A cross-disciplinary soil-proteomics and modelling approach for predicting switches between hydrophilic and hydrophobic soil surface responses

Lead Research Organisation: Plymouth University
Department Name: Sch of Geog Earth & Environ Sciences

Abstract

A strange property of many soils is that they do not readily wet on contact with rain, which has many implications for soil management. Although these soils may not be especially hydrophobic, wetting is slower than would be inferred from the sizes of their pores. This property is usually defined as sub-critical water repellency. Where water repellency is high (critical repellency), it causes ponding of water at soil surfaces. Water repellency affects the routes through which water and dissolved or suspended chemicals drain through the soil profile, leading to preferential surface run-off, infiltration paths resulting in serious erosion events, and flooding.
Soil water repellency may be influenced by both natural and man-made events. It is known that cycles of heating and drying (amongst many other factors) may produce quite dramatic changes in this soil property. Soil water repellency results from interactions between microbial activity and physico-chemical structure, but their complexity is such that at present they are only understood on an empirical and anecdotal basis. The purpose of this project is to develop a theoretical basis to understand soil water repellency and to predict some of its consequences. The practical implications of such an understanding are profound and widespread, since they may guide land management practice and flood prevention.
The three soils selected for study will be; (i) Malvern Hill clay loam, found in a previous study to exhibit extreme hydrophobicity under moderately moist summer conditions and also following air-drying in the laboratory, (ii) Gower silt loam, used in our NERC-funded proof-of-concept proteomics study and found to display up to medium levels of hydrophobicity, and (iii) Rothamsted Research Park Grass plot 3 silt loam, presently the subject of the large-scale soil metagenomic sequencing project 'Terragenome', and subcritically hydrophobic.
Soil water content will be adjusted to (i) just above and (ii) just below the Critical Soil-water Content, i.e. the content at which there is a transition between hydrophobic and hydrophilic behaviour. Further perturbations will include further drying at different temperatures to water contents simulating soil conditions that may be experienced during extreme drought periods, which are likely to cause further increases in hydrophobicity.
Information relating to water repellency will be obtained by the examination of soil properties at various scales of size (from nanometres to centimetres). We will establish the role of proteins in the development of water repellency using metaproteomics and specific hydrophobic protein isolation approaches. Atomic force microscopy (AFM), only recently applied to soil particles, will be used to examine their surface geography, hardness, stickiness and water repellency at this small scale. This technique combined with laser scanning microscopic techniques will be used to examine the water repellency of soil microbial proteins labelled with fluorescent dyes. Water repellency at two coarser scales will be examined using a water contact angle technique and penetration times using very small drops of water.
These estimates of water repellency and soil particle properties will be incorporated into a detailed computer model of soil structure, which will be used to predict the consequences of water repellency at the decimeter scale in soil, and will be compared with laboratory measurements of the wettability of cores of a few centimeters in diameter.
When the model is calibrated and validated, we will be able to use it, together with the experimental data, to predict how the perturbations change wettability. These effects will be incorporated into an existing climate model used by the Met Office, called JULES, so that predictions can be made about the likely effect of climate change. Then we will be able to suggest ways to manage UK and other soils to minimize run-off, erosion and flood risk.

Planned Impact

The project has many facets, from strictly basic research contributions to more pragmatic environmental management applications on a landscape scale. Therefore the beneficiaries of our efforts will range widely and include: fellow scientists, water quality managers, soil, environmental and materials scientists, irrigation and global change specialists, environmentally sustainable materials manufacturers and the general public.
A prime beneficiary is the MetOffice, who maintain and develop further the simulation package JULES (Joint UK Land Environment Simulator). The MetOffice is interested in incorporating into JULES a new climate-dependent hydrology module based on our project's parametrised output. This will enable JULES to better predict climate change-induced soil hydrological changes at the catchment and regional scale, including estimating the risks of flooding and runnoff, which will be of benefit to those concerned with larger scale land management and with global climate change.
The PoreXpert model (www.porexpert.com) is being extensively tested by 5 disparate users prior to release. Current industrial applications include the characterisation of graphite porosity to enable the longer safe running of the UK's AGR nuclear power stations, ultra high speed ink-jet paper coatings, and filter efficiency prediction. Wide academic interest is shown by 3 academic sales 3 months before its release date. Novel proteins could also be used for innovations in materials sciences.
Soil and environmental scientists, irrigation specialists and water quality managers will benefit from the better understanding in underlying molecular-level processes by offering a better prospect for developing methods of ameliorating and reducing the adverse effect of soil hydrophobicity on site productivity and environmental degradation.
The wider life and soil science community will benefit through gaining an understanding of which elements of the entire genetic potential of one of the tested soils (Rothamsted Grass plot 3) is expressed under different climatic conditions via functional ecosystems genomics by comparing our metaproteomic datasets with the publicly available metagenomic data sets from the Metasoil project.
Other beneficiaries includes the specific landowners of our sites of study (National Trust and Rothamsted Research), but other landowners, local/regional/national authorities (eg Water industry, Environment Agency, SEPA, Defra), farmers and their organisations (eg Potato Council) may also benefit, via gaining a better insight of environmental conditions that liely induce hydrophobicity and its potential impacts, for improvement of, eg monitoring policies. Other beneficiaries such as managers and specialists dealing with irrigation and water transmission and quality, especially passage of fertilisers and other amendments into and through the soil, will benefit from project results at the particulate-core scale. The rapid transfer of solutes from amendments via 'finger flow' in repellent soils, adversely affects water quality by faster movement of nutrients and contaminants into the groundwater. The quality of waterways is also affected by soil hydrophobicity through increased overland drainage of soil and nutrients via surface runoff, especially after periods of intense precipitation. More complete insight to movement of these contaminants could lead to more efficient application of soil management practices which would minimise the adverse environmental consequences of soil repellency.
The general public is also a likely beneficiary through a better understanding and interpretation of their environment and the phenomena occuring within it (eg water infiltration issues).
The UK will also benefit from the project through professional training and skills base development of the PDRAs. They will experience working in an interdisciplinary project, with close links to non-academic organisations, with many networking opportunities.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This project has involved a study of soil hydrophobicity - i.e. when soil is or becomes water-repellent. The detrimental impacts of soil hydrophobicity include increased runoff, erosion and flooding, reduced biomass production, inefficient use of irrigation water and preferential leaching of pollutants. Its impacts may exacerbate flood risk associated with more extreme drought and precipitation events predicted with UK climate change scenarios. We have studied soil hydrophobicity over length scales ranging from atomic through molecular, core and landscape scale. Our project set out to prove whether changes in soil protein abundance and localization, induced by variations in soil moisture and temperature, are major driving forces for transitions between hydrophobic and hydrophilic conditions at soil particle surfaces. Three soils were chosen based on the severity of hydrophobicity that can be achieved in the field: severe to extreme (Cefn Bryn, Gower, Wales), intermediate to severe (National Botanical Garden, Wales), and subcritical (Park Grass, Rothamsted Research near London). The latter is already highly characterised so was also used as a control. Hydrophobic/ hydrophilic transitions were measured from water drop penetration times. We have made scientific advances in the following five areas:
(i) the identification of soil proteins, including key hydrophobic proteins, by proteomic methods, using a novel separation method which reduces interference by humic acids, and allows identification by ESI and MALDI TOF mass spectrometry and database searches,
(ii) the examination of such proteins, which form ordered hydrophobic ridges, and measurement of their elasticity, stickiness and hydrophobicity at nano- to microscale using atomic force microscopy adapted for the rough surfaces of soil particles,
(iii) the novel use of a picoliter goniometer to show hydrophobic effects at a 1 um diameter droplet level, which avoids the averaging over soil cores and particles evident in microliter goniometry, with which the results are compared,
(iv) measurements at core scale using water retention and wicking experiments, and
(v) the interpretation, integration and upscaling of the results using a development of the PoreXpert void network model, a significant advance on the Van Genuchten approach.
Exploitation Route The project has not yet finished. During the planned remaining active time of the project, the results will be incorporated into the JULES hydrological model of the UK Meteorological Office, used to predict flooding for different soil types and usage. All of the key findings within this project provide an important base for further research into soil hydrophobicity at different length scales, and of ways of understanding the interplay of the effects at these different scales, both through an understanding of the processes, and how they upscale, and also by the use of scalable models. The input to JULES will generate direct societal impact, in that it will refine the Met Office forecasting of flood likelihood under moderate rainfall conditions.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

URL http://www.swr-switch-model.com/home.html
 
Title Quantitative nanomechanical atomic force microscopy methodology for soil 
Description Trialled QNM-AFM on different soil types, established how to avoid creation of artefact images/data, data processing 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact A manuscript describing the methodology is in preparation and will be submitted for publication to enable other groups to use. A manuscript on the opportunities QNM-AFM offers to soil and microbial sciences has been published in 2016. 
URL http://www.microbiologysociety.org/publication/past-issues/future-tech.html
 
Description Departmental seminar at University of Groningen, Netherlands Dec 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Discussions on microbiology studies over magnitudes of scale in soil.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Keynote Address MMEG2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact ~70 delegates of mostly early-career microbial ecologists attended the annual MMEG meeting held at Newcastle University in Jan 2017 to learn about novel methods and approaches in microbial ecology, which resulted in great discussions afterwards and changed perceptions of studies over magnitudes of scale. Afterwards an invitation for a departmental seminar was received.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Oral presentation Biohydrology 2016 conference on AFM in soil 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presented to conference on AFM in soil, many questions afterwards sparking discussions, afterwards requests made for new collaborations and invitations to speak at EGU.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Seminar for own department 2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Overview of project presented to department, sparked discussions, and initiated plans for new proposal development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description poster presentation at Soil Metagenomics conference Dec 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Poster presented on soil metaproteomics to delegates at various career stages, influencing their perceptions on possibilities and approaches in soil ecology and microbiology.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016