CLIMIT: CLimate change impacts on Insects and their MITigation

Lead Research Organisation: NERC CEH (Up to 30.11.2019)
Department Name: Hails

Abstract

Insects react rapidly to environmental change: for example, regional extinction rates of European butterflies have exceeded those of birds and higher plants by an order of magnitude in recent decades. We have also shown that butterflies are accurate indicators of change in less conspicuous invertebrate groups, including dominant insects such as ants that have major impacts on all other species in their environment. Here we propose to measure the combined impacts of human-induced changes in climate and habitat (area, isolation, patch quality) on some of Europe's most specialised and threatened grassland insects that interact with ants ('myrmecophiles' such as Adonis, Chalkhill, Silver-studded and 5 species of Large Blue butterflies, and two hoverflies whose young stages live 2 years inside ant nests), by studying their local adaptations, changing niches and different needs across a gradient of local climates from the Mediterranean to the North/Baltic seas. We will model the processes that limit each system's (meta-)populations, and predict the impacts of future scenarios of land-use, climate and socio-economic change in different regions. We will make new predictions, based on mathematical models, about how to mitigate the harmful impacts of multiple drivers of biodiversity change, and we will test our recommendations using existing and new large scale experiments of nature reserves and other conservation sites where the soil depth, topography and grazing management have been altered to create our current definitions of the optimum habitat for the Large blue and other butterflies, and the ants on which they depend. Finally, we will draw general conclusions about the changing needs of myrmecophiles, of which perhaps 100,000 species exist globally, including a disproportionate number of Red Book species, and of non myrmecophilous butterflies, in the latter case through comparing our model predictions with patterns of recorded change in all (UK) or representative (European) species across the climatic gradient, using the Centre for Ecology & Hydrology's dataset of annual changes in all UK butterfly population sizes since 1976, and other national and European datasets available to the consortium. A summary of the detailed hypotheses and objectives of this extensive proposal can be found in the main proposal on VR and in a shorter version under objectives on this form.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description CLIMIT - CLimate change impacts on Insects and their MITigation

CLIMIT assessed the combined impacts of human-induced changes in climate and habitat (area, isolation, patch quality) on some of Europe's most specialised and threatened grassland insects that depend on ants (myrmecophiles), by studying their local adaptations, changing niches and different needs across a gradient of local climates from the Mediterranean to the North/ Baltic seas.

We compared the fates of species that have different relationships with ants under different scenarios of climate and land use change, as well as studying their potential to evolve adaptations to new environments.

Finally, CLIMIT will tested ideas for adaptive management to conserve myrmecophiles on existing and new sites across landscapes.
Exploitation Route Further research to build on CLIMIT publications
Sectors Environment

URL http://climit-project.net/index.php
 
Description We reported previously (Ecology Letter 2006) that the presence of a social parasite, attacking ant societies unexpectedly benefited infested colonies by increasing the production of new queens. The study suggested the social dynamics in infested colonies could result in this counterintuitive outcome. Here we present an ant-colony simulation model showing that such dynamics would be stable and provide the predicted emergent properties. Our model indicates that selfish behaviour in an unregulated system with decentralized resource distribution produces stable, but suboptimal outcomes for any societies, and that the activities of parasites can have a surprising beneficial impact overall (Hovestadt et al 2012 Am Nat).
First Year Of Impact 2012
Sector Environment
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Conservation of Threatened Insects in Europe: Managing habitats for land use and climate change adaptation
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Citation in other policy documents
Impact Insects react rapidly to changes in land use and climate because of their generally short life cycles and, in many cases, their dependency on other species. For species which directly depend on one another, a change in one species can have a severe impact on the other. A recent report by the European Environment Agency has revealed dramatic declines in some grassland butterfly populations in Europe since 1990. Based on research results of the BiodivERsA-funded CLIMIT project, conservation schemes could be improved to help halt the extinction of the threatened insects studied in the project. Specific conservation measures could help improve the status of these species by allowing them time to adapt to environmental changes,and to maintain or progress towards favourable conservation status. Such adaptive management measures can contribute significantly to reaching the targets of the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020 and to fulfil the obligations in the EU Habitats Directive. CLIMIT outcomes: Some highly-specialized insects, such as the Large Blue butterfly (Maculinea arion), are highly vulnerable to environmental changes The use of appropriate adaptive management measures, in particular integrating ecological knowledge and promoting habitat patches and heterogeneity have been demonstrated to be beneficial to insect conservation A spectacular increase in the Large Blue population in the United Kingdom was possible through specific conservation measures Adequate monitoring and management of Natura 2000 sites and integration of ecological knowledge into management practices are essential for species adaptation Creating and restoring grassland patches enhances insect conservation, as supported by the EU Biodiversity Strategy and recent policy on Green Infrastructure National Rural Development Programmes under the Common Agricultural Policy could better contribute to enhancing grassland conservation EU Member States should build on the advice given in the new European Commission Guidelines on Climate Change and Natura 2000 in their site management planning Target audience(s): Independent Research Organisation;Research Council/Institute;Public Research Organisation;Government Department
URL http://www.biodiversa.org/556/download
 
Description Oxford University 
Organisation University of Oxford
Department Department of Zoology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Zoology department: We work in areas of chemical & behavioural ecology. Botany department: here I collaborate on issues related to tree health
Collaborator Contribution The Zoology department in Oxford, specifically Prof emeritus J Thomas, works in conservation ecology and we still publish on past collaboration. In Botany I work with Andrew Hector and Elsa Field (PhD student) studying climate matching plantations of oak.
Impact A range of publications incl. a policy paper at EU level, presentation, and collaborations with other EU partners
Start Year 2009