From evaluation to licencing of low-cost miniature conductivity temperature and dissolved oxygen sensor technology

Lead Research Organisation: National Oceanography Centre
Department Name: Science and Technology

Abstract

Measuring water parameters is required in many industries and in environmental science. The most widely measured and required parameters are temperature, salinity and dissolved oxygen. These measurements are used in multiple applications such as weather forcasting, climate modelling, water quality assessment, sewage processing and aquaculture. In many cases a high precision measurement and continuous data is required. Commercial sensors with high performance have delivered this data and have enabled dramatic advances in these fields. However, they are expensive (~$10000) and large preventing widespread use in high density data collection systems. Smaller and cheaper ($500) sensors are available, but currently are not sufficiently accurate or precise for many applications.

The University of Southampton and the National Oceanography Centre have developed a unique ultra miniature high-precision salinity temperature and dissolved oxygen sensor for water analysis. These parameters are all measured on a small glass chip (8 x 10 mm) with patterned metal tracks to form the sensors. Salinity is calculated from a combination of temperature and conductivity measured with four micro electrodes in contact with the water. This chip is plugged into custom made electronics that operates the chip and stores the data and communicates with the outside world. The total sensor system is the size of a marker pen.

The technology has significant market potential (estimated $420M at 2011 rates) and has received significant commercial interest. However, the current barrier to commercialisation is a technical problem with long term stability. This is only 0.016 C in three months, but many applications require only 0.001 C stability over 3 months.

We have identified that the source of the problem as water uptake which causes swelling (1.6% by volume) of the polymer that we use to package and insulate the metal tracks. This swelling causes the chip and metal track sensors to bend or elongate over time causing the drift. This affects the temperature and conductivity measurement and hence the salinity accuracy.

The solution is to replace the polymer insulator with a hard and water resistant material such as Silicon Oxide. Silicon oxide is widely used in electronics where very thin (100 nm, one ten thousandth of a millimetre) layers are deposited. In our chip we require a much thicker layer > 0.01 mm. The challenge is to develop a process to manufacture these thick layers and new sensor chips.

Once this technical problem is resolved, we will conduct short and long term testing to verify sufficient performance for the markets and applications. We will do this in partnership with sensor companies who we hope to work with to bring the product to market. The outcome of the project should be a license agreement with a company and a new product line.

Planned Impact

This project will improve the prospect of achieving commercial uptake by solving the current technological barrier to adoption namely long term drift caused by water uptake into the sensor insulation. Further it will increase its value by improving the performance of measurement, making it comparable with instruments that are an order of magnitude larger and cost 20 times more. This will greatly extend the addressable market and should maximise sales.
The project will also enable extensive knowledge exchange and market building activities which will improve industry engagement, will significantly increase awareness of the technology in user groups and for potential licensees. This activity will lead to a license agreement with a company enabling commercialisation of the technology, bringing global impact in multiple sectors.
Wider societal and environmental benefit will stem from the availability of a new low-cost high performance water quality sensor that will enable more frequent, more widespread and better quality measurement and management of our environment. For example this will enable improved response times to events (such as storm driven flooding and pollution events). More better data will also enable improved forecasting and modelling of the environment (e.g. for weather forecasting).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description That many markets require a very low cost conductivity temperature and dissolved oxygen sensors and these are accessible to our current sensor technology which therefore has commercial potential. We have discovered and solved a number of engineering issues affecting performance and are continuing testing with our commercial partners to verify the required performance has been reached prior to mass production.
Exploitation Route The market understanding, fault finding and solving, and technology evaluation completed in this project will enable commercialisation of our sensor technology
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Chemicals,Electronics,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description We established a strong collaborative relationship with a commercialisation partner with our product being evaluated by them . They have 3 patent applications to national phase and are contributed to the research and productization effort to create a market ready device. However, in late 2018 they declined to take a license and we are now pursuing alternative commercialisation strategies. Two companies are discussing licensing and negotiations are now active with both.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Electronics,Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Technology based impact assessment tool foR sustaInable, transparent Deep sEa miNing exploraTion and exploitation
Amount € 16,000,000 (EUR)
Funding ID 101091959 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 01/2023 
End 12/2027
 
Description CEFAS lowestoft lab 
Organisation Centre For Environment, Fisheries And Aquaculture Science
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We collaborate with CEFAS Lowestoft on the development and application of new sensor technologies for their operational and research requirements. We provide sensors R&D, deliver sensors we have developed, as well as with operational support of demonstration deployments and operational data gathering campaigns.
Collaborator Contribution CEFAS Lowestoft provide access to operational infrastructure including instrumented buoys, autonomous vehicles and ships often with co-sampling that can be used to benchmark sensor performance which is essential for demonstrating sensor performance and value in an application. They also supply operational and scientific knowledge of applications enabling the technology to have enhanced impact into resource management and policy.
Impact Deployment of nutrient sensors on the RV Endevour and on Smart Bouys in the Thames and coastal sites
Start Year 2009
 
Title APPARATUS FOR SENSING AT LEAST ONE PARAMETER IN WATER 
Description Apparatus (2) for sensing at least one parameter in water, which apparatus (2) comprises: (i) a dissolved oxygen sensor (4) for sensing dissolved oxygen in the water; and which apparatus (2) is such that: (ii) the dissolved oxygen sensor (4) has a working electrode and a reference electrode; and (iii) a voltage signal is applied between the working electrode and the reference electrode, and the voltage signal provides a conditioning waveform, then a wait time, and then a measurement function. 
IP Reference WO2014044998 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2014
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact Licence in negotiation, costs paid by potential licensee
 
Title APPARATUS FOR SENSING AT LEAST ONE PARAMETER IN WATER 
Description Apparatus (2) for sensing at least one parameter in water, which apparatus comprises: (i) a conductivity sensor (6) for sensing conductivity in the water; (ii) a dissolved oxygen sensor (4) for sensing dissolved oxygen in the water; (iii) a glass substrate (14); and (iv) the conductivity sensor (6) and the dissolved oxygen sensor (4) are fabricated on the glass substrate (14) using photolithography and etching. 
IP Reference WO2014044999 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2014
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact license in negotiation with potential licensee paying patent costs
 
Title APPARATUS WITH A SELF-CLEANING ELECTRODE FOR SENSING AT LEAST ONE PARAMETER IN WATER 
Description Apparatus (2) for sensing at least one parameter in water, which apparatus (2) comprises: (i) at least one electrode based sensor (4, 6) for sensing at least one parameter in water; and which apparatus (2) is such that: (ii) the electrode based sensor (4, 6) has a self-cleaning electrode; (iii) the electrode based sensor (4, 6) has a reference electrode; (iv) the self-cleaning electrode is stable in water; (v) the apparatus (2) is configured to operate by liberating chlorine from the water using a first waveform applied to the self- cleaning electrode; (VI) the apparatus (2) is configured to operate by liberating chlorine and oxygen from the water using a second waveform applied to the self-cleaning electrode; and (VII) the apparatus (2) is configured to preserve the condition of the reference electrode by periodically regenerating the reference electrode. 
IP Reference WO2014045001 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2014
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact license in negotiation with two companies
 
Title APPARATUS WITH A SELF-CLEANING ELECTRODE FOR SENSING AT LEAST ONE PARAMETER IN WATER 
Description Apparatus (2) for sensing at least one parameter in water, which apparatus (2) comprises: (i) at least one electrode based sensor (4, 6) for sensing at least one parameter in water; and which apparatus (2) is such that: (ii) the electrode based sensor (4, 6) has a self-cleaning electrode; (iii) the electrode based sensor (4, 6) has a reference electrode; (iv) the self-cleaning electrode is stable in water; (v) the apparatus (2) is configured to operate by liberating chlorine from the water using a first waveform applied to the self- cleaning electrode; (VI) the apparatus (2) is configured to operate by liberating chlorine and oxygen from the water using a second waveform applied to the self-cleaning electrode; and (VII) the apparatus (2) is configured to preserve the condition of the reference electrode by periodically regenerating the reference electrode. 
IP Reference WO2014045001 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2014
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact Licensing in negotiation
 
Title Apparatus for sensing e.g. parameter in sea water for industrial and environmental applications, has conductivity sensor comprising electrodes for current stimulation geometrically bounding and enclosing electrodes for voltage sensing 
Description The design of a planar conductivity cell with geometry that constrains the field limiting the error caused by either conductors or insulators placed in proximity to the sensor. I.e. only the water conductivity is measured. 
IP Reference WO2014044997-A1 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed Commercial In Confidence
Impact This IP is currently the subject of negotiations for a license to one UK and one non UK company