Re-inventing the planet: the Neoproterozoic revolution in oxygenation, biogeochemistry and biological complexity

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Earth Sciences

Abstract

The Earth is a truly remarkable planet. In addition to the physical processes driving plate tectonics, climate and ocean-atmospheric exchange, it supports an extraordinary diversity of living organisms, from microbes to mammals and everything in between. Such wasn't always the case, however, and it is clear that both the planet and its biosphere have evolved - indeed, co-evolved - over deep time. In the past two billion years, by far the most fundamental shift in this co-evolutionary process occurred during the Neoproterozoic (1000 to 542 million years ago), a planetary revolution that culminated in the modern Earth system. The Neoproterozoic begins with a biosphere populated almost exclusively by microbes, and ends in the midst of its greatest ever evolutionary radiation - including the diverse macroscopic and biomineralizing organisms that define the modern biosphere. At the same time, it witnessed the greatest climatic and biogeochemical perturbations that the planet has ever experienced, alongside major palaeogeographic reconfigurations and a deep ocean that is becoming oxygenated for the first time. There is no question that these phenomena are broadly interlinked, but the tangle of causes, consequences and co-evolutionary feedbacks has yet to be convincingly teased apart. In order to reconstruct the Neoproterozoic revolution, we propose a multidisciplinary programme of research that will capture its evolving geochemical and biological signatures in unprecedented detail. Most significantly, these collated data will be assessed and modeled in the context of a co-evolving Earth system, whereby developments in one compartment potentially facilitate and escalate those in another, sometimes to the extent of deriving entirely novel phenomena and co-evolutionary opportunities. Our approach will be guided by three general hypotheses, testable against accruing data and theory: H1) that the enhanced weathering associated with land-dwelling eukaryotes was initiated in the early Neoproterozoic leading to major environmental change, including extreme glaciations and stepwise increase(s) in atmospheric oxygen concentration; H2) that major environmental changes in the mid Neoproterozoic triggered the emergence of animals; and H3) that the late Neoproterozoic-Cambrian radiations of animals and biomineralization were themselves responsible for much of the accompanying biogeochemical perturbation. Primary data for this project will be assembled from field studies of key geological sections in the UK and North China, along with contributed sample sets from Namibia, Spitsbergen and various archived collections. Together, these offer close to comprehensive coverage of the Neoproterozoic - not least, spectacular new surfaces of Ediacaran macrofossils from Charnwood Forest. Collected samples will be analysed to assess associated weathering and climate (Sr, C, O and S isotopes), oceanic redox conditions (Fe speciation and trace metals), nutrient dynamics (P speciation and trace metals) and biological constituents (microfossils, macrofossils and biomarker molecules). These data will be integrated and interrogated through the development of heuristic, spatial and evolutionary models. Beyond its integrative approach, the strength of this proposal lies in the diversity of the contributing researchers. Alongside our own expertise in biogeochemistry, palaeobiology and Earth system modelling, we are very pleased to have attracted world-class project partners in Neoproterozoic stratigraphy, geochronology and biomarker analysis. Further insight will come from our contingent of two PDRAs and three PhD students working across the range of topics and linked via a schedule of regular team meetings. Taken together, we anticipate a fundamentally improved understanding of the Neoproterozoic Earth system and the co-evolutionary interplay between the biosphere and planet.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description PhD project on the Ediacaran fossils of Charnwood Forest currently in progess (Charlotte Kenchington): new taxa discovered and described; detailed analysis of the associated sedimentology

PhD project on Ediacaran microfossils from the Biskopas Formation of southern Norway currrently in progress (Peter Adamson): new taxa discovered and described; detailed analysis of associated sediments and phosphate diagenesis; follow-up work on comparable material from China

For the consortium as a whole, we have published a major synthesis paper integrating/modelling geochemical, palaeontological and Earth history data. Contrary to much conventional thinking, we find little evidence for rising atmospheric oxygen levels at the end of the Neoproterozoic

Geochemical analysis of sediments from between 1200 and 800 million years ago (with much of our primary data derived from consortium fieldwork in China) reveals a major change in the oxygen content of the oceans around 1000 million years ago, broadly coincident - possibly even causally connnected - with a change in fossil expression (Guilbaud et al. Nature Geoscience [in review].

March 2016 Update:
There has now been considerable progress with this project.

1) The Guilbaud et al. (2015) paper, documenting a major change in ocean chemistry near the Mesoproterozoic-Neoproterozoic boundary, has now been published in Nature Geoscience.

2) Charlotte Kenchington has just defended her PhD thesis, in which she describes a number of new Ediacaran taxa from Charnwood Forest (Leicestershire) and, more broadly, carries out some innovative statistical and sedimentological analyses that illuminate the ecology of these deeply enigmatic fossils. Some of this work has been published, and there are three other substantial manuscripts soon to be submitted for publication.

3) Peter Adamson is in the final year of his PhD work and is writing up both his thesis and manuscripts for publication. His discovery of Ediacaran microfossils in the carbonate infill of the Biskopas Conglomerate (southern Norway) has revealed a significant new source of palaeobiological information, with important palaeobiological implications; he is planning to submit a ms to _Geology_ within the next month. Other manuscripts will focus on the taxonomy and biostratigraphic applications of this increasingly rich microfossil biota, along with comparative studies based in South China and Oman.

March 2017 update:
1) Romain Guilbaud has moved on to a faculty position at the University of Lancaster

2) Charlotte Kenchington has moved on to a post-doctoral position at the Memorial University of Newfoundland, and has published a paper from her PhD thesis

3) Peter Adamson has recently defended his PhD thesis, and is working up chapters for publication

March 2019 update:

1) Charlotte Kenchington has moved on to a post-doctoral position at the University of Cambridge and has blished a number of high-imact papers from her thesis
Exploitation Route Our results will be used primarily by Earth scientists and evolutionary biologists interested in the the evolution of the modern Earth System. The statistical and sedimentological approach developed by Kenchington is likely to be adopted more broadly as a means of understanding the relationship of Ediacaran macrofossils to their environment. Likewise, Peter Adamson's discovery of a rich microfossil biota within the interstices of the Biskopas Conglomerate points to an important new source of palaeontological data.
Sectors Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description This grant is part-funding two research students, both of whom are studying aspects of Ediacaran (latest Neoproterozoic) palaeobiology. Charlotte Kenchington will be finishing up in April 2015; Peter Adamson in December 2015. Both have presented their research at several national and international meetings and are gaining well deserved reputations as experts in this relatively crowded field. At the consortium level, we published a major synthesis of Neoproterozoic Earth history in Nature Geoscience (Lenton et al. 2014), modelling the feedbacks between tectonics, biological evolution and oxgen availabilty to understand the origins of the modern Earth system. The significance of this paper has already been noted at international meetings. We also have another ms currently in review with Nature Geoscience (lead author Romain Guilbaud). In this study we document important changes in marine redox chemistry near the beginning of the Neoproterozoic, and discuss its implications for the subsequent evolution of eukaryotes. Update: March 2016 Charlotte Kenchington has just defended her thesis, and Peter Adamason is in the process of writing up. Update: March 2017 Charlotte Kenchington is now a post-doc at Memorial University of Newfoundland; Peter Adamson has successfully defended his thesis Update: March 2019 Peter Adamson has submitted a major chapter of his PhD thesis for publication in Precambrian Research. He has moved on to a job in academic publishing
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Education,Energy,Environment
Impact Types Cultural