Structures and deformation mechanisms in a slowly slipping subduction thrust, Hikurangi Margin, New Zealand (IODP Expedition 375)

Lead Research Organisation: CARDIFF UNIVERSITY
Department Name: School of Earth and Ocean Sciences

Abstract

Slow slip events are a recently discovered phenomenon, where slip occurs at a rate faster than plate boundary deformation, but too slow to generate seismic waves. The discovery of these slow slip events has challenged the long-held paradigm that faults either accumulate displacement steadily, at rates of centimetres per year, or fail episodically in potentially damaging earthquakes. Instead, there is now evidence that faults can slip at rates that very across a huge spectrum, from slower than fingernail growth to the meter per second velocity that occurs in damaging earthquakes. We do, however, not understand the physical controls on this range in fault slip behaviour.

The Hikurangi Margin, New Zealand, presents a unique opportunity in drilling into a fault that is known to accommodate slow slip events. Whereas most slow slip has been detected at depths in excess of ten kilometres, out of range of ocean drilling, the Hikurangi Margin experiences slow slip events that propagate to depths less than 2 km, and maybe even all the way to the sea floor. Observatories to be installed during expedition 375 will better define the geometry, but critically to this proposal, expedition 375 will also sample the materials that host the plate boundary fault, and therefore also the slow slip events.

With samples from expedition 375, I will investigate the rocks that host slow slip events in the Hikurangi Margin. Using state-of-the-art scanning electron microscopy at Cardiff University, the composition and microstructure of the materials entering the subduction zone can be studied in great detail. The planned boreholes intersect the ocean floor and the overlying oceanic and terrestrial sediments, allowing us to know what rock type(s) slip is(are) occurring in. A borehole will also intersect the shallowest inferred active fault at the front of the accretionary prism, allowing insights into how the sediments deform when faulted.

Specifically in this proposal, I propose to characterise the structures that have developed in the incoming sediments and oceanic crust as these rocks enter the subduction zone. This characterisation will show how deformation is distributed at the very shallowest level of the plate boundary, and allow inferences of where in the incoming sequence the plate boundary fault localises. Importantly, seeing what structures have developed at the microscale also allows inference of what deformation mechanisms are active in each sampled rock unit. This inference lets us know what rocks are likely to fracture, and what rocks may deform by other mechanisms. This information is important in understanding how some materials may host earthquakes, and others slow slip events.

Planned Impact

The key aim of IODP expedition 375 is to investigate the materials and in situ conditions that allow subduction zone slow slip events to occur at the Hikurangi margin, New Zealand. The main potential beneficiaries for such research are:

1. Communities and policy makers in regions of seismic hazard. This is because an improved understanding of faults that host slow earthquakes can help bridge the knowledge gap in what controls the speed at which faults slip. Making sure the research can reach seismic and tsunami hazard teams will be a joint effort of the science team on Expedition 375, working along side onshore collaborators. Specifically for this moratorium proposal, work on recognising the type of sediments and fault rocks that may host slow earthquakes will be communicated to existing collaborators in New Zealand and Japan, and results presented at major international conferences such as the American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting.

2. More specifically, local New Zealand communities will gain improved understanding of their offshore geology, and particularly an improved understanding of seismic hazard related to the Hikurangi subduction zone. Reaching these communities will occur through existing links with the governmental Earth Science agency GNS Science and New Zealand participants on Expedition 375.

3. Education and outreach activities have long been central to IODP expeditions, and through participating in the expedition, and undertaking post-cruise research, I will contribute to creation of education and outreach materials, and presentation of such materials in the UK. Two outreach specialists sail on the expedition to assist with creation of outreach materials. There is also tradition and history for IODP expeditions producing outreach material onboard. The web portal in particular encourages broader participation of the general public in the science occurring on board the ship during expedition 375.
 
Description The key objective of this award was to analyse materials recovered by scientific ocean drilling along the east coast of New Zealand. This target was chosen to better understand the subduction of the Pacific ocean floor at the New Zealand tectonic plate boundary zone. This zone has hosted historical tsunami earthquakes, and is a site of ongoing 'slow slip'. 'Slow slip' is a style of plate boundary slip that was recently discovered and is still poorly understood - it occurs when slip is too slow to generate an earthquake, but faster than the typical, finger-nail growth pace of plate boundary motion. The NERC-funded project formed a component of a larger, international collaboration under the umbrella of the International Ocean Discovery Programme (IODP). As such, we also participated in writing and editing of reports published by IODP, that detail all the findings from the drilling project. These reports are available, Open Access, on the web.

Specifically for this project, we looked at the geology of two boreholes - one through a shallow fault, and another through the sediments that are arriving at the subduction zone on the ocean floor. In an Open Access publication in the journal GEOLOGY, we describe the shallow fault, and conclude that it is capable of hosting both brittle and ductile deformation. This is important, and can be interpreted to mean that the fault hosts more than one slip style. If this is correct, the same fault could host earthquakes, slow slip, or average plate motion rates, rather than having a 'characteristic' style of slip. By looking at ocean floor sediments approaching the subduction zone, we established that these are also capable of multiple deformation styles. In particular, they may host both chemical processes, where deformation occurs by dissolution and precipitation of materials, and physical processes where fractures form to accomplish deformation. This work is published, open access, in the journal Tectonics, and was led by Harold Leah as part of his PhD studies.
Exploitation Route One major outcome is that the results of this project, and other projects arising from International Ocean Discovery Program scientific drilling in New Zealand, have both provided new insights and highlighted areas in need of further study and data collection. As such, a new proposal for scientific drilling offshore New Zealand has been developed, a pre-proposal was submitted, and a full proposal has been recommended by the International Ocean Discovery Program's science panel. The outcomes are thereby taken forward for future use and research. Both the current project and the new proposal are in collaboration with local institutes working on natural hazard mitigation in New Zealand.

Findings in this project also forms part of educational resources, including a blog (https://joidesresolution.org/guest-blog-ake-fagereng/) and an article (https://futurumcareers.com/taking-to-the-seas-to-discover-how-the-earths-surface-moves) developed with high school users in mind. The International Ocean Discovery Program is known to be used in both high school and university teaching as it produces large and varied data sets suitable for science teaching and outreach.
Sectors Education,Environment

URL http://publications.iodp.org/proceedings/372B_375/372B375title.html
 
Description A key aim of this project, and the larger collaborative effort on the New Zealand subduction margin, has been to generate new knowledge on earthquake and tsunami hazard. On the scale of the scientific drilling project as a whole, much of this science is distributed by East Coast Lab (https://www.eastcoastlab.org.nz/) and GNS Science (https://www.gns.cri.nz/Home/Learning/Science-Topics/Earthquakes/New-Zealands-Largest-Fault) to interested parties in New Zealand. It is too early to say what impact the project will have on earthquake and tsunami resilience, but it is partly driving future directions, including in particular the development of a new scientific drilling proposal for further data collection offshore New Zealand. A preliminary drilling proposal (IODP 959-Pre) was submitted in April 2019 and a full proposal has been invited. Findings in this project also forms part of educational resources, including a blog (https://joidesresolution.org/guest-blog-ake-fagereng/) and an article (https://futurumcareers.com/taking-to-the-seas-to-discover-how-the-earths-surface-moves) developed for high school users. The International Ocean Discovery Program is know to be used in both high school and university teaching as it produces large and varied data sets suitable for science teaching and outreach.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Title IODP Expedition 375 Site U1520 Unit IV fault and stylolite frequency and texture observations 
Description Data collected on this project, from input sediments sampled at site U1520, have been uploaded to the National Geodata Centre, hosted by the British Geological Survey, as per the data management plan. The DOI assigned to the data is doi:10.5285/af50c4d2-fc87-4052-a41b-226d0590c12b Data are either (1) depths and spacings between stylolites and faults within Unit IV, (2) images from IODP drill core image logs of the locations of samples observed, (3) photomicrographs and flatbed thin section scans of thin sections cut from samples, (4) SEM BSE or EDS data collected at Cardiff University. These data form the basis of: Leah et al. "Brittle-ductile strain localisation and weakening in pelagic sediments seaward of the Hikurangi margin, New Zealand", Tectonics, Submitted. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The data underpins a publication currently in revision from our group (led by PhD student Harold Leah): Leah et al. "Mixed brittle and ductile strain localisation and weakening in pelagic sediments seaward of the Hikurangi margin, New Zealand", Tectonics, in Revision. When the publication is available to share, we will make it widely available and include a link to the open database. 
URL https://www.bgs.ac.uk/services/ngdc/citedData/catalogue/af50c4d2-fc87-4052-a41b-226d0590c12b.html
 
Description IODP 
Organisation International Ocean Discovery Programme (IODP)
Country United States 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution I sailed as a structural geologist on IODP Expedition 375, after having been part of the proposal writing and cruise planning team since 2010. In this particular project, as part of this team, I contributed directly to shipboard core descriptions and reports. I also participated in the post-cruise editorial meeting to finalise the expedition report. Myself and my team further contribute through post-cruise sample descriptions, structural analyses, and modelling of deformation conditions based on observations of core samples and borehole data. This moratorium project contributes directly by detailed study of samples from the input sites U1520 and U1526. I led the publication of observations in a drilled fault zone, published as Fagereng et al. 2019 in Geology, listed elsewhere in this submission.
Collaborator Contribution The collaboration allows for the unique opportunities created by scientific ocean drilling. In the particular case of Expedition 375. the collaboration provides samples to undertake my geological research, as well as shipboard and post-cruise contextual data, such as borehole logs, core descriptions, age models, and geochemical analyses. None of the research in this project could occur without the IODP collaboration.
Impact A preliminary report co-authored by all participants (me included) was published soon after the cruise as Saffer et al. (2018), and is reported elsewhere in the forms for this project. A full report was published as Wallace et al. (2019). The Cardiff team has led two peer-reviewed publications: Fagereng et al. (2019) and Leah et al. (2020). The collaboration is multi-disciplinary, including geology, geophysics, geochemistry, paleontology, and paleomagnetism, and also involves technological advances in ocean drilling, borehole logging, and sea floor observation.
Start Year 2010
 
Description Article in 'The Conversation' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Article written and published in 'The Conversation'. The article has had more than 6,000 readers by the end of 2020.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://theconversation.com/how-we-discovered-the-conditions-behind-slow-earthquakes-that-happen-ove...
 
Description Educational article for Futurum Careers 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Provided text, photographs, and answered questions from the editor to produce an educational resource on slow slip events in general and IODP Expedition 375 in particular. The publication FUTURUM has published an open access article and associated activity sheet, aimed at high school educators and students, available from their website on a permanent doi. The publication was made available in February 2020 and thus the impact is not yet known.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://futurumcareers.com/taking-to-the-seas-to-discover-how-the-earths-surface-moves
 
Description Public Outreach Talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A talk on the outcomes of this project was presented, virtually, as part of the Cardiff University School of Earth and Environmental Sciences 'GeoTalk'series. It was subsequently posted to YouTube. Some discussion occurred afterwards, and questions have also been received from interested public (including a U3A group) that have watched the recording. Several requests were received for further information.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pgi5mThYPwY&list=PLMGi6DdxkaDafwbuqC_lppugO_UnLMypt
 
Description Shipboard blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Part of series of blogs written by shipboard scientists during IODP 375 cruise, explaining the research on the ship to a general audience, but particularly targeting schools that were following the research expedition as part of their learning.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://joidesresolution.org/guest-blog-ake-fagereng/
 
Description UKIODP Keynote 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Keynote address at the annual meeting of the UK International Ocean Discovery Project. The meeting was open, virtual, and registration was free. The presentation was followed by a discussion across different research communities interested in scientific ocean drilling.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020