Safeguarding adolescent mental health in India: a co-designed feasibility study of a systems intervention targeting youth anxiety and depression.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: School of Psychology

Abstract

Good mental health is essential to one's enjoyment of life, ability to have relationships and capacity for work. Mental health conditions like anxiety and depression are common, and evidence shows that these often start during the teenage years and continue into adulthood. India has the largest number of adolescents in the world (243 million) and many experience poor mental health. It is estimated that 9.8 million Indian 13-17 year olds have a diagnosable mental health condition, often anxiety and depression. There is widespread concern in India about the mental health of young people as suicide is the leading cause of death among adolescents. Young people in India who attend school are at even greater risk of poor mental health as Indian school culture places extreme pressure on young people and there widespread use of corporal punishment. Young people report that these have serious effects on their mental health. There is also little understanding of mental health in families or school communities and there is no school mental health programme in India, even though evidence shows that these can protect and improve mental health. There is an urgent need to find solutions to improve the mental health culture of Indian schools in order to safeguard the mental health of Indian young people.

Our project, called SAMA (meaning equal in Sanskrit) aims to develop and test school-based interventions to provide Indian adolescents with information and strategies to take care of their mental health and to improve school cultures to support well-being. We know that interventions are most effective when they are designed by the people who will be involved or affected by them. Therefore, in Year 1 of SAMA, we will co-design interventions with young people, parents, teachers, school leaders, mental health professional, policy makers and representatives from Indian health and education departments. We will build on international evidence and interventions where available. We plan to have four interventions that (1) help young people understand and manage their own mental health, especially anxiety and depression; (2) help teachers reduce their use of corporal punishment and improve their understanding of adolescent mental health; (3) improve the school climate for mental health and reduce mental health stigma; and (4) improve parents' understanding of adolescent mental health to support their young person. We will develop plans to implement and evaluate these interventions, with close attention to training people who deliver them and how to prepare an intervention's 'soft landing' in school to increase chances of success. In Year 2, we will recruit eight secondary schools in Bangalore. We will test how feasible and acceptable the interventions are when delivered together in these schools and identify the cost implications. In Year 3, we will work with the communities to learn about what we need to do to improve interventions so that we can build towards a trial to determine if the interventions are effective. SAMA will also learn how to increase the use of evidence on school mental health programmes in Indian health policy.

Throughout SAMA, listening to young people will be central. As well as being involved in the design and evaluation of interventions, other young people will be on our Youth Advisory Panel and still others will be involved in community filmmaking. Films will give outsiders an insider view into adolescent mental health and school in India. They will be used, along social media and community events, to raise awareness and campaign for better mental health care within Indian schools. Our UK-India partnership includes the National Institute of Mental Health and Neuroscience (Bangalore), Sangath (NGO in Goa), Mahatma Gandhi Institute (Puducherry) and the Universities of Leeds, Bradford, Birmingham and Oxford. SAMA will strengthen research capacity for school mental health research in low-and-middle income countries.

Technical Summary

Anxiety and depression in Indian adolescents are common and youth suicides outnumber AIDS-related and maternal deaths combined. Indian secondary schools, which is often harsh and punitive, can present serious risk factors to adolescent mental health. In principle, schools can be mental health promoting for all young people, and for symptomatic young people, early intervention in the form of low-intensity psychoeducation or self-help can prevent escalation of symptoms to levels of clinical disorder. However, India is without a universal school-based mental health approach. Our 36 month project will co-design and feasibility / acceptability test four interventions to run in parallel in 8 schools (3 to waitlist) with the primary aim of reducing the prevalence of adolescent anxiety and depression. Co-design/co-adaptation will build on evidence and resources where available and LMIC relevant, and span content, implementation and evaluation protocols. Interventions will be target evidence-based individual and contextual risk and protective factors for adolescent mental health. Intervention for young people will be a universal (as recommended by previous reviewers), transdiagnostic, psychologically informed mental health curriculum approach. Interventions for parents and teachers will be MHL, and for teachers also training in positive behaviour practices. School climate will be targeted to reduce stigmatising attitudes and improve community MHL. We will target the wider community and sector with MHL campaigning. Based on rules for progression to trial (centering on trial recruitment, protocol adherence and outcome data), we will determine intervention feasibility and acceptability, and (via process measures) what is needed to optimise the intervention. We will generate cost-estimates, identify pathways to increase policy action on the evidence, promote the visibility of young people, and strengthen mental health research capacity in India and the UK.

Planned Impact

Young people in India are the key beneficiaries of this project. Those who participate in our co-design and film-making components will benefit from mental health information, promoting youth voice, new experiences and skills, and community action. Young people in our study schools will benefit from our delivery of multiple interventions there. From intervention 1 (WP1), a curriculum based mental health program, we anticipate improvements in young people's mental health and quality of life. Longer-term impacts could include prevention of new cases of anxiety and depression disorder. However, it is not enough to improve young people's mental health understanding and coping strategies without also addressing the mental health risks in the wider contexts in which young people are living their lives. Therefore, intervention 2 (WP2), a teacher training intervention, is expected to improve teacher mental health literacy and reduce the extent of corporal punishment in Indian schools. This is likely to be a significant improvement to school experience, mental health and safety for young people. Improved school climate and reduced mental health stigma is an aim of intervention 3 (WP3). This will benefit Indian young people via greater agency and involvement in school community change and by anticipated improvements in the care climate of school towards mental health needs, including reduced stigma. Intervention 4 (WP4) aims to improve the mental health literacy of Indian parents in order to improve their awareness and support of their young person's mental health. If intervention feasibility and acceptability is established and progression to an effectiveness trial is supported, these anticipated benefits will be accessible to more young people in India, in other low- and middle-income countries, and in high income countries. There is also potential for Indian young people to benefit from improved policy attention to young people and school mental health which SAMA will seek via WP6.

Indian teachers and schools are likely to benefit from co-design participation enabling them to shape interventions to meet their needs, preference and contexts. This is important given embedded cultural practices around Indian schooling. They can also benefit from participating in interventions 2 and 3. WP2 and 3 will help teachers and schools understand adolescent mental health better, enable them to use positive discipline practices over harsh ones, and to use evidence-based strategies to improve school climate to support adolescent well-being. Indian parents are also likely to benefit from co-design (e.g. meeting other parents, improved understanding of mental health influencing action) and from WP4 intervention to enhance their ability to support adolescent mental health at home.

Policy makers and health and education sector stakeholders (both in our target state of Karnataka and beyond) can benefit from new evidence on ways to tackle the burden of poor mental health in India and from greater insight into community needs and preferences for young people, schools and families for intervention.

Indian and global researchers and mental health professionals can also benefit from the data that SAMA will generate including, for example, new evidence on adolescent mental health, teacher / parent mental health literacy, and public (school) mental health interventions, newly validated mental health measures and developed theory, as well as training for capacity building in implementation research and filmmaking for community participatory projects. Projects in the UK and other LMICs that are designing and testing school based mental health will be able to learn from our study findings.
 
Title Ayran versus the bullies 
Description A short animations that explored the ways in which SAMA is supporting young people in their school to address particular challenges they might face. Aryan versus the Bullies tells the story of a fictional school student, Aryan, as he tries to find a way to escape the unwanted attention of 3 aggressive boys in his class. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The films were premiered at an impact event, organised by NIMHANS, that brought together youth counsellors, child right activists, those involved in mental health promotion activities in schools and NGO personnels working with schools and children. The noticeable impact from developing the adolescent animation was the increased awareness of Project SAMA and the greater appreciation from viewers for the importance young people's perspective (and lived experience). Currently has 30 views on vimeo. 
URL https://vimeo.com/789262063
 
Title SAMA and US 
Description A documentary style film, where adolescents introduced the audience to their experience of SAMA, what the programme physically 'looks like' in their school, showcasing the views of students who had taken part in the programme, as well as one of the teachers in the school, a SAMA lay counsellor (Snehitharu) and the Head Mistress. In so doing, the film sought to capture the 'whole school's understanding of the programme, in line with the SAMA's own 'whole school' approach to mental health and wellbeing. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The films were premiered at an impact event, in India that brought together youth counsellors, child right activists, those involved in mental health promotion activities in schools and NGO personnels working with schools and children. The noticeable impact from developing the adolescent documentary was the increased awareness of Project SAMA and the greater appreciation from viewers for the importance young people's perspective (and lived experience). In addition it has 39 views on vimeo. 
URL https://vimeo.com/789431327
 
Title Viona is back on Track 
Description Viona is Back on Track highlights the pressures adolescents can feel to achieve academically while also having to deal with other pressures at home or amongst their friends. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The films were premiered at an impact event, organised by NIMHANS, that brought together youth counsellors, child right activists, those involved in mental health promotion activities in schools and NGO personnels working with schools and children. The noticeable impact from developing the adolescent animation was the increased awareness of Project SAMA and the greater appreciation from viewers for the importance young people's perspective (and lived experience). Currently has 41 views on vimeo. 
URL https://vimeo.com/789228355
 
Description Impact Event_2023
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description University of Leeds Doctoral Scholarship
Amount £210,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Leeds 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2021 
End 12/2023
 
Description Alberta Health Service: Mental Health Literacy Training 
Organisation Alberta Health Services
Country Canada 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We shared culturally specific conditions that informed increased awareness of cross-cultural applications of their work.
Collaborator Contribution They provided training and guidance in mental health literacy to inform our interventions.
Impact UK and Indian project research team members trained in mental health literacy (Canadian version).
Start Year 2021
 
Description Co-production workshops with Indian young people, teachers, parents and professionals 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Multiple, separate workshops were conducted with each stakeholder group (adolescents, parents, teachers, headteachers, and professionals) to co-produce the study. Workshops explored preferences and needs for intervention content, implementation, recruitment, ethics, safeguarding and evaluation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Conference Symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presented SAMA interventions at the conference "Social Work in Education" held at Tumkur, Karnataka, South India. As social workers have scope in schools in India, the symposium aimed at giving an insight to the social work students about ways to plan and conduct school mental health programmes. The symposium generated discussions about the activities that can be conducted in school for promotion of adolescent emotional well-being.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Conference Symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A symposium was conducted by the SAMA team at the International Conference "Child and Adolescent Mental Health: Shaping the Future" held at Dubai on 4th to 9th December, 2022. The symposium titled 'Co-Producing a whole school-based interventions for prevention of adolescent anxiety and depression' presented the findings from the coproduction workshops. The audience was oriented about the project, the challenges experienced and tactics to manage the challenges.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.iacapap2022.com/
 
Description Impact event: Implementation Science in School Mental Health Research 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Activity:
An online seminar to discuss why do so many school programs and initiatives start but go nowhere. This seminar targeted researchers and commissioners involved in the implementation of school programs, who might find that implementation science could help them to understand the key barriers to implementation within the school setting and then help to guide the development of appropriate implementation strategies.

Purpose:
- To explain why implementation can be so difficult especially in the context of school programs, and how we can make the best implementation strategies to help us obtain expected results.
- To explore what needs to happen once implementation starts, including the importance of ongoing adaptation, and human relationships.
- To explain how Project SAMA will be building and using an implementation framework to boost the landing of the interventions in their schools in Karnataka.

Outcomes:
- improve understanding of implementation science (for school programs)
- enhanced understanding of the importance of addressing implementation issues from the outset of program development

Impacts:
- sign ups to the SAMA newsletter
- sign ups to the SAMA professionals network
- increased interest to collaborate with Project SAMA
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.sama.org.uk/events/jciyhmelnpeejb54njfd2wrar9k2af
 
Description Professional Network Event - The role of the school environment on young people's mental health: Insights from research and practice 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact 21 attendees came together to delve into the findings of a systematic review conducted to identify evidence-based programmes to specifically improve the school climate. Following this, Prachi Khandeparkar (Adolescent Health Project Lead and Psychologist at Sangath, India) discussed how school climate is linked with the health and achievements of students. Finally, the network discussed 'empowering schools'. This event sparked discussions of:
- Why there is such a focus on anti-stigma interventions for school environment.
-The development of the concept 'school connectedness' and how young people are no longer considered to have a passive role in this and are instead viewed as important people in the community.
-Implementation tips (specifically focusing on incorporating the hierarchies of a school structure)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6101192c2cfe4d4a70fd4219/t/62f4d0ba30a7732b35a48aa3/166021138...
 
Description Professional Network Event - What do young people want us to understand about their mental health and school? Young people take the platform 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 32 event attendees with adolescents (2 youth advisory board members of Project SAMA), where they shared their perspectives and lived experiences regarding youth mental health and the role of their school environment. The following questions were addressed:
•What do young people think and feel about 'mental health'?
•What are the biggest challenges to youth mental health right now?
•What role does school play in youth mental health?
•What must adults absolutely understand about youth mental health?
•How can schools be better for young people's mental health?
•What is a key priority for your mental health right now?
Overall this event showed adolscents as experts by lived experience and permitted them to play a vital role in contextual knowledge development, idea generation and content development which could benefit future research. Discussion explored: the value of having youth voice at the centre of research decisions, gender equality, the toxic culture of classroom favoritism and how it can affect the well-being of adolescents, how down time and fun are missing from the school schedule, and finally the impact of bullying in schools. Following the event 75% of attendees agreed that young people's participation in mental health research is important for the progression of research. All rated themselves as more aware of the impacts that the school environment can have on adolescent mental health.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6101192c2cfe4d4a70fd4219/t/62b17bdb1742ae38692d4aa7/165579874...
 
Description Project Launch Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This event was held for the stakeholders of adolescent mental health in India (Karnatka State), including Block Education Officers, heads of schools, teachers, tesearchers, mental health professionals, personnel from the NGOs working in the area of school and adolescent mental health. The participants were briefed about the Project and Scientific sessions were conducted on child and adolescent mental health; engaging with policy makers; and school mental health programmes. The project team's aim of networking and the way forward was also explained.

The event created awareness about the project, discussions related to child and adolescent mental health, future project activities and the need for collaboration. Particiapnts could sign up for the project newsletter and to be a part of the professionals network.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.sama.org.uk/events/project-sama-launch-event
 
Description SAMA Project Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Creation of the SAMA website to be a public interface to:
- Find out about Project SAMA
- Understand the timeline of Project SAMA
- Understand the SAMA work packages and how they interconnect and the theory they are based on
- Provide Project information and answer FAQ for SAMA participants (pupils, headteachers, teachers, parents, schools)
- Have a platform for our youth lead voice (Youth Advisory Board)
- Host the networks created by project SAMA (SAMA School Well-being network and SAMA network for professionals)
- Advertise SAMA events
- Host the SAMA blog
- Provide news relating to Project SAMA
- Publish guides, manuals and tools created by the Project team (Training young people in film-making, A Facilitators Guide)
- Provide a list of help resources
- Provide a means for the general public to contact the SAMA research team

Impact:
- Over 2.3K website visits
- Sign ups to collaborate with SAMA = 60
- Professional network subscriptions = 60
- SAMA newsletter subscriptions = 65
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.sama.org.uk/
 
Description Science Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A Science Day was organized at NIMHANS, India, where the departments conducted awareness activities for event attendees. The SAMA team conducted activities to generate awareness about adolescent emotional well-being (normalizing help-seeking and discussions around mental health; coping mechanisms; use of resources to manage stress and the emotional spiral)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://nimhans.ac.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/National-Science-Day-2023_Poster_Fin.pdf
 
Description UK Team visit to India - School Visits 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact The UK SAMA research team visited India. During there stay they visited multiple schools to meet with teachers (10), students and lay counsellors to hear their perspectives on how SAMA is going. These discussions also allowed the research team to understand ways to improve SAMA interventions to become more feasible, acceptable and better implemented within the school system. The team also conducted engagement meetings with headteachers to promote study retention and future upscaling
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Youth Advisory Board 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This will be a recurring activity. The Youth Advisory Board is made up of young Indian people who represent the intended end users of the research. The Board will function to ensure youth perspectives of mental health are central, and the study are youth-centered.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021