The Durability of immune Responses to vaccination against SARS-CoV-2 and its Variants.

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Infectious Disease

Abstract

This proposal has been developed by a team who have worked at the forefront of studies to understand immunity to the SARS-COV-2 virus throughout the pandemic. With time, the focus of these questions has changed. As more people receive COVID-19 vaccination, a key concern becomes the need to understand the details of protective immunity and how long it is typically likely to remain protective in the 'real-life settings' of the many different vaccines available globally. Furthermore, compared to the reductionist conditions under which initial clinical trials were conducted, we now face a situation whereby many people receiving vaccines having been previously infected by SARS-CoV-2 or its alpha to delta variants. We showed that prior infection substantially boosts the response to vaccination. These points in mind, our aim is to generate the detailed immunological datasets enabling us to understand how long protective immunity lasts and thus, when boosts are likely to be needed. To do this, we bring together our work on diverse, longitudinal, COVID-19 cohorts, already developed and characterised with our collaborators over the past year. Our cohorts encompass 12097 individuals, with different exposures to SARS-CoV-2 and its variants, in the UK, South Africa and Brazil. We will be able to study people receiving different vaccines, with or without infection by SARS-CoV-2 and the alpha, beta, gamma and delta variants of concern. Our work aims to understand the durability and nature of immune protection, including susceptibility to reinfection and breakthrough infections. To track longitudinal immunity we will use existing protocols to measure diverse aspects of immunity in sequential blood samples. Tests will consider virus neutralisation by antibody, as well as assessing 'immune memory' (-ability of a primed immune response to 'remember' the virus and so protect) in B cells (which make antibody) and T cells (which orchestrate the antiviral response). Put simply, our question can be framed as: some studies indicate that protective antibodies in serum wane rapidly, so that relatively frequent boosters may be needed, while others show that immunity progressively improves after vaccination, termed 'affinity maturation', and that B and T cell memory are long-lived, implying the possibility of longer delays to boosting. By building a detailed, longitudinal dataset of many measures of immunity, we will model the timecourse from vaccination to the predicted loss of protective immunity. This will enable us to offer precise input to policy-making about immune-monitoring and boosting strategy, as well as informing the realities of applying 'immune certification' measures in everyday life - assessing how long certification is likely to be meaningful. Analysis needs to be mindful of the point that people are diverse. We know that vaccination responses encompass a spectrum, with high-responders and poor-responders at each end. We will analyse data from our large sample in the context of factors such as gender, ethnicity, age and obesity. From past studies, some will make a sub-optimal immune response because of the medicines they are taking. We here include two such cohorts. In one, we consider the impact of one of the most common drugs given to people with autoimmune conditions such as inflammatory bowel disease and rheumatoid arthritis (anti-TNF biologics). In another, we consider the impact of drug treatment in people with chronic myelogenous leukaemia. In summary, the knowledge-gap we aim to fill is the definition of protective immunity and its stability in longitudinal analysis during the year following vaccination. This will supply the dataset and predictive models to inform decision-making on timing of boosters, variant breakthrough, diversity of protective responses within the population and optimisation of protocols for the immunosuppressed.

Technical Summary

This proposal comes from a team who have been at the forefront of decoding immune parameters in COVID-19 throughout the pandemic, giving us a sharp focus on the current questions. The concern is to understand, at a qualitative and quantitative level, the details of immune response durability in 'real-life settings' of different vaccination regimens, with or without prior infection. We will study large, longitudinal, cohorts (totalling 12097 individuals) with different exposures to SARS-CoV-2 and its variants, in the UK, South Africa and Brazil, enabling us to study vaccination using diverse platforms, with or without infection by SARS-CoV-2 and the alpha, beta, gamma and delta variants of concern (VoC). These are cohorts with a high-granularity history, encompassing infection and symptom history as well as immune data. Moving forward, we wish to understand the durability and nature of immune protection, including susceptibility to reinfection and breakthrough infections. To achieve this, we will track longitudinal immunity, analysing serum antibody durability, live virus neutralisation, antibody affinity, B cell receptor repertoire and B cell memory frequency, both to wild-type and variant targets. In terms of T cell immunity, we will track durability of response frequency to wild-type and variant epitopes using a wide range of approaches. The CLARITY and CML-Co-vax Cohorts will enable us to probe vaccine response impairment and its mitigation in immunosuppressed cohorts (IBD and chronic myelogenous leukemia) after Infliximab or tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) therapy respectively. Data will be modeled in relation to CoP values to extrapolate and provide guidance regarding the need / timing of boosts for different vaccine platforms in healthy adults and immunosuppressed patients to achieve protective immunity.

Publications

10 25 50

 
Description BARTS UCL UK HCW COVIDsortium 
Organisation Barts Health NHS Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Laboratory based research on the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection, VOC and following COVID-19 vaccination. Study design of sub-study cohorts looking at the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection comparing infected and uninfected HCW leading to several publications including a manuscript on discordant immunity in published in Science Immunology and a manuscript on aborted infection in published in Nature. Study design of COVID-19 vaccine and VOC sub-study cohorts leading to several publications including one in Lancet describing hybrid immunity and two in Science - one describing how prior infection rescues immunity against VOC and one describing immune imprinting by SARS-CoV-2 infection. Processing PBMC, serum, RNA during longitudinal recruitments from July 2020 onwards.
Collaborator Contribution The COVIDsortium [initially set up by Prof James Moon (Chief Investigator), Prof Mahdad Noursadeghi, Dr Thomas Treibel, Dr Charlotte Manisty, Prof McKnight] provided access to a longitudinal HCW cohort including clinical and demographic data collected during the first 16 weeks of weekly f/u by PCR/serology/symptom diaries. Prof McKnight's team at QMUL provided expertise in nAb studies and nAb data using live SARS-CoV-2 virus. Tim Brooks and Amanda Semper at PHE provided rapid and comprehensive N and S1 RBD serology data. All members of the COVIDsortium core team (Moon/Noursadeghi/Treibel/Manisty/McKnight/Boyton/Altmann/Maini/Chain/Mills) met weekly for the first 2y of the COVID-19 pandemic to facilitate collaborative research, share their expertise, resources and intellectual input.
Impact Science Immunology: T cell, serology and neutralising antibody heterogeneity in mild disease European Heart Journal: Patterns of myocardial injury from troponin positive COVID Lancet E-BioMed: antibody dynamics in mild SARS-CoV-2 infection Jacc Imaging: cardiovascular late effects of mild disease (none) Lancet: second booster vaccine not necessary after prior covid Lancet E-ClinMed: infection risk, BAME and health role. Science: Impact of vaccination on T and B cell response to variants The Lancet microbe : viral transcriptomics Nature Abortive infection: Seronegative x-reactive T cells to rna polymerase CELL: HOST-MICROBE Prior infection with variants differentially boosts after J and J vaccine Science: first encounter with COVID-19 shapes future immune response to new infections
Start Year 2020
 
Description BARTS UCL UK HCW COVIDsortium 
Organisation Public Health England
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Laboratory based research on the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection, VOC and following COVID-19 vaccination. Study design of sub-study cohorts looking at the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection comparing infected and uninfected HCW leading to several publications including a manuscript on discordant immunity in published in Science Immunology and a manuscript on aborted infection in published in Nature. Study design of COVID-19 vaccine and VOC sub-study cohorts leading to several publications including one in Lancet describing hybrid immunity and two in Science - one describing how prior infection rescues immunity against VOC and one describing immune imprinting by SARS-CoV-2 infection. Processing PBMC, serum, RNA during longitudinal recruitments from July 2020 onwards.
Collaborator Contribution The COVIDsortium [initially set up by Prof James Moon (Chief Investigator), Prof Mahdad Noursadeghi, Dr Thomas Treibel, Dr Charlotte Manisty, Prof McKnight] provided access to a longitudinal HCW cohort including clinical and demographic data collected during the first 16 weeks of weekly f/u by PCR/serology/symptom diaries. Prof McKnight's team at QMUL provided expertise in nAb studies and nAb data using live SARS-CoV-2 virus. Tim Brooks and Amanda Semper at PHE provided rapid and comprehensive N and S1 RBD serology data. All members of the COVIDsortium core team (Moon/Noursadeghi/Treibel/Manisty/McKnight/Boyton/Altmann/Maini/Chain/Mills) met weekly for the first 2y of the COVID-19 pandemic to facilitate collaborative research, share their expertise, resources and intellectual input.
Impact Science Immunology: T cell, serology and neutralising antibody heterogeneity in mild disease European Heart Journal: Patterns of myocardial injury from troponin positive COVID Lancet E-BioMed: antibody dynamics in mild SARS-CoV-2 infection Jacc Imaging: cardiovascular late effects of mild disease (none) Lancet: second booster vaccine not necessary after prior covid Lancet E-ClinMed: infection risk, BAME and health role. Science: Impact of vaccination on T and B cell response to variants The Lancet microbe : viral transcriptomics Nature Abortive infection: Seronegative x-reactive T cells to rna polymerase CELL: HOST-MICROBE Prior infection with variants differentially boosts after J and J vaccine Science: first encounter with COVID-19 shapes future immune response to new infections
Start Year 2020
 
Description BARTS UCL UK HCW COVIDsortium 
Organisation Queen Mary University of London
Department Blizard Institute
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Laboratory based research on the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection, VOC and following COVID-19 vaccination. Study design of sub-study cohorts looking at the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection comparing infected and uninfected HCW leading to several publications including a manuscript on discordant immunity in published in Science Immunology and a manuscript on aborted infection in published in Nature. Study design of COVID-19 vaccine and VOC sub-study cohorts leading to several publications including one in Lancet describing hybrid immunity and two in Science - one describing how prior infection rescues immunity against VOC and one describing immune imprinting by SARS-CoV-2 infection. Processing PBMC, serum, RNA during longitudinal recruitments from July 2020 onwards.
Collaborator Contribution The COVIDsortium [initially set up by Prof James Moon (Chief Investigator), Prof Mahdad Noursadeghi, Dr Thomas Treibel, Dr Charlotte Manisty, Prof McKnight] provided access to a longitudinal HCW cohort including clinical and demographic data collected during the first 16 weeks of weekly f/u by PCR/serology/symptom diaries. Prof McKnight's team at QMUL provided expertise in nAb studies and nAb data using live SARS-CoV-2 virus. Tim Brooks and Amanda Semper at PHE provided rapid and comprehensive N and S1 RBD serology data. All members of the COVIDsortium core team (Moon/Noursadeghi/Treibel/Manisty/McKnight/Boyton/Altmann/Maini/Chain/Mills) met weekly for the first 2y of the COVID-19 pandemic to facilitate collaborative research, share their expertise, resources and intellectual input.
Impact Science Immunology: T cell, serology and neutralising antibody heterogeneity in mild disease European Heart Journal: Patterns of myocardial injury from troponin positive COVID Lancet E-BioMed: antibody dynamics in mild SARS-CoV-2 infection Jacc Imaging: cardiovascular late effects of mild disease (none) Lancet: second booster vaccine not necessary after prior covid Lancet E-ClinMed: infection risk, BAME and health role. Science: Impact of vaccination on T and B cell response to variants The Lancet microbe : viral transcriptomics Nature Abortive infection: Seronegative x-reactive T cells to rna polymerase CELL: HOST-MICROBE Prior infection with variants differentially boosts after J and J vaccine Science: first encounter with COVID-19 shapes future immune response to new infections
Start Year 2020
 
Description BARTS UCL UK HCW COVIDsortium 
Organisation University College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Laboratory based research on the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection, VOC and following COVID-19 vaccination. Study design of sub-study cohorts looking at the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection comparing infected and uninfected HCW leading to several publications including a manuscript on discordant immunity in published in Science Immunology and a manuscript on aborted infection in published in Nature. Study design of COVID-19 vaccine and VOC sub-study cohorts leading to several publications including one in Lancet describing hybrid immunity and two in Science - one describing how prior infection rescues immunity against VOC and one describing immune imprinting by SARS-CoV-2 infection. Processing PBMC, serum, RNA during longitudinal recruitments from July 2020 onwards.
Collaborator Contribution The COVIDsortium [initially set up by Prof James Moon (Chief Investigator), Prof Mahdad Noursadeghi, Dr Thomas Treibel, Dr Charlotte Manisty, Prof McKnight] provided access to a longitudinal HCW cohort including clinical and demographic data collected during the first 16 weeks of weekly f/u by PCR/serology/symptom diaries. Prof McKnight's team at QMUL provided expertise in nAb studies and nAb data using live SARS-CoV-2 virus. Tim Brooks and Amanda Semper at PHE provided rapid and comprehensive N and S1 RBD serology data. All members of the COVIDsortium core team (Moon/Noursadeghi/Treibel/Manisty/McKnight/Boyton/Altmann/Maini/Chain/Mills) met weekly for the first 2y of the COVID-19 pandemic to facilitate collaborative research, share their expertise, resources and intellectual input.
Impact Science Immunology: T cell, serology and neutralising antibody heterogeneity in mild disease European Heart Journal: Patterns of myocardial injury from troponin positive COVID Lancet E-BioMed: antibody dynamics in mild SARS-CoV-2 infection Jacc Imaging: cardiovascular late effects of mild disease (none) Lancet: second booster vaccine not necessary after prior covid Lancet E-ClinMed: infection risk, BAME and health role. Science: Impact of vaccination on T and B cell response to variants The Lancet microbe : viral transcriptomics Nature Abortive infection: Seronegative x-reactive T cells to rna polymerase CELL: HOST-MICROBE Prior infection with variants differentially boosts after J and J vaccine Science: first encounter with COVID-19 shapes future immune response to new infections
Start Year 2020
 
Description CLARITY / VIP study 
Organisation Royal Devon and Exeter NHS Foundation Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Laboratory experimental work and expertise in T cell and memory B cell studies. Expertise in the immune response to infection and vaccination, intellectual input.
Collaborator Contribution Expertise, intellectual input in setting up the CLARITY cohort. Access to clinical and serological data and PBMC for T cell studies
Impact Manuscript accepted for publication in Nature Communications
Start Year 2020
 
Description COVAX study 
Organisation Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution We provided knowledge and expertise and about the immune response to COVID-19 vaccination and designed and performed serological analysis, T cell studies and memory B cell studies.
Collaborator Contribution COVAX study PI - Dr Dragana Milojkovic. Provided a clinical cohort of patients with CML on TKI inhibitors and age/sex matched controls that were followed up longitudinally pre-vaccination and after their 1st, 2nd and 3rd vaccine doses. Provided their clinical expertise, intellectual input developing the cohort, access to clinical data serum and PBMC samples for laboratory analysis
Impact Immunology data currently being analysed that will be written up as a manuscript and published
Start Year 2021