Invisible Women, Invisible Workers: Focusing a gendered lens on health and safety in the global garment industry

Lead Research Organisation: University of Nottingham
Department Name: Sch of Geography

Abstract

"Fast fashion should worry all of us" was The Guardian newspaper's provocative headline calling for an international response to the exploitation of workers in global garments and footwear manufacturing. Worldwide, 70 million people work producing clothing and shoes, mostly in developing countries but also in advanced economies like the UK. 80% of these workers are women. The industry is worth US$2 trillion per year, yet workers receive poverty wages to live and work in dangerous conditions. In 2014, for example, over 1000 workers in Bangladesh were crushed to death in a factory collapse, highlighting the prioritisation of profit at the expense of people.

Although workers in supply chains are vital to our everyday lives, we know very little about the women who make our clothes and shoes. The UK government's Work and Opportunities for Women programme highlights urgent concern that there is a lack of systemic collection and reporting of gender-disaggregated data by companies and other organisations involved in managing global supply chains. Women workers in supply chains are simply invisible workers. Sustainable Development Goal 8.8 targets "safe and secure working environments for all workers". Yet without systemic data the problems that lessen women's quality of life in the garment industry are not fully known and are therefore are hard to address. This Future Leaders Fellowship addresses this knowledge and practice gap by generating evidence and promoting action on the specific threats posed to female garment workers.

In the global South, as well as the UK, most garment workers are young women from poor households, often living far away from home. Building on a commitment from the International Labour Organisation to eradicate gendered violence in "the world of work" (Convention 190, 2019), including acknowledging threats that occur beyond the workplace, we will evidence the risks that women workers face inside and outside of the factory, where malnutrition, mass fainting, reproductive and mental health crises, and sexual and physical abuse are reported to be commonplace. Using feminist theory and methods, we aim to highlight and challenge where gender-blind health and safety programmes hide or ignore these pervasive threats to women's wellbeing.

We focus on four producer countries that represent different sites in the evolution of supply chain outsourcing: Cambodia, Ethiopia, Jordan and the UK. Across these locations, a combined 1 million people work making clothes and shoes for leading UK brands including M&S, Topshop and ASOS. Bringing together a diverse and transdisciplinary team, the project uses a participatory and ethnographic approach to investigate women's health and wellbeing at 8 industrial sites in each country, before examining the (inter)national organisation of labour and trade governance, to understand the institutional processes that make and unmake healthy working bodies. Our global approach allows us to identify the complex, more-than-local factors that perpetuate women's vulnerability in garment work and target action to address the systemic causes of inequity within supply chains.

To ensure our project amplifies women workers, we are collaborating with global partners and advisors, including international organisations (ILO/IFC Better Work), labour rights advocates (Worker Rights Consortium), women's rights charities (Care), trade justice campaigns (Traidcraft Exchange) and social movements (Fashion Revolution). We will share our findings in 10 academic papers, 6 interim briefs, 4 local workshops and exhibitions, and an accessibly written final report and monograph. Our initial phase of research for impact culminates in a global launch and exhibition of outputs at Fashion Revolution Week in 2025, intended to counter the invisibility of women workers, generating media attention to galvanise policy and public support for transformative change towards just garment supply chains.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our scoping research in Cambodia revealed an increasing share of garment labour working within informal "shadow" or subcontract factories, rather than formal exporting factories. Work in the informal industry has been thought to be associated with a number of Decent Work deficits. To date, however, the full extent of the informal industry and the standards of work, labour rights, and legal protections has not been reliably known or quantified due to a lack of data and evidence. Using follow on funding secured from the University of Nottingham, our research team has conducting the first ever full mapping, census and survey of the garment industry in two provinces of Cambodia, including both formal and informal manufacturers, identifying more than 500 factories and 100,000 workers. This data has enabled us to provide the first rigorous quantitative evaluation of the proportion of workers employed in the informal industry, measured at 15% in these two provinces, and the status of fundamental rights and critical workplace standards and safety compliance for workers within these sites. The findings from a representative survey of a sample of 500 workers within the informal segment of the industry show widespread labour rights abuses including evasion of legal minimum wage entitlements, non-provision of legally-entitled social security benefits, and non-fulfilment of fundamental labour rights including freedom of association for trade unions.
Exploitation Route These findings are likely to be of use to a cross-section of industry stakeholders interested in improving standards regulation and work in the informal garment industry in Cambodia, including government (in UK, Cambodia and elsewhere), industry (including global brands and local suppliers), development partners and policymakers, third sector organisations and trade unions. We presented the summary findings at a workshop for these stakeholders in Phnom Penh in March 2023 and are now looking at ways of taking this forward in partnership with these stakeholders, including expanding the scope of the work to include a national mapping of the garment industry in Cambodia and policy and advocacy initiatives to extend and enforce legal obligations and protections to workers in the informal industry.
Sectors Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description Many key markets for garment imports, including the EU, are considering or have enacted mandatory legislation to regulate the corporate responsibility to protect human rights in overseas supply chains. Working in collaboration with four large garment buyers and brands in Cambodia, the research team has conducted a review of workplace grievance mechanisms in the garment sector, collecting primary data with workers and managements in 12 factories. Understanding the effectiveness of workplace grievance mechanisms is vital for understanding how workers can hold their employers accountable for safety and health within the workplace. The findings of the review were presented at the ILO-IFC Better Factories Cambodia Business Forum in March 2023, to an audience of government (including Ministry of Labour and Ministry of Economics and Finance), industry (including global brands and local retailers), development partners, third sector organisations, and trade unions in Cambodia, alongside recommendations to different stakeholders for improving grievance mechanisms in Cambodia.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Follow on sub-contracting factory survey in Cambodia (GNCA/Other ODA Research Award)
Amount £44,650 (GBP)
Organisation University of Nottingham 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2022 
End 03/2023
 
Description Presentation (Business Forum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Presented research findings at the annual ILO-IFC Better Factories Cambodia Business Forum 2023 to an audience of government, development partner, brands/buyers, suppliers, third sector, and trade union representatives from the garment sector on workplace grievance mechanisms in the garment sector, with suggestions to stakeholders for improving grievance handling
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Presentation (OECD Due Diligence Forum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Presented research findings to government, policymakers, practitioners and third sector at the OECD Forum for Due Diligence in the Garment and Footwear Sector, and shared recommendations to establish regulation of international supply chains by UK Parliament as part of "Fashion Watchdog" campaign
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023