BRITICE

Lead Research Organisation: British Antarctic Survey
Department Name: Science Programmes

Abstract

Recent satellite measurements of the Earth's polar ice sheets highlight that changes in ice extent and thickness are occurring at rates far higher than expected. The challenge for researchers is to place these observations into a longer-term context and produce computer models ('ice sheet forecasts') that reliably predict the fate of ice sheets over this century and beyond. Although remote from habitation, the polar ice sheets influence global sea level. Retreat by increased melting and iceberg calving produces higher sea levels and concerns exist that sea level may rise by metres displacing many millions of people, and their livelihoods, from their coastal homes. At this point in time, it is not possible to study the full life cycle of the present Antarctic or Greenland ice sheets as they are still evolving and undergoing large-scale changes. Instead, we will use an ice sheet that has now fully retreated; the ice sheet that covered most of Britain, Ireland and the North Sea during the last ice age.

The last British-Irish ice sheet covered up to 1,000,000 km2 at its maximum size, around 25,000 yrs ago, and was relatively small by global standards. However, its character, setting and behaviour have striking parallels with both the modern West Antarctic and Greenland Ice Sheets. Large parts of the British-Irish Ice Sheet were marine-influenced just like in west Antarctica today; and numerous fast-flowing ice streams carried much of its mass, just like in the Greenland Ice Sheet today. All three are or were highly dynamic, in climatically sensitive regions, with marine sectors, ocean-terminating margins and land-based glaciers. All these common factors make the British-Irish Ice Sheet a powerful analogue for understanding ice sheet dynamics on a range of timescales, operating now and in the future.

Recent work by members of this consortium has revealed the pattern of ice sheet retreat that once covered the British Isles, as recorded by end moraines and other glacial landforms. Other work by members of this consortium has used sophisticated computer models to simulate the ice sheet's response to climate change at the end of the last Ice Age. However, these models can only be as good as the geological data on which they are based, and the pattern is poorly constrained in time. We need to know more about the style, rate and timing of ice sheet decay in response to past climate change. Such knowledge allows us to further refine computer modelling so that better predictions can be made. The main focus of the project therefore, is to collect sediments and rocks deposited by the last ice sheet that covered the British Isles, and use these, along with organic remains, to date (e.g. by radiocarbon analyses) the retreat of the ice sheet margins. The project will use over 200 carefully chosen sites, dating some 800 samples in order to achieve this. Offshore, samples will be extracted using coring devices lowered from a research ship to the seabed, and onshore by manual sampling and by use of small drilling rigs. Once the samples are dated and added to the pattern information provided by the landforms, maps of the shrinking ice sheet will be produced. These will provide crucial information on the timing and rates of change across the whole ice sheet. The British-Irish Ice Sheet will become the best constrained anywhere in the world and be the benchmark against which ice sheet models are improved and tested in the future.

Knowledge on the character and age of the seafloor sediments surrounding the British Isles is also useful for many industrial, archaeological and heritage applications. Accordingly, the project is closely linked to partners interested, for example, in locating offshore windfarms, electricity cables between Britain and Ireland, and heritage bodies aiming to preserve offshore archaeological remains.

Planned Impact

The key tenet of Britice-CHRONO is addressing the concerns of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) about the ability to predict rates of change and the dynamics of collapsing ice sheets. Numerical ice sheet models are capable of prediction, but they need further developing and crucially, validating against the pattern and timings of shrinking ice sheets. We lack the observations and relevant duration of evidence from contemporary ice sheets and an analogue from the past is a more achievable target. We aim to provide the World's best reconstruction of ice sheet (IS) demise across the transition from marine-terminating to entirely land-based using the now-disappeared British-Irish Ice Sheet (BIIS). Thus our key contribution, during years 4-5, is providing modellers with the reconstructions necessary to develop and test the purportedly-leading IS models to assess the impacts of iceberg calving, tidal regime, grounding line dynamics and ice stream mechanics in governing rapid ice sheet retreat. The end game is to improve predictions for the possible rapid collapse of sites of global significance (e.g. West Antarctica and Greenland). This research will improve the evidence base from which IPCC advises the 194 member countries about future environmental and socio-economic impacts arising from IS collapse and the associated threats from atmosphere-ocean-ice interactions. The increased credibility of such a coupled predictive model, via Britice-CHRONO and other ongoing research, will hopefully kick-start mitigation procedures in areas vulnerable to sea level change and support-mechanisms for areas with limited resources to react instantaneously to climate change-related natural disasters.

Britice-CHRONO will collate and collect geological and geomorphological data both on- and offshore around Britain and Ireland, with the associated interpretation of the area's deglacial and postglacial history. Britice-CHRONO will thus generate information of considerable benefit to marine and terrestrial industries, conservation agencies responsible for Bio- and Geodiversity, and the heritage environment (HE). Britice-CHRONO's outcomes will also allow for a more cost-effective design for the various phases of development projects (e.g. Aggregates, Power Infrastructure, Renewable Energy), as explained in the Impact Plan.

Britice-CHRONO research will also benefit both terrestrial and marine bio- and geo-diversity, and enable Natural England (NE), Countryside Council for Wales (CCW), Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) to meet some of their marine obligations. The research would help in identifying new conservation sites and improving understanding of existing protected sites both on- and off-shore. The proposal also aligns with significant marine Historic Environment (HE) elements of English Heritage and Historic Scotland's plans for heritage protection. The interplay of deglaciation and a marine ice margin will inform archaeologists and the HE community about the position of the coast and extent of terrestrial environments during a period with rapidly changing sea levels. The research will aid understanding of the environments available to early human communities and thereby inform management of HE assets across the present land-sea boundary.

Reading stories preserved in the landscape has contributed significantly to popular culture of late, with landmark television series such as Coast, and the British Isles: a natural history and the Making of Scotland's Landscape. The research proposed would reveal the seldom seen glacial heritage preserved on Britain and Ireland's seascape, and shows the scale and dynamic magnitude of changes that affected these islands during the last deglaciation. This understanding of the pattern and controls on ice sheet decline has considerable potential for raising literacy and enthusiasm about science, the natural environment and global change issues, especially for children and the general public.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Over the past two or three decades sonar soundings have provided a detailed bathymetry of the seas surrounding Great Britain and Ireland. In the northern part, these measurements clearly indicate glacial activity extending to the continental shelf edge, arising from the expansion and contraction of the British and Irish Ice Sheet (BIIS). These data led to a successful NERC consortium bid, with two cruises being funded. The results from these cruises clearly show the retreat of an ice-sheet, either with a marine terminus in the deeper parts or a land-based terminus in the remainder.

The results will be used to interpret how a dynamical instability, the 'grounding line instability' led to the BIIS waxing and waning in response to glacial climatic changes. The plausibly unstable retreat of the BIIS, driven by the warming occurring at the end of the last glacial has led to concerns that warming due to increased CO2 may force the Antarctic and Greenland ice-sheets to retreat. We have been carrying out modelling to determine the extent to which the grounding-line retreat is due to external forcing or to internal ice-sheet instabilities.

Such retreat will raise sea-levels, maybe by as much as 1 m in CE 2100, and by somewhat greater amounts over longer time-scales. In London, for example, this will result in the one-in-a-thousand year flood becoming very much more frequent, perhaps recurring on a centurial basis.

We will present up-to-date bathymetries from around Great Britain and Ireland, illustrating glacial activity. We will also present calculations of grounding-line retreat and the use of these to predict Antarctic ice-sheet retreat in the future.
Exploitation Route These data can be used by
(i) glacial geologists to refine their ideas about BIIS retreat
(ii) by solid-earth geophysicists to understand the current uplift patterns in Great Britain and Ireland
(iii) by applied mathematicians seeking to model ice-sheets past, present and future
Sectors Environment

 
Description BRITICE has been widely publicised since it has been a very successful project
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Title Determining contribution of internal instabilities and external forcing to ice-stream formation and geometry 
Description Ice streams were identified in the Antarctic ice-sheet in the 1970s, and seen to have existed in the former Northern Hemisphere ice-sheets in the 1980s. They are between 20km and 100km wide and 100-300 km long. It is clear that ice-sheet thermodynamics can cause these streams to arise spontaneously within certain parameter ranges (accumulation rate, geothermal flux, bed slipperiness), and it is also very clear that external forcing can determine where the streams form. We (me and Gisela Hiess) are running ice-sheet models to evaluate the respective role of internal instabilities and external forcing. So far, neither has been shown to have a dominating effect. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2012 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Studies in the BRITICE project have shown that ice-streams existed in locations surrounding Ireland and Great Britain, and that certain aspects of their dynamics remain unexplained. We have shown that internal instabilities may have played a role in the dynamics of such streams. 
 
Title Generation of large internal plumes in ice-sheets that emanate from the base 
Description In the past decade ice-penetrating radars have identified large plumes within ice-sheets that emanate from the bed. These plumes are up to 1 km thick and 20 km long. There are three separate theories regarding their origin. We (Carlos Martin BAS, Gwendolyn Leysinger Vieli and Martin Luethi Zurich University) are interested in the idea that they are caused by freeze-on in locations where water is flowing uphill. My personal contribution is providing software to solve the advection equation in flowing ice, in order to understand how the geometry of the plumes evolves. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Publication in 2018 in Nature Communications lead authored by Leysinger Vieli. 
 
Title Modelling ice-sheet grounding-line migration 
Description In the 1970s several papers were published pointing out that if ice-flux across the grounding-line (the origin of the floating ice-shelf) increased with ice thickness, then grounding-lines situated on locations where the bed deepened up-glacier (has a 'reverse slope'), the situation was potentially unstable. For example, a small retreat of the grounding line would increase ice-flux, causing the ice-sheet to lose volume and induce further retreat of the grounding line. In contrast, a small advance would reduce ice-flux, allowing the ice-sheet to gain volume and result in more advance. These ideas had to wait until 2007 before they were given a rigorous mathematical footing by Schoof. Schoof gave a formula for flux as a function of thickness, which allowed the testing of numerical models. Two model intercomparisons have been carried out, both lead-authored by Frank Pattyn, with DOI's 10.5194/tc-6-573-2012 and 10.3189/2013JoG12J129. Richard Hindmarsh participated in these intercomparisons. We now have greatly increased confidence in the ability of numerical models to accurately compute grounding-line migration. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2012 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Greatly increased confidence in the numerical simulations of grounding line motion. 
 
Title Questions about ice dynamics formulated on the basis of newly acquired data 
Description The large group of earth scientists involved in investigating the palaeo-Antarctic Ice-Sheet (p-AIS) and palaeo-British-Irish Ice-Sheet (p-BIIS) has quite naturally led them to think about ice dynamical explanations for their observations. Nearly all of their conjectures and questions are well thought-through, which ultimately create questions for ice dynamicists and modellers to answer. We are improving and amending models to focus on these questions. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact There are several different groups working on the p-AIS and p-BIIS, all aiming to make use of the new data. These groups talk with each other, but are all interested in different aspects of the behaviour of the ice-sheet. 
 
Description BRITICE 
Organisation University of Sheffield
Department Department of Geography
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution BRITICE is a collaborative effort amongst many UK institutions, gaining and analysing data relevant to the time-dependent coverage of the British and Irish Ice Sheets over the North Sea and Norwegian Sea. These data are anticipated to be able to constrain ice-sheet models, coupled with models of other components of the Earth System. Hindmarsh (BAS) will supervise the running of these models.
Collaborator Contribution BRITICE are gathering and analysing the data from both geophysical cruises and land-based studies.
Impact The data have been gathered and but require further analysis before the modelling can commence. The two cruises funded have been carried out. Journal of Quaternary Science 36(5), 2021 contains a collection of papers, with the lead paper written by the six members of the Steering Group - Clark, C.D., R.C. Chiverrell, D. Fabel, R.C.A. Hindmarsh, C. Ó Cofaigh and J.D. Scourse, (2021), "Timing, pace and controls on ice sheet retreat; the BRITICE-CHRONO transect reconstructions of the British-Irish Ice Sheet", J. Quat. Sci., 36(5) Special Issue: BRITICE-CHRONO reconstructions of the last British-Irish Ice Sheet, 673-680, doi:10.1002/jqs.3326. The volume URL is https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/toc/10991417/2021/36/5
Start Year 2013
 
Description Durham LGM Antarctica 
Organisation Durham University
Department Department of Geography
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution BAS have organised the data gathering, geophysical surveying of ice-rises by radar-techniques. We can use these data to date the retreat of the main Antarctic grounding line. These ice-rises are located within the Ronne Ice Shelf.
Collaborator Contribution The project is ongoing - Durham have committed to using the data to model the behaviour of the Antarctic ice-sheet since the Last Glacial Maximum.
Impact BAS have completed the geophysical surveys. The data are due to be shared; once this occurs, Durham will use the data, in conjunction with other data they have acquired and models, to constrain the behaviour of the West Antarctic ice-sheet in the Weddell Sea area. BAS will contribute by collaborating on the organisation of the modelling studies.
Start Year 2013
 
Title BASISM - the BAS Ice Sheet Model 
Description BASISM has been developed over the past fifteen years, and has achieved successes in formal model intercomparison projects (MIPs), as well as being used to settle some long-standing problems. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2013 
Impact This software (and its brethren) have been used in MIPs to validate theoretical advances in grounding-line motion/stability and ice-stream formation. 
 
Description Modelling panel for BRITICE, for groups both internal and external to the main BRITICE project 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The new data acquired by BRITICE from the North, Norwegian and Celtic Seas shows very clearly that the British-Irish Ice Sheet (BIIS) was a marine ice-sheet. The stability of such ice sheets is a major concern, since Antarctica is a marine ice-sheet and its observed retreat threatens to raise global sea-level by between 0.5m and 2m by 2100 CE. The quantity of new data points means the the BIIS is the most well-described marine ice-sheet, and already these data are illuminating issues of marine ice-sheet stability.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014,2015,2016,2017,2018