Lost at Sea - where are all the tyre particles? (TYRE-LOSS)

Lead Research Organisation: Plymouth University
Department Name: Sch of Biological and Marine Sciences

Abstract

In the UK 330 billion road miles are driven every year, generating particles of synthetic rubber as a consequence of friction between the tyre and the road surface. It has been estimated that tyre wear could account for 65% (18,000 tonnes annually) of all microplastics released to UK surface waters. However, these estimates are in stark disagreement with environmental data where polyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene and PET are the main types of microplastics and on a global scale only around 1% of studies report finding any tyre particles at all. This contradiction is concerning because tyres contain a range of potentially hazardous chemicals which have been shown to cause harm to marine life.

Tyre particles are challenging to identify from environmental samples and this might explain the discrepancies between modelling estimates and actual field sampling. In this proposal, we will use an approach that has been recently trialled by the team and has shown that very substantial quantities of tyre particles are indeed entering the sea via storm water, waste water and from airborne dust.

This project will measure tyre particle concentrations at their points of entry to the marine environment and then describe their subsequent transport in the water column. We will measure concentrations in the water, sediment and marine life at increasing distances from the places where these particles enter the sea and construct and validate mathematical models to describe the dispersal of tyre particles in inshore waters. This information will then be used establish the potential for any associated risks to marine life at environmentally relevant concentrations.

The proposal brings together the Universities of Plymouth, Exeter and Newcastle, together with Plymouth Marine Laboratory and an Advisory Group comprising 14 organisations including policy makers, tyre, automobile, plastics and water industries as well as academia and environmental charities (see letters of support). Our research team includes world-leading experts in microplastics, marine litter, environmental chemistry, coastal dynamics and ecotoxicology who have pioneered the field with numerous collaborative projects, jointly authored papers and awards for their work. Their previous research has had significant, broad impact influencing policy and industry on a global scale to help reduce plastic contamination in the environment.

There has been considerable media attention on plastic pollution in recent years and this has translated into an urgent call for action by the public, policy makers and industry. However, current understanding of the most appropriate actions is less clear and reliable information on the relative importance and associated risks from various sources of microplastic, including tyre particles, is lacking. The outcomes of this research are therefore of critical importance to guide policy and industry intervention. The number of road vehicles is set to double by 2050 leading to increased particle emissions; however, there are interventions that could reduce the rate of tyre particle generation, hence the proposed research is both urgent and timely.

The outcomes of this project will be widely disseminated via a dedicated Work Package on communication and impact, facilitated by an Impact Champion and the Advisory Group that has been specifically assembled for the project.

Planned Impact

Knowledge generated through this project will be of direct benefit to government regulators and policy makers as well as industry and the general public.

Current uncertainty and disagreement about the relative importance of various sources of microplastics, and especially the importance of tyre particles is hindering interventions to reduce microplastic pollution. Government members, regulators and policy makers charged with legislation and environmental protection will benefit directly from clear evidence on the sources, quantities and impacts of tyre particles in relation to other forms of microplastic pollution. The proposal is of direct relevance to NERC's Societal Challenges (managing environmental change), the UK Government's 25 year Environment Plan (see Letter of support from Defra CEO Gideon Henderson), the UK Industrial Strategy by linking two key grand challenges, Future of mobility and Clean growth, and Marine Strategy Framework Directive, Descriptor 10: requires that EU member states keep marine litter (including microplastics) at levels that will not cause harm. Our research will also contribute in support of UN Sustainable Development Goal 14 'Conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development', specifically Goal 14.1 that states 'By 2025, prevent and significantly reduce marine pollution of all kinds, in particular from land-based activities, including marine debris'. These goals cannot be reliably addressed without accurate information on the relative importance of microplastic sources, which this proposal seeks to address.

The project will be of direct relevance to industry across the automotive sector, including the design of vehicles, tyres and braking systems as well as those involved in traffic management. This automotive industry are currently challenged with being a major source of microplastic contamination - yet the evidence to underpin this is lacking. Hence the project outcomes will be of direct relevance across the automotive sector who are keen to minimise the impacts of vehicles. In addition the outcomes are of wider relevance to those in the food industry who are concerned about contamination of fish and shellfish by microplastics and those involved in monitoring air and water quality.

To maximise dissemination and interactions with these key stakeholders we have established an Advisory Group for the project comprising: DEFRA; UK Water Industries Research, South West and Wessex Water; Mott MacDonald, the British Tyre and Rubber Manufacturers Association, automotive manufacturers, and Plastics Europe; Eunomia Consulting; waste and circular economy experts, Ellen MacArthur Foundation and NGOs such as the Marine Conservation Society.

The general public includes those interested in conservation of marine life, and who enjoy the marine recreational activity and seafood. Our results will provide enhanced understanding of microplastics - where they go and what effects they have. This will help with subsequent assessment of how safe it is to eat seafood and the potential influence on marine ecosystems. Ultimately such information will help inform personal choices on tyre and vehicle purchase as well as driving style. For example, there are considerable synergies between vehicle wear, efficient fuel use and tyre wear. This is relevant to increasing use of electric vehicles which are considerably heavier and typically have faster acceleration than conventional vehicles.

PDRAs and early career researchers in our consortium will have the opportunity to develop their awareness of, and skills in, science communication and knowledge transfer by; a) participating in educational outreach events run by our organisations and long term collaborator Digital Explorer, such as their 'Oceans Academies' and Skype Classrooms; b) encouraging them to write articles for the popular press and social media; c) attending NERC training on science communication.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Prior to this award we had established that substantial quantities of tyre and road wear particles were passing to aquatic environments from roads. So far in this project we have quantified their accumulation in estuarine sediments as a first step to establishing environmental distribution and impacts
Exploitation Route Measures to intercept tyre wear particles prior to their rerelease to the environment for example via settlement ponds and reed beds; or measures to reduce the wear rate of tyres for example via industrial innovation or policy
Sectors Environment,Transport

 
Description Finding have been presented to policy audiences at national and international level (CoP 26, Glasgow, 2021; Cop 27 Egypt, 2022; UN Oceans meeting, Lisbon 2022). UK National Highways funded a study: Work Order T0051 Microplastics Phase 2. Appendix X: Quantifying tyre wear particles and other microplastics from the Strategic Road Network which will be published later this year.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Environment,Transport
 
Description Highways England Specialist Professional and Technical Services 2 Framework
Amount £178,151 (GBP)
Funding ID T0051 Microplastics Phase 2 
Organisation Highways England 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2021 
End 11/2022
 
Description Micro and nano plastics and human health
Amount £60,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Plymouth 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2022 
End 09/2026
 
Description Collaboration with the TU-Ilmenau, Germany 
Organisation Technical University Ilmenau
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Dr Florian Pohl reached out to the TU-Ilmenau to acquire tyre wear particles. Prof. Valentin Ivanov and Dr David Hesse agreed to deliver tyre wear particles from their test rig to be used in hydrodynamic experiments at University of Plymouth.
Collaborator Contribution The tyre wear particles have been analysed for their density and morphology at the University of Plymouth, and results have been shared with the partners at the TU-Ilmenau.
Impact No outputs yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Consultant to the project Microplastics from roads to aquatic environments: occurrence, transport, prevention and reduction strategies 
Organisation University of Coimbra
Country Portugal 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Consultant activities by Dr Florian Pohl for the project proposal "Microplastics from roads to aquatic environments: occurrence, transport, prevention and reduction strategies" - Call for R&D Projects in All Scientific Domains - 2022. Consultant activities included drafting and editing of the research proposal.
Collaborator Contribution To be announced
Impact Co-authorships is future publications.
Start Year 2022
 
Description 'Tyre Sustainability Challenge' session at Global Research and Innovation in Plastics Sustainability (GRIPS) conference in March 2022. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact GRIPS 2022, following on from a very successful GRIPS 2021.https://web-eur.cvent.com/event/0eb1e106-588a-4943-87f0-d30a03db196e/summary
The event in 2022 will again showcase research and innovation from both the academic and industrial community that make polymers more sustainable. It will bring together companies and individuals to highlight the best of the UK and select international activities which will lead to plastics being less likely to reach landfill, end up incinerated, or become fugitive in the environment.
Research and innovation from both the academic and industrial community will be showcased at GRIPS 2022. The event will provide a platform to help develop commercial success of these developments and build links within the polymer/plastics supply chain to strengthen the offer to UK and wider international actors in application sectors such as plastic packaging/FMCG, construction, agriculture, textiles, healthcare etc. Each session aims to identify recommendations for immediate action in the plastics value chain. The event will focus on Finding the Future of Plastics & Polymers with 80+ speakers, 50 exhibitors, and 3 days of interactive sessions driven by sector experts with themes on: construction; legislation; agriculture; healthcare; net zero; marine plastics; chemical recycling' sustainable design; innovation opportunities in global markets; plastic packaging; behaviour change and many more.'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://web-eur.cvent.com/event/0eb1e106-588a-4943-87f0-d30a03db196e/summary
 
Description Exhibition stand on the COP - United Nations Climate Change Conference (2022), Egypt 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation from a exhibition stand at COP27 - United Nations Climate Change Conference (2022), Egypt. UOP designed a stand where the research questions and aims of the Tyre Loss project were presented alongside other UoP marine litter and climate related projects. Our activity emphasised the need for a systems approach to climate and transport considering both carbon and particulate emission. We demonstrated how potential mitigation strategies can work in synergy as well as antagonistically.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://twitter.com/ProfRThompson/status/1590734429286461441
 
Description Exhibition stand on the COP26 - United Nations Climate Change Conference (2021), Glasgow, UK 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation in the Green Zone on the COP26 - United Nations Climate Change Conference (2021), Glasgow, UK. Title: The road to zero emissions is not just about carbon.

We designed an exhibition stand where the research questions and aims of the Tyre Loss project were presented. Our activity emphasised the need for a systems approach to climate and transport considering both carbon and particulate emission. We demonstrated how potential mitigation strategies can work in synergy as well as antagonistically. Following activities have been conducted:

1. A 90 second TV animation film on a repeating loop was presented - illustrating the sources of particulate emissions, knowledge gaps and solutions; the connection between traffic and carbon emissions; highlighting the need to consider the system, rather than its individual components.
2. A board game quiz was designed and presented - participants were asked to correctly answer nine questions around tyre-wear particle emissions, guided by a poster.
3. Poster(s) outlining our current research on particulate emissions including: transport pathways, environmental concentrations and accumulations points, and toxicity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qRKxdQKM9Y&t=3s
 
Description Futures 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact In September 2021, over 500 individuals and families locally and across the South West joined us to discover research across science, heritage, health and history, and meet the University of Plymouth researchers who work to make a difference to our daily lives.

FUTURES2021 brought research to life in new and exciting ways online and in-person, with a whole host of events ranging from storytelling to panel discussions, comedy, quizzes and broadcasts on community radio stations.

FUTURES is an annual public engagement festival dedicated to showcasing research and innovation, as part of the 2021 European Researchers' Night celebrations. With more than 300 cities across 30 European countries taking part, this exciting annual event showcases the South West's rich scientific and cultural heritage through fun, interactive learning with the Universities of Bath, Bath Spa, Bristol, Exeter and Plymouth.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.plymouth.ac.uk/research/futures2021
 
Description Oral presentation on the 42nd Annual Meeting of the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Pohl, F., Parker-Jurd, F.N.F. & Thompson, R.C.: How Concerned should we be about Tire Particles? - Fluxes from Roads to the Marine Environment. Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC), North America 42nd Annual Meeting (2021)

Oral conference presentation (online), presenting the aims and goals of the Tyre Loss project and results from previous research at University of Plymouth related to the project. The live online presentation was attended by ca. 160 participants. Multiple questions have been asked which help to further plan the upcoming research activities of the project.

Abstract:
Tire wear particles are generated due to friction between the tire and the road surface and are assumed to present a major source of microplastic emissions to terrestrial and aquatic environments. It has been estimated that tire wear could account for 65% (18,000 tones annually) of all microplastics released to UK surface waters. Despite their apparent significance, data on the pathways for tire wear particles from roads to the marine environment is sparse. On a global scale, only around 1% of studies report finding any tire particles at all. This contradiction is concerning because tires contain a range of potentially hazardous chemicals which have been shown to cause harm to marine life.
Here we quantify tire particle fluxes to the marine environments away from roadways. For this, 96 samples have been collected from Plymouth and Bristol, two coastal cities in the UK. Examined particle pathways include: (1) Wastewater effluents, (2) Storm water runoff, and (3) Airborne tyre particles next to roadsides. All samples were analyzed using Pyr-GC-MS to determine tire wear mass using N-cyclohexyl-2-benzothiazolamine as a marker. In addition, a subset of tire particles was isolated and exanimated by visual identification to obtain particle characteristics.
Tire wear was present in each of the three pathways examined, detected within 88 % of samples, with concentrations of up to 8.2 mg/L collected from storm water drains. For the Plymouth area, back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest a tire wear flux through storm water runoff of up to ~600 tones annually. In contrast, wastewater effluents showed much lower concentrations of up to 0.3 mg/L. Airborne tire particle concentrations were generally higher in closer proximity to roadways with highest concentrations detected next to motorways with, up to 97 mg tire particles per meter square.
Our study suggests that storm water drains present a major pathway for tire wear to the marine environment, while wastewater effluents may be of lesser importance. In addition, airborne particle emission might be of significance in areas where roadways are in close proximity to the coastline or river systems. Future work should examine the fate of tire particles in the marine environment and identify potential accumulation hot spots in seafloor sediments. Knowledge on tire wear fluxes, concentrations, and accumulation zones are essential to determine ecotoxicological risks imposed by tire wear to the marine environment.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Project specific webpage 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Webpage of the Tyre Loss Project describing the project aims. In context with the COP26 a 90 second animation was added to the webpage, describing potential pathways of tyre wear particles to the aquatic environment.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.plymouth.ac.uk/research/marine-litter/tyre-loss
 
Description Speaker :United Nations Oceans Conference Side Event From Ambition to Action: Ending Plastic Pollution in All Environments 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact United Nations Oceans Conference Side Event
From Ambition to Action: Ending Plastic Pollution in All Environments
27th June, time 6-8pm, commencing after the interactive dialogues on marine pollution
Location: Ikonik Hotel Lisboa (approx. 10mins walk from Blue Zone)
Speakers
? Jo Royle, Founder and CEO, Common Seas
? Dr Jeanne d'Arc Mujawamariya, Minister of Environment, the Republic of Rwanda (pre-recorded via video link)
? Amb. Gustavo Meza Cuadra, Permanent Mission of Peru to the United Nations
? Virginijus Sinkevicius, European Commissioner for Environment, Oceans and Fisheries, European Commission
? Ed Shepherd, Senior Global Sustainability Manager - Circular Economy - Unilever
? Professor Richard Thompson OBE FRS, Director of the Marine Institute, University of Plymouth
? Rebecca Pow, Minister for Environment, UK Government

Moderator: Christina Dixon, Ocean Campaign Leader, Environmental Investigation Agency

Introduction
Thank you for joining Common Seas and EIA's event, co-hosted by Rwanda, Peru, CIEL and the European Commission, which is part of the United Nations Ocean Conference side event programme.
Plastic pollution constitutes a planetary crisis with impacts on our oceans, health, biodiversity and the climate system. Following the adoption of the resolution End Plastic Pollution: Towards an International Legally Binding Instrument at the 5th Session of the United Nations Environment Assembly in 2022 (UNEA-5), countries have a chance to come together and address the root causes of plastic pollution to safeguard our oceans and our planet. If we are to achieve SDG 14, an ambitious, coordinated and equitable approach that reflects the need to enable all countries to respond, including through support for low capacity countries and SIDS, will be essential.
Stakeholders from civil society, government, business and the scientific community will lead this high-level dialogue on priority issues for addressing plastic pollution as we look towards international negotiations in 2022 and an ambitious eventual agreement that meets the scale of the crisis at hand. From highlighting the critical importance of plastic pollution to SDG 14 and our oceans, the discussion will also cover other interlinkages, such as the sustainable production and consumption of plastics (SDG 12), product design and standards, the need for a non-toxic circular economy and the environmentally sound management of waste - all anchored in evidence-based decision making and the need to turn words into urgent action through action plans and reporting requirements.
The session will bring perspectives from different geographies and contexts, underscoring the need for a collaborative global vision to end plastic pollution that intervenes at all stages of the plastics life cycle.
The session aims to:
? Provide an update on the progress towards developing a legally binding instrument to end plastic pollution following UNEA 5.2
? Highlight essential elements to ensure the success of the instrument from different stakeholder perspectives, including business, government, scientific and civil society
? To provide insights into the interlinkages between SDG 14 and other SDGs in the context of addressing pollution across the full lifecycle of plastics
Link to the Conference Theme: Scaling up Ocean Action Based on Science and Innovation for the Implementation of Goal 14: Stocktaking, Partnerships and Solutions
? In advance of UNEA 5.2, EIA coordinated the launch of a Scientists' Declaration on the Need for Governance of Plastics Throughout Their Life Cycles, which highlighted that approaches currently proposed for addressing plastic pollution focus primarily on waste management and actions lower down the waste hierarchy. It also noted that the 'marine litter' lens does not adequately reflect the findings of UNEP's Scientific Advisory Committee for Marine Litter and Microplastics, which concluded that a full life cycle approach is needed which principally focuses on prevention, reduction and redesigning problematic plastics out of the global economy.
? The Declaration called on governments to support the establishment of a new global treaty based on independently peer-reviewed scientific consensus and Traditional Knowledge, Innovations and Practices (TKIP) of Indigenous peoples and local communities. Stakeholders from around the world and across the plastics value chain are committed to a global agreement that is grounded in and responsive to such expert opinion and evidence.
? Common Seas also sees an equitable approach to addressing plastic pollution as vital, and has developed the Plastic Drawdown tool as a mechanism for supporting low capacity countries and SIDS to take early action. The health impacts should also not be ignored. Peer-reviewed research commissioned by Common Seas found microplastics in 77% of the human blood samples that were tested. As a result, Common Seas are calling for more funding for research into the links between plastic exposure and human health. This is another reason why a new global treaty needs to focus on upstream action.
? This side event will focus discussion on the need for a global agreement with evidence-based measures that includes within its design the scientific mechanisms and approaches that will be required to inform ambitious policy-making to achieve SDG 14 and other related goals.
Structure
After introductory remarks from EIA, the panel will be introduced and asked to provide reflections on the essential elements for the plastics treaty from their stakeholder perspective. The panel will be Chaired by Christina Dixon.
After each speaker has the chance to provide a few minutes of initial reflections, they will be asked at least one question specific to their expertise and context to elaborate further on their position. We will work with you to shape these questions, to ensure we can draw out the key messages you want to share about plastic pollution.
Following the questions posed to the speakers, we will invite a small number of interventions from the floor.
The room is booked for two hours to allow time for networking and refreshments but the official programme is not envisaged to last longer than one hour. We anticipate starting by 6.30pm and concluding by 7.30pm to allow time for networking. This timing should enable people to move from the Interactive Dialogues to this venue with adequate time.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://eia-international.org/from-ambition-to-action-ending-plastic-pollution-in-all-environments/
 
Description Stakeholder workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact We organised a two-hour workshop in which the research team presented aims and workpackages of the TYRE-LOSS project to partners and stakeholders. These included academics, government, industry partners, and NGOs.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Student Futures and Research Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact This five-day event is for career professionals, researchers, and student peers to engage and speak to university students from undergrad to PhD about their career areas, global challenges, and research. The aim of the event is to both inform and excite students interested in ecology and natural history about the career choices available to them and allow them to present their work to their peers. Attending the conference will be an audience of up to 300 undergraduate, postgraduate, Masters and PhD students, and others interested in ecology.
Further information can be found on the Eventbrite page: Student Futures and Research Conference 2022 | Eventbrite
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/the-student-futures-and-research-conference-2022-tickets-249397192717
 
Description UN Oceans Side Event Plastic pollution: what is holding us back from solutions; what key science and innovation is needed to tackle this global environmental challenge? Tue 28 Jun 2022, 4.00 pm 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact O28 June 2022, 16:00-17:30
Event streamed live from Lisbon, Portugal
The topic of plastic pollution has received considerable global attention and as a consequence, was the focus of a recent UNEA 5.2 resolution entitled 'End Plastic Pollution: Towards an internationally legally binding instrument.'
Most of the evidence around plastic pollution originates from the marine environment, yet most of the causes and hence the interventions to reduce plastic pollution, are grounded in supply chains and actions that lie on land. Do we have sufficient evidence to inform the recent UNEA resolution and if not, where are the evidence gaps? More broadly, are there lessons that can be learned from our current understanding of plastic pollution and our progress towards interventions that can help guide the way toward prioritisation of actions in relation to other environmental contaminants?
This online discussion, question and answer session with experts from industry, policy and academia helped to identify the critical science and innovation needed to tackle this global environmental challenge.
This panel debate featured short presentations from a diverse multinational panel (academia, policy, industry and innovation, finance, legal frameworks) followed by a Q&A session from the audience of conference delegates. Some of the key questions addressed:
Do we need more evidence on the problem at sea or more on the trade-offs between solutions on land?
What are the differences in applicability of solutions between nations?
What is the relative importance of interventions at the design stage vs waste management to achieve circularity?
What types of legal framework are needed to achieve success?
What are the necessary national/international standards and enforcement?
In short, what are the priorities for evidence to inform intervention in the context of UNEA 5.2? More broadly with regard to other forms of marine pollution, how best to link environmental evidence of impacts to effective solutions, in a timely manner?
View the conference website
See follow up article in Nature written by our Lisbon panellists outlining the evidence needs to inform the plastic treaty
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.plymouth.ac.uk/whats-on/plastic-pollution-2022-un-ocean-conference-official-virtual-side...