The role of bioplastics, social plastics, and just plastics in a circular economy
Lead Research Organisation:
University of St Andrews
Department Name: Philos Anthrop and Film Studies
Abstract
This renewed research project and fellowship extension will further explore the viable future of a 'circular plastics economy from an anthropological perspective. This means the way in which plastic waste can be minimised, the useful life of plastics can be extended, and (bio)plastics can contribute to regenerating 'nature'. The project has a specific interest in integrating social justice and just transition principles into definitions of the circular economy, as already occurs with conceptualizations of Sustainable Development. It does so through three thematic work packages that build on the original FLF: bioplastics, social plastics, and just plastics.
Bioplastics are often considered problematic in waste policy circles, given the difficulty with which they are composted and their tendency to contaminate conventional plastics recycling streams. Yet they are heralded by the sustainable business community and continue to grow. This work package combines ethnographic research with a producer of two different bioplastic forms of packaging for the pharmaceutical industry with historical research into the debates and controversies surrounding the original bioplastics (casein, parkesine, cellophane) and their replacement with fully synthetic polymers during the twentieth century. Thus, a range of materials that are currently are debated by a limited range of actors in terms of excitement at the production phase and frustration with regards to disposal will benefit from both a nuanced ethnographic study and from a long-lens historical perspective.
Social Plastics explores the way in which the social economy of cooperatives, social enterprises and non-for-profit organisations intersects with a circular economy of plastics, ensuring an important role for underprivileged actors and an approach that is socially as well as environmentally responsible. Specifically, this strand compares plastics wastepickers cooperatives in Argentina and Cuba, seeking to understand the barriers to wastepickers moving up the plastics value chain and how they can be overcome. Through research into successful case-studies, wastepickers in other countries will benefit from an anthropological focus on these issues. The wider business community of plastics packaging generators who want to ensure a regular supply of recycled plastics from wastepickers whilst guaranteeing their human rights will also benefit. A partnership with a New Scots plastics collective in Dundee will ensure South-North knowledge exchange between groups seeking to minimise plastic pollution while providing decent work for underprivileged and vulnerable groups.
Just Plastics focuses on the role that plastics wastepickers are playing in the UNEP plastic pollution treaty and how they are being included in national action plans to tackle plastic pollution. In this work package, the research team will look at the case of South Africa (TBC), chair of the Friends of Wastepickers group at UNEP and a country with some of the most progressive waste policies with regard to the involvement and protection of wastepickers. A complementary study will also be carried out in collaboration with Zero Waste Scotland that will explore the range of policy options available to Scotland in anticipation of the binding and voluntary treaty targets, ensuring a comparative North-South dimension to this work package. As well as international wastepicker organisations and policymakers, a key beneficiary of this package will be the UNEP secretariat itself, since it will provide world-leading social scientific research on the role of wastepickers in plastics recycling and reducing plastic pollution, complementing the natural and chemical science knowledge base that predominates in this sphere.
Bioplastics are often considered problematic in waste policy circles, given the difficulty with which they are composted and their tendency to contaminate conventional plastics recycling streams. Yet they are heralded by the sustainable business community and continue to grow. This work package combines ethnographic research with a producer of two different bioplastic forms of packaging for the pharmaceutical industry with historical research into the debates and controversies surrounding the original bioplastics (casein, parkesine, cellophane) and their replacement with fully synthetic polymers during the twentieth century. Thus, a range of materials that are currently are debated by a limited range of actors in terms of excitement at the production phase and frustration with regards to disposal will benefit from both a nuanced ethnographic study and from a long-lens historical perspective.
Social Plastics explores the way in which the social economy of cooperatives, social enterprises and non-for-profit organisations intersects with a circular economy of plastics, ensuring an important role for underprivileged actors and an approach that is socially as well as environmentally responsible. Specifically, this strand compares plastics wastepickers cooperatives in Argentina and Cuba, seeking to understand the barriers to wastepickers moving up the plastics value chain and how they can be overcome. Through research into successful case-studies, wastepickers in other countries will benefit from an anthropological focus on these issues. The wider business community of plastics packaging generators who want to ensure a regular supply of recycled plastics from wastepickers whilst guaranteeing their human rights will also benefit. A partnership with a New Scots plastics collective in Dundee will ensure South-North knowledge exchange between groups seeking to minimise plastic pollution while providing decent work for underprivileged and vulnerable groups.
Just Plastics focuses on the role that plastics wastepickers are playing in the UNEP plastic pollution treaty and how they are being included in national action plans to tackle plastic pollution. In this work package, the research team will look at the case of South Africa (TBC), chair of the Friends of Wastepickers group at UNEP and a country with some of the most progressive waste policies with regard to the involvement and protection of wastepickers. A complementary study will also be carried out in collaboration with Zero Waste Scotland that will explore the range of policy options available to Scotland in anticipation of the binding and voluntary treaty targets, ensuring a comparative North-South dimension to this work package. As well as international wastepicker organisations and policymakers, a key beneficiary of this package will be the UNEP secretariat itself, since it will provide world-leading social scientific research on the role of wastepickers in plastics recycling and reducing plastic pollution, complementing the natural and chemical science knowledge base that predominates in this sphere.
People |
ORCID iD |
| Patrick O'Hare (Principal Investigator / Fellow) |
Publications
O'Hare P
(2024)
"The human face of the UN plastics treaty"? The role of waste pickers in intergovernmental negotiations to end plastic pollution and ensure a just transition
in Cambridge Prisms: Plastics
| Description | For now, only the PDRA Matteo Saltalippi has conducted fieldwork for this project and has generated key findings. From his research it was possible to estimate that a total population of between 50,000 and 80,000 waste pickers and second-hand market sellers can recover and bring to the market between 164,500 - 263,200 tons of goods to be sold in a year. The data was gathered through a quali-quantitative methodology to estimate at three second hand markets in Italy over three months. |
| Exploitation Route | The data discussed above will be published by ISPRA (the Italian National Institute for Environmental Protection and Research), the research body of the Italian Ministry of the Environment. As a consequence every time the Italian parliament discusses a law or a decree on waste management or related green policies, Italian waste pickers, given the amount of goods they can recover from waste, will be considered as an important stakeholder. Given this, Rete ONU (see collaboration section) can intervene on behalf of the waste pickers in the governmental discussion. |
| Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy Environment |
| Title | Quali-quantitative |
| Description | To gather data on vendors/waste pickers ISPRA and Rete ONU elaborated a methodology to estimate the number of tons that this group recovers, recycles, and reintroduces into consumer cycles. This allows ISPRA and Rete ONU to quantify the impact of waste pickers and reuse operators in the reuse market. Together with researcher (MS) of this project he methodology has been reviewed and applied to collect data in three flea markets in Italy: Turin, Rome and Palermo. The methodology used to carry out the research took into account this population and deemed relevant a sample of 60 participants. The data gathering was quali-quantitative, relying on a 24-question survey (see the table below). The questions were posed directly to participants by the researcher (MS) member University of St. Andrews who collected the data firsthand by interpreting the answers of the participants to obtain the necessary quantitative data. Every vendor was considered as an autonomous microenterprise or sole trader with costs, prospect and actual revenue and earnings. The structured questionnaire was designed to gather such information, specifically about the annual cost and revenue of every seller, data were then cross-referenced with the weight of the objects sold on the participant's stalls at the market. The 60 interviews were conducted in the markets of Via Carcano in Turin (40), Ballarò in Palermo (16), the Integrated Market - Via Ardeatina 850 in Rome (3), and the Piazza dei Mirti market in Rome (1). The questionnaire was divided into questions aimed at obtaining a microenterprise analysis and questions to estimate the weight of objects divided by categories the answers to this questions were obtained either by physically weighing the displayed items or by making an estimate to collect quantitative data on the weight of the objects sold by individual vendors. The data gathering lasted respectively 8 weeks in Turin, 1 week in Palermo and 3 days in Rome. |
| Type Of Material | Data analysis technique |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | No |
| Impact | The data show that the largest quantity of objects recovered from the waste or prevented from going into the bin and sold on the markets' stalls belong to the clothes/textile category with 43.6% and a total amount of 86,052 Kg. This is followed by 51,309 Kg of electrical and electronic equipment amounting to 26% of the total. The category with the smallest percentage is furniture with 6.1% and 12,130 kg, this is because furniture are bulky items, which require often a large, motorized mean of transport to be taken to the market, take up the same space as a more items amounting to higher value, and could easily damage during the recovery and transport operation making the items in this category often not convenient for the seller/waste pickers to trade. During the period of observation, the measuring of this category was only possible 2 times, that is only 2 sellers interviewed sold furniture and 1 time in Palermo. The objects in the category "Other items" make up 24.3% of the total, for 47,924 kg. These are items made of a great variety of materials and serving a vast array of purposes which don't fit the other three categories. The final data analysis shows that every street seller on average is able to recover 1,434 kg of clothes/textile, 855 kg of electrical and electronic equipment, 799 kg of other items and 202 kg of furniture. Given this and based on the total population estimated between 50,000 and 80,000 operators the total amount of goods reused per year is between 164,500 and 263,200 of tons of which, between 71,700 t - 114,720 t of clothes/textile, 42,750 t - 68,400 t of electrical and electronic equipment, 39,950 t - 63,920 t of other items, and 10,100 t - 16,160 t of furniture. The estimation doesn't include the unsold objects. Once published the data will be cited by ISRPA and can mean the first recognition of aste pickers/ vendors in national policies discussion thanks to their ability to recover such large quantity of materials and objects. |
| Description | Convenor, Waste Management and Existing Plastic Pollution Working Group, Scientists Coalition for an Effective Plastics Treaty. |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
| Results and Impact | I chair the Waste Management and Existing Plastic Pollution Working Group of the Scientists Coalition for an Effective Plastics Treaty (SCEPT). This has involved regular meetings to discuss updates and work to give policymakers involved in the Global Plastics Treaty (GPT) objective scientific advice and guidance in treaty areas relevant to plastics waste management and tackling existing plastic pollution. The main outputs from this participation have been policy briefs, of which I co-authored 3, and which cumulatively have been viewed 1200 times and downloaded over 360 times. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022,2023,2024,2025 |
| Description | Learning to Reduce and Reuse. A citizen science project with school children in Fife. Workshops on reuse at primary schools in Fife |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Regional |
| Primary Audience | Schools |
| Results and Impact | IIF Impact and Innovation Fund Rapid Response - Awarded Internal fund University of St. Andrews (10099-IIFSALTA) TITLE: Learning to Reduce and Reuse. A citizen science project with school children in Fife. PI: Matteo Saltalippi Co-I: Patrick O'Hare This project stems from and builds on the knowledge acquired through "The role of bioplastics, social plastics, and just plastics in a circular economy'. Ref: MR/Y003853/1 The workshops were held at Canongate Primary School in St. Andrews and Kingsbarns Primary School, involving two P5 and P4-7 classes from each school. It was co-designed and delivered with the support of Transition StAndrews, an environmental organisation. Their input was integral, particularly in providing feedback on the educational materials. The focus of the workshop is on the importance of reuse practices in reducing demand for new products, curbing pollution (especially plastic waste), and promoting economic efficiency. Teaching these principles to students is crucial for tackling environmental challenges. Having two St Andrews schools onboard and enthusiastic about working with applicant and having established a collaboration with Transition St Andrews, enhanced the value of this project and lays the foundation for future partnerships. The project integrates social justice principles into the circular economy, focusing on reuse and repair knowledge.It delivers workshops to schoolchildren in Fife to inspire them to develop plastic waste-reduction practices.Students have tracked their reuse practices for two weeks, collaborate to identify best practices, and compile these into a booklet. This pedagogical output combines academic knowledge with first-hand data, it was be designed to be accessible to school students, and sent to central education services in Fife, to teacher councils, and to schools beyond the region to engage schools with students of diverse socio-economic backgrounds to promote socio-environmental change through sustainable practices. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |