Diagnosing multiscale entrainment in density-driven flows in the ocean

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Aeronautics

Abstract

It is well-known in ocean modelling that small scale mixing processes in density-driven flows that take place in the ocean are crucial for the global ocean circulation (and hence climate), but the scale of mixing is much smaller than one grid cell in global ocean circulation models (where the number of cells is constrained by the limits of computer power). These processes include the rapid sinking of dense (cold/salty) water due to storms and ice formation at the ocean surface (such as takes place in the Labrador Sea), and the flow of dense water over steep slopes in the ocean floor. The solution to this is to apply physical knowledge of these processes so that their effects can be prescribed in the global models (this is called parameterisation). A key quantity which must be accurately predicted is the entrainment into these flows. If one considers hot air rising from a factor chimney, then it is possible to predict how high and how fast the air will rise based on the difference between the density of the hot air and the lower density of the surroundings. As the air rises, the flow becomes turbulent, and air from the surroundings is mixing into the hot air, changing the density: this is called entrainment. In the case of many small scale mixing processes in the ocean, it is hard to predict the entrainment (because the effect of the rotation of the Earth is important, and the dynamics is rather complicated). The aim of this project is to build up a complete picture of small scale mixing in these density-driven flows by studying data from idealised models of these flows. We will use data obtained from the Imperial College Ocean Model (ICOM), which has a dynamically changing grid that is very suitable for studying these problems. The key concept will be Lagrangian particle trajectories: the paths that fluid particles take as they move with the flow. Following these paths reveals how water from the surroundings is mixed into the flow. The first part of the project will be to build a computational tool for computing Lagrangian particle trajectories on large datasets obtained from ocean models. The main challenge is to produce a code which can be run on a computer with many processors, although the basic strategy for this is well-developed and so one can make use of existing software to take care of the parallel aspects. The second part of the project is to apply a range of techniques to studying the particle trajectories to identify the key mixing processes in the density-driven flows. A complete picture of the mixing will be produced which can then be used to develop parameterisations for use in global ocean models.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Cotter C (2009) Estimating eddy diffusivities from noisy Lagrangian observations in Communications in Mathematical Sciences

publication icon
Cotter C. J. (2009) ESTIMATING EDDY DIFFUSIVITIES FROM NOISY LAGRANGIAN OBSERVATIONS in COMMUNICATIONS IN MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES

publication icon
Cotter CJ (2017) Stochastic partial differential fluid equations as a diffusive limit of deterministic Lagrangian multi-time dynamics. in Proceedings. Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences

publication icon
Van Sebille E (2018) Lagrangian ocean analysis: Fundamentals and practices in Ocean Modelling

 
Description The aim of this project was to develop new tools for diagnosing mixing

and entrainment in the ocean. These tools can be used to further our

understanding of the contribution to the global circulation of

multiscale processes and flows. These multiscale processes are known

to be crucial in determining the large scale ocean circulation and

hence the response to global warming. This project focussed on the use

of Lagrangian particles, particles that move passively with the fluid

flow, to characterise mixing by small scale processes that can then be

used to guide parameterisations of these processes in coarse-grained

ocean and climate models. The project concentrated on two aspects:



(1) Delivery of software for computing Lagrangian trajectories from

adaptive unstructured mesh computational fluid dynamics simulations.

(2) Techniques for extracting information from these Lagrangian

trajectories that can be used to develop and inform

parameterisations in ocean models.

Computing Lagrangian trajectories on adaptive unstructured

meshes: The key technical challenge in producing such a tool is

that unstructured mesh data uses indirect addressing. This means that

there is no natural ordering of the mesh points as there is for a

structured mesh and the flow data may be stored in an arbitrary

order. Hence, searching for the element that contains a Lagrangian

particle with given coordinates is an expensive process, and should

only be done infrequently. This is particularly the case in parallel

simulations, which are required for high fidelity large scale

simulations, such as those facilitated by Kramer, Cotter and Pain,

Ocean. Modell. (2010), where it is also necessary to determine which

processor owns the element containing the Lagrangian particle. In this

project we developed a new algorithm for solving this problem, which

is a modification of the guided search algorithm developed for

high-order finite element methods by Coppola, Sherwin and Peiro,

J. Comp. Phys. (2001). Our version of the algorithm locates the next

stage of the explicit Runge Kutta algorithm iteratively by searching

through neighbouring elements, handing off the particle to another

processor when the particle leaves the domain from a halo element that

is owned by the other processor. This is a robust and scalable

algorithm that does not depend on determining element ownership from

floating point conditions where the two processors may disagree. This

algorithm is being documented in a paper in preparation which also

applies the algorithm to diagnosing mixing in a density driven lock

exchange problem. The algorithm has been implemented as software as

part of the Fluidity/ICOM suite (from where it can be applied to data

obtained from any model output as prescribed velocity data), and has

already been adopted as the coupling engine between Fluidity/ICOM and

the Virtual Ecology Workbench plankton modelling project at Imperial

College.



Extracting information from Lagrangian trajectories: In

this project we developed a new approach to designing

parameterisations of mixing and entrainment in coarse-grained ocean

models. Instead of building the parameterisation from first

principles, homogenisation theory is used to establish the form of a

coarse-grained stochastic model, for which it is necessary to estimate

parameters. These parameters can be estimated from observational data,

or in the case of this project, from high-resolution numerical

simulations. We call this approach ``data-driven coarse-graining''. In

Cotter and Pavliotis, Comm. Math. Sci (2009), we showed that this

approach can be used to estimate coarse-grained models of Lagrangian

particle motion, which can then be used to model transport of

temperature, salinity and potential vorticity in the ocean, from

Lagrangian trajectories calculated from multiscale flows. The

calculation of the parameters (in this case the eddy diffusivity

parameter) by maximum likelihood estimators was shown (theoretically

and through numerical experiments) to converge statistically provided

that the data is subsampled (i.e. most of the data is

discarded). The advantage of this approach is that it can be computed

for single Lagrangian trajectories and then averaged, and that it only

requires forward model runs. In further work presented at EGU 2011, it

was shown (through numerical experiments) that under fairly broad

conditions it is not possible to improve the estimates by trying to

reuse the discarded data; all the relevant information is in the

subsampled data. This work led to the Imperial College London Grantham

Institute for Climate Change funding a PhD studentship on stochastic

modelling of eddy subgrid motion in collaboration with Dr Pavel

Berloff.
Exploitation Route This project produced a parallel Lagrangian trajectory calculation tool

which is now the main tool for this purpose used in the Imperial

College Fluidity code which is open source and has hundreds of

uses across geosciences and forms part of the Imperial College

Ocean Model in particular.
Sectors Environment

 
Description This project was blue skies research that has led to software tools which are in use in many applied projects within the Fluidity Project (http://fluidityproject.github.io), including applications in coastal oceanography and chemical engineering.
First Year Of Impact 2008
Sector Environment
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Standard Grant: Improving Prediction of Fronts
Amount £379,737 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/K012533/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2014 
End 01/2017
 
Description Standard Grant: Moving meshes for global atmospheric modelling
Amount £128,254 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/M013634/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2015 
End 08/2018