Using the complexity of secondary organic aerosols to understand their formation, ageing and transformation in three contrasting megacities

Lead Research Organisation: University of York
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

Exposure to poor air quality is the top environmental risk factor of premature mortality globally. By far the most damaging air pollutant to health is particulate matter, with the greatest effects associated with particles less than 2.5 microns in diameter (PM2.5). In megacities, with large numbers of inhabitants/emissions sources, PM2.5 can often exceed recommended guideline values. The World Health Organization recommend an annual mean concentration of less than 10 micrograms/m3, as current evidence suggests lower health risks below this value. However, over 90 % of the worlds population live in regions where this value is exceeded, with London, Beijing and Delhi having values in 2016 ~ 1.5, 8 and 15 times higher. Secondary organic aerosol (SOA) can make up a significant fraction of PM2.5 in urban areas, and this may increase as many counties act to reduce emissions of ammonia and NOx. Current analytical approaches fail to provide sufficient chemical speciation to routinely apportion the contributing sources of SOA, limiting the opportunities to develop more targeted PM abatement strategies. High complexity approaches have revolutionised biomedicine, however uptake within the environmental community has been slower. In this project, we will embrace the atmosphere's complexity to make a step change in our understanding of the sources and transformation of SOA in urban atmospheres. This will be achieved through the combination of two state of the art research areas; high resolution mass spectrometry (MS) and machine learning. We will develop new tools to allow high throughput screening and quantification of SOA tracers in atmospheric aerosol samples. We will develop a mass spectral database of SOA tracer species built using a novel aerosol flow reactor designed at the University of York and supplemented with samples from 6 world-leading simulation chambers. The key here is to identify unique source specific tracer molecules that allow a direct link between the gas phase organic molecule that is emitted to the atmosphere and it's specific oxidation products that can be measured in ambient particles. The MS uses electrospray ionization, one of the most common approaches used in analytical labs throughout the world. This method is ideally suited to many SOA tracer molecules, however the ionization efficiency is strongly dependent on the chemical structure. We will carry out a systematic evaluation of the ionization efficiencies of a wide range of molecules with different functionalities to build a regression model to predict instrument response as a function of a molecular "fingerprint". We will combine these tools to carry out the most comprehensive quantification of SOA tracers in ambient aerosol and use machine learning methods to determine the factors that impact SOA concentration and estimate the relative strength of biogenic and anthropogenic sources of SOA to PM2.5. Our project will provide the first demonstration of such methods; the lack of sufficient chemical speciation and low time resolution in previous studies has so far restricted our proposed analysis. The timing of this project allows us to exploit recent investment in the NERC Air Pollution and Human Health program, providing access to an archive of PM2.5 samples and a wealth of co-located air quality data collected by leading groups from the UK, China and India. To communicate our results we will produce city specific policy reports, highlighting the main conclusions for each city, for use by government and regulatory agencies. This will be aided by a two month knowledge transfer placement in the Air Quality policy group at the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in London. This project will provide evidence of the key factors that control the amount of SOA in cities, using London, Beijing and Dehli as test cases. However, the methodology could be applied in cities across the globe to develop abatement policies that would target SOA reduction.

Planned Impact

Air pollution is one of the top environmental risk factors globally, with the World Health Organisation (WHO) estimating 3 million premature deaths per year as a result of associated strokes, heart disease, lung cancer and chronic respiratory diseases. Nine out of 10 people worldwide breathe polluted air, where air quality levels exceed WHO guidelines. The largest socioeconomic and health impacts affect developing regions such as SE Asia. However even in developed countries such as the UK, air pollution costs the economy around £16 billion per annum and reduces the average person's life expectancy by ~6 months. As an example of impacts and benefits, a policy which aimed to reduce the annual average concentration of PM2.5 by only 1 microgram/m3 would result in a saving of approximately 4 million life years for people born in 2008 in the UK.

Many countries have introduced policies to reduce emissions of primary particulate matter and the precursors for secondary inorganic aerosol, such as ammonia, nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxide, however in many places ambient levels have not reduced as anticipated. A study of PM composition in 15 cities across the globe indicated that on average 25 % was made up of oxidised organic aerosol. Current analytical approaches fail to provide sufficient chemical speciation to routinely apportion the contributing sources of SOA, limiting the opportunities to develop more targeted PM abatement strategies.

This proposal will exploit a novel high-resolution analytical methodology and integrate it with modern machine learning approaches to make a step change in our understanding of SOA in the atmosphere. To test the approach we have chosen to study three megacities (London, Beijing and Delhi) as they suffer frequent poor air quality and have a different mix of sources, emission controls and meteorology. In order to communicate our results with regional and national governments, we will produce city specific policy reports identifying the major sources of SOA and the key factors that control their concentrations and transformation in the urban polluted atmosphere. The researcher will carry out a two-month knowledge exchange placement at the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs within the Air Quality group to produce the initial evidence statement related to SOA in London. Being embedded at DEFRA, will provide valuable insight into the policy making process, particularly how research is used to inform decision-making. This placement will also achieve impact by improving engagement between government and academia and allow the researcher to build a network of contacts, while working in an interdisciplinary environment. The knowledge gained will be used to produce policy reports for Beijing and Delhi and we will exploit our on-going collaborations developed as part of the NERC funded Air Pollution and Human Health program with Chinese and Indian scientists and their links with policy makers to disseminate the report widely.

The tools developed in this project would be applicable to other areas of atmospheric and environmental science and beyond. The software tools developed will be released under the GPU general public license along with training and test data to ensure transferability to other areas. The regression model developed could transform calibration methods for electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, which represents a significant fraction of the global mass spectrometry market ($~7 billion in 2017). We have on-going collaborations with a range of mass spectrometry manufacturers and will exploit these links should this methodology prove successful. We will ensure academic impact through peer reviewed publications and conference attendance. We will deposit our database of SOA tracer concentrations in CEDA, with links to the APHH projects, to allow subsequent follow on epidemiological or modelling studies to use this novel resource.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Pereira K (2019) A new aerosol flow reactor to study secondary organic aerosol in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques

 
Title Coast to Coast Leakages 
Description Performance art by Clare Natress- coast to coast cycle ride described in a Artist Book. A face mask was worn during the ride and analysed using the methods developed in this project. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact We have since obtained discipline hopping funding from NERC joint with York St Johns University. Funding has been obtained for a minivol filter sampler that Clare can place on her bike. The face mask sampled primarily human emissions and not air pollution particles. 
URL https://www.clarenattress.co.uk/work/coast-to-coast-leakages
 
Description This work has lead to a number of publications exploring the formation processes of secondary organic aerosol. We have shown that biogenic emissions from plants can be an important source of SOA in megacities and we have identified the key anthropogenic-biogenic interactions that occur. Further work is ongoing to use machine learning approaches to classify the SOA observed in beijing and Delhi. The project has also lead to a predictive model for estimating the ionisation efficiencies of aerosol tracer compounds without commercially available standards. This has shown the current methods that produce avaerage SOA metrics are not suitable and the importance of structure is vital. Finally, we develoepd a collaboration with an artist through the work in this grant and a NERC discpline hopping grant. A exhibition was held in York to showcase the results and to make Yorks air pollution visible.
Exploitation Route The model used to produce the relative ionisation efficiencies based on structural descriptors is open access. The mass spectral database being developed will be open access and will use a community repository.
The understanding obtained from the Art-Science interface work is available online and a publication is planned to allow the scientist and the artist to share details of their collaboration and what they have learnt through this process.
Sectors Creative Economy,Environment

 
Description Our methodologies have been used to study pollution collected on face masks by performance artist Clare Nattress. This form part of her work Coast to Coast - Leakages.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Education,Environment
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Hazard Identification Platform to Assess the Health Impacts from Indoor and Outdoor Air Pollutant Exposures, through Mechanistic Toxicology
Amount £411,043 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/W002051/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2021 
End 07/2025
 
Description Ingenious: UnderstandING the sourcEs, traNsformations and fates of IndOor air pollUtantS
Amount £1,506,870 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/W002256/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2021 
End 07/2025
 
Title Dataset for "Strong anthropogenic control of Isoprene SOA" 
Description This dataset contains quantified Isoprene secondary organic aerosol (iSOA) species measured via Ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry in offline filters collected in summertime Beijing 2017. Alongside relevant atmospheric pollutants and meteorological variables measured at the same time as the collection of the offline filters. The "Filter_times" sheet contains the datetime of the midpoint of the filter collection times, as well as the start and end times of the filters in local time. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Publication 
URL https://pure.york.ac.uk/portal/en/datasets/dataset-for-strong-anthropogenic-control-of-isoprene-soa
 
Description Collaboration on wildfire emissions in singapore 
Organisation Nanyang Technological University
Country Singapore 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We analysed the composition of particle samples collected in Singapore and are investigating the impact of peat land wildfires.
Collaborator Contribution Collection of filters samples over the course of a year. Measurement and analysis of gas phase pollutant measurements
Impact None yet
Start Year 2020
 
Description The Art Science Interface: making York's air pollution visible. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Exhibition of art works: The artistic responses created over this three month collaboration were exhibited at Blossom Street Gallery in York, a gallery space that is located in a congested crossroads close to the train station. An eight minute documentary video piece captured the collection process. The viewer could watch footage captured by a videographer of the artist cycling the selected bus routes over the three month period, as well as footage from a GoPro that was attached to the front handlebars. The film was interwoven with clips of nature and greenery, such as parks and rural locations that revealed high pollution readings. The documentary footage can be viewed here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut4E-aZ-Cbg.

The video piece was positioned adjacent to six discoloured filters; one from each of the bus routes housed side by side within a glass vitrine. Upon closer inspection, the filters differed in greyish colourways respective of their journey along the individual routes. These MiniVol filters were photographed and investigated under a microscope revealing interesting microscopic matter and visible colour change.

An artist book with documentary photographs and writing about the collaboration, and the performance tool (the bicycle) was exhibited in its post performance state, coated in visible environmental matter for the public to engage with. The artist book can be viewed here https://www.clarenattress.co.uk/work/artist-scientist-artist-book.

Lastly an iPad displayed a website interface that the public could interact with. The interface can be accessed at this website address www.artscienceinterface.clarenattress.co.uk.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.clarenattress.co.uk/work/the-art-science-interface
 
Description Webinar for the RSC 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Around 100 people attended the webinar describing results from a recent paper.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021