Understanding the impact of severe wildfires on moorland carbon dynamics

Lead Research Organisation: University of Glasgow
Department Name: School of Interdisciplinary Studies

Abstract

The spring of 2011 saw an unprecedented number of large wildfires break out across the length and breadth of the UK. These fires were associated with a prolonged period of unusually warm and dry weather that led to flammable vegetation, dry peat soils and the potential for severe ecological impacts. Wildfires can cause significant damage to ecosystem function, particularly in areas of high severity where ground-level layers of moss and peat deposits are extensively heated or ignited. Smouldering combustion in layers of peat releases significant amounts of fossil carbon and can have a profound effect on total UK emmissions. Smoulering and extensive soil heating also destroys belowground plant structures and soil seedbanks leading to fundamental changes in patterns of plant and wildlife biodiversity, the loss of moorland habitats and a potential imbalance between the carbon lost from burnt vegetation and that which can be sequesterd by regeneration. Severe fires are also associated with a range of other environmental impacts such as increased soil erosion. Despite the serious environmental consequences of such impacts, almost all of the scientific knowledge of the impacts of moorland wildfires comes from a single event some 35 years ago. There is increasing concern about potential feedbacks between climate, fire frequency, fire severity and carbon fluxes from peatlands. For this reason there is an urgent need to ensure we develop sustainable management practices with regards to moorland biodiversity and carbon stores. This research will play an important role in beginning to fill this fundamental knowledge gap on the impacts of wildfires on UK moorlands. We will visit and assess the immediate impact of recent severe wildfires across the UK, and collect data to allow an initial comparison to be made of the effects of varying burn severities on the above and below ground carbon balance and ecosystem functioning of moorlands. We will map the perimeter of recent wildfires and the distribution of broad classes of fire severity. In areas of differing severity we will make estimates of the total amount of carbon lost from the system due to combustion and assess differences in vegetation regeneration and carbon fluxes from peat in burnt and unburnt plots. By establishing a network of permanent plots, the project will also create a valuable scientific resource that will allow us to track ecosystem change over time and provide a focus for future research.

Planned Impact

There is a broad consensus among fire scientists and land-managers that there is a research gap relating to fire, biodiversity and carbon cycling in moorlands on peat soils. This community engages both non-academic and academic stakeholders to address fire issues, and as such, is helping to drive science and address societal needs in tandem. Our pathways to impact will therefore address both non-academic and academic stakeholders simultaneously and aims to involve as many of these groups as possible.

The beneficiaries of the research include: members of the fire service, natural resource managers, statutory agencies, government policy makers, non-governmental organisations, the game industry and researchers of climate, biogeochemistry, and ecology. We are fortunate in having a well developed network of contacts in the fire science community (e.g. both PI and Co-I were involved in the 'FIRES' ESRC/NERC Transdisciplinary Research Seminars) and will seek to exploit these links.

Apart from the impacts to biodiversity and carbon cycling, there is also a financial cost associated with extinguishing wildfires, with productivity lost as a result of these burns and a cost associated with restoring burnt areas. This research will contribute to the understanding of the processes involved in wildfire events and has the potential to identify mitigating effects thus helping to reduce costs to fire services and land-managers. This research will provide societal benefits, contribute to the evidence base, and help in the formulation of policy and best practice by providing data on:
1. How fire management and wildfire influence the capacity for moorlands to sequester C and mitigate climate change.
2. Whether wildfire in moorlands decreases or increases biodiversity.
3. Whether managed fire can be used to mitigate increased severe wildfire risk due to climate change
4. The impacts of fire on moorland biodiversity and C cycling.
5. Fire regulating processes.
6. GHG fluxes in relation to fire.
The project will also provide a geo-referenced resource for scientists to quantify future vegetation succession and carbon cycling.

We will share and disseminate our findings through a range of mechanisms and activities, including:
1. Already established mechanisms e.g. Scottish and English Wildfire Forums, FireBeaters etc. that consists of key stakeholders (e.g. Fire service, land managers, SNH, NE, Forest Research, GCWT, DEFRA, SEPA and representatives of local community organisations).
2. Use established interactive websites e.g. FireBeaters; which can host data, a calendar of events, news highlights of key findings, and an interactive forum.
3. Wide circulation of research findings in the format of a summary for policymakers
4. Periodic review meetings; to facilitate on-going communication among end-users and investigators.
5. Presentation at national and international conferences and seminars to disseminate our findings to a broad, multidisciplinary group (non-academic and academic).
 
Description We surveyed the environmental consequences of six recent peatland wildfires. We developed a semi-quantitative methology that allowed us to assess fire severity after the event.

Fire severity varied significantly both within and between individual fires. Interestingly average severity varied up to two-fold between fires but as much as three-fold within some fires.

There was a significant degree of variation in fuel consumption. Consumption varied significantly between plots within fires but there was limited evidence of a significance difference in average consumption between fires.

Substantial differences were recorded in average soil temperature between burnt and unburnt plots. Day-night temperature fluctuations in burnt plots were frequently more than twice that seen in unburnt plots. This has significant implications for modelling the lostt of carbon from peatland soils.

Both carbon dioxoide and methane production were noticeably different between burnt and unburnt plots but substantial differences also existed between different fires. Methane fluxes were consistently lower on burnt sites whilst carbon dioxide fluxes were generally higher.
Exploitation Route Intense fire behaviour in the shrub and grass fuels that dominate the British uplands has distracted attention from what appears to be the critical issue - the structure and moisture content of ground fuels. Our work lends support to suggestions that a useful wildland fire dangaer rating system, that forecasts the potential for damaging wildfires, could be developed if models of fuel moisture content can be developed. Such models do already exist and would only need adjustment/ground-truthing for use in peatland conditions
Sectors Environment

URL http://fireregimes.org.uk/index.html
 
Description Use of the results of our study are current at an early date as preparation of our data for formal publication is still in progress. Our work has, however, been presented a number of scientific and stakeholder events and has attracted considerable interest. This has led to the PI being invited to give keynote addresses at recent and forthcoming conferences. The Project PI has also been invited to usse his expertise to help inform the on-going review of prescribed burning regulations in Scotland as well as to provide advice and input to the work of the Scottish, and England and Wales, Wildfire forums. Research on peatland carbon dynamics in response to wildfire is at a comparatively early stage globally and the work stemming from this project has attracted international interest. We anticipate that our work will continue to inform attitudes to the sustainable use of fire on peatlands and the importance of managing fire impacts with respect to the carbon cycle. Nationally the work helps oush forward the argument that a system to forecast the potential for damaging wildfires could be developed with only moderate research investment.
First Year Of Impact 2011
Sector Environment
Impact Types Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Review of Muirburn guidelines
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
Impact I have provided evidence to the Scottish-government's on-going review or prescribed burnign regulations. Advice provided will leave to the safer and more sustainable application of managed burning to peatland habitats in the U.K.
 
Description Kelvin Smith PhD Scholarhsip
Amount £55,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Glasgow 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2012 
End 09/2016
 
Title Peatland Composite Burn Index 
Description We developed a modified version of the Composite Burn Index (CBI). The CBI was developed in the USA to provide a semi-quantitative means to assess the severity of wildfires. The method records fire impacts on multiple ecological strata including the forest canopy, surface vegetation and soil. We have produced and tested a version that accounts for the treeles character of many temperate and boreal ecosystems and which pays particular attention to fire impacts on peat forming species such as Sphagnum. The method has been successfully used to characerise the effects of a number of wildfires in the U.K. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2012 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Six separate wildfire case studies have been characterised using this method. CBI-derived fire severity has been linked to variation in fire weather conditions and subsequent ecological changes including soil carbon dyanamics and vegetation regeneration. 
 
Title Wildfire Case-study Database 
Description We have collected in-depth information on the ecosystem effects of multiple severe wildfires that have burnt peatlands in the U.K. Information included in the database consists of: fire severity (as assessed by the Peatland CBI methodology); fuel consumption; soil CO2 and CH4 fluxes; post-fire soil temperarture dynamics; vegetation regeneration (presence/absence of all vascular plants, mosses and liverworts). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact A number of publications are currently in preparation using data contained in this database. Data has already formed the basis of a number of presentations and scientific conferences. To our knowledge this is the most complete and wide-ranging set of information collected on peatland wildfires in northern-Europe. 
 
Description BES Presentation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Useful discussions with potential reserch collaborators
Important career development opportnity for project Post-Doc (who presented)

Increase in potential for research collaboration
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description Knowledge for Wildfire talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Discussion and debate with a wide range of stakeholders relevant to peatland fire management

Talk has precipitated renewed interest in researching controls on fire behaviour and severity in the U.K.
A number of collaborative research bids have been prepared as a result
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.kfwf.org.uk/_assets/documents/launch_event_at_wildfire.pdf
 
Description Participation in FRISK-GO 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Discussion centred on developing arguments and evidence to create a European Forest Risk Facility

On-going collaboration and discussion with FRISK members.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.friskgo.org/
 
Description Seminar ar Ohio State University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact General discussion about approaches to researching fire effects and carbon dynamocs

No notable impacts
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
URL http://presenter.cfaes.ohio-state.edu/utz.15/Wildfire_severity_and_carbon_dynamics_in_the_British_up...
 
Description Stakeholder Conference - Wildfire 2013 
Form Of Engagement Activity Scientific meeting (conference/symposium etc.)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation paper presentation
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Considerable interest in research from practioner colleagues. Stimulating discussions. Further research proposal currently in preparation.
Added to evidence supporting calls for a wildlandfire danger rating system that can forecast the ecologically-damaging fire weather conditions.

A number of research proposals have been submitted. This has allowed collaboration with new partners including the University of Manchester, CEH, and SUERC.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.ruraldevelopment.org.uk/wildfire/wildfire-details/wildfire-2013-presentations/