Ecological effects of reduced versus oxidised nitrogen deposition

Lead Research Organisation: University of York
Department Name: Environment

Abstract

Summary Atmospheric deposition of nitrogen compounds has increased dramatically in Europe in the 2nd half of the 20th century. Over the same period, important changes in species composition of various vegetation types, and the loss of many characteristic species, have occurred which cannot be explained by factors such as changes in management. From the early 1990s onwards, evidence was found that increased nitrogen deposition was associated with some of these changes in species composition. It is now widely recognised that the increased atmospheric nitrogen deposition over the past 50 years is a major factor in the sharp decline of many characteristic plant species from a variety of ecosystems. Nitrogen deposition can act by increasing the acidity of soil, because base cations such as calcium are released and leach out of the system; this can lead to base cation deficiencies in plants. It also increases the amount of available nitrogen in the soil, a process which is often referred to as eutrophication. Both base cation deficiency and eutrophication are known to be mechanisms involved in the decline of characteristic species. Nitrogen (N) deposition is largely composed of two forms: reduced N, which is emitted mainly from animal waste and manure, and oxidised N which is emitted mainly from fuel combustion. It is important to understand which of these forms of nitrogen has the greatest ecological impacts, so that policies to control emissions and protect sensitive species are effective, especially as there are large spatial differences in the rates of reduced and oxidised N deposition across Europe. Very few experimental or field studies up to now have properly compared the different effects of reduced and oxidised N deposition, and even fewer have considered the importance of interactions with soil acidity. However, recent research has shown that elevated deposition of reduced, but not oxidised, N is detrimental for many plant species from sensitive ecosystems, especially when these ecosystems have already become acidified. The aims of this study are:- (i) to determine whether differences in the atmospheric deposition of reduced, rather than oxidised, nitrogen to sensitive ecosystems accounts for the changes in plant species composition seen in northern Europe in recent decades; (ii) to identify the mechanisms which lead to reduced nitrogen deposition, and/or high reduced/oxidised N ratios, having a greater impact when soils have low levels of base cations; and (iii) to use this information to identify habitats, species and locations at greatest risk from N deposition. We will use a combination of laboratory and field experiments, and data analysis from field surveys in both the UK and The Netherlands, to meet these aims.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Jorgensen, S. E.; Fath, Brian (2008) Encyclopedia of Ecology: Volume 1-5

publication icon
Stevens CJ (2011) Ecosystem responses to reduced and oxidised nitrogen inputs in European terrestrial habitats. in Environmental pollution (Barking, Essex : 1987)

publication icon
Sutton, Mark; Howard, Clare; Erisman, Jan-Willem; Bleeker, Albert; Billen, Gilles; Grennfelt, Peringe; Grinsven, Hans Van; Grizzetti, Bruna (2011) The European Nitrogen Assessment: Sources, Effects and Policy Perspectives

publication icon
Van Den Berg LJ (2008) Reduced nitrogen has a greater effect than oxidised nitrogen on dry heathland vegetation. in Environmental pollution (Barking, Essex : 1987)

 
Description This study focussed on the relative effects of the two dominant nitrogen forms in nitrogen deposition (NHx and NOy) on the plant species composition and soil chemistry of some key UK habitats. The study combined manipulation experiments and analysis of national surveys of plant species composition. The experiment showed that dominance of the reduced form of nitrogen (NH4+) results in acidification of the soil, a decline in the cover of mosses and an increase in the cover of the purple moor grass (Molinia caerulea). The survey analysis showed that the reduced form of nitrogen tended to have a greater effect in changing species composition to plants that are adapted to higher levels of nitrogen availability. This provides important new evidence that the chemical form of nitrogen deposited from the atmosphere is important as well as the total amount of that deposition.
Exploitation Route Our research suggests that control of the agricultural sources that produce the reduced form of nitrogen would have greater ecological benefits than control of the energy and transport related sources of the oxidised form of nitrogen, a finding that is relevant to both agencies responsible for pollution control and those responsible for conservation of sensitive habitats. However, our work focussed on a limited number of habitats and species, and in some cases, responses were greater to oxidised nitrogen. More experimental and survey work is needed to clarify the underlying mechanisms before our findings could provide a reliable basis for predictions of the effects of different air pollution control measures.
Sectors Environment

 
Description The results of this work contributed to the European Nitrogen Assessment, a synthesis of evidence and policy related to the environmental and health effects of nitrogen in Europe.
Sector Environment
Impact Types Policy & public services