Contagious by Nature: Understanding Optimisation of Social Networks in Wild Populations

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Biology

Abstract

In any society, the invisible web of diverse forms of social interactions that link individuals together can be conceptualised as their 'social network'. This network provides the pathways for socially-contagious elements to spread, which hold essential benefits (e.g. disseminating information) as well as great costs (e.g. infectious diseases). As such, 'social trade-offs' exist, whereby social connections deliver fundamentals that are essential to individuals lives and to societal functioning (e.g. new innovations, cooperative actions) but also provide transmission routes for harmful contagions (e.g. viruses).

Many questions surround these trade-offs in contagions: Where can individuals position themselves within the network to reap the benefits most important to them while avoiding the risks? Which type of social bonds and relationships shape the different contagions at play? How should a society be structured to promote positive contagions while simultaneously controlling harmful transmission? Notably, the recent COVID19 pandemic clearly exampled this, with countries struggling to maintain societal functioning while controlling the contagion. Yet, the considerations here are actually general to any social system exposed to contagions, and this proposed research aims to provide new empirically-based insights into each of the aforementioned questions, as understanding currently remains critically limited.

Here, I propose that wild animal systems are expected to be well-versed in coping with relevant social trade-offs, as social connections in these societies simultaneously act as pathways for infectious disease while also being relied upon for beneficial social transmission processes Therefore, I will capitalize on the unrecognized potential of natural animal populations for addressing these fundamental knowledge gaps, through (i) synthesising hundreds of studies quantifying wild animal social networks in great detail, and (ii) carrying out unique experiments (social manipulations) within these real-world systems. In this way, I will use the unique opportunities that natural populations offer to provide much-needed empirical insights into how social networks can be harnessed for optimising a broad range of contagion processes in real-world settings.

Through continuing my interdisciplinary collaborations with applied practitioners across fields, this fellowship will also explore three areas of wider impact, specifically focusing on (i) identifying which social interventions within human social networks can best control diseases (particularly COVID19) while causing minimal disruption, (ii) how new initiatives can be optimally spread within conservation-relevant systems to promote sustainable behaviours and (iii) how social behaviour can contribute to mental health particularly when social systems suffer disruption.

Finally, through building foundational comprehension of social behaviour and contagions, this fellowship will also develop of future lines of investigation, and construct a conceptual frameworks for examining (a) how multiple types of contagions feedback onto one another (e.g. does disease spread alter the opportunities for behavioural contagions through changing individuals' behaviours?) and (b) how contagion processes operate on longer-timeframes (e.g. how do contagions shape individuals' survival or reproduction? does the spread of behaviours shape the evolution of culture over generations?).

As such, this research will provide new scientific understanding into how real-world social networks can be optimized for varied contagions, particularly in regards to how individuals position themselves, the quantity and extent of different social bonding types, and the overall architecture of the population's social network. This will produce new fundamental scientific understanding, be used for generating broad applied impact across a range of fields, and open up new areas of advancement.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Social Ageing and Society Structure in Wild Birds 
Organisation University of Leeds
Department School of Mathematics Leeds
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Providing data and analysis, and synthesising research into how social ageing influences society structure in wild birds
Collaborator Contribution Mathematical and statistical insights into the analysis, designing models for predicting how social ageing influences social network structure
Impact Carrying out interdisciplinary workshop into this topic (http://www.theswarmlab.com/meetings/data_model_2019/), currently designing upcoming publications
Start Year 2019
 
Description Sociality and Ageing in Red Deer 
Organisation University of Edinburgh
Department Institute of Evolutionary Biology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Designing, Analysing and Synthesising research on red deer sociality and ageing
Collaborator Contribution Producing data and providing data, providing insights into analysis and study design, and synthesising the research
Impact Upcoming
Start Year 2019
 
Description Invited Seminar: Sheffield University; Ecology, Evolution and Environment seminar series 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Invited Seminar: Sheffield University; Ecology, Evolution and Environment seminar series - Nov 2022

The Behavioural Ecology of Contagions: Pandemics, Passerines, and Permuted Populations
Josh A Firth, Department of Biology, Oxford University.

Whether we consider an infectious disease or a new piece of social information, the spread of any contagious element depends on the invisible web of social connections that link individuals together: the social network. All real-world social networks are fundamentally governed by behavioural ecology, as societies are structured by ecological forces shaping the population and the fine-scale behaviour of the individuals embedded within it. As such, understanding contagions of varied forms requires a behavioural ecology approach, particularly when questioning 'social trade offs' whereby social connections deliver fundamentals that are essential to individuals lives and to societal functioning (such as new innovations) but also provide transmission routes for harmful contagions (i.e. disease). Where can individuals position themselves within the network to reap the social benefits most important to them while avoiding the risks? Which type of social bonds and relationships shape the different contagions at play? How should a society be structured to promote positive contagions while simultaneously controlling harmful transmission? Notably, the recent COVID19 pandemic clearly exampled these trade-offs, with countries often struggling to maintain societal functioning while controlling the contagion.

In this talk I will draw upon three lines of research surrounding these questions in the behavioural ecology of contagions: First I will discuss the importance of considering behavioural variation when predicting the spread and mitigation of COVID-19 in real-world social networks, and what this means for maximising disease control while minimising social disturbance. Second, I will present how experiments and fine-scale individual tracking creates unique potential for animal populations to advance our understanding of social contagions, particularly in the context of a case study considering the spread of behaviours in wild passerines (mainly Great tits - Parus major) in Oxford. Third, across these examples (the COVID19 pandemic and the passerine model system), I will describe analytical techniques based on permutating populations, and how these can be used for building insights into the fundamentals of contagions in real-world social systems. The talk will conclude by highlighting some major unreached questions at the interface of behavioural ecology and social contagions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Plenary Talk: Chinese Biodiversity Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Plenary Talk: Chinese Biodiversity Conference - Beijing (Online), 11th Nov.


Beyond Biomonitoring: Illuminating the social ecology of wild great tits through combining long-term monitoring with automated tracking experiments

Our fundamental understanding of diverse topics in ecology and evolution has benefitted significantly from long-term study populations that monitor individual animals over their entire lifetimes and across multiple generations. Now, the field of animal ecology is being rapidly transformed by novel technologies that provide rich high-resolution data on many individuals as once, and allows new insights into individuals' interactions with one-another and how these affect ecological processes. This seminar will discuss how integrating new tracking technologies has provided a unique opportunity to gain new scientific insights from a long-term study population of wild Great tits (Parus major) in Wytham Woods, Oxford. In particular, the talk focus on how long-term monitoring of this great tit population and in-depth knowledge of individuals' life-history allowed the deployment of new research methods that have furthered understanding of the causes and consequences of social interactions. Specifically, this seminar will first examine the common challenges surrounding studying sociality in the wild, and how these might be addressed by combining large-scale observational data and fine-scale experiments. Second, the seminar will discuss how these approaches within this great tit population has provided broad insights into the structure and significance of 'social networks' for various aspects of life, ranging from foraging, territory structuring, breeding decisions, and the spread of information.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Plenary Talk: People, Animals & Waste Systems Conference - Oxford, 27-28 Mar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Talk at the India-Oxford Initiative for the 'People, Animals and Waste Systems' OneHealth conference
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023