine, Hasanuddin University (UNHAS), Makassar - our partner University. The facility will be sustained beyond the life of the project and act as a springboard to establish a new molecular reference facility for Eastern Indonesia. To this end we have conducted the first in a series of seminars and practical training in molecular biology, sample handling and use of molecular research techniques (January 2020). All of the sample processing and molecular screening for this study will be in UNHAS, including nucleic acid preparation for out- sourcing ultra deep sequencing. We will, through continuous training, ensure that the lab runs to Good Laboratory Practice. Staff development is essential to the success of our study and also to the sustained life of the new facility - training future trainers. The study postdoc will be based in UNHAS to co-ordinate and oversea all fieldwork and be responsible for sample collection, processing and training - ensuring that protocols are followed with precision.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners/collaborators have contributed expertise (clinical, medical entomology and veterinary), physical facilities and essential insight in the design and execution of this study, particularly remote field work. They have travelled to potential study sites and directed the selection of communities that live in what conforms to our model study location (living close to the forest fringe, use of forest resources). They have worked tirelessly in forming relationships with the local healthcare providers and wildlife rangers, obtaining ethical and other documents, essential to the study, in a timely manner. The senior members have supported and engaged in our training sessions and in identifying young career researchers (lab-based, clinical and veterinary) to work on the study and be trained to GLP and good clinical practice (GCP). Our partnership is productive and strong.
Impact We will complete the first year of the three year study and are well placed to begin field work on schedule in April 2020.
Start Year 2019
 
Description University Malaysia Sarawak (UNIMAS) 
Organisation University Malaysia Sarawak (UNIMAS)
Country Malaysia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This collaboration was the direct result of the Pathogen exchange study. Du Muh Fauzi (UNDIP)was a post doc on the study and now lecturer in UNDIP. The PI and co-I Dr Cyrus Daneshvar are mentoring Dr Muh Fauzi in setting-up his independent research team with the view to using the protocols and bioinformatics methods developed in the Pathogen exchange study in EID research in Java. Dr Paul Divis (UNIMAS) joined the partnership during a capacity strengthening workshop March 2023
Collaborator Contribution Out longstanding partners Dr Isra Wahid and Dr Irfan Idris, Hasanuddin University (UNHAS) have opened the opportunity for collaborative research and are sharing laboratory facilities with Dr Muh Fauzi. As part of capacity strengthening during the pathogen study a new research facility to undertake molecular genetics and genomics research was established in the Faculty of Medicine UNHAS and the purpose was to facilitate collaborative research. Dr Paul Divis UNIMAS is an established researcher and has offered bilateral training opportunities and collaborative research on EID's in the region (Malaysian and Indonesian Borneo, Sulawesi and Java). MOU's are in process
Impact The collaboration is multidisciplinary - Infections diseases, epidemiology, molecular genetics and genomics and Bioinformatics.
Start Year 2022
 
Description ASA 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact ASA2021 Plenary Anthropology and Epidemics
Invitation to be a plenary speaker:

Short description: This plenary will foster interdisciplinary dialogue between anthropologists and life scientists whose work focuses on epidemics and infectious diseases.
Plenary Abstract: COVID-19 has generated interest in epidemics and infectious diseases across different fields of anthropology. This plenary draws together anthropologists and life scientists with long-term commitments to the study of epidemics so as to discuss how responding and preparing for such phenomena require reconceptualisations of health, illness, and infection, and the ways in which they challenge and trouble existing, Global Health and One Health frameworks of responsibility.

My feed back to organiser: I just wanted to say thank you so much for the opportunity to interact with social anthropologists and historians in the broadest sense.

My eyes have been opened and I feel enriched by the experience - so many thoughts, points for discussion and new connections.

Frédéric Keck and David Napier have been in touch and my world has expanded for the better!
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://theasa.org/conferences/asa2021/
 
Description International Conference Urban Health -Organised by MOH Indonesia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was invited to give a keynote lecture:
Topics - Emerging infectious disease
Zoonotic disease transfer from natural hosts to humans
Crowd diseases
Risk factors - crowds not enough
What we have learned so far:Human vulnerabilityTransmission and spreadVariability and adaptability - host and pathogen
Living with Coronavirus (SARS CoV-2) - COVID 19
Empowering communities to recognise, contain and ultimately prevent emerging infectious diseases?
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description On-line symposium interdisciplinary - From Zoonotics to Anthroponotics 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invitation - and subject area of my participation in the debate:
I am writing to invite you to participate to an online symposium titled From Zoonotics to Anthroponotics: The Past and Present of Disease Transmission between Animals and Humans) which my Wellcome project (The Global War Against the Rat and the Epistemic Emergence of Zoonosis) is co-organising with Monica Green on December 14, 14:00-19:00 GMT.

The symposium is centered around the recent findings of the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 within white deer populations in the United States. The ability of the new coronavirus to transmit within captive animal populations (mink and zoo animals) was already documented in 2020. Transmission into wild animal populations, however, raises issues of broader consequence, both for present disease management and surveillance and also long-term control of the disease. After an initial presentation by Prof. Kuchipudi (author of the deer SARS-CoV-2 paper), panelists will present short response-papers on disease spread from humans into wild animal populations, as well as the spread and establishment of animal reservoirs of infectious disease from their own disciplinary perspective and research experience.

We are hoping that you may be interested in contributing to this debate from the perspective of your research on zoonotic malaria in Sulawesi.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://wwrat.wp.st-andrews.ac.uk/events-2/
 
Description Webinar - emerging zoonoses 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Speaker1: Janet Cox Singh, PhD. St. Andrews University, UK. Mechanism of pathogen jumping from wild live to human in emerging diseases, with focus on SARS CoV2.
Speaker2: Cyrus Daneshvar, MD., PhD. Plymouth Hospital, UK. Clinical aspects of Covid-19: Pathomechanism, @ssue injuries, immune responses, asymptoma@c and relapsing cases.
The webinar is planned as a panel discussion where all speaker will deliver their presenta@on for max 30 minutes and we will have discussion @me about 60 minute at the end of the webinar.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021