The Svalbard exemplar of Neoproterozoic glaciation

Lead Research Organisation: British Geological Survey
Department Name: NERC Isotope Geosciences Laboratory

Abstract

Although life successfully moderates surface conditions on Earth, some events in Earth History have threatened the viability of most life forms. Arguably the most profound and long-lasting challenge in the last 2 billion years was glaciation on a near-global scale, with the best documented event being around 650 to 630 million years ago ('Marinoan' glaciation). The Snowball Earth hypothesis proposes that snow and ice became so widespread that the Earth become much more reflective of solar radiation and cooled to a mean temperature of around -50 degrees Celsius. Glaciation was eventually terminated by the build-up of carbon dioxide emitted from volcanoes, that was not used up by the weathering of rocks since rocks were buried beneath the extensive snow and ice cover. Almost all facets of the Snowball Earth hypothesis, and of alternative hypotheses, are open to challenge, there is general agreement that glaciation reached tropical latitudes at sea level. New lines of evidence are needed to refresh the debates and constrain future modelling efforts. We have recently made a breakthrough through generating a new suite of chemical data on exceptionally well-preserved carbonate precipitates in saline glacial lakes in the allegedly Wilsonbreen Formation rocks of Svalbard thought to be the same age as glacial deposits found on all the continents and referred to as 'Marinoan'. Firstly we find that in terms of oxygen isotopes, these carbonates are the most evaporative yet discovered and so must have formed in a hyperarid environment. Secondly we use new discoveries about the meaning of the abundances of the isotope 17-O in relation to our measurements of stable sulphur isotope ratios in order to show that the atmosphere was profoundly different from that which existed during younger glaciations: the simplest explanation for it is that the atmosphere was very high in carbon dioxide. This implies that weathering was indeed inhibited by an extensive ice cover. This study and various previous studies have demonstrated the outstanding importance of the rock exposures in these remote locations to understanding this extraordinary event in Earth history - indeed they are the only place where we can find a chemical sedimentary record that allows us to understand conditions on the Earth surface and in the atmosphere. We propose to make two field expeditions that will enable us to fully describe and archive the field relationships and collect suites of samples that will enable us to understand more clearly the preserved evidence. We will use magnetic properties to reconstruct the palaeolatitude of the glacial deposits and will try to determine the age directly by radiometric methods to see if it is consistent with the 'Marinoan'. Our favoured modern analogue for the Wilsonbreen formation saline glacial lakes are found in the intensely cold McMurdo Dry Valleys of Antarctica. We will test this idea using physical properties of the sediment whilst the chemical properties will be used to constrain the how much water is cycled through the atmosphere, how oxidizing the atmosphere was and whether carbon dioxide had already built up in the atmosphere by the time the first glacial lakes formed. Our work will also extend to the apparently warm- and cool-climate marine deposits that are found above and below two glacial units in the Svalbard in order to understanding the broader context. and . Our work includes a number of new approaches as well as applying tried-and-tested modern methods of dating and magnetic analysis in a new area. We expect to emerge with a clear and vivid picture of the nature of the land surface during one of the most extreme cold events in the history of the planet. We will also find out whether this location could be the best place int he world to formal place a 'golden spike' at the base of the Cryogenian geological period. The information will be disseminated and archived in novel ways.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We attempted to date carbonate rocks associated with a 'snowball Earth' glaciation that occurred some 700 million years ago. Direct dating of carbonates is non-routine and the materials we analysed were not suitable for dating. This was always going to be a high-risk endeavor.
Exploitation Route No results were obtained that can be used to constrain the age of the sediments with an degree of increased confidence. A negative result.
Sectors Other

URL http://www.birmingham.ac.uk/research/activity/geosystems/projects/gains2010/index.aspx
 
Description EAR Division Of Earth Sciences
Amount $39,000 (USD)
Organisation National Science Foundation (NSF) 
Sector Public
Country United States
Start 06/2016 
End 05/2018
 
Description EAR Division Of Earth Sciences
Amount $20,000 (USD)
Funding ID 1323158 
Organisation National Science Foundation (NSF) 
Sector Public
Country United States
Start 01/2014 
End 12/2016
 
Description Geological time: we're on a roll! A contribution to Science in the Park 2023, part of British Science Week 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Blurb used to advertise the event: Have you ever wondered just how far back in time we can go? What about how long humans have been on the planet? Whilst we can't time travel (yet), we can use geology to give us a window into our planet's history to look for answers. Join us as we explore the vastness of geological time and put the history of Earth into perspective. We'll explore Earth's timeline starting with the formation of our planet 4.567 billion years ago and roll our way through time to the present day, stopping by key geological events such as the evolution of complex life 600 million years ago. Come and explore the major events in Earth's history, life on the planet and how we got to where we are today!

The purpose was to engage with the general public, to relate human and historical timescales to the longer timescales over which geological timescales operate.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://wollatonhall.org.uk/science-in-the-park/
 
Description Public Open day for the British Geological Survey - we contributed two activities: (1) Speed Dating; and (2) the Toilet Roll of Time. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact (1) Speed Dating - demonstrating U-Pb dating in real time, along with getting people into the sample prep and mass spectrometry laboratories;
(2) Toilet Roll of Time - an interactive demonstration that explored historical and geological timescales and included a 50 meter long time scale that illustrated the tempo of Earth's evolution.
~2000 people attended the event, a subset of whom interacted with our two activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2022
URL https://www.bgs.ac.uk/news/bgs-open-day-2022/