Understanding Normative Change to Address the Climate Change Emergency

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Politics and International Studies

Abstract

In 2019 the Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz declared that "The climate crisis is our third world war". Many scientists and politicians agree that the efforts required to prevent catastrophic climate change are indeed comparable with or will exceed the efforts mobilised during the Second World War. An increasing number of countries, cities, organizations are declaring climate emergency and committing to achieve net zero greenhouse emissions by 2050 or even 2030. But it is unclear how this commitment can be reached and how the population can be rallied behind the necessary but currently unpopular policies that must be implemented.
This challenge is also a puzzle in social science research. The required extent and pace of necessary social change in response to climate emergency is unprecedented and so existing theories of change are inadequate in specifying pathways of social transformation. This fellowship will generate insights into how we can affect and accelerate social change (i.e. structural and behavioural change) to contribute to preventing the catastrophes that climate science tells us lie ahead. This will close the social science research gap on rapid social learning and help to answer political questions about how robust climate change policies can gather broad popular support.
The focus of the study will lie on social change driven by normative change. Differently from values, which define what people consider important to them, social norms define behaviours and attitudes that are considered acceptable in a society. As such norms have a more direct impact on behaviours and institutions. Previous research indicates that normative change (changes to social norms) can lead to social change on a large scale. I will investigate to what extent recent global climate protests such as Fridays For Futures and Extinction Rebellion, have set in motion normative change that is contesting existing norms regarded as inadequate in response to climate emergency. I will study what new norms are emerging, and whether they are likely to be broadly adopted by society, and the likely consequences for politics. I will also analyse resistance to normative change, apparent for instance in populist attacks on climate change activists such as Greta Thunberg. Do "norm antipreneurs" inhibit changes in social norms among the wider population? I will use various data sources (including social media data from climate change protest movements and their opponents, survey data, elections data, parliamentary data and qualitative interviews) along with a wide range of analysis approaches (computational, quantitative, qualitative) to understand the processes and dynamics of normative change and its likely outcome and effect.
To better understand how normative change can drive rapid changes in behaviour and institutions, I will study individual and community-level environmental behaviour, electoral behaviour and political officials' conduct and discourse. I will conduct a smartphone-based field-experimental study to reveal how effective normative interventions are in changing environmental behaviour. A survey experiment will be conducted to understand how fallible psychological defence mechanisms in response to climate change threat can be turned into empowering and adequate responses to the climate crisis rather than increasing support for populist policies. And to understand institutional change, open data (parliamentary data on debates, divisions etc., COP24, 25, 26 reports, etc.) will be analysed along with interviews with key political officials. Finally, all insights will be integrated to understand how normative and social change can be accelerated.
In the second stage of the fellowship (years 5-7) I will turn my attention to specific communities affected by climate change and how artificial intelligence (AI) technology can be used to empower these communities.
 
Description One year and four months into the project we were able to gain important insights and meet some of the award objectives already.
The main objective of this fellowship is to transform our understanding of normative and social change, and how it can be accelerated in response to the climate emergency. The main objective can be broken down in a set of specific objectives, of which the first was to understand unfolding normative change (change in what behaviours are perceived as desirable/morally right/socially acceptable), with a focus on civil society actors as norm entrepreneurs and assess to what extent the new norms are taking root within wider society and political institutions. The first objective has been almost entirely met. Having analysed vast amount of data we can show how climate protest movements, and in particularly the youth climate movement (Fridays for Future) have indeed triggered normative change, by seeding new norms or re-interpreting existing norms in the light of the climate crisis, challenging other existing norms and narratives, by getting norm champions en board, who are crucial for reinforcing new normative frames and spreading them beyond the networks of activists and sympathisers. We were able to show empirically that the new normative frames advanced by the Fridays or Future movements have penetrated the climate change debate and social networks around the annual UNFCCC COPs with a lasting effect. Moreover, having interviewed MPs, House of Lord members and civil servants we can also see the influence these normative frames are having on the national policy makers. Currently we are trying to better understand the competing dynamics of the new normative frames and opposing frames around climate action delay. We are also preparing to conduct further interviews with those involved at the UNFCCC COP negotiations, to understand to what extent climate movements are not only influencing the public discourse around the UNFCCC COPs, but also the negotiations (affiliated PhD project).
The second specific objective on the project was to identify what is blocking normative and social change .This objective has been partially met. An analysis of a pilot survey experiment revealed that exposure to climate change threat can mobilise people to embrace climate action by making them angry about the lack of response to the climate crisis but on the other hand it can make those, who hold rather authoritarian values, to become even more reactionary, which then means they are less likely to support climate action (blocking normative and social change), something that can be exploited by populist politicians.
We also made some progress with respect to the third objective to determine how normative and social change can be strengthened, amplified and accelerated through various interventions and specifically on the sub-objective (a) to understand to what extent normative change can drive behavioural change and how it interacts with other factors that facilitate or prohibit behavioural change. We conducted a pilot to test with normative/moral arguments for climate actions people find most convincing and how this interacts with their political affiliations, with the values they hold and with other socio-demographic factors. This pilot was done in preparation of the field-experiment study to be conducted in the third year.
These results are summarised in the four papers referenced, one of which is published, while the other three are currently in review, but available as pre-prints.
Exploitation Route Our research on the influence of climate protest movements can be used by the activists and other civil society actors to better understand what has resonated with the general public and policy makers (including at the international level), what strategies have worked and which norm champions they still need to recruit to spread their influence further. For that purpose we are meeting activists for instance in the context of the Scientists for Future UK group. We are also communicating our research through podcasts, blogs and public talks. Engagement with activists will be further expanded in the fourth year of the fellowship through dedicated workshops.
Our research on the political psychological effects of exposure to climate change threat has been of interest to the Climate Change Committee UK and is important for policy makers to be aware of to frame their communication accordingly. However, this pilot will be followed up by a more in-depth investigations in the third year and once we have these results we will communicate these outcomes more widely through various channels and engagement activities.
Sectors Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice

URL https://cdp.leeds.ac.uk/research/normative-change-climate-emergency/
 
Description There is an increasing recognition that in order to meet UK's net-zero goal social and behaviour change needs to be taken into account and given the focus of my research there is an in increasing interest in the results of the research as they start to come in. I have communicated these results and provided consultancy in various forms through written evidence submitted to enquiries (e.g. by the House of Lord's Environment and Climate Change Committee, or Chris Skidmore's Net Zero Review), through online meetings with civil servants preparing certain campaigns, through engagement with city councils, through engagement with civil society groups, through engagement with the UK' Climate Change Committee or through a review of the University of Leed's Climate Plan. It is too early to say what specific impact these interactions and exchanges had, but it's clear that my research has the potential to impact policy making and civil society's activities and as the research progresses so will it's impact.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Citation in House of Lords, Environment and Climate Change Committee Report
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Citation in other policy documents
URL https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/30146/documents/174873/default/
 
Description Consultation on national climate change communication campaign (Department of Transport, Ireland)
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health
Impact Since the communication campaign is still in preparation stage, it is difficult to assess the specific benefits that resulted from the impact activity at this stage. Robert did suggest that the consultation was very helpful for him in going forward with the campaign. Further impact activities are likely to follow and will be updated within this entry.
 
Description Post-Doctoral Enrichment Award
Amount £2,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 2022PEA 
Organisation Alan Turing Institute 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2022 
End 01/2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation ETH Zurich
Country Switzerland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research
Country Germany 
Sector Learned Society 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation University of Exeter
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation University of Graz
Country Austria 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation University of Groningen
Department Faculty of Behavioural and Social Sciences
Country Netherlands 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration on HORIZON grant application 
Organisation University of Oslo
Country Norway 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am leading on work package WP6 of the bid (HORIZON bid (HORIZON-CL5-2023-D1-01-09: Behavioural change and governance for systematic transformations towards climate resilience) and contribute to other work packages.
Collaborator Contribution The application is coordinated by the Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change, University of Graz, with Ilona Otto being the PI , other involved researchers and civil society partners contribute to various degrees to various work packages.
Impact A grant application will be submitted in April 2023. If successful, this collaboration will result in various academic publications and impact activities across Europe.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Low-carbon infrastructure transition in the North of England 
Organisation Bradford Metropolitan District Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Within this project I and my team conducted research, organised multi-stakeholder workshops and wrote a report. The research was meant to be a pilot for research on regional decarbonisation efforts, co-designed and co-conducted with local stakeholders
Collaborator Contribution Energy Leeds (a University of Leeds research centre) coordinated the research and stakeholder activities and contributed financial means for research and engagement activities. Leeds City Council, Bradford City Council and Bradford City Council assisted with organising stakeholder activities and provided feedback throughout the project.
Impact We produced a report on the basis of the research and engagement activities, see URL above. This collaboration was multi-disciplinary, involving civil engineering, economics and political science
Start Year 2021
 
Description Low-carbon infrastructure transition in the North of England 
Organisation Hull City Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Within this project I and my team conducted research, organised multi-stakeholder workshops and wrote a report. The research was meant to be a pilot for research on regional decarbonisation efforts, co-designed and co-conducted with local stakeholders
Collaborator Contribution Energy Leeds (a University of Leeds research centre) coordinated the research and stakeholder activities and contributed financial means for research and engagement activities. Leeds City Council, Bradford City Council and Bradford City Council assisted with organising stakeholder activities and provided feedback throughout the project.
Impact We produced a report on the basis of the research and engagement activities, see URL above. This collaboration was multi-disciplinary, involving civil engineering, economics and political science
Start Year 2021
 
Description Low-carbon infrastructure transition in the North of England 
Organisation Leeds City Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Within this project I and my team conducted research, organised multi-stakeholder workshops and wrote a report. The research was meant to be a pilot for research on regional decarbonisation efforts, co-designed and co-conducted with local stakeholders
Collaborator Contribution Energy Leeds (a University of Leeds research centre) coordinated the research and stakeholder activities and contributed financial means for research and engagement activities. Leeds City Council, Bradford City Council and Bradford City Council assisted with organising stakeholder activities and provided feedback throughout the project.
Impact We produced a report on the basis of the research and engagement activities, see URL above. This collaboration was multi-disciplinary, involving civil engineering, economics and political science
Start Year 2021
 
Description "The eyes of all future generations are upon you" - how to galvanise climate action (blog) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The blog was published by Policy Leeds as part of a blog series around COP26 in Glasgow in 2021.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://medium.com/policy-leeds/the-eyes-of-all-future-generations-are-upon-you-how-to-galvanise-cli...
 
Description Ask A Climate Researcher Short Video Series by the Priestley International Centre for Climate 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact 'Ask A Climate Researcher' is a video series produced by the Priestley International Centre for Climate, where some climate researchers based at the Priestley International Centre for Climate answer climate change FAQs. Many of these have been asked at our 'Ask A Climate Researcher' stand at events or send via email by the general public.
We contributed to the four videos: What is COP?, What is the best way to stop climate change? What action is the government taking, and is it quick enough? and Do climate strikes really make a difference?
I and my postdoc Dr Nicole Nisbett have also been at the Ask A Climate Researcher stands at events, such as school strikes in Leeds, or campus climate change events around COP27.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLzAZe1VE-JW4BwgQ1dgxpHv5zlktoFK4k
 
Description Contributing to Stakeholder Conference, Futurebuild 2023, London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I was chairing a panel on behavioural change required to meet UK's net-zero goal, introducing the topic, introducing the speakers, steering the debates, taking questions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.futurebuild.co.uk/activity/the-big-behaviour-debate-changing-our-professional-and-person...
 
Description ESRC Festival of Social Science 2021 - How can we drive social change in response to the climate emergency? (workshop) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact I offered an online workshop for secondary-school-age young people on How can we drive social change in response to the climate emergency? After a brief presentation the workshop was more interactive with various activities, where the participants had to discuss certain questions in smaller groups and then report back.
12 children attended and we had some engaged discussions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.ukri.org/what-we-offer/public-engagement/public-engagement-esrc/festival-of-social-scien...
 
Description PLOS Climate Panel Discussion on COP27 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact PLOS Climate organised a webinar, a panel discussion on COP27 outcomes, inviting me, along with Géraldine Pflieger, Shobhakar Dhakal, Nana Ama Browne Klutse and Emma Archer. This was an event open to the general public, meant to be relevant for academics, policy makers, activists, educators etc. It was live, but was also recorded and will be made available and distributed more widely by PLOS Climate.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://vimeo.com/782657019
 
Description Settee Seminars - Season Five, Episode Two, Stabilising Earth's Climate: Key Social Dynamics (Podcast) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Settee Seminars is a podcast series of fascinating short talks by leading experts, introducing the general public to a wide range of topics. It consists of several seasons, with each season containing up to five episodes (podcasts), which are professionally produced. We were invited to contribute to Season Five with a podcast broadly on climate change. We agreed that we will produce a podcast talking about the complex social dynamics and processes around climate change and how societies respond to the climate crisis, focussing on how social change in response to the crisis, can happen.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL http://www.ilkleyliteraturefestival.org.uk/whats-on/settee-seminars/settee-seminars-season-five